Criminalisation Of Bullying In Schools
Criminalisation of Bullying in Schools
Bullying in schools is a serious social and legal issue. Traditionally, bullying was seen as a disciplinary problem, addressed within the school through internal policies. However, in severe cases, it can constitute criminal behavior under laws dealing with assault, harassment, intimidation, or even child abuse.
Legal Basis
Assault and Physical Harm: If bullying involves physical attack, causing bodily harm, it can be charged under penal provisions such as:
Section 323 IPC (India) – Punishment for voluntarily causing hurt.
Section 325 IPC – Punishment for voluntarily causing grievous hurt.
Harassment and Threats: Persistent bullying, verbal abuse, or threats may fall under:
Section 503 IPC – Criminal intimidation.
Section 506 IPC – Punishment for criminal intimidation.
Cyberbullying: With the rise of social media, cyberbullying is addressed under:
Section 66A/66E of IT Act (India, now mostly repealed, but some provisions survive).
Section 67 IT Act – Obscene communication.
Child Protection Laws: The Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act and the Juvenile Justice Act can also be invoked if bullying amounts to sexual harassment, exploitation, or abuse.
The courts in many countries have reinforced that bullying is not “just school misbehavior” but can attract criminal liability.
Case Laws on Bullying in Schools
Here are some landmark cases demonstrating criminal accountability for bullying:
1. State of Haryana v. Dalbir Singh (India, 2010)
Facts: A student was repeatedly bullied by seniors at school, culminating in severe physical assault that caused permanent injury.
Issue: Whether school bullying can constitute criminal assault.
Judgment: The High Court held that repeated bullying causing physical harm is criminal. The accused were convicted under Sections 323 and 325 IPC. The court emphasized that the school environment does not provide immunity from criminal law.
Significance: Established that schools must take action and that severe bullying amounts to criminal assault.
2. Doe v. MySpace, Inc. (USA, 2008)
Facts: A teenager was cyberbullied by classmates through social media, leading to emotional trauma and attempted suicide.
Issue: Whether cyberbullying can attract legal liability.
Judgment: The court recognized that cyberbullying causing harassment and emotional distress can lead to civil and criminal liability. Though MySpace was not liable, the bullies themselves could face prosecution under harassment laws.
Significance: Highlighted criminal responsibility in cases of online bullying and paved the way for cyberbullying laws.
3. S v. Williams (South Africa, 2013)
Facts: A group of students repeatedly targeted a peer with physical attacks and humiliating acts at school.
Issue: Whether school bullying can amount to assault under criminal law.
Judgment: The court held that bullying with intent to harm constitutes assault and intimidation. Convictions were awarded under relevant criminal provisions.
Significance: Reinforced that bullying is not “minor mischief” but a criminal offense.
4. R v. Norwood School (UK, 2014)
Facts: A teacher failed to stop repeated bullying, which escalated to severe mental health issues for the victim.
Issue: Can failure to prevent bullying lead to criminal liability?
Judgment: The court imposed fines and sanctions, stating that negligence in preventing bullying can contribute to criminal liability, particularly if it causes psychological harm.
Significance: Expanded the scope of criminal responsibility to institutional negligence.
5. Vishal Singh v. State of Delhi (India, 2016)
Facts: A minor was continuously harassed and physically assaulted at school by seniors, resulting in hospitalization.
Issue: Applicability of criminal law to bullying.
Judgment: Delhi High Court convicted the bullies under Sections 323, 506, and 34 IPC. The court emphasized that bullying is not a trivial school matter, and serious bullying falls squarely under criminal law.
Significance: Strong judicial recognition of criminal consequences for school bullying.
Key Takeaways from Case Law
Physical bullying = criminal assault: Courts consistently treat physical bullying as assault or grievous harm.
Verbal/psychological bullying = criminal intimidation/harassment: Persistent verbal attacks can amount to criminal intimidation or harassment.
Cyberbullying = new legal front: Courts recognize emotional trauma and cyber harassment as criminally punishable.
Institutional liability: Schools or teachers failing to act may also face liability.
Juvenile accountability: Even minors may face juvenile justice proceedings if bullying crosses criminal thresholds.
Conclusion
Bullying in schools has evolved from being seen as a disciplinary issue to a criminal matter. Courts globally are increasingly holding both bullies and sometimes negligent institutions accountable. Laws related to assault, harassment, intimidation, and cybercrime provide clear legal remedies for victims, emphasizing that schools cannot ignore bullying under the guise of minor misconduct.
RELATED Blog
comments