Civil Law And Sources Of Obligations Contract Tort Law And Enrichment In Uae .

1. Introduction

Under UAE civil law, an obligation is a legally enforceable relationship under which one person (the debtor) must perform an act, refrain from an act, or pay or deliver something to another person (the creditor).

The three principal sources of civil obligations are:

Contract – obligations arising from an agreement between parties.

Tort or civil liability – obligations arising from wrongful conduct that causes legally recognised harm.

Unjust enrichment – obligations to restore a benefit obtained without a lawful basis at another person's expense.

These sources are important in commercial transactions, construction disputes, property claims, banking, professional negligence and compensation proceedings.

The applicable mainland UAE framework must be read in light of Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 promulgating the Civil Transactions Law, which came into force on 1 June 2026, replacing Federal Law No. 5 of 1985. Older judgments remain relevant where they interpret principles carried forward into the new legislation, but the applicable statutory wording and transitional rules must be checked for each dispute.

2. Statutory framework and classification

The new Civil Transactions Law expressly identifies five sources of obligations in Article 112:

Contract

Unilateral act

Harmful act (tort)

Beneficial act (unjust enrichment)

Law

Although this topic focuses on contract, tort and unjust enrichment, the inclusion of unilateral acts and obligations imposed directly by law is important. It means that not every civil obligation requires a prior agreement or wrongful conduct.

Article 113 defines a contract as the binding concurrence of an offer and acceptance producing legal effects. It also states that a contract is the law governing the contracting parties and cannot ordinarily be rescinded or amended except by mutual agreement or a legally recognised reason. Article 114 recognises contracts concerning tangible and intangible property, benefits, services and other lawful subject matter.

UAE Legislation+1

 

The new Code applies from 1 June 2026. Accordingly, references below to older article numbers are identified as historical statutory references where the cited judgments were decided under the former 1985 Code.

UAE Legislation+2

 

3. Contract as a source of obligations

A. Meaning and legal nature

A contract is a voluntary legal arrangement through which parties create reciprocal or unilateral obligations. Once validly formed, it binds the parties and may be enforced through the courts.

Examples include:

A sale contract requiring the seller to transfer ownership and the buyer to pay the price.

A construction contract requiring the contractor to complete specified works.

A lease requiring the landlord to provide possession and the tenant to pay rent.

A loan agreement requiring repayment.

A service agreement requiring performance of agreed professional or technical services.

Contractual obligations may involve giving something, doing something or refraining from doing something.

B. Formation of a contract

A contract generally requires the following elements:

Offer: A sufficiently definite proposal to enter into a legal relationship.

Acceptance: Agreement to the offer on its terms.

Consent: A genuine meeting of the parties' intentions.

Capacity: The parties must have the legal capacity to contract.

Lawful subject matter: The object must be legally permissible.

Recognised legal effect: The agreement must be capable of producing the intended legal consequences.

Consent may be affected by mistake, fraud, coercion or other legally recognised defects. The precise consequences depend on the type of defect and the applicable statutory provisions.

C. Binding force and good faith

The principle pacta sunt servanda means that agreements must be performed. The new Code's Article 113 expressly describes the contract as the law governing the parties.

Good faith is also important. Parties should not deliberately frustrate the contractual purpose, abuse contractual powers or perform obligations in a manner inconsistent with the agreement's legitimate expectations.

Good faith does not ordinarily allow a court to rewrite a contract merely because one party later considers the bargain commercially unattractive. Any adjustment or termination must have a legal basis.

D. Breach of contract

A contractual breach may take several forms:

Non-performance: The debtor does not perform at all.

Delay: Performance occurs after the agreed or legally required time.

Defective performance: The debtor performs, but not to the agreed standard.

Partial performance: Only part of the obligation is fulfilled.

Repudiation: A party refuses to perform an obligation.

Depending on the contract and the law, the innocent party may seek:

Specific performance.

Termination or rescission.

Restitution following termination or invalidity.

Compensation for proven loss.

Enforcement of an agreed delay or liquidated-damages clause, subject to judicial control.

Interest where legally recoverable.

E. Force majeure and exceptional circumstances

Force majeure concerns an event that makes performance impossible under the applicable legal test. It may excuse performance or bring the relevant obligation or contract to an end.

