Hybrid Financial Institutions Regulation Spain Fintech Banks

HYBRID FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS REGULATION IN SPAIN: FINTECH BANKS – DETAILED LEGAL EXPLANATION WITH CASE LAWS

1. Introduction

Hybrid Financial Institutions are financial organisations that combine traditional banking activities with financial technology (FinTech), digital payment services, electronic money, lending platforms, crowdfunding, investment services and technology-based financial infrastructure.

In Spain, the growth of hybrid financial institutions has transformed the traditional banking structure. Financial institutions increasingly operate through combinations of conventional banking licences, digital platforms, third-party technology providers, electronic payment systems and alternative financing arrangements.

Examples include:

Traditional banks offering fully digital banking services.

FinTech companies partnering with licensed Spanish banks.

Electronic money institutions providing digital wallets and payment services.

Banking institutions using artificial intelligence for credit assessment.

Digital lending platforms cooperating with regulated credit institutions.

Financial institutions combining payment services, investment products and digital asset services.

Spanish law does not recognise Hybrid Financial Institution as a separate statutory licensing category. Instead, regulatory treatment depends on the actual financial activities performed, the legal status of the institution and the risks created by its business model.

The central regulatory principle is that financial institutions cannot avoid banking regulation merely by describing themselves as technology companies or digital platforms.

2. Legal Framework Governing Hybrid Financial Institutions in Spain

The regulatory framework consists of Spanish banking legislation and directly applicable European Union financial legislation.

A. Law 10/2014 on the Regulation, Supervision and Solvency of Credit Institutions

Ley 10/2014 is one of the principal Spanish statutes governing credit institutions.

It regulates:

Authorisation of credit institutions.

Banking governance.

Capital adequacy.

Risk management.

Internal control systems.

Supervisory intervention.

Administrative sanctions.

Directors' responsibilities.

Prudential supervision.

A FinTech company that conducts activities legally reserved for credit institutions cannot avoid the authorisation requirement by using a digital business model.

For example, a company accepting repayable funds from the public and granting credit on its own account may fall within the regulated banking perimeter.

However, not every FinTech lender is automatically a credit institution. Lending from its own funds, payment intermediation and deposit-taking are legally distinct activities.

B. Royal Decree 84/2015

Royal Decree 84/2015 develops the implementation of Law 10/2014.

It addresses:

Conditions for authorisation.

Organisational requirements.

Shareholder suitability.

Management suitability.

Internal governance.

Supervisory requirements.

Information obligations.

Hybrid institutions must demonstrate that their governance arrangements remain adequate even where important operational functions are performed through external technology providers.

C. Law 5/2015 on the Promotion of Business Financing

Ley 5/2015 regulates important aspects of alternative business financing in Spain.

It provides a framework for certain financial lending and crowdfunding activities.

Its importance for hybrid financial institutions arises from the development of alternative credit channels that operate alongside conventional banks.

However, crowdfunding activities must also be considered under Regulation (EU) 2020/1503, which establishes the European crowdfunding service provider regime.

D. Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 on Payment Services

Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 implements important elements of the EU Payment Services Directive 2 (PSD2).

It regulates:

Payment institutions.

Payment initiation services.

Account information services.

Payment transaction execution.

Strong customer authentication.

Authorised and unauthorised transactions.

Consumer protection.

Payment service provider liability.

This legislation is particularly important for hybrid financial institutions because many FinTech businesses operate without being conventional banks.

A payment institution may provide regulated payment services without possessing a banking licence.

However, a payment institution cannot simply undertake all activities reserved for a credit institution.

E. Law 21/2011 on Electronic Money

Electronic money institutions are subject to a separate regulatory framework.

Electronic money involves electronically stored monetary value representing a claim against the issuer, issued on receipt of funds and accepted by persons other than the issuer.

Electronic money institutions may provide payment services and issue electronic money subject to the applicable authorisation and prudential requirements.

They are not automatically equivalent to banks and cannot treat customer electronic money balances as ordinary bank deposits.

F. Law 7/2020 on the Digital Transformation of the Financial System

Law 7/2020 establishes the Spanish financial regulatory sandbox.

