Case Law On Protection Of Women And Children Under Uae Law
Case 1: Mother Granted Custody Despite Father’s Objection
Court: UAE Federal Supreme Court, 2015
Facts: A divorced mother applied for custody of her two children after divorce. The father, who had been granted custody initially, opposed, arguing that the children should remain with him due to the mother’s perceived absence from childcare.
Legal Issue: Whether a mother can regain custody despite the father having legal guardianship and initial custody.
Judgment: The Court granted the mother custody, emphasizing the child’s best interest as the primary consideration. It noted that custodial rights are not permanently lost to temporary absence and that the mother’s active role in the child’s upbringing was vital.
Significance: Reaffirmed that UAE courts prioritize the child’s welfare over parental claims and that mothers can regain custody if they prove it benefits the child.
Case 2: Mother Retains Custody Beyond Statutory Age Limit
Court: UAE Federal Supreme Court, 2016
Facts: A mother had custody of her sons. Under older law, custody of boys traditionally transferred to the father when they reached 11. The father demanded transfer based on age.
Legal Issue: Does statutory age automatically determine custody, or can the court exercise discretion based on child welfare?
Judgment: The Court ruled that custody decisions must focus on the child’s welfare, not just age. The mother retained custody because it served the best interest of the child.
Significance: Set a key precedent: numerical age is a guideline, not an automatic determinant, reinforcing a flexible child-centered approach.
Case 3: Mother Loses Custody for Illegal Relocation Abroad
Court: Dubai Personal Status Court, 2017
Facts: A mother, granted custody, took her children abroad without the father’s consent. The father filed for loss of custody.
Legal Issue: Does relocating children abroad without guardian consent automatically affect custody?
Judgment: The court ruled that the mother forfeited custody rights for moving the children illegally. The children were returned to the father, who had legal guardianship.
Significance: Demonstrated strict adherence to guardian consent rules under UAE Personal Status Law and highlighted limits on the custodial parent’s mobility with children.
Case 4: Mother Granted Weekly Visitation Rights
Court: UAE Federal Supreme Court, 2015
Facts: A divorced mother sought regular visitation with her children, who were under father’s custody.
Legal Issue: Does a non-custodial mother have enforceable visitation rights?
Judgment: The Court granted weekly visitation rights, emphasizing that parental access is a child’s right.
Significance: Established that custody loss does not mean visitation loss, balancing parental rights with child welfare.
Case 5: Protection of Children Under Domestic Violence Situations
Court: Abu Dhabi Court of First Instance, 2018
Facts: A mother applied for emergency protection and custody for her children after experiencing domestic violence from her husband.
Legal Issue: Can courts intervene to protect children when the mother faces domestic abuse?
Judgment: The court granted temporary custody to the mother, issued restraining orders against the father, and mandated social services supervision.
Significance: Demonstrated active legal protection for children in abusive households, showing UAE law’s responsiveness to domestic violence.
Case 6: Custody of Children Born Out of Extramarital Relationship
Court: Sharjah Court of First Instance, 2019
Facts: A mother sought custody of her child born out of wedlock. The father contested custody, claiming the child was illegitimate.
Legal Issue: Are children born out of wedlock entitled to custody protection under UAE law?
Judgment: The court granted custody to the mother while recognizing the child’s right to care and protection, ensuring the child’s welfare was prioritized.
Significance: Reinforced child welfare as paramount, regardless of legitimacy status, and strengthened the legal protection of women and children in sensitive family matters.
Case 7: Father’s Guardianship Challenged in Absence of Child Welfare Consideration
Court: Dubai Court of Cassation, 2020
Facts: A father sought to revoke the mother’s custody of his child citing her marital status and relocation plans.
Legal Issue: Can custody be revoked solely based on the parent’s marital or living situation?
Judgment: The court ruled custody decisions must focus solely on child welfare, rejecting arguments based on marital status. Custody remained with the mother.
Significance: Affirmed child welfare as the overriding factor, ensuring that custody decisions cannot be used to punish a parent unjustly.
Key Principles Emerging from UAE Case Law
Child’s Best Interest Supersedes Parental Preference: Every case emphasizes child welfare over procedural or parental convenience.
Custody vs Guardianship: Custody (care) and guardianship (legal authority) are separate; fathers may retain guardianship while mothers have physical custody.
Visitation Rights: Non-custodial parents retain enforceable visitation rights.
Protection from Abuse: Courts actively intervene in domestic violence cases affecting children.
Relocation Limits: Custodial parents cannot unilaterally relocate children abroad without consent.
Flexibility Beyond Statutory Age: Age thresholds for custody transfers are not automatic; courts assess child welfare case-by-case.
RELATED Blog
comments