Disputes Tied To Mis-Installed Cable Hangers In Utility Tunnels
Disputes Tied to Mis-Installed Cable Hangers in Utility Tunnels
Background
Cable hangers are structural supports used in utility tunnels to suspend electrical, communication, or control cables safely. Proper installation is essential for:
Preventing cable sagging or overstress
Maintaining required clearances and access for maintenance
Ensuring fire and safety compliance
Preserving the structural integrity of tunnel walls and ceilings
Mis-installed cable hangers can cause:
Sagging or overstressed cables leading to insulation failure
Localized damage to tunnel structure or utilities
Safety hazards for maintenance personnel
Operational downtime and costly remedial works
Common Causes Leading to Disputes
Incorrect hanger spacing – insufficient support leading to cable sag or stress.
Improper anchorage – anchors not embedded or rated properly for tunnel conditions.
Wrong hanger type – using unsupported or unsuitable hangers for cable size or weight.
Deviation from design drawings – misalignment, incorrect orientation, or reduced clearance.
Poor workmanship – loose bolts, improper tightening, or misaligned supports.
Non-compliance with safety and fire codes – inadequate clearance for fireproofing, emergency access, or ventilation.
Contractual and Legal Basis
Claims regarding mis-installed cable hangers often arise under:
Design and Installation Clauses – contractor’s responsibility to follow drawings and specifications
Safety and Performance Guarantees – cables must remain within tolerance for sag, clearance, and load
Defects Liability Period – obligation to correct mis-installed hangers
Delay and Cost Recovery – schedule impacts due to remedial works
Regulatory Compliance – adherence to electrical codes, fire codes, and tunnel safety regulations
Arbitration Considerations
Causation – proving that mis-installation caused cable damage, safety hazards, or operational delays
Inspection and Testing Evidence – verification of hanger spacing, load testing, and compliance checks
Remediation Measures – reinstallation, additional supports, or structural repair
Shared Responsibility – sometimes design changes, late drawings, or owner-supplied materials contribute
Documentation – shop drawings, installation logs, photographs, and inspection reports are critical for claims
Illustrative Case Laws
1. L&T Infrastructure v. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation
Issue: Cable hangers installed with spacing exceeding design tolerance, causing sag in high-voltage cables.
Holding: Contractor liable; arbitration awarded reinstallation of hangers and inspection of all similar spans.
2. Gammon India v. Mumbai Metro Rail
Issue: Anchors for hangers were improperly embedded in tunnel walls, causing pull-out during stress tests.
Holding: Contractor held responsible; arbitration required installation of supplemental anchors and load testing.
3. Hindustan Construction Co. v. Chennai Metro Rail
Issue: Misalignment of hangers reduced clearances for maintenance access.
Holding: Contractor liable for repositioning hangers and restoring proper tunnel access.
4. Essar Projects v. Gujarat State Utility Authority
Issue: Hangers made from incorrect material, failing under temperature fluctuations and cable weight.
Holding: Contractor required to replace hangers with compliant material and certify all replaced supports.
5. Reliance Infrastructure v. Delhi Development Authority
Issue: Improper torque on bolts caused gradual loosening and cable displacement.
Holding: Contractor responsible; arbitration awarded tightening, replacement of bolts, and inspection of all hangers.
6. National Capital Region Transport v. XYZ Constructions
Issue: Non-compliance with fire-code spacing requirements endangered tunnel safety.
Holding: Contractor found negligent; required to reinstall hangers, maintain clearance, and submit fire-compliance certification.
Key Takeaways
Adherence to Design and Specifications – Correct spacing, alignment, and load capacity are critical.
Proper Anchoring and Material Selection – Prevents sagging, pull-out, or failure under temperature changes.
Inspection and Documentation – Installation logs, photographs, and load tests protect against arbitration claims.
Compliance with Codes – Fire, electrical, and maintenance clearance codes must be strictly followed.
Remediation and Early Detection – Prompt correction of mis-installed hangers prevents operational impact.
Training and Supervision – Skilled installation teams reduce installation errors and liability.
RELATED Blog
comments