It enables innovative financial technology projects to be tested under controlled conditions and with appropriate safeguards.

The sandbox supports:

Financial innovation.

Artificial intelligence applications.

Digital banking.

Blockchain-based services.

Automated financial advice.

Innovative payment infrastructure.

Regulatory cooperation.

Participation in the sandbox does not automatically grant a banking licence or exemption from applicable financial legislation.

3. European Union Regulatory Framework

Spanish hybrid financial institutions must also comply with EU financial legislation.

A. Capital Requirements Regulation and Capital Requirements Directive

Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 (CRR), as amended, and Directive 2013/36/EU (CRD), as amended, establish important prudential requirements for credit institutions.

They cover:

Minimum capital requirements.

Liquidity requirements.

Leverage ratios.

Credit risk.

Operational risk.

Governance.

Supervisory review.

Large exposures.

The revised CRR and CRD framework must be considered alongside the applicable EU implementation timetable.

Hybrid institutions that are licensed banks cannot claim reduced prudential obligations simply because their services are digitally delivered.

B. PSD2 and the Payment Services Framework

Directive (EU) 2015/2366 regulates payment services across the European Union.

It recognises several important payment service categories, including:

Payment institutions.

Payment initiation service providers.

Account information service providers.

Electronic money institutions.

Credit institutions providing payment services.

PSD2 has encouraged cooperation between traditional banks and technology-based financial service providers.

The regulatory objective is to encourage competition while maintaining customer protection and payment security.

C. Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II)

Directive 2014/65/EU applies where hybrid financial institutions provide investment services.

Relevant services include:

Investment advice.

Portfolio management.

Reception and transmission of orders.

Execution of financial instrument transactions.

Operation of trading platforms.

A FinTech company providing automated investment recommendations may fall within the investment services regulatory framework depending on the substance of its activities.

D. Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation (MiCA)

Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 establishes a harmonised regulatory framework for crypto-assets.

MiCA regulates crypto-asset service providers and specified categories of crypto-assets.

It introduces requirements concerning:

Authorisation.

Governance.

Client asset protection.

Conflicts of interest.

Complaints handling.

Disclosure.

Operational resilience.

Market abuse prevention.

MiCA has applied generally since 30 December 2024, with certain provisions applying earlier.

Its transitional arrangements have now expired by November 2026.

A hybrid financial institution providing crypto-asset services must assess whether it falls within the MiCA authorisation framework.

Traditional banking authorisation alone does not automatically authorise every crypto-asset service.

E. Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA)

Regulation (EU) 2022/2554, known as DORA, has applied since 17 January 2025.

It is particularly important for hybrid financial institutions.

DORA establishes requirements concerning:

ICT risk management.

Digital operational resilience.

Cybersecurity.

Incident reporting.

ICT third-party service providers.

Digital resilience testing.

Business continuity.

ICT concentration risk.

Financial institutions relying on cloud computing, outsourced software, digital identity systems and external payment infrastructure must maintain appropriate oversight of these arrangements.

F. Anti-Money Laundering Legislation

Spain's Law 10/2010 on the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing remains a central part of the domestic framework.

Hybrid financial institutions may be subject to:

Customer identification.

Beneficial ownership verification.

Customer due diligence.

Enhanced due diligence.

Transaction monitoring.

Suspicious transaction reporting.

Recordkeeping.

Internal compliance controls.

The EU AML regulatory framework, including the AML package adopted in 2024, must also be considered according to its respective application dates.

4. Regulatory Classification of Hybrid Financial Institutions

A major legal issue is determining the correct regulatory classification of an institution.

Different activities attract different licences.

A. Hybrid Banking Institutions

These are institutions holding a banking licence while providing digital financial services.

They remain subject to banking authorisation, prudential requirements, capital rules and banking supervision.

B. FinTech Payment Institutions

These institutions provide payment services without necessarily accepting deposits as a bank.

Their activities are principally regulated under the payment services framework.

C. Electronic Money Institutions

These institutions issue electronic money and may provide associated payment services.

They must comply with the applicable safeguarding and prudential requirements.

D. Banking-FinTech Partnerships

These arrangements involve a licensed bank working with a technology company.