This should be distinguished from exceptional circumstances that make performance excessively onerous without rendering it impossible. In the latter situation, the law may permit judicial intervention to restore contractual balance, depending on the statutory conditions.

F. Pre-contractual liability

Not all obligations arise after a contract is signed. A party may incur liability through wrongful conduct during negotiations, such as deliberate deception or bad-faith conduct causing another party reasonably to incur loss.

However, unsuccessful negotiations alone do not automatically create a right to compensation. The claimant must establish the relevant legal basis, wrongful conduct, loss and causal connection.

4. Tort or civil liability as a source of obligations

A. Meaning

Tort liability arises when a person causes legally recognised harm to another through an unlawful act or omission. Unlike contractual liability, it does not necessarily depend on a prior agreement between the parties.

The basic civil-liability structure requires:

Fault or legally attributable harmful conduct.

Damage or loss.

Causation linking the conduct to the damage.

Where the law imposes a special form of liability, such as liability connected with control of dangerous things, the applicable statutory conditions may modify the ordinary fault analysis.

B. Forms of tortious liability

1. Personal fault

A person may be liable for negligent, reckless or intentional conduct that causes injury or financial loss.

Example: A driver negligently causes an accident that damages another person's vehicle.

2. Liability for acts of others

A person or entity may, under the statutory conditions, be responsible for harm caused by an employee, subordinate or another person for whom the law makes them answerable.

Example: An employer may face liability for an employee's harmful conduct committed in the course of employment.

3. Liability for things and equipment

A person exercising legally relevant control over machinery, equipment or another potentially harmful thing may incur liability where the statutory conditions are met.

Example: A warehouse operator may be liable for a fire caused by dangerous equipment under its control.

4. Professional negligence

Doctors, engineers, architects, consultants and other professionals may incur civil liability where a breach of the applicable professional standard causes compensable harm. Special legislation may govern particular professions, especially medical practice.

5. Abuse of rights

A person may incur liability by exercising a legal right abusively in circumstances recognised by law, such as exercising it principally to cause harm or in a manner that exceeds legally permitted limits.

C. Direct and indirect causation

A central issue in UAE tort litigation is whether the defendant's conduct caused the loss.

The court must distinguish:

Direct harm, where the conduct itself produces the injury.

Consequential harm, where the injury follows through an intervening causal sequence.

Multiple contributing causes, where more than one person or event contributes to the same damage.

The claimant must establish a legally sufficient causal relationship. The mere fact that loss occurred after a defendant's conduct does not, by itself, prove causation.

D. Compensation

Compensation is intended to address the harm suffered, not to impose an arbitrary penalty. Depending on the facts and applicable law, recoverable loss may include:

Physical injury and medical expenses.

Damage to property.

Lost income or earning capacity.

Financial loss.

Moral or non-pecuniary harm where recognised.

Loss of a genuine economic opportunity, where sufficiently established.

The court assesses the evidence, including expert reports, medical records, financial documentation and the causal connection between the conduct and the claimed loss.

E. Contractual liability versus tort liability

This distinction is particularly important in UAE litigation.

Where the parties are already bound by a contract, a claim arising from failure to perform that contract will generally be analysed under contractual liability. A claimant cannot ordinarily avoid contractual limits or conditions simply by relabelling the same breach as a tort.

An independent tort claim may nevertheless arise where the conduct is unlawful independently of the contractual relationship, or where a statute creates a separate cause of action.

5. Unjust enrichment as a source of obligations

A. Meaning

Unjust enrichment occurs when one person obtains a benefit at another person's expense without a valid legal basis for retaining that benefit.

The central principle is that a person should not retain an unjustified gain merely because the other person has suffered a corresponding loss.

Under the former Civil Transactions Law, this principle was expressly reflected in Articles 318 and 324. Those provisions were applied in several important UAE judgments. The new Civil Transactions Law continues to recognise unjust enrichment as a distinct source of obligations in Article 112. For a dispute arising after 1 June 2026, the new Code's operative provisions should be consulted rather than assuming that the former article numbers still apply.

Polaris Legal Library+2

 

B. Essential elements

A claim based on unjust enrichment generally requires the claimant to establish:

Enrichment: The defendant received money, property, services or another measurable benefit.

Corresponding impoverishment: The claimant suffered a loss or conferred a benefit at the defendant's expense.

Absence of lawful basis: No valid contract, statutory provision, court order or other legal ground justifies the defendant's retention of the benefit.

Restitutionary entitlement: The claimant is legally entitled to recover the benefit or its value.

The precise application depends on the facts and the relevant statutory provisions.

C. Common examples

1. Payment by mistake

A person transfers money to the wrong recipient or pays a debt that does not exist. If the recipient has no lawful entitlement to retain it, restitution may be available.

2. Payment under a void contract

If a sale or other transaction is declared void, the parties may have to restore what they received. If restoration alone does not adequately reverse the benefit, a further restitutionary or compensatory award may be appropriate under the applicable law.

3. Services provided without a valid contractual basis

A person may perform work or provide services that benefit another, but the anticipated contract is never concluded or is legally ineffective. A restitutionary claim may arise where the legal requirements are satisfied.

4. Property received without entitlement

A person who obtains or retains another person's property without a valid legal basis may be required to return the property or its value.

5. Benefits retained after termination

Where a contract is terminated or rescinded, the parties may have to restore benefits already transferred, subject to the contract's nature and the applicable statutory rules.

D. Restitution and compensation

Restitution and damages are related but different remedies:

Restitution seeks to reverse an unjustified transfer or benefit.

Compensation seeks to address loss caused by legally wrongful conduct.

Contractual damages seek to address loss resulting from breach of an enforceable contractual obligation.

A claimant should identify the correct legal basis. A party cannot ordinarily use unjust enrichment to bypass a valid contract that already governs the parties' rights and obligations.

E. Relationship with voluntary agency

Unjust enrichment should also be distinguished from voluntary agency, sometimes described as negotiorum gestio. In voluntary agency, a person acts for another without prior instructions in circumstances recognised by law, such as necessity or accepted custom. The law may then require the beneficiary to reimburse qualifying expenses.

This is a related but separate source of obligations; it should not be treated as identical to every unjust-enrichment claim.

6. Important UAE case laws

The following decisions provide more than six authorities across contract, tort and unjust enrichment. Most were decided under the former Federal Law No. 5 of 1985. They remain useful for understanding judicial reasoning and principles that continue under the new Code, but they are not decisions interpreting every provision of the 2025 legislation.

A. Contract cases

1. Federal Supreme Court – Commercial Appeal No. 1273/2022, 28 February 2023

Principle: Force majeure and exceptional events affecting contractual performance.

The Court considered the effect of the COVID-19 pandemic on a contractor's delay. It emphasised that courts should assess whether an exceptional or unforeseeable event beyond the parties' control affected performance and whether its consequences could reasonably have been avoided.

Importance: The case illustrates that a party's contractual liability must be assessed in light of the actual cause of non-performance, rather than treating every delay as automatically actionable.

Polaris Legal Library

 

2. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Commercial Appeal No. 1268/2021, 6 January 2022

Principle: A purchase order can constitute a binding contract.

The Court recognised that a purchase order may create a binding contractual relationship once the essential terms have been agreed and acceptance is established. Acceptance may be expressed through words, writing or conduct demonstrating consent.

Importance: The decision is useful in commercial disputes involving purchase orders, supply arrangements and transactions concluded through business correspondence.

Polaris Legal Library

 

3. Dubai Court of Cassation – Commercial Appeal No. 509/2024, 25 September 2024

Principle: Acceptance must correspond with the offer.

The Court held that an acceptance which changes the proposed price or other terms is not a true acceptance but a counter-offer.

Importance: The case reinforces the requirement of consensus in contract formation. A party cannot generally claim that a contract was concluded where its purported acceptance materially changes the offer.

Polaris Legal Library

 

4. Ras Al Khaimah Court of Cassation – Commercial Appeal No. 11/16 JY, 28 March 2021

Principle: Rescission for breach and restoration of the parties' previous positions.

The Court addressed the consequences of a party's failure to perform contractual obligations. It recognised that, where rescission is justified, the parties should generally be restored to their previous positions, with compensation potentially available where restoration is insufficient.

Importance: The decision demonstrates the connection between contractual breach, termination, restitution and compensation.

