Arbitration Law in Bolivia
Arbitration Law in Bolivia
Bolivia's legal framework for arbitration has been evolving in recent years, with the country making efforts to align itself with international standards for dispute resolution. Arbitration is recognized as a legitimate and effective means of resolving commercial and civil disputes, and the legal environment for arbitration in Bolivia has been strengthened through the adoption of new laws and reforms.
1. Legal Framework
Bolivian Code of Civil Procedure (1999)
- The Bolivian Code of Civil Procedure (Código Procesal Civil) contains provisions for arbitration, and it governs both domestic and international arbitration in Bolivia. The law, initially enacted in 1999, was updated to modernize its approach to arbitration.
- Articles 660 to 690 of the Civil Procedure Code specifically address the provisions related to arbitration agreements, the appointment of arbitrators, the arbitration process, and the recognition of arbitral awards.
- These provisions establish the formal framework for arbitration in Bolivia, allowing for arbitration to be used for resolving both commercial and civil disputes.
Law No. 164 of 2011: "Law of Arbitration and Conciliation"
- Law No. 164, enacted in 2011, is Bolivia’s specific law on arbitration and conciliation. It was a significant step forward in modernizing Bolivia's arbitration laws, as it aligns the country’s legal framework with international standards, particularly the UNCITRAL Model Law on International Commercial Arbitration.
- The Law of Arbitration and Conciliation (Ley de Arbitraje y Conciliación) governs both domestic and international arbitration, providing a clear and comprehensive legal structure for the arbitration process.
- It outlines key concepts such as arbitration agreements, arbitrators’ appointments, the conduct of proceedings, and the enforcement of arbitral awards.
The New York Convention (1958)
- Bolivia is a signatory to the New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (1958). This international treaty provides a framework for the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards issued in other signatory countries.
- Bolivia's adherence to the New York Convention ensures that foreign arbitral awards are generally recognized and enforced within the country, subject to limited exceptions.
2. Key Features of Arbitration in Bolivia
Arbitration Agreement
- An arbitration agreement in Bolivia must be in writing. The agreement may be part of a broader contract or a separate document. For an agreement to be enforceable, it must clearly express the parties' intent to submit disputes to arbitration rather than litigation.
- The arbitration agreement must also meet basic requirements, such as the identification of the parties, the subject matter of the dispute, and the method for selecting arbitrators.
Party Autonomy
- Party autonomy is a fundamental principle in Bolivia’s arbitration laws. Parties are free to determine key aspects of the arbitration process, including:
- The seat of arbitration (location where arbitration will take place).
- The number of arbitrators (usually one or three).
- The rules governing the arbitration (e.g., UNCITRAL, ICC, LCIA).
- The language of the arbitration.
- The applicable law governing the dispute.
- This flexibility allows parties to tailor the arbitration process to meet their specific needs.
Arbitral Tribunal
- The arbitrators in Bolivia are typically chosen by the parties in accordance with the arbitration agreement. If the parties are unable to agree on the appointment of an arbitrator, the Law of Arbitration and Conciliation provides for the court's assistance or the involvement of an arbitration institution.
- Arbitrators are required to act impartially and independently. If a party challenges an arbitrator on the grounds of bias or conflict of interest, the courts may be involved in resolving the dispute.
Judicial Intervention
- The role of the courts in arbitration is limited, as the Law of Arbitration and Conciliation emphasizes minimal judicial intervention. The courts are only allowed to intervene in limited circumstances, such as:
- Enforcing the arbitration agreement if one party refuses to participate.
- Assisting with the appointment of arbitrators if the parties cannot reach an agreement.
- Setting aside an arbitral award on grounds such as procedural errors or violations of public policy.
- This approach aligns with international arbitration norms, which seek to maintain the finality of arbitral awards and reduce judicial interference.
3. Enforcement of Arbitral Awards
Domestic Awards
- In Bolivia, domestic arbitral awards are generally enforceable under the Law of Arbitration and Conciliation and the Civil Procedure Code. The party seeking enforcement can apply to the Bolivian courts for recognition and enforcement of the award.
- The grounds for refusing to enforce a domestic arbitral award are limited and generally include violations of public policy, lack of impartiality of the arbitrator, or procedural fairness.
Foreign Awards
- Bolivia is a signatory to the New York Convention, which provides the framework for the recognition and enforcement of foreign arbitral awards.
- As a result, Bolivia will typically enforce foreign arbitral awards made in other New York Convention member states, subject to limited exceptions such as:
- Violation of public policy in Bolivia.
- Lack of due process or fair treatment during the arbitration process.
- Non-arbitrability of the subject matter under Bolivian law.
4. Arbitration Institutions in Bolivia
Bolivian Arbitration Center (Centro de Arbitraje de Bolivia - CAB)
- The Bolivian Arbitration Center (CAB) is a key institution in Bolivia that facilitates arbitration and alternative dispute resolution (ADR). The CAB offers services for commercial arbitration, including providing arbitrators, facilitating the process, and applying arbitration rules.
- The CAB provides both domestic and international arbitration services, using arbitration rules similar to those of international institutions, such as UNCITRAL.
Chamber of Commerce of Santa Cruz
- The Chamber of Commerce of Santa Cruz also plays a significant role in arbitration in Bolivia, particularly for commercial disputes. The Chamber has its own arbitration center and offers arbitration services in various sectors, including trade, construction, and finance.
Ad Hoc Arbitration
- In addition to institutional arbitration, ad hoc arbitration is also recognized in Bolivia. In such cases, the parties can agree on the rules and procedures to follow, with many choosing internationally recognized frameworks such as the UNCITRAL Arbitration Rules or ICC Rules.
5. Challenges and Considerations
Limited International Recognition
- While Bolivia’s legal framework for arbitration is in line with international norms, its reputation for arbitration and the enforcement of foreign awards remains under development. Though Bolivia is a signatory to the New York Convention, its arbitration culture is not as robust as other jurisdictions in Latin America, which could be a consideration for international parties.
Public Policy
- As with many jurisdictions, Bolivia allows the setting aside or non-enforcement of arbitral awards on the grounds of public policy. This could include disputes related to matters such as family law, labor law, or other issues that are deemed to affect the country’s essential values.
Need for Further Development
- While Bolivia has a relatively modern arbitration law, there remains room for further development, especially in areas like institutional support and arbitration infrastructure. The country’s arbitration landscape is still in transition, and there is potential for growth as international trade and commercial disputes increase.
6. Arbitration in Bolivia for International Disputes
Attractive Venue for Regional Disputes
- Bolivia's strategic location in South America and its membership in organizations like Mercosur and the Andean Community make it a potentially attractive venue for resolving regional disputes. Arbitration can be particularly useful for resolving commercial disputes in industries such as mining, energy, construction, and agriculture, which are significant sectors in Bolivia.
Cross-Border Arbitration
- Bolivia's membership in the New York Convention enhances its attractiveness for cross-border arbitration, making it easier for foreign parties to enforce awards issued in other Convention countries.
Conclusion
Bolivia has taken significant steps to modernize its arbitration framework, particularly through the Law of Arbitration and Conciliation (2011), which brings the country closer to international standards. While domestic arbitration is well-regulated, the enforcement of foreign awards and the country's arbitration culture may still be developing. Bolivia’s pro-arbitration approach and adherence to the New York Convention position it as a growing arbitration venue in South America, especially for commercial disputes.
RELATED Blog
0 comments