The bank may provide the regulated financial product, while the FinTech company supplies:

Digital interfaces.

Customer onboarding technology.

Credit scoring.

Payment infrastructure.

Identity verification.

Customer support.

Cloud computing.

The bank cannot transfer its ultimate regulatory responsibility merely by outsourcing these functions.

E. Crowdfunding and Digital Lending Institutions

Crowdfunding platforms may fall under Regulation (EU) 2020/1503 where they facilitate covered business funding activities.

Other lending models must be assessed under the relevant Spanish and EU credit, consumer protection and financial services laws.

5. Role of Spanish Financial Supervisory Authorities

Several authorities supervise hybrid financial institutions in Spain.

A. Banco de España

The Banco de España is responsible for important aspects of banking supervision and oversight of payment institutions and electronic money institutions.

Its responsibilities include:

Banking authorisation and supervision within its competence.

Prudential supervision of relevant institutions.

Payment services supervision.

Electronic money supervision.

Financial stability.

Supervisory enforcement.

It also participates in the European banking supervisory framework.

B. European Central Bank

The ECB supervises significant credit institutions under the Single Supervisory Mechanism (SSM).

Less significant institutions are generally supervised directly by national competent authorities, subject to the ECB's oversight powers.

The ECB is particularly relevant when a hybrid institution operates as a significant banking group.

C. Comisión Nacional del Mercado de Valores (CNMV)

The CNMV supervises Spanish securities markets and relevant investment service providers.

Its responsibilities include:

Investment service regulation.

Securities market supervision.

Investor protection.

Market abuse enforcement.

Supervision of relevant crypto-asset service providers under the applicable framework.

D. SEPBLAC

SEPBLAC is Spain's Financial Intelligence Unit and the competent authority for important AML-related functions.

It receives and analyses suspicious transaction information and performs supervisory functions within the Spanish AML framework.

E. Agencia Española de Protección de Datos (AEPD)

The AEPD supervises compliance with data protection legislation.

Hybrid financial institutions processing customer financial data must comply with the GDPR and applicable Spanish data protection legislation.

6. Capital Adequacy and Prudential Regulation

One of the principal legal challenges for hybrid financial institutions is determining the applicable capital requirements.

A fully authorised credit institution must comply with the relevant CRR and CRD requirements.

These include:

Common Equity Tier 1 capital.

Additional Tier 1 capital.

Tier 2 capital.

Risk-weighted assets.

Liquidity coverage requirements.

Net stable funding requirements.

Leverage requirements.

The regulatory requirements depend on the institution's classification and applicable exemptions.

A payment institution or electronic money institution is subject to its own prudential regime rather than automatically being treated as a bank.

This distinction is important because a technology company providing payment services cannot claim that it is exempt from all financial supervision simply because it does not accept traditional deposits.

7. Governance and Management Responsibilities

Hybrid financial institutions often combine conventional financial management with technology-based operational systems.

This creates additional governance risks.

Spanish banking governance requirements and applicable EU prudential standards require appropriate management oversight.

Important governance obligations include:

Fit and proper assessment of directors.

Independent risk management.

Compliance functions.

Internal audit.

Conflict-of-interest management.

Operational risk monitoring.

Cybersecurity governance.

Outsourcing oversight.

Senior management remains responsible for ensuring that outsourced technology systems do not undermine regulatory compliance.

A bank cannot defend a regulatory breach merely by arguing that the relevant failure occurred within an external technology provider.

8. Outsourcing and Cloud Computing Risks

Hybrid financial institutions frequently rely on external service providers.

Examples include:

Cloud hosting companies.

Artificial intelligence service providers.

Digital identity verification companies.

Payment processors.

Cybersecurity contractors.

Customer relationship management platforms.

DORA creates a detailed regulatory framework for ICT risk management and third-party ICT arrangements.

Financial institutions must maintain:

A documented ICT risk management framework.

Appropriate contractual safeguards.

Access and audit rights.

Incident notification arrangements.

Business continuity arrangements.

Exit strategies.

Monitoring of critical ICT providers.

Outsourcing does not remove the financial institution's responsibility towards its regulators or customers.

9. Consumer Protection and Customer Rights

Hybrid financial institutions must comply with the relevant consumer protection rules.

