Humanity Commons Claims .
1. Introduction
Human-AI Collective Rights is an emerging area of legal and technological scholarship concerned with the rights, responsibilities, interests and legal protections arising when human beings and artificial intelligence systems work together, make decisions collectively, create intellectual property, participate in social activities or exercise forms of shared agency.
The concept examines how law should regulate relationships between humans and AI systems when their combined activities affect individual rights, collective interests, public institutions and society.
Human-AI collaboration is increasingly visible in:
AI-assisted medical diagnosis.
Human-AI scientific research.
Autonomous transportation systems.
AI-supported judicial administration.
Human-machine industrial operations.
AI-generated creative works.
Digital education and collaborative learning.
AI-supported democratic participation.
Human-AI decision-making in financial institutions.
Collective intelligence and research networks.
The central legal question is:
When humans and artificial intelligence systems jointly produce decisions, knowledge, creative works or social outcomes, how should legal rights, responsibilities, ownership and accountability be distributed?
An important qualification is necessary: Human-AI collective rights are not currently recognised as a separate, established category of fundamental rights in most legal systems. Existing law generally recognises human and organisational rights, while treating AI systems as technological tools or systems operated by legally responsible persons and entities.
Therefore, the subject is best understood as an emerging legal framework built from constitutional law, civil liability, intellectual property, data protection, corporate law, human rights and AI governance.
2. Meaning and Conceptual Foundations
Human-AI collective rights concern the legal interests of people who collaborate with AI systems and the protection of those people when collective human-machine activities affect their rights.
The concept involves five major dimensions.
A. Human-AI collaborative autonomy
Humans should retain meaningful control over decisions made with AI assistance.
Examples:
Doctors using AI diagnostic systems.
Lawyers using AI legal research tools.
Researchers using AI to analyse scientific information.
Employees collaborating with AI-powered industrial systems.
B. Collective intellectual contribution
Human-AI collaboration creates questions concerning the ownership and protection of jointly developed knowledge and creative output.
Examples include:
AI-assisted literary works.
Human-directed AI artwork.
Scientific discoveries supported by machine-learning systems.
Collaborative software development.
C. Collective privacy and data protection
AI systems often process information relating to large groups of individuals.
Legal concerns include:
Group profiling.
Collective surveillance.
Behavioural prediction.
Biometric identification.
Unauthorised data aggregation.
Discriminatory group classification.
D. Shared responsibility and accountability
When human decisions and AI recommendations jointly produce harm, law must determine the responsibility of the relevant actors.
These may include:
AI developers.
System providers.
Employers.
Professional users.
Platform operators.
Government authorities.
E. Collective participation and equality
AI systems should not undermine the ability of communities and groups to participate in decisions affecting their lives.
This includes protection against discriminatory algorithms, automated exclusion and manipulation of collective behaviour.
3. Legal Nature of Human-AI Collective Rights
Human-AI collective rights can be divided into three broad categories.
| Category | Legal character |
|---|---|
| Existing enforceable human rights | Privacy, equality, dignity, expression and freedom |
| Rights arising from collective human activity | Shared authorship, data protection, employment and contractual interests |
| Emerging proposed rights | Human-AI collaborative autonomy, collective algorithmic accountability and protection against machine-mediated domination |
A crucial distinction is that AI itself does not automatically acquire constitutional rights or legal personality merely because it collaborates with humans.
The legal system generally protects the humans, organisations and communities affected by AI activities.
4. Important Legal Principles
A. Human dignity
AI systems must not undermine the dignity, autonomy or inherent worth of individuals.
B. Human oversight
Consequential decisions should have appropriate human supervision, review and accountability.
C. Equality and non-discrimination
AI-supported collective decisions should not reproduce unlawful discrimination.
D. Privacy and informational autonomy
Individuals must receive protection against unlawful processing, profiling and surveillance.
E. Fair distribution of benefits
The economic and intellectual benefits of human-AI collaboration should be distributed according to applicable laws, contracts and legitimate rights.
F. Accountability
The use of AI must not create a legal accountability gap in which every responsible actor avoids responsibility by blaming the technology.