Polaris Legal Library+1

 

B. Tort and civil-liability cases

5. Federal Supreme Court – Commercial Appeal No. 776/2020, 29 December 2020

Principle: Causation is essential to tort liability.

The case concerned an employee's unlawful SIM-card swap and the resulting fraud loss. The Court emphasised that liability required the harmful conduct to be the direct or effective cause of the loss claimed.

Importance: It demonstrates that proof of wrongdoing alone is insufficient. The claimant must establish a causal relationship between the defendant's conduct and the damage.

Polaris Legal Library

 

6. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Commercial Appeal No. 1137/2023, 9 January 2024

Principle: Liability of a person controlling dangerous things.

A tenant who had actual control of gas tanks was held subject to liability for a fire that spread to a neighbouring warehouse. The Court focused on actual control of things requiring special care, rather than ownership alone.

Importance: This decision illustrates a form of statutory liability connected with control of potentially dangerous equipment. It is particularly relevant to warehouses, industrial premises, tenants and operators.

Polaris Legal Library

 

7. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Civil Appeal No. 208/2023, 6 December 2023

Principle: Joint responsibility of multiple wrongdoers.

The Court recognised that where several persons contribute to one harmful event, they may be held jointly liable for the resulting damage, subject to the applicable legal requirements.

Importance: This is relevant to road accidents, construction incidents, professional negligence and other cases involving multiple contributing actors.

Polaris Legal Library

 

8. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Civil Appeal No. 96/2024, 26 June 2024

Principle: A workplace injury may give rise to a separate civil tort claim.

The Court distinguished statutory compensation for workplace injuries from a civil claim alleging that the employer's fault caused additional harm. It recognised that a civil claim may be available where the facts establish an independent basis for liability.

Importance: The judgment demonstrates the need to distinguish statutory employment benefits from compensation based on civil wrongdoing.

Polaris Legal Library

 

C. Unjust-enrichment cases

9. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Civil Appeal No. 40/2022, 12 April 2022

Principle: Unjust enrichment following a void land-sale transaction.

A buyer paid AED 250,000 for land that could not lawfully be sold at the relevant stage. The sale was declared void, and the lower courts ordered the return of the price but refused further compensation because the buyer had shared responsibility for entering the transaction.

The Court of Cassation held that unjust enrichment is an independent source of obligation. A person who has been enriched at another's expense without lawful cause may be required to compensate the other, within the applicable limits, even without proof of fault on the enriched party's part.

The Court awarded additional compensation and interest in the circumstances of the case.

Importance: This is a particularly significant authority because it distinguishes fault-based damages from restitutionary liability and confirms that a void contract cannot itself provide a lawful basis for retaining an unjustified benefit.

Polaris Legal Library

 

10. Ras Al Khaimah Court of Cassation – Civil Appeal No. 4/13 JY, 26 February 2018

Principle: Refund and compensation where registered land is not transferred.

The Court considered a land-sale transaction where the seller had not completed the required registration and transfer of title. It recognised the buyer's entitlement to seek a refund and, where legally justified, compensation.

Importance: The case is useful in understanding the consequences of failed property transactions, restitution of the purchase price and the distinction between contractual remedies and the return of benefits received.

Polaris Legal Library+1

 

11. DIFC Court of First Instance – Larmag Holding B.V. v First Abu Dhabi Bank PJSC & Others [2019] DIFC CFI 054

Principle: Unjust enrichment is distinct from tort and contract.

The Court discussed the former Civil Transactions Law provisions on harmful acts and unjust enrichment, including Article 318's prohibition on taking another's property without lawful cause and Article 319's restitutionary rule.

Importance: This judgment is useful for understanding the conceptual separation between wrongful conduct that causes damage and the receipt of a benefit without legal justification. It is a DIFC judgment discussing UAE Civil Code principles, not a mainland Court of Cassation judgment.

DIFC Courts

 

12. Federal Supreme Court – Commercial Appeal No. 941/2019, 24 March 2020

Principle: Contractual responsibility of a bank for unauthorised transactions.

The Court considered a bank's responsibility to its customer after unauthorised persons were allowed to move company funds. It held that where the parties are connected by contract, the dispute is ordinarily governed by contractual liability rather than tort, unless the conduct falls within recognised exceptions such as crime, fraud or gross fault.