The applicable legislation depends on the nature of the financial product.

Important areas include:

Transparent pricing.

Clear contractual information.

Fair lending practices.

Protection against misleading advertising.

Unauthorised payment transaction liability.

Complaint handling.

Data protection.

Responsible lending.

Protection against unfair contractual terms.

For consumer credit, Spanish Law 16/2011 on Consumer Credit Contracts is particularly relevant.

Where mortgage lending is involved, Law 5/2019 regulating real estate credit contracts may apply.

Digital lending platforms must not use their technology-based structure to circumvent consumer protection requirements.

10. Artificial Intelligence and Algorithmic Lending

Artificial intelligence is increasingly used by hybrid financial institutions for credit assessment, fraud detection and customer profiling.

These activities create legal risks involving:

Algorithmic discrimination.

Inaccurate credit scoring.

Lack of transparency.

Unlawful processing of personal data.

Automated decision-making.

Model risk.

Inadequate human oversight.

The EU Artificial Intelligence Act, Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, is relevant to financial institutions using AI systems.

AI systems used for evaluating the creditworthiness of natural persons or establishing their credit score generally fall within the high-risk category, subject to the precise scope and exceptions of the Regulation.

The principal obligations include appropriate risk management, data governance, technical documentation, recordkeeping, transparency and human oversight, as applicable.

Financial institutions must also consider Articles 5, 6, 13, 14 and 22 of the GDPR where relevant.

11. Financial Stability and Systemic Risk

Hybrid financial institutions can create new forms of financial stability risk.

Examples include:

Concentration of financial infrastructure in a small number of cloud providers.

Rapid digital bank withdrawals.

Cyberattacks against payment infrastructure.

Automated lending failures.

Liquidity pressures arising from digital banking.

Operational dependence on external technology providers.

Contagion between traditional banks and FinTech companies.

The regulatory approach must therefore consider both conventional financial risk and technology-related operational risk.

DORA, CRR, CRD and the applicable ECB and Banco de España supervisory frameworks are important in this context.

12. Important Case Laws

There is no single landmark Spanish Supreme Court judgment establishing a comprehensive legal category of hybrid financial institutions. The following judgments are relevant to the principal legal questions arising from their operation.

Case 1: European Federation for Financial Institutions v European Banking Authority (EBA), Case C-911/19, Judgment of 15 July 2021

This is an important judgment concerning the legal status and supervisory significance of EBA guidelines.

The Court of Justice examined the legal effects of guidelines issued by the European Banking Authority.

Legal principle:

EBA guidelines do not generally have the same binding legal force as EU legislative acts. Nevertheless, national competent authorities must make every effort to comply with them and explain their position where they do not intend to follow them.

Relevance to hybrid financial institutions:

Hybrid banks and FinTech institutions operate within a regulatory environment where supervisory guidelines are important.

The judgment clarifies the legal significance of supervisory guidance and the distinction between binding legislation and supervisory soft law.

Case 2: Lexitor Sp. z o.o. v Spółdzielcza Kasa Oszczędnościowo-Kredytowa im. Franciszka Stefczyka, Case C-383/18, Judgment of 11 September 2019

The case concerned the calculation of costs refundable to consumers following early repayment of consumer credit.

The CJEU interpreted Article 16(1) of Directive 2008/48/EC.

Legal principle:

A consumer who repays a credit agreement early is entitled to a reduction in the total cost of credit, including costs that do not depend on the duration of the agreement, subject to the interpretation of the Directive.

Relevance:

Digital lending platforms and hybrid banking institutions offering consumer credit must comply with applicable early repayment rights and transparent cost disclosure requirements.

Case 3: Banco Español de Crédito SA v Joaquín Calderón Camino, Case C-618/10, Judgment of 14 June 2012

The case concerned unfair contractual terms in consumer financial agreements.

The CJEU considered the obligations of national courts under Directive 93/13/EEC.

Legal principle:

National courts must examine potentially unfair contractual terms and must provide effective consumer protection.

The judgment also addressed the limitations on judicial modification of unfair contractual terms.

Relevance:

Hybrid financial institutions frequently use standardised digital loan agreements.

The use of automated acceptance systems does not exempt financial institutions from unfair terms legislation.

Case 4: Andriciuc and Others v Banca Românească SA, Case C-186/16, Judgment of 20 September 2017

The case concerned foreign currency loan agreements and the transparency of contractual terms.

Legal principle:

Contractual transparency requires consumers to understand the potentially significant economic consequences of contractual obligations.

A consumer must be able to assess the potential financial risks associated with a foreign currency loan.

Relevance:

Hybrid banks offering digitally distributed foreign currency loans must provide understandable information about exchange-rate risks and the financial consequences of their products.

Case 5: DenizBank AG v Verein für Konsumenteninformation, Case C-287/19, Judgment of 11 November 2020

The case concerned contactless payment transactions and the application of PSD2 provisions.

The CJEU examined the treatment of certain contactless payment arrangements under the payment services framework.

Legal principle:

The judgment clarifies the application of PSD2 requirements and the scope of certain exemptions concerning contactless payment instruments.

Relevance:

Digital wallets, contactless payment providers and hybrid payment institutions must carefully determine which PSD2 obligations apply to their products.

Case 6: Verein für Konsumenteninformation v Amazon EU Sàrl, Case C-191/15, Judgment of 28 July 2016

The case concerned consumer protection and contractual choice-of-law clauses in online commercial arrangements.

Legal principle:

Contractual choice-of-law provisions cannot deprive consumers of mandatory protections available under applicable consumer law.

Relevance:

Hybrid financial institutions offering cross-border digital financial services must ensure that contractual terms do not unlawfully exclude mandatory consumer protection rights.

Case 7: Spanish Supreme Court, Judgment No. 149/2020 of 4 March 2020

This judgment concerned revolving credit arrangements and the application of Spanish usury legislation.

The Supreme Court considered the interest rate applicable to a revolving credit agreement under Law of 23 July 1908 on the Suppression of Usury.

Legal principle:

A revolving credit interest rate may be considered usurious where it is substantially higher than the relevant market reference rate under the applicable legal test.

Relevance:

Digital banks and hybrid lending institutions offering revolving credit must ensure that interest rates comply with Spanish usury legislation.

Case 8: Spanish Supreme Court, Judgment No. 258/2023 of 15 February 2023

This judgment further addressed revolving credit and the assessment of potentially usurious interest rates.

Legal principle:

The Supreme Court refined the approach to comparing revolving credit interest rates with the appropriate market reference rate.

Relevance:

Hybrid institutions using automated revolving credit products must ensure that their pricing structures comply with the Supreme Court's interpretation of Spanish usury legislation.

13. Liability of Hybrid Financial Institutions

Hybrid institutions may incur several types of legal liability.

A. Administrative Liability

Regulatory breaches may result in administrative sanctions.

Examples include:

Operating without the necessary authorisation.

Failure to maintain required capital.

Inadequate AML controls.

Failure to comply with payment services requirements.

Breach of cybersecurity obligations.

Inadequate outsourcing arrangements.

B. Civil Liability

Institutions may face civil claims arising from:

Unauthorised transactions.

Negligent financial advice.

Misleading disclosures.

Unfair contractual terms.

Failure to protect customer funds.

Improper handling of customer information.

C. Criminal Liability

Under applicable Spanish criminal law, financial institutions and individuals may face criminal consequences for conduct involving fraud, money laundering, unlawful access to systems or other relevant offences.

Corporate criminal liability must be assessed under Article 31 bis of the Spanish Criminal Code.

D. Data Protection Liability

The GDPR and Spanish data protection legislation may result in administrative fines and other remedies where personal data are processed unlawfully.

14. Cross-Border Supervision and European Banking Passport

Hybrid financial institutions operating across EU Member States must consider the European single-market framework.

A credit institution authorised in one Member State may provide services or establish branches in another Member State under the applicable passporting framework.

Similar passporting arrangements exist for qualifying payment institutions, electronic money institutions, investment firms and authorised crowdfunding service providers.

However, passporting depends on the relevant regulatory category and compliance with applicable notification procedures.

An institution cannot assume that authorisation for one financial activity automatically permits every other financial activity throughout the EU.

15. Major Regulatory Challenges in Spain

The principal regulatory challenges include:

Regulatory classification: Determining whether a FinTech entity requires a banking, payment institution, electronic money or investment services authorisation.

Regulatory arbitrage: Preventing companies from structuring their business models to avoid financial regulation.

Outsourcing: Ensuring that technology providers do not undermine regulatory accountability.

Cybersecurity: Protecting payment systems and customer financial information.

Artificial intelligence: Preventing discriminatory or inaccurate algorithmic credit decisions.

Consumer protection: Ensuring that digital contracts provide transparent and fair terms.

AML compliance: Preventing digital financial channels from facilitating money laundering.

Cross-border supervision: Coordinating Banco de España, CNMV, ECB and other European authorities.

Financial stability: Monitoring operational concentration and interconnected financial risks.

Crypto-asset regulation: Ensuring that institutions providing crypto services comply with MiCA.

16. Recommendations for Improving Hybrid Financial Institution Regulation

Spain should continue developing a proportionate but technologically neutral regulatory framework.

Important regulatory improvements include:

Strengthening coordination between Banco de España and CNMV.

Improving supervisory monitoring of digital lending.

Enhancing cybersecurity requirements.

Strengthening AI governance and algorithmic accountability.

Increasing transparency in digital credit agreements.

Improving cloud outsourcing supervision.

Strengthening customer fund safeguarding.

Developing effective cross-border supervisory cooperation.

Encouraging responsible financial innovation through the regulatory sandbox.

Improving regulatory reporting for interconnected financial institutions.

The regulatory framework should encourage financial innovation without compromising financial stability, consumer protection and market integrity.

17. Conclusion

Hybrid Financial Institutions represent an important development in Spain's modern financial system.

They combine conventional banking activities with digital payments, electronic money, alternative lending, investment services, artificial intelligence and technology-based financial infrastructure.

Spanish law does not create a single universal licence for hybrid financial institutions. Instead, regulation is determined by the activities performed and the relevant statutory classification.

Law 10/2014, Royal Decree-Law 19/2018, Law 21/2011 and Law 7/2020 form important parts of the domestic framework, while EU legislation such as CRR, CRD, PSD2, MiFID II, MiCA, DORA and the AI Act provides additional regulatory obligations.

The Banco de España, CNMV, ECB, SEPBLAC and AEPD play important roles in ensuring compliance.

The central legal principle is that technological innovation does not eliminate financial regulatory responsibility. Hybrid institutions must comply with the regulatory obligations applicable to their actual activities, protect customers, maintain operational resilience and preserve the stability of the Spanish financial system.

Accordingly, Spain's regulatory approach seeks to achieve a balance between financial innovation, prudential supervision, consumer protection, cybersecurity and European financial market integration.

18. Important Legislative References

Spanish Law 10/2014 on the Regulation, Supervision and Solvency of Credit Institutions.

Royal Decree 84/2015.

Spanish Law 5/2015 on the Promotion of Business Financing.

Royal Decree-Law 19/2018 on Payment Services.

Spanish Law 21/2011 on Electronic Money.

Spanish Law 7/2020 on the Digital Transformation of the Financial System.

Spanish Law 10/2010 on the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing.

Spanish Law 16/2011 on Consumer Credit Contracts.

Spanish Law 5/2019 regulating Real Estate Credit Contracts.

Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 (CRR), as amended.

Directive 2013/36/EU (CRD), as amended.

Directive (EU) 2015/2366 (PSD2).

Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II).

Regulation (EU) 2020/1503 on European Crowdfunding Service Providers.

Regulation (EU) 2022/2554 (DORA).

Regulation (EU) 2023/1114 (MiCA).

Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (Artificial Intelligence Act).

Regulation (EU) 2016/679 (GDPR).

Directive 2008/48/EC on Consumer Credit.

Directive 93/13/EEC on Unfair Terms in Consumer Contracts.

Overall legal position: Hybrid financial institutions in Spain are governed by an activity-based regulatory framework. Their digital or hybrid character does not exempt them from licensing, prudential supervision, consumer protection, AML, data protection or operational resilience obligations.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT