Criminal Law Responses To Domestic Violence In Rural Nepal
1. Legal Framework in Nepal
Domestic Violence (Crime and Punishment) Act, 2009: Criminalizes physical, mental, sexual, and economic abuse in the household.
Penalties: Fine from NPR 3,000 to 25,000, imprisonment up to six months, or both. Repeat offenders or public servants committing domestic violence face stricter penalties.
Implementation Issues in Rural Areas: Limited police presence, social stigma, preference for mediation, and economic dependence of victims often hinder criminal prosecution.
2. Case Studies
Case 1: Death Due to Domestic Violence in Bara District (2022)
Facts:
Pinky Kurmi, aged 32, was repeatedly physically abused by her husband and in-laws in a rural Terai household.
Dowry disputes and long-standing abuse culminated in Pinky’s death.
Legal Issues:
Determining whether the perpetrators are liable under the Domestic Violence Act or more serious criminal provisions like murder or grievous hurt.
Evidentiary challenges in rural settings where documentation of abuse is minimal.
Outcome:
Police lodged a formal investigation; the husband and in-laws faced criminal charges.
Highlighted that domestic violence escalating to death can attract severe criminal liability beyond standard domestic violence penalties.
Key Takeaway:
Rural domestic violence can escalate to fatal outcomes. Effective prosecution requires bridging social pressures and enforcement gaps.
Case 2: Physical Assault in Syangja District (2011)
Facts:
A woman in Waling‑13, Syangja, suffered physical, mental, and sexual abuse by her husband.
Despite being educated, she was economically dependent, which prevented her from seeking police assistance initially.
Legal Issues:
Accessibility of criminal remedies in remote rural areas.
Cultural and social obstacles to invoking criminal liability.
Outcome:
Complaint eventually lodged, but prosecution was delayed due to reluctance and mediation pressures.
Key Takeaway:
Legal provisions exist, but rural women often struggle to access justice due to social norms and isolation.
Case 3: Severe Burns from Domestic Violence (2018)
Facts:
A woman, asleep at home, was doused with kerosene and set on fire by her husband in a rural area. She sustained third-degree burns.
Legal Issues:
Determining if the case falls under domestic violence law or general criminal law (attempt to murder, grievous hurt).
Collecting evidence and witness statements in isolated rural settings.
Outcome:
Husband arrested and prosecuted under criminal law for grievous hurt and attempted murder.
Key Takeaway:
Severe domestic violence may require prosecution under general criminal law in addition to domestic violence statutes.
Case 4: Obstacles to Enforcement in Rural Court (2024)
Facts:
A rural woman filed a domestic violence case against her husband, and the Supreme Court ruled in her favor.
Local enforcement was delayed for years due to corruption, influence of the husband, and lack of local judicial resources.
Legal Issues:
Even where criminal liability is recognized, practical enforcement in rural Nepal is often weak.
Outcome:
Case remained largely unenforced for several years, leaving the victim vulnerable.
Key Takeaway:
Criminal law is effective only when backed by enforcement infrastructure. Rural victims face significant procedural and structural barriers.
Case 5: Widespread Mediation over Prosecution in Kapilvastu (2019)
Facts:
In Kapilvastu district, 90% of domestic violence complaints were resolved through reconciliation rather than formal prosecution.
Only a few cases actually proceeded to court.
Legal Issues:
The preference for reconciliation undermines the deterrent effect of criminal law.
Victims often withdraw cases due to social pressure or fear of economic loss.
Outcome:
Few perpetrators faced criminal penalties, highlighting the gap between law and rural practice.
Key Takeaway:
Rural societal norms and mediation culture often prevent effective criminal prosecution of domestic violence.
3. Key Observations from the Cases
Criminal Liability Exists: Perpetrators can be prosecuted under the Domestic Violence Act and, for severe cases, under general criminal provisions.
Severity Determines Charges: Assault, burns, or deaths attract stronger criminal liability.
Reporting Barriers: Victims face social stigma, economic dependence, and geographic isolation.
Enforcement Challenges: Even after convictions, rural victims often struggle to see judgments enforced.
Cultural Norms Influence Outcomes: Mediation and reconciliation often take precedence over formal criminal prosecution.
RELATED Blog
comments