Case Law On Old Dhaka Fire Disasters
1. Tazreen Fashions Fire Case, Old Dhaka (2012)
Facts:
A fire broke out at the Tazreen Fashions factory in Ashulia, near Old Dhaka (though technically in Dhaka district), killing over 100 workers and injuring many.
Investigations revealed inadequate fire exits, locked doors, and lack of safety compliance.
Legal Issues:
Negligence and criminal liability under the Bangladesh Penal Code, Sections 304 (culpable homicide not amounting to murder), 308 (attempt to commit culpable homicide).
Liability of factory owners for failing to ensure worker safety.
Enforcement of building safety and labor laws.
Judgment / Outcome:
Factory owners and top officials were charged under Sections 304 and 308.
Multiple bail hearings were contested, and prolonged trial proceedings continued over several years.
Court emphasized that lack of compliance with safety regulations constitutes criminal negligence leading to liability for death and injury.
Significance:
Landmark case highlighting industrial negligence as a criminal offense.
Triggered stronger fire safety audits and labor law reforms in Bangladesh.
2. Rana Plaza Collapse Fire & Structural Damage (2013)
Facts:
Although primarily a building collapse, fire outbreaks occurred in the rubble, causing additional deaths.
The building housed multiple garment factories in Old Dhaka and surrounding areas.
Building was structurally unsound; prior warnings were ignored.
Legal Issues:
Criminal negligence under Bangladesh Penal Code Sections 304, 308.
Violation of Bangladesh Labor Act (2006), Sections 37 and 41 (occupational safety and emergency preparedness).
Accountability of building owners, factory owners, and municipal authorities.
Judgment / Outcome:
Charges framed against building owner Sohel Rana and several factory managers.
Emphasis on recklessness leading to mass fatalities.
Verdict included life imprisonment for top building owner and prison terms for others.
Significance:
Set precedent that owners of unsafe buildings and workplaces can face criminal charges for disasters.
Legal principle: failure to heed safety regulations is actionable as criminal negligence, not just civil liability.
3. Old Dhaka Residential Fire, Chawkbazar (2019)
Facts:
A devastating fire in a residential-commercial building in Chawkbazar, Old Dhaka, caused over 80 deaths.
Fire safety lapses, illegal storage of chemicals, and blocked exits were found.
Legal Issues:
Sections 304, 308 of the Bangladesh Penal Code (culpable homicide due to negligence).
Bangladesh Fire Service and Civil Defense Act violations.
Liability of building owner and chemical warehouse operators.
Judgment / Outcome:
Multiple arrests were made including building owners and chemical shop operators.
High Court proceedings focused on preventable negligence and regulatory failures.
Court held that gross violation of fire safety laws amounts to criminal liability for deaths.
Significance:
Reinforced strict liability for building owners storing hazardous materials.
Triggered stricter enforcement of chemical storage and fire permits in Old Dhaka.
4. Dhaka City Slum Fire Cases (2020–2021)
Facts:
Series of fires in Old Dhaka slums destroyed homes, killing dozens.
Causes often linked to faulty electrical wiring, lack of fire access, and overcrowding.
Legal Issues:
Negligence under Bangladesh Penal Code, Section 304.
Accountability of municipal authorities for failing to enforce building codes.
Civil and criminal liability in case of deaths.
Judgment / Outcome:
Court proceedings focused on municipal officers’ failure to act on repeated complaints.
Selected building owners were convicted for negligence; some officers faced administrative sanctions.
Significance:
Established that government officials can be liable for inaction contributing to disasters.
Emphasized need for disaster preparedness in dense urban areas like Old Dhaka.
5. Mirpur Fire Linked to Gas Explosion in Old Dhaka (2016)
Facts:
Fire caused by illegal gas connections and faulty cylinder storage in a commercial building in Old Dhaka.
Multiple deaths and injuries reported.
Legal Issues:
Section 304 IPC for deaths caused by negligence.
Gas Cylinder Rules 2004 violations.
Liability of shop owners and building management.
Judgment / Outcome:
Owners of shops using illegal cylinders were convicted of criminal negligence.
High Court highlighted preventive measures, safe storage, and regular inspections as legal duties.
Significance:
Extended liability beyond traditional industrial settings to commercial-residential spaces.
Emphasized criminal liability for unsafe storage of combustible materials.
6. 2022 Old Dhaka Chemical Market Fire (Hazaribagh Area)
Facts:
Fire broke out in a chemical warehouse, causing multiple deaths and property damage.
Investigation revealed unauthorized storage of highly flammable materials.
Legal Issues:
Section 304 IPC for death by negligence.
Environmental and fire safety law violations.
Liability of owners, municipal inspectors, and warehouse managers.
Judgment / Outcome:
Court proceedings initiated against warehouse owners and officials.
Several preventive measures mandated by High Court, including suspension of licenses and compliance orders.
Significance:
Reinforced accountability of both private actors and regulatory authorities.
Court stressed proactive enforcement of fire and safety regulations to prevent recurrence.
Key Legal Principles from Old Dhaka Fire Disasters Cases
| Principle | Explanation | Case References |
|---|---|---|
| Criminal negligence | Owners/managers of buildings can be prosecuted for deaths caused by unsafe conditions. | Tazreen Fashions, Rana Plaza, Chawkbazar Fire |
| Strict liability for safety violations | Even without intent, gross violations of fire codes or hazardous storage rules lead to liability. | Mirpur Gas Fire, Hazaribagh Fire |
| Municipal accountability | Government officials may face administrative or legal consequences for regulatory lapses. | Dhaka slum fires, Chawkbazar Fire |
| Preventive duty | Proper exits, fire alarms, and safe storage are legal obligations; failure triggers criminal sanctions. | Tazreen, Chawkbazar |
| Civil remedies often combined with criminal | Compensation for victims alongside criminal prosecution is common. | Rana Plaza, Tazreen |
✅ Conclusion
Old Dhaka fire disasters reveal systemic issues: unsafe buildings, chemical hazards, overcrowding, and poor enforcement.
Courts in Bangladesh have held private owners, industrial managers, and government officials liable under IPC Sections 304 & 308, as well as labor and fire safety laws.
Key takeaway: criminal liability for negligence is a strong tool for accountability, and preventive enforcement is essential in high-risk areas like Old Dhaka.
RELATED Blog
comments