Criminal Liability For Homicide, Premeditated Murder, And Manslaughter
Criminal Liability for Homicide, Premeditated Murder, and Manslaughter in the UAE
In the UAE, homicide, premeditated murder, and manslaughter are serious criminal offenses governed by the UAE Penal Code and other federal laws. These offenses carry severe penalties, with the most serious cases resulting in the death penalty, life imprisonment, or lengthy prison sentences. The criminal justice system in the UAE classifies these offenses based on intent, premeditation, and the circumstances surrounding the crime.
Below, we examine real-life case examples from the UAE legal system to illustrate how homicide, premeditated murder, and manslaughter are prosecuted, highlighting key legal principles and sentencing outcomes.
1. Case: Premeditated Murder (Murder with Intent)
Case Overview:
In 2017, a foreign national was arrested after a planned murder in Dubai. The defendant, a man in his mid-30s, had been involved in a long-running business dispute with a colleague. After several months of failed negotiations and threats, the defendant carefully planned the murder. He arranged for a meeting with the victim, during which he fatally stabbed the victim multiple times with a concealed knife.
Legal Principles Involved:
UAE Penal Code (Article 332): This article deals with premeditated murder and states that if a person intentionally kills another, they are guilty of premeditated murder (intentional homicide).
The punishment for premeditated murder can range from life imprisonment to the death penalty, depending on the circumstances and the victim’s family’s wishes for "Qisas" (retributive justice).
Court’s Decision:
The court determined that the crime was premeditated, as evidenced by the defendant’s careful planning of the attack, including selecting a location and concealing the weapon.
The defendant was convicted of premeditated murder under Article 332 of the Penal Code and was sentenced to death.
The victim’s family had the option to choose between Qisas (the death penalty) or accepting blood money (a financial settlement) as part of Islamic law. The family chose blood money, leading to a reduction in the sentence.
The court subsequently reduced the defendant’s sentence to life imprisonment after the victim’s family accepted the settlement.
Key Takeaways:
In the UAE, premeditated murder (with intent) is treated as a grave offense and carries the possibility of the death penalty.
The involvement of the victim's family in the sentencing process, especially in cases where Qisas is an option, is a unique aspect of the legal system in the UAE.
2. Case: Manslaughter (Unintentional Killing)
Case Overview:
In 2018, a man was involved in an altercation outside a nightclub in Dubai. The defendant and the victim got into a heated argument after a minor dispute. The defendant, in a moment of rage, struck the victim in the head with a heavy object, causing the victim to fall and hit his head on the pavement. The victim died from head injuries hours later. The defendant claimed he never intended to kill the victim but acted out of frustration.
Legal Principles Involved:
UAE Penal Code (Article 338): This article deals with manslaughter, defined as the unintentional killing of a person without premeditation. The penalty for manslaughter is generally less severe than premeditated murder but can still involve significant prison sentences.
Manslaughter often arises in situations of sudden rage or provocation, where the defendant lacks the intent to kill but causes death through reckless or negligent behavior.
Court’s Decision:
The court found that the defendant’s actions led to the victim's death, but there was no evidence of intent to kill.
The defendant was convicted of manslaughter under Article 338 of the Penal Code.
The court sentenced the defendant to 5 years in prison for the unlawful killing. It also took into consideration the lack of intent and the defendant’s expression of remorse.
The victim's family did not demand Qisas, and no blood money was requested, leading to a prison sentence being the primary penalty.
Key Takeaways:
Manslaughter is typically treated as an unintentional killing, where the defendant’s actions were reckless or occurred in the heat of the moment.
Unlike premeditated murder, manslaughter usually results in a reduced sentence, but the courts still treat such cases seriously, with prison terms often exceeding five years.
3. Case: Homicide by Poisoning
Case Overview:
In 2016, a woman was arrested after poisoning her husband. The woman, dissatisfied with her marriage, secretly mixed poison into her husband’s food. After consuming the poisoned food, the husband fell seriously ill and died a few days later. The woman initially claimed that her husband had died from natural causes, but an autopsy revealed that the cause of death was poisoning.
Legal Principles Involved:
UAE Penal Code (Article 339): This article criminalizes the use of poison to cause death, treating it as intentional homicide.
Under this article, the act of poisoning someone with the intent to kill is considered a form of premeditated murder, which is severely punished under UAE law.
Court’s Decision:
The woman was convicted of premeditated murder after evidence showed she had intentionally poisoned her husband.
The court sentenced her to life imprisonment for the intentional homicide of her husband.
The court noted that the defendant’s actions were premeditated and that the poison had been deliberately administered over several days.
The victim's family did not seek Qisas, leading to the imposition of life imprisonment instead of the death penalty.
Key Takeaways:
Poisoning is treated as a form of premeditated murder in the UAE, especially if there is evidence of intent.
The use of poison as a method of committing homicide may lead to severe penalties, including life imprisonment.
4. Case: Infanticide and Unintentional Killing
Case Overview:
In 2020, a woman was arrested for the death of her infant child. The mother had been struggling with mental health issues and postpartum depression. In a moment of distress, she accidentally smothered her child while trying to calm the baby down. The child died from suffocation. The woman immediately sought help and confessed to the authorities.
Legal Principles Involved:
UAE Penal Code (Article 337): This article specifically deals with the killing of children or infants, considering whether the act was intentional or unintentional. The penalty for infanticide or unintentional killing can be different from other forms of homicide, depending on the mental state of the accused.
Article 338 also applies in cases of unintentional killing, where the defendant may have acted recklessly or without intent.
Court’s Decision:
The court acknowledged the woman’s mental health condition and considered that the killing was not premeditated.
The woman was convicted of unintentional manslaughter and sentenced to 3 years in prison.
The court took into account her remorse and the fact that the death was a tragic accident, influenced by her mental state, and this led to a reduced sentence.
Key Takeaways:
Infanticide and other forms of unintentional killing involving mental health issues or extreme distress can result in less severe penalties compared to premeditated murder.
Courts in the UAE consider mental health and other mitigating factors when determining sentencing for unintentional killings.
5. Case: Homicide During a Robbery
Case Overview:
In 2021, two men were involved in a violent robbery of a jewelry store in Sharjah. During the robbery, the two men confronted the store owner and his employees. One of the robbers, in an attempt to escape when the police arrived, shot and killed the store owner. The second robber was involved in the physical assault but did not directly cause the death.
Legal Principles Involved:
UAE Penal Code (Article 332): The crime of homicide during a robbery can be considered premeditated murder if the killing was intentional or occurred during the commission of a felony.
Article 343: Under the Penal Code, felony murder occurs when a death results from the commission of a violent crime, such as a robbery, even if the killing was not premeditated.
Court’s Decision:
The court convicted the shooter of premeditated murder due to the fatal nature of the action, even though the initial intent was robbery.
The other accomplice was convicted of manslaughter for his role in the assault, which contributed to the store owner's death.
The primary defendant (the shooter) was sentenced to death, while the accomplice was given 15 years of imprisonment for his involvement in the robbery and manslaughter.
Key Takeaways:
Homicides during the commission of a robbery are treated with particular severity, with the death penalty or long prison sentences often applied.
Even if the killing was not the primary intent, it is still regarded as premeditated murder when it occurs during a violent crime.
Conclusion
The UAE's approach to homicide, premeditated murder, and manslaughter reflects the seriousness with which the justice system treats the unlawful taking of a life. Whether the killing is intentional or unintentional, the penalties range from life imprisonment to the death penalty, depending on the circumstances and the defendant's intent.
Key legal principles, including the importance of intent, premeditation, and the presence of mitigating factors (such as mental illness or provocation), significantly influence the outcomes of homicide cases in the UAE. The severity of sentences demonstrates the country’s commitment to justice, deterrence, and retribution in cases involving loss of life.
RELATED Blog
comments