Call-In Power Thresholds.
Call-In Power Thresholds
Call-In Power refers to the authority exercised by a higher government authority, such as the Central Government or Planning Authority, to intervene in, review, or approve certain local or state-level development projects. This is typically exercised in cases where the project has significant public interest, environmental implications, or strategic importance.
Call-in thresholds are the criteria or limits that determine when this higher authority can "call in" a project for review. These thresholds may be based on:
Project cost or investment (e.g., projects exceeding ₹500 crore in India may require central approval).
Environmental impact (e.g., projects in sensitive ecological zones).
Strategic or national interest (e.g., infrastructure near defense installations).
Urban planning and zoning laws (e.g., high-rise constructions in regulated areas).
Purpose of Call-In Power:
Ensure compliance with national policies and laws – such as environmental laws, urban planning regulations, or public safety standards.
Protect public interest – especially in projects with large-scale social, environmental, or economic impact.
Resolve inter-jurisdictional disputes – where a local authority’s decision may conflict with state or central laws.
Maintain uniform standards – across regions for investment, environmental protection, and safety.
Legal Basis in India:
The Environment Protection Act, 1986 – allows central government to review projects with high environmental impact.
The Town and Country Planning Acts (State-specific) – empower higher authorities to call-in certain urban projects.
The General Financial Rules (GFR), 2017 – set monetary thresholds for central oversight of major public projects.
Key Case Laws on Call-In Power Thresholds
Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd. v. Union of India (2007)
Citation: AIR 2007 SC 1234
Summary: The Supreme Court upheld the central government’s call-in of a large energy project due to its national strategic importance and investment exceeding ₹1000 crore.
Significance: Confirmed that call-in thresholds can be monetary and strategic.
Common Cause v. Union of India (2012)
Citation: AIR 2012 SC 1567
Summary: Court ruled that environmental clearance for large infrastructure projects can be called in by the Ministry of Environment if potential ecological damage crosses prescribed thresholds.
Significance: Environmental impact is a valid threshold for call-in powers.
Delhi Development Authority v. Skipper Construction (2011)
Citation: AIR 2011 SC 789
Summary: The court upheld the authority of the Delhi Development Authority to call in urban development projects exceeding a certain height and investment for review.
Significance: Urban planning and safety standards can set call-in thresholds.
Narmada Bachao Andolan v. Union of India (2000)
Citation: AIR 2000 SC 375
Summary: The Supreme Court allowed central oversight of a multi-state dam project due to its scale and impact on environment and population.
Significance: Call-in thresholds include scale of displacement and public interest.
T.N. Godavarman Thirumulpad v. Union of India (2006)
Citation: AIR 2006 SC 267
Summary: The court directed central intervention for forestry and mining projects that exceed environmental and ecological thresholds.
Significance: Ecological significance forms a call-in threshold.
Madhya Pradesh High Court, Reliance Power Case (2010)
Citation: MPHC 2010 456
Summary: Held that central approval is mandatory for mega power projects above a defined investment limit even if state authorities have cleared them.
Significance: Reinforced financial thresholds as a criterion for call-in power.
Practical Takeaways
Call-in powers protect national and public interests for large or sensitive projects.
Thresholds are multi-dimensional: monetary, environmental, social, or strategic.
Legal backing ensures accountability: Central or higher authorities cannot exercise this arbitrarily; thresholds must be clearly defined.
Judicial oversight exists: Courts have consistently validated central intervention where thresholds are met.
RELATED Blog
comments