5. Important Case Laws on Human-AI Collective Rights
The following cases are important because they address AI legal personality, human-machine responsibility, intellectual property, collective interests and algorithmic decision-making. Some are directly concerned with AI, while others establish legal principles relevant to human-AI collaboration.
Case 1. Thaler v. Vidal (2022)
Citation: 43 F.4th 1207
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit.
Facts:
Dr. Stephen Thaler developed an artificial intelligence system called DABUS (Device for the Autonomous Bootstrapping of Unified Sentience).
He submitted patent applications identifying DABUS as the inventor of inventions allegedly generated autonomously by the AI system.
The United States Patent and Trademark Office rejected the applications because the named inventor was not a natural person.
Judgment:
The Federal Circuit held that an inventor under the US Patent Act must be a natural person.
An AI system could not independently qualify as a statutory inventor.
Legal principles:
Patent inventorship is governed by statutory definitions.
AI-generated inventions do not automatically create AI legal personality.
Human and machine contributions must be distinguished.
Patent ownership and inventorship are separate legal questions.
Technological capability does not automatically confer legal rights.
Relevance to Human-AI Collective Rights:
This case raises the question of how intellectual contributions should be recognised when humans and AI systems jointly participate in innovation.
It demonstrates the need for legal rules identifying the human contributors, inventors, owners and responsible entities in collaborative technological activities.
Case 2. Thaler v. Perlmutter (2023; affirmed 2025)
Citation: 687 F. Supp. 3d 140; affirmed, No. 23-5233 (D.C. Cir. 2025).
Court: United States District Court for the District of Columbia; United States Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit.
Facts:
Dr. Thaler sought copyright registration for an artwork generated by his AI system without human authorship.
The United States Copyright Office refused registration because the work was identified as having been created autonomously by AI.
Judgment:
The District Court held that human authorship is required under US copyright law.
The D.C. Circuit affirmed that decision in 2025, holding that a work must initially be authored by a human being to qualify under the Copyright Act.
Legal principles:
Copyright law requires human authorship.
AI-generated output does not automatically belong to the AI system.
Human creative contributions remain legally significant.
Ownership cannot be established merely by claiming that an AI generated a work.
Relevance to Human-AI Collective Rights:
This decision is important for determining how collaborative human-AI creative activities should be legally recognised.
It highlights the distinction between human creativity, machine-generated material and legally protectable human contributions.
Every CRS Report
Case 3. Thaler v. Comptroller-General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks (2023)
Citation: [2023] UKSC 49
Court: Supreme Court of the United Kingdom.
Facts:
Dr. Thaler attempted to register DABUS as the inventor of two inventions under UK patent law.
The central question was whether an AI machine could qualify as an inventor under the Patents Act 1977.
Judgment:
The UK Supreme Court unanimously held that an inventor under the legislation must be a natural person.
DABUS could not be recognised as an inventor.
The Court also distinguished the question of who invented something from the separate question of who owns the invention.
Legal principles:
Legal inventorship must satisfy statutory requirements.
AI systems do not automatically obtain patent rights.
Ownership of an AI system does not automatically make its owner the inventor.
Legal responsibility and technical contribution must be distinguished.
Relevance to Human-AI Collective Rights:
The case demonstrates the need for clear legal arrangements concerning human contributions to AI-assisted inventions.
It also shows that collaborative innovation requires appropriate rules for attribution, ownership and economic benefits.
Case 4. Commissioner of Patents v. Thaler (2022)
Citation: [2022] FCAFC 62
Court: Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia.
Facts:
Dr. Thaler challenged the rejection of a patent application that identified DABUS as the inventor.
The initial Federal Court decision had accepted that an AI system could be named as an inventor.
The Commissioner appealed.
Judgment:
The Full Court reversed the first-instance decision and held that an inventor under Australian patent legislation must be a natural person.
The High Court subsequently refused special leave to appeal.
Legal principles:
Inventorship is a legal status defined by legislation.
AI systems cannot independently hold the statutory status of inventor.
AI-assisted innovation requires identifiable legal actors.
Patent rights must be allocated according to applicable statutory rules.
Relevance to Human-AI Collective Rights:
This decision demonstrates the difficulties of distributing intellectual property rights when innovation results from human-machine collaboration.
It also illustrates why legal systems need clear rules for recognising human contributions to technological development.
Case 5. Moffatt v. Air Canada (2024)
Citation: 2024 BCCRT 149
Court: Civil Resolution Tribunal of British Columbia, Canada.
Facts:
A customer used Air Canada's website chatbot to obtain information about bereavement fares.
The chatbot provided incorrect information about the availability of a retrospective bereavement discount.
The customer relied on the information and subsequently sought compensation.
Air Canada argued that the chatbot was a separate entity responsible for its own statements.
Judgment:
The Tribunal rejected Air Canada's argument and held the airline responsible for information provided through its website, including the chatbot.
The Tribunal found negligent misrepresentation and ordered compensation.
Legal principles:
Businesses remain responsible for representations made through their digital systems.
Deploying an AI chatbot does not automatically transfer legal responsibility to the technology.
Consumers may rely on information supplied by automated customer-service systems.
Human and corporate accountability must remain identifiable.
Relevance to Human-AI Collective Rights:
This decision is particularly relevant to human-AI collaboration in commercial environments.
It demonstrates that businesses cannot avoid responsibility by treating AI systems as independent legal actors.
It supports the principle that human and organisational responsibility must accompany AI deployment.
Case 6. State v. Loomis (2016)
Citation: 881 N.W.2d 749
Court: Supreme Court of Wisconsin, United States.
Facts:
Eric Loomis challenged a criminal sentence that relied partly on a risk assessment generated using the COMPAS algorithm.
The system assessed the likelihood of reoffending and produced a risk score used in the sentencing process.
Loomis argued that reliance on an algorithm raised concerns about due process, transparency and the possibility of bias.
Judgment:
The Wisconsin Supreme Court upheld the sentence while recognising important limitations concerning the use of algorithmic risk assessments.
It emphasised that COMPAS could not determine the sentence by itself and that courts must exercise independent judgment.
Legal principles:
Algorithmic recommendations must not replace judicial responsibility.
Transparency and procedural safeguards are important.
Risk-assessment tools must be used with caution.
Human decision-makers must understand the limitations of automated systems.
Relevance to Human-AI Collective Rights:
This case is important for understanding collective human-AI decision-making in public institutions.
It demonstrates the need to preserve human accountability when automated systems influence decisions affecting liberty and fundamental rights.
Case 7. SyRI (System Risk Indication) Case (2020)
Citation: ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2020:1878
Court: District Court of The Hague, Netherlands.
Facts:
The Dutch Government used the SyRI system to identify possible fraud in areas involving public benefits, taxation and other government services.
The system combined information from different government databases to identify individuals considered potentially associated with fraud risks.
Human rights organisations challenged the system on privacy and proportionality grounds.
Judgment:
The District Court found that the legislation governing SyRI violated Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights because it did not provide a sufficiently fair balance between public interests and individual privacy.
Legal principles:
Automated government systems must respect privacy.
Data aggregation can create serious risks for individuals and communities.
Algorithmic systems require transparency and safeguards.
Public authorities must justify interference with fundamental rights.
Technology must not create disproportionate surveillance.
Relevance to Human-AI Collective Rights:
The decision is important for understanding the collective consequences of AI-supported government decisions.
It demonstrates how algorithmic systems can affect entire communities, particularly economically disadvantaged populations, and why collective privacy and equality interests require protection.
Case 8. Naruto v. Slater (2018)
Citation: 888 F.3d 418
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
Facts:
A macaque named Naruto took photographs using a camera belonging to a wildlife photographer.
An animal-rights organisation attempted to bring a copyright infringement claim on Naruto's behalf.
The dispute raised the question of whether a non-human entity could possess copyright-related legal standing.
Judgment:
The Ninth Circuit held that the Copyright Act did not expressly authorise animals to sue for copyright infringement.
Legal principles:
Statutory standing depends on the applicable legislation.
Non-human entities do not automatically possess legal rights.
Legal personality and legal standing must be established through law.
The ability to produce something does not necessarily establish the ability to own intellectual property.
Relevance to Human-AI Collective Rights:
Although the case concerned an animal rather than AI, it provides a useful comparison concerning non-human participation in creative activities.
It demonstrates why the ability to generate an output and the ability to hold legal rights must be treated as separate questions.
Legal distinction: These cases do not establish a general right of AI systems to participate as legal persons in human-AI collectives. They provide judicial principles for regulating collaboration, attribution, responsibility and the rights of affected humans.
6. Major Categories of Human-AI Collective Rights
A. Right to collaborative participation
This concerns the ability of individuals to participate meaningfully in activities involving AI systems.
Examples:
Human participation in AI-supported scientific research.
Employee involvement in AI-assisted workplace decisions.
Public participation in AI-supported government projects.
Human supervision of autonomous systems.
The law should prevent organisations from excluding humans from consequential decisions merely because automated systems are available.
B. Right to intellectual contribution and attribution
Human-AI collaboration creates questions concerning ownership and recognition.
Important issues include:
Who owns AI-assisted inventions?
Who receives copyright in AI-assisted creative works?
How should human contributions be identified?
Can AI-generated outputs be commercially exploited?
Who receives financial benefits from collaborative innovation?
The legal position depends on the relevant intellectual property legislation and contractual arrangements.
C. Collective data protection rights
AI systems frequently process information concerning groups of individuals.
Examples include:
Facial recognition databases.
Population-level behavioural profiling.
Workplace monitoring.
Predictive policing.
Collective health-data analysis.
A collective privacy framework should address risks that may affect groups even where no single individual's information is disclosed.
D. Right to algorithmic accountability
Individuals and communities should be able to challenge consequential decisions made through AI-assisted systems.
This includes:
Access to relevant explanations.
Human review.
Correction of inaccurate information.
Independent auditing.
Effective complaints mechanisms.
Remedies for discriminatory outcomes.
E. Right to fair distribution of benefits
Human-AI collaboration may generate considerable economic value.
Legal questions include:
Distribution of productivity gains.
Protection of employee contributions.
Fair licensing arrangements.
Compensation for human creative contributions.
Protection of researchers and data contributors.
7. Human-AI Collective Rights and Intellectual Property Law
Intellectual property is one of the most important areas of this emerging subject.
| Legal issue | Principal concern |
|---|---|
| Copyright | Ownership of AI-assisted creative works |
| Patent law | Recognition of human inventorship |
| Trade secrets | Protection of collaborative technological knowledge |
| Database rights | Rights in aggregated data |
| Moral rights | Attribution and integrity of human contributions |
| Licensing | Allocation of commercial usage rights |
| Contract law | Responsibility and ownership agreements |
Indian legal position
The Copyright Act, 1957 contains an important provision under Section 2(d)(vi), which identifies the person who causes a computer-generated literary, dramatic, musical or artistic work to be created as its author.
However, the application of this provision to modern generative AI remains unsettled.
Similarly, Indian patent law requires identification of an inventor under the Patents Act, 1970. AI itself is not recognised as an independent legal person or patent owner.
Accordingly, human-AI collaboration must be evaluated according to human contribution, applicable statutory provisions and contractual arrangements.
8. Human-AI Collective Rights and Civil Liability
When humans and AI systems jointly perform an activity that causes harm, civil liability becomes particularly important.
Major liability situations
1. Medical negligence
A doctor relies on an AI diagnostic recommendation that produces an incorrect diagnosis.
2. Employment discrimination
An employer uses an AI recruitment system that unfairly excludes qualified candidates.
3. Financial loss
A financial institution relies on an automated credit assessment that unlawfully discriminates against applicants.
4. Intellectual property infringement
A business uses AI-generated material that unlawfully reproduces protected creative works.
5. Consumer protection
An organisation provides misleading information through an AI chatbot.
6. Privacy violations
An AI system collects and processes personal information without a lawful basis.
Possible responsible parties
AI developers.
AI manufacturers.
Employers and deploying organisations.
Data controllers and processors.
Professional users.
Platform operators.
Government agencies.
Responsibility depends on the applicable legal duty, control, conduct, causation and statutory framework.
9. Human-AI Collective Rights and Constitutional Law in India
The Indian Constitution provides several foundations for regulating human-AI relationships.
| Constitutional provision | Relevance |
|---|---|
| Article 14 | Equality and protection against arbitrary algorithmic decisions |
| Article 19(1)(a) | Freedom of expression in AI-assisted communication |
| Article 19(1)(g) | Freedom to pursue professions and occupations |
| Article 21 | