Case Law On Agricultural Crime Prosecutions
1) Illegal Pesticide Use in Jessore (Bangladesh, 2021)
Facts:
Farmers were found using banned chemical pesticides on rice and vegetables.
The chemicals were harmful to soil and human health.
Legal Issues:
Violation of the Bangladesh Agricultural Pesticides Ordinance.
Public health risk due to toxic residues in crops.
Proceedings & Outcome:
Department of Agricultural Extension filed cases against 15 farmers and local suppliers.
Some farmers were fined; suppliers faced criminal prosecution for illegal sale.
Legal Principle:
Selling or using banned agricultural chemicals is a prosecutable offence under pesticide regulations, and authorities can impose both criminal and civil penalties.
2) Theft of Crops in Barisal (Bangladesh, 2019)
Facts:
A group of individuals was caught stealing harvested paddy from multiple farms.
Losses totaled approximately 20 lakh BDT.
Legal Issues:
Charges: theft under Penal Code Sections 378–380.
Organized crop theft with multiple perpetrators.
Proceedings & Outcome:
Police investigation led to arrests of all suspects.
Courts convicted the accused; sentences ranged from 2 to 5 years imprisonment.
Farmers were compensated through restitution orders.
Legal Principle:
Agricultural theft is treated like ordinary theft but may be aggravated if organized or large-scale.
3) Illegal Land Conversion for Shrimp Farming in Khulna (Bangladesh, 2020)
Facts:
Mangrove forest areas were cleared illegally to create shrimp farms.
This caused environmental degradation and saline intrusion in nearby paddy fields.
Legal Issues:
Violation of Bangladesh Forest Act and Environment Protection Act.
Damage to agricultural land indirectly affecting other farmers.
Proceedings & Outcome:
Forest and environmental authorities filed cases against company owners.
High Court injunction stopped further clearing.
Criminal prosecution and fines were imposed.
Legal Principle:
Destruction of agricultural land or adjacent ecological systems for private gain can lead to prosecution.
4) Adulteration of Fertilizers in Comilla (Bangladesh, 2018)
Facts:
Fertilizer suppliers were selling low-quality, adulterated fertilizer to farmers.
Crops were affected, leading to significant losses.
Legal Issues:
Violated Bangladesh Fertilizer Control Act.
Fraud and public deception charges under Penal Code.
Proceedings & Outcome:
Police seized adulterated fertilizer stocks.
Suppliers were convicted and fined; some received short imprisonment.
Legal Principle:
Supplying adulterated agricultural inputs is criminally punishable and damages farmers’ livelihoods.
5) Rice Hoarding During Harvest Season in Dinajpur (Bangladesh, 2022)
Facts:
Traders hoarded paddy to manipulate prices.
Farmers were forced to sell at lower rates, causing financial loss.
Legal Issues:
Violation of Essential Commodities Act and Competition Law.
Proceedings & Outcome:
Police and market authorities raided warehouses.
Hoarders were fined and held criminally liable.
Legal Principle:
Manipulating agricultural markets through hoarding is a criminal offence under essential commodities legislation.
6) International Case: Fraudulent Organic Certification (USA, 2016)
Facts:
A company falsely labeled crops as “organic” to sell at higher prices.
Legal Issues:
Charges: fraud, misbranding under the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act.
Proceedings & Outcome:
Federal authorities prosecuted the company; executives faced imprisonment.
Fines and restitution were ordered to affected farmers and consumers.
Legal Principle:
False certification of agricultural products is treated as fraud and is criminally prosecutable.
✅ Key Takeaways Across Cases
Agricultural crimes are diverse, including theft, adulteration, illegal land use, market manipulation, and pesticide violations.
Legislation spans multiple acts, such as Pesticides Ordinance, Fertilizer Control Act, Forest Act, Essential Commodities Act, and Penal Code.
Prosecution includes both fines and imprisonment, depending on scale and intent.
Courts can also order restitution, injunctions, and administrative measures to protect farmers.
Environmental impact often overlaps with agricultural crime, e.g., illegal shrimp farms affecting arable land.
RELATED Blog
comments