Civil Law And Strict Liability Risk Allocation Theory In Uae Civil Law .

1. Introduction

Strict liability is an important principle of civil liability under the United Arab Emirates (UAE) legal system. It refers to a situation in which a person may be legally responsible for damage caused to another person even without proof of conventional negligence, intention, or fault.

The principle is particularly relevant where damage results from:

Dangerous machinery and industrial equipment.

Defective products and consumer goods.

Animals and hazardous objects.

Building collapses and structural defects.

Motor vehicle accidents.

Industrial and construction activities.

Activities involving unusually high risks.

UAE civil law is primarily based on Federal Law No. 5 of 1985 concerning Civil Transactions, traditionally known as the UAE Civil Code, as amended.

The central principle is that a person who causes harm to another may be required to compensate the injured party. However, UAE law does not impose one universal strict-liability rule covering every dangerous activity. Different statutory provisions establish different liability standards.

An important distinction must therefore be made between:

Liability based on personal fault.

Liability based on responsibility for another person's conduct.

Liability based on ownership, custody, or control of dangerous things.

Statutory liability that does not require proof of negligence.

2. Statutory framework governing strict liability

A. Article 282 – General civil liability

Under Article 282 of the former Civil Transactions Law, any harm caused to another person could give rise to an obligation to compensate, even where the person causing the harm lacked legal capacity.

This provision established the broad foundation of UAE civil liability.

Its principal elements were:

An act or omission causing harm.

Actual damage suffered by the claimant.

A causal connection between the conduct and the damage.

A legally recognised basis for imposing liability.

Article 282 should not, however, be treated as making every defendant automatically liable without considering the applicable statutory requirements.

B. Article 283 – Direct and indirect causation

Article 283 distinguished between direct harm and harm caused indirectly.

Direct causation: Where the defendant's act directly causes injury, compensation is generally obligatory.

Indirect causation: Where the harm results through an intermediate event, the additional requirements concerning wrongdoing, intention or causation become relevant.

This distinction is particularly important in accidents involving machinery, industrial operations and hazardous substances.

C. Article 287 – External causes and force majeure

Article 287 recognised circumstances in which a defendant could avoid liability by establishing that the damage resulted from an external cause beyond their control.

Examples included:

Natural disasters.

Unavoidable accidents.

Force majeure.

The act of a third party.

The act of the injured person.

The availability of this defence depended on the applicable statutory liability provision. A general defence could not automatically override a special statutory rule.

D. Article 315 – Collapse of buildings

Article 315 specifically addressed damage resulting from the collapse of a building, whether the collapse was complete or partial.

The owner or person responsible for the building could be held liable unless the statutory conditions for avoiding liability were established.

The provision was particularly relevant to:

Structural failures.

Defective construction.

Poor building maintenance.

Falling building components.

Damage to neighbouring properties.

E. Article 316 – Things and machinery

Key former strict-liability provision

Article 316 was one of the most significant provisions governing strict liability in the UAE's former Civil Code.

It imposed liability on a person controlling:

A thing requiring special care to prevent danger.

Mechanical equipment or machinery.

The person exercising control could be liable for damage caused by the thing or machinery, subject to the statutory exception for damage that could not have been prevented.

Legal significance: The claimant did not necessarily need to establish conventional negligence in operating or maintaining the dangerous object. The defendant's control over the object and the connection between that object and the damage were central considerations.

3. Important legislative development: the 2026 Civil Transactions Law

An important qualification is necessary when studying UAE strict liability in November 2026.

Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 introduced a new Civil Transactions Law and replaced the former Federal Law No. 5 of 1985 with effect from 1 June 2026. Consequently, Articles 282, 283, 287, 315 and 316 discussed above belong to the former statutory framework. They should not automatically be cited as the current article numbers for events governed by the new law.

Polaris Legal Library+1

 

The former provisions remain important for understanding historical judgments, including cases involving accidents that occurred while the old law applied.

For legal proceedings, the applicable statutory version must be determined by reference to the relevant dates and transitional provisions.

F. Current Article 271 – Liability for dangerous things and machinery

Current law – 2026

The corresponding provision in the new Civil Transactions Law is Article 271 of Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025.

It provides that a person who has under their control:

Things requiring special care to prevent harm; or

Mechanical machinery,

is liable for damage caused by those things or machinery, except damage that could not have been prevented, subject to applicable special legislation.

This provision preserves the essential risk-based liability approach of former Article 316.