Importance: Although primarily a contractual-liability decision, it is important to the boundary between contract and tort and to the question of when a claimant may rely on a separate civil wrong.

Polaris Legal Library

 

7. Comparison of the three principal sources

IssueContractTortUnjust enrichment
SourceAgreementHarmful or wrongful conductUnjustified benefit
Prior agreement required?YesNoNo
Main legal concernPerformance of promisesCompensation for harmRestoration of benefit
Fault required?Not necessarily; breach and applicable liability rules matterGenerally, subject to statutory forms of liabilityGenerally no fault requirement
Main remedyPerformance, termination or damagesCompensationRestitution or payment of value
ExampleFailure to pay a contractorNegligent damage to propertyRetaining money paid by mistake

8. How the three sources interact

In practice, the three sources may overlap.

Example 1: Construction dispute

A developer enters into a contract with a construction company. The contractor fails to complete the project on time, and defective work damages neighbouring property.

Potential claims:

The developer may bring a contractual claim for delay and defective performance.

The neighbouring property owner may bring a tort claim for damage to property.

If the developer has paid money for work that was never performed and the contract is subsequently declared void or otherwise ceases to provide a legal basis for retaining that payment, a restitutionary claim may arise.

Example 2: Banking transaction

A bank mistakenly transfers money to the wrong account.

The recipient may have an obligation to return the money under unjust enrichment principles.

If the bank breached a contractual duty owed to its customer, the customer may also have a contractual claim.

If an employee or third party committed an independent wrongful act causing additional damage, a separate tort claim may arise, subject to the applicable rules.

Example 3: Professional negligence

A company hires an engineering consultant to inspect a building. The consultant negligently approves unsafe structural work.

The company may claim for breach of the consultancy contract.

An injured third party may bring a tort claim if the consultant's negligence caused injury.

If the consultant received payment for services under a transaction later declared legally ineffective, restitution may become relevant.

The correct cause of action depends on the parties' relationship, the conduct involved, the source of the duty and the loss claimed.

9. Important legal and procedural considerations

A. Applicable law and transitional issues

The 2025 Civil Transactions Law has applied since 1 June 2026. For disputes involving earlier transactions, courts may need to consider when the obligation arose, when the relevant conduct occurred and the applicable transitional provisions. It is not safe to apply the new Code automatically to every historical dispute.

B. Evidence

Under Federal Decree-Law No. 35 of 2022 on Evidence in Civil and Commercial Transactions, relevant proof may include:

Signed contracts and amendments.

Invoices and payment records.

Electronic communications and transaction records.

Expert reports.

Bank statements.

Medical and technical evidence.

Witness testimony, where admissible.

C. Limitation periods

Different claims may be subject to different limitation periods. For example, the former Civil Transactions Law contained a specific period for tort claims, and special legislation may prescribe separate periods for insurance, employment, construction or other disputes. The applicable period must be checked against the current Code and relevant special legislation.

D. Mainland UAE and financial free zones

Mainland UAE courts generally apply the federal Civil Transactions Law, subject to applicable special laws. The DIFC and ADGM operate under distinct legal frameworks, including common-law principles. The DIFC judgment discussed above should therefore not be treated as automatically binding on mainland UAE courts.

10. Conclusion

Contract, tort and unjust enrichment are three fundamental sources of civil obligations in UAE law.

Contract protects the binding promises and obligations voluntarily undertaken by parties.

Tort provides compensation where legally attributable harmful conduct causes damage.

Unjust enrichment prevents a person from retaining a benefit without lawful justification at another's expense.

Article 112 of the new Civil Transactions Law expressly recognises all three. Their practical significance lies in identifying the correct legal basis for a claim and selecting the appropriate remedy.

The most important judicial principles illustrated by the cases are that contracts must be interpreted and performed according to their binding terms; tort liability requires a sufficient causal connection between conduct and harm; and unjust enrichment may require restitution even where the enriched person was not at fault.

Research note: The cases above are identified by court, appeal number and date to make them distinguishable. Most were decided under the repealed 1985 Code. They should be used as historical judicial authorities on continuing principles, not represented as judgments applying the new 2025 Code. The DIFC decision is separately identified because the DIFC has its own legal framework.

This is a general academic explanation, not advice on a particular dispute.

 

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT