Bonus Share Issuance Rules
Bonus Share Issuance — Legal Framework & Issues
1. What is a Bonus Issue?
A bonus issue is the capitalization of a company’s reserves into share capital by issuing fully paid shares to existing shareholders free of cost, in proportion to their holdings.
👉 No cash inflow
👉 No change in total shareholder wealth
👉 Conversion of reserves → share capital
It is also called a scrip issue or capitalization issue.
2. Legal Framework in India
Companies Act, 2013
| Provision | Role |
|---|---|
| Section 63 | Governs issue of bonus shares |
| Section 52 | Securities premium can be used |
| Section 123 | Dividend rules (contrast with bonus) |
SEBI (ICDR) Regulations & LODR
For listed companies:
Stock exchange approval
Disclosure of reserves, ratio, record date
No default in debt obligations
Restrictions if company has outstanding convertible instruments
3. Sources for Bonus Shares
Allowed only from:
✔ Free reserves
✔ Securities premium account
✔ Capital redemption reserve
❌ NOT allowed from:
Revaluation reserves
Unrealized gains
Capital reserves not realized in cash
4. Conditions for Bonus Issue
Authorized by Articles of Association
Board recommendation
Shareholder approval (if required)
No default in:
Deposits
Debt securities
Statutory dues
Partly paid shares must be made fully paid first
Cannot be issued in lieu of dividend
5. Key Legal Principles
A. Bonus is Capitalization, Not Distribution
It is not income; it’s a rearrangement of capital structure.
B. Protection of Creditors
Bonus must not weaken capital base.
C. Equality of Shareholders
Bonus must be proportionate within a class.
D. No Artificial Inflation of Capital
Cannot use fictitious or revaluation profits.
E. Regulatory Disclosure
Listed companies must ensure transparent disclosures.
6. Major Legal Issues
Use of improper reserves
Bonus during financial distress
Issuing bonus while in default
Misleading market by announcing bonus without capacity
Bonus issue to influence share price (market manipulation concerns)
7. Important Case Laws
1. Dalmia Investment Co. Ltd. v. CIT (1964, SC India)
Bonus shares are not income but capital.
Clarified accounting and tax nature.
2. CIT v. General Insurance Corporation (2006, SC India)
Capitalization of reserves does not amount to distribution of profits.
3. Kesoram Industries & Cotton Mills Ltd. v. CWT (1966, SC India)
Bonus issue represents conversion of reserves into capital, not fresh wealth.
4. Re Spanish Prospecting Co. Ltd. (1911, UK)
Only realized profits can be capitalized; fictitious profits invalid.
5. Re Evans & Sons Ltd. (1939, UK)
Revaluation reserves cannot support bonus issue.
6. Gold Mohore Investment Co. Ltd. v. CIT (1969, SC India)
Bonus shares do not represent income; reinforces capital nature.
**7. SEBI v. Rakhi Trading Pvt. Ltd. (2018, SC India)
(Principle relevant to misuse of corporate actions)**
Corporate actions that distort market fairness can attract regulatory scrutiny.
**8. McDowell & Co. Ltd. v. CTO (1985, SC India)
(Principle on colorable devices)**
Corporate structuring cannot be used as a device to evade law — applies if bonus issue misused.
8. Consequences of Non-Compliance
| Violation | Legal Consequence |
|---|---|
| Bonus from improper reserves | Voidable issue |
| Misleading disclosure | SEBI penalties |
| Bonus during debt default | Regulatory bar |
| Unequal allotment | Oppression claims |
| Manipulative intent | Market abuse proceedings |
9. Governance Best Practices
✔ Auditor certification of reserves
✔ Legal opinion on eligibility
✔ Clear board resolution stating source of funds
✔ Exchange filings before record date
✔ Stress test liquidity post-issue
✔ Avoid bonus during financial stress
10. Bonus Issue vs Dividend vs Rights Issue
| Feature | Bonus Issue | Dividend | Rights Issue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cash Outflow | No | Yes | Yes (from shareholders) |
| Nature | Capitalization | Distribution | Capital raising |
| Shareholding Pattern | Same proportion | Same | May change |
| Regulatory Focus | Reserve integrity | Profit sufficiency | Disclosure & pricing |
Summary
Bonus share issuance is a balance sheet restructuring tool, not a reward distribution. Courts insist on:
Real, realized reserves
No prejudice to creditors
Equal shareholder treatment
No market manipulation
Cases like Dalmia Investment, Spanish Prospecting, and Evans & Sons show that misuse of reserves can invalidate the issue and trigger regulatory action.
RELATED Blog
comments