UAE Legislation+1

 

G. Current Articles 269 and 270 – Animals and buildings

The new law also expressly addresses two important categories of responsibility.

Article 269 – Animals

The person responsible for guarding an animal, even if not its owner, is liable for damage caused by the animal unless they establish that the incident resulted from an external cause for which they were not responsible.

Article 270 – Building collapse

The person responsible for guarding a building, even if not its owner, is liable for harm resulting from its total or partial collapse, subject to the statutory exceptions concerning external causes, maintenance negligence, age and defects.

These provisions are important because they distinguish responsibility based on custody or control from responsibility based exclusively on ownership.

UAE Legislation+1

 

4. Essential elements of strict liability under UAE law

A claimant seeking compensation under the dangerous-things provision should generally establish the following:

1. Control over the dangerous object

The defendant must have actual responsibility or control over the relevant thing or machinery. Ownership alone is not necessarily decisive.

2. Dangerous character or special-care requirement

The object must fall within the statutory category of things requiring special care or mechanical machinery.

3. Occurrence of damage

The claimant must establish actual injury, property damage or another legally compensable loss.

4. Causal relationship

The damage must have resulted from the relevant thing or machinery.

5. Absence of an applicable defence

The defendant may rely on the statutory exception for damage that could not have been prevented, together with other defences available under applicable legislation.

5. Difference between strict liability and negligence liability

Legal issueNegligence liabilityStrict liability
Proof of negligenceGenerally requiredNot necessarily required
Proof of damageRequiredRequired
Causal connectionRequiredRequired
Dangerous objectNot essentialOften central
Control of machineryRelevant evidenceCentral statutory element
DefenceAbsence of fault or causationStatutory exceptions and applicable defences
Main purposeCompensation for wrongful conductAllocation of risks associated with dangerous things

Strict liability does not mean unlimited liability. The claimant must still satisfy the relevant legal requirements.

6. Important UAE judicial decisions and case laws

The following judgments illustrate the development of UAE civil liability. Some directly concern strict liability under former Article 316, while others concern closely related principles such as statutory no-fault compensation, construction liability, causation and allocation of responsibility.

This distinction is important: not all seven decisions should be described as direct applications of strict liability.

Case 1. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Commercial Appeal No. 1137/2023

Direct strict-liability authority

Date: 9 January 2024

Subject: Fire caused by LPG gas tanks.

Two commercial entities operated neighbouring premises. A fire originating from gas tanks under the control of one business spread to the neighbouring company's warehouse.

The Court considered the responsibility of the person controlling dangerous things under former Article 316.

Legal principles:

Liability may arise without conventional proof of negligence.

Actual control over dangerous objects is important.

The person responsible need not necessarily be the legal owner.

A tenant exercising actual control may also be liable.

The statutory exception for damage that could not have been prevented remains relevant.

Importance: This is particularly significant for industrial facilities, gas storage, hazardous materials and commercial property damage.

Case 2. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Civil Appeals Nos. 96 and 97/2024

Date: 26 June 2024

Subject: Workplace injury and statutory no-fault compensation.

A worker suffered catastrophic injuries in a workplace accident. The employer and certain employees had been convicted for failing to provide adequate safety measures.

The worker subsequently sought civil compensation.

Legal principles:

Statutory compensation for workplace injuries can arise without proof of employer negligence.

A separate civil compensation claim may arise where the employer's own wrongful conduct caused the injury.

Statutory employment compensation and civil tort compensation have distinct legal foundations.

The civil court may determine the separate tort claim.

Importance: This judgment demonstrates that UAE law recognises risk-based compensation independently of ordinary fault-based civil liability. It is an example of statutory no-fault liability, rather than a direct application of Article 316.

Polaris Legal Library+1

 

Case 3. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Commercial Appeal No. 855/2024

Date: 16 September 2024

Subject: Construction defects and building collapse.

The dispute concerned a building collapse and the responsibility of construction-related parties. Expert evidence attributed the relevant defects to design and site-supervision failures rather than the concrete supplier.

The Court considered the contractor's and supervising engineer's statutory obligations under former Articles 878 and 880.

Legal principles:

Construction responsibility must be assessed according to the applicable statutory duties.

Contractors and supervising engineers may have decennial liability for collapse and serious structural defects.

A supplier is not automatically liable merely because its materials were used in the project.

Technical expert findings are important in determining causation and responsibility.

Importance: The judgment demonstrates how UAE law allocates risks associated with defective buildings and construction activities. It concerns statutory construction liability, not a direct Article 316 dangerous-things claim.

Polaris Legal Library

 

Case 4. Dubai Court of Cassation – Appeals Nos. 168 and 174/2006

Date: 24 January 2007

Subject: Flooding caused by a burst pipe.

The dispute concerned flooding allegedly caused by a burst pipe after construction works had been completed.

The Court considered whether the contractor and consultant remained responsible under the dangerous-things liability framework.

Legal principles:

Actual control of the relevant object is important.

Liability under former Article 316 cannot be imposed merely because a defendant previously participated in construction.

The court must examine who had responsibility for the object when the damage occurred.

The timing of completion and transfer of control may affect liability.

Importance: This decision is particularly useful for understanding the difference between construction responsibility and responsibility for machinery or dangerous objects under actual control.

Case 5. Dubai Court of Cassation – Appeal No. 511/2002

Date: 5 April 2003

Subject: Damage to a vessel's engine.

The dispute involved damage to a vessel's engine and subsequent modifications made by the vessel owner to increase its speed.

The Court considered whether the damage could be attributed to the subsequent modifications.

Legal principles:

Causation must be established before compensation can be imposed.

Subsequent conduct by the injured party may affect the assessment of responsibility.

A defendant may rely on an intervening cause where the evidence supports it.

Expert evidence is relevant to determining the technical origin of damage.

Importance: This judgment illustrates the significance of causation and external intervention when assessing responsibility for damage involving mechanical equipment.

Case 6. Dubai Court of Cassation – Appeals Nos. 93, 132 and 188/2004

Date: 15 May 2005

Subject: Construction obligations and vehicle theft from a car wash.

These connected appeals concerned the application of the Civil Code's construction and contractual responsibility principles in disputes involving vehicle-related loss.

Legal principles:

A party's responsibility depends on the legal source of the obligation.

Contractual custody and construction-related obligations must be distinguished from general tort liability.

An intervening event does not automatically remove liability.

The court must examine whether the event actually breaks the causal relationship.

Importance: These decisions are useful when studying the boundaries between contractual responsibility, custody-related duties and civil liability. They should not be treated as independent direct rulings under former Article 316.

Ethernet University

 

Case 7. Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation – Civil Appeal No. 208/2023

Date: 6 December 2023

Subject: Multiple wrongdoers and compensation for common harm.

The Court considered circumstances involving multiple persons responsible for a harmful event and the relationship between criminal and civil proceedings.

Legal principles:

Several persons may bear responsibility for the same harm.

The court may determine joint responsibility where the applicable conditions are established.

A final criminal judgment binds the civil court on matters necessarily determined by that judgment.

The civil court must assess the causal connection and responsibility of the parties.

Importance: This case assists in determining how compensation should be allocated when dangerous activities involve several operators, contractors or responsible parties. It is a related civil-liability decision, not a direct strict-liability judgment.

Polaris Legal Library+1

 

7. Application of strict liability in different sectors

A. Industrial and manufacturing industries

Factories and industrial operators may face strict liability where dangerous machinery causes injury or property damage.

Examples:

Factory machine accidents.

Industrial explosions.

Chemical leakage.

Pressure-vessel failures.

Automated production equipment accidents.

The operator exercising actual control over the machinery may be responsible even if the claimant cannot prove conventional negligence.

B. Construction and real estate

Strict and statutory liability principles are particularly relevant to construction projects.

Potential situations include:

Structural collapse.

Falling construction materials.

Crane accidents.

Elevator malfunctions.

Defective building installations.

Damage caused by construction machinery.

Articles 270 and 271 of the new Civil Transactions Law are particularly relevant, alongside the separate statutory rules governing construction contracts and decennial liability.

C. Transportation and logistics

Transportation businesses may face liability involving:

Dangerous loading equipment.

Industrial vehicles.

Mechanical lifting systems.

Hazardous cargo.

Equipment used in warehouses and ports.

Special transport, traffic and insurance legislation may also apply.

D. Oil, gas and energy industries

The UAE's oil and gas industry presents significant potential applications of strict liability.

Examples include:

LPG storage explosions.

Pipeline leakage.

Refinery fires.

Chemical contamination.

Pressure equipment failures.

The LPG fire judgment in Abu Dhabi Commercial Appeal No. 1137/2023 provides a particularly relevant judicial illustration.

E. Technology and automated machinery

The principles can also apply to modern technologies, including:

Industrial robots.

Autonomous machinery.

Automated warehouse systems.

Artificial-intelligence-controlled equipment.

Automated lifting and transportation systems.

The central question is who exercises legally relevant control over the dangerous equipment and whether the damage resulted from it.

8. Defences against strict liability

A defendant may seek to avoid liability by establishing an applicable statutory defence.

DefenceLegal significance
Unavoidable accidentDamage could not reasonably have been prevented
Force majeureAn external event beyond the defendant's control
Third-party interventionAn independent act caused the damage
Victim's conductThe injured party contributed to the damage
Absence of controlDefendant was not responsible for the dangerous object
Absence of causationDamage was not caused by the relevant object
Special statutory defenceA specific law provides an applicable exemption

The precise requirements differ between Articles 269, 270 and 271 and other applicable legislation.

9. Compensation and remedies

Where strict liability is established, the court may award compensation for legally recognised losses.

Potential forms of compensation include:

Physical injury: Compensation for bodily harm and permanent disability.

Property damage: Repair or replacement costs.

Economic loss: Financial loss sufficiently connected to the harmful event.

Medical expenses: Reasonable treatment and rehabilitation costs.

Loss of income: Proven income loss resulting from the injury.

Other legally recognised damage: Including eligible moral or non-material harm.

The court considers causation, the nature of the injury, supporting evidence and applicable statutory rules when determining compensation.

10. Strict liability and insurance

Insurance plays an important role in managing strict-liability exposure.

Relevant insurance arrangements include:

Public liability insurance.

Product liability insurance.

Industrial risk insurance.

Construction all-risk insurance.

Employer-related insurance.

Motor vehicle third-party liability insurance.

However, insurance coverage does not automatically eliminate the defendant's legal responsibility. The insurer's obligation depends on the applicable insurance legislation, policy wording, exclusions and coverage limits.

11. Critical analysis of strict liability under UAE civil law

The UAE's strict-liability framework reflects an important legal policy: the person exercising control over a potentially dangerous object should generally bear responsibility for the risks associated with that object.

Three features are especially significant.

First, control rather than ownership. A person who operates or controls dangerous machinery may be responsible even if another party legally owns it.

Second, risk allocation. The law recognises that certain activities create risks requiring greater legal protection for injured persons.

Third, preventive justice. Strict liability encourages businesses to maintain machinery, implement safety procedures and establish effective risk-management systems.

The 2026 legislative reform is particularly relevant because Article 271 preserves the special-care approach while Articles 269 and 270 separately regulate animal and building-related responsibility.

12. Conclusion

Strict liability is an important component of UAE civil law because it provides a mechanism for compensating individuals who suffer damage from dangerous things, mechanical machinery, animals and building collapses.

The new Civil Transactions Law, Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025, effective from 1 June 2026, maintains this approach through Articles 269, 270 and 271.

The Abu Dhabi Court of Cassation's decision in Commercial Appeal No. 1137/2023 remains a particularly important historical illustration of liability arising from actual control over dangerous objects.

Ultimately, UAE strict liability seeks to balance three objectives:

Protection of injured persons.

Fair allocation of risks to those controlling dangerous activities.

Encouragement of responsible industrial, commercial and property management.

13. Important statutory and case-law references for research

ReferenceLegal subject
Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025Current UAE Civil Transactions Law
Article 269Liability for animals
Article 270Liability for building collapse
Article 271Dangerous things and machinery
Former Article 282, Federal Law No. 5 of 1985General civil liability
Former Article 315Building collapse
Former Article 316Dangerous things and machinery
Abu Dhabi Cassation 1137/2023Direct strict liability
Abu Dhabi Cassation 96/97/2024Statutory no-fault workplace compensation
Abu Dhabi Cassation 855/2024Construction and decennial liability
Dubai Cassation 168/174/2006Control of dangerous objects
Dubai Cassation 511/2002Mechanical damage and causation
Dubai Cassation 93/132/188/2004Contractual and construction responsibility
Abu Dhabi Cassation 208/2023Multiple wrongdoers and civil compensation

Academic qualification: The reported decisions above include judgments decided under the repealed 1985 Civil Code. They are useful for understanding the historical development of strict liability, but their statutory interpretation must be read alongside the new 2026 Civil Transactions Law. The case-law list deliberately distinguishes direct strict-liability authority from related decisions rather than presenting all seven as Article 271 precedents.

 

 

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT