Assisted Suicide and Passive Euthanasia
Assisted Suicide and Passive Euthanasia
1. Definitions
Assisted Suicide:
When a person voluntarily helps another person to end their own life, usually by providing means or information to commit suicide. The key point is that the final act is done by the person who wants to die, with help.
Passive Euthanasia:
The deliberate withdrawal or withholding of life-sustaining medical treatment (like a ventilator or feeding tube) allowing a patient to die naturally from their illness. The patient is not actively killed, but death is permitted to occur.
2. Differences
| Feature | Assisted Suicide | Passive Euthanasia |
|---|---|---|
| Action | Providing means or aid for suicide | Withholding/withdrawing medical treatment |
| Who performs final act? | The patient themselves | Nature takes its course once treatment stops |
| Legal Status | Often criminal or highly restricted | Sometimes permitted under strict guidelines |
3. Legal and Ethical Issues
Both deal with ending human life, raising questions about:
Right to life vs. right to die
Autonomy and consent
Medical ethics and “do no harm”
Potential for abuse or coercion
Courts weigh these factors carefully, often requiring:
Clear and informed consent by the patient.
Terminal illness or unbearable suffering.
Guidelines to prevent misuse.
4. Important Case Law
A. Passive Euthanasia: Aruna Shanbaug Case
Aruna Shanbaug was in a vegetative state for decades after an assault.
The Supreme Court recognized passive euthanasia as legally permissible in certain circumstances, where treatment can be withdrawn with court approval.
The judgment stressed:
Respect for human dignity.
Need for strict safeguards.
Only passive euthanasia allowed (not active killing).
This case established legal recognition of passive euthanasia under strict controls.
B. Assisted Suicide: Common Legal Stance
Assisted suicide is generally prohibited or criminalized because:
It can be misused.
It involves direct help to cause death.
Courts are reluctant to legalize it but may recognize the right to refuse treatment (passive euthanasia) as distinct.
5. Summary
| Aspect | Passive Euthanasia | Assisted Suicide |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Withholding life support | Helping someone to commit suicide |
| Legal Recognition | Allowed with strict safeguards (e.g., Aruna Shanbaug) | Generally illegal or restricted |
| Ethical Considerations | Seen as allowing natural death | Involves active assistance, controversial |
| Consent Requirement | Patient consent or legal guardian's decision | Patient’s voluntary request essential |
6. Conclusion
Passive euthanasia is gradually gaining legal acceptance under strict conditions, recognizing the patient's right to die with dignity without unnecessary suffering.
Assisted suicide remains largely illegal due to ethical concerns and risk of misuse.
Courts differentiate clearly between allowing to die (passive) and helping to die (active).
RELATED Blog
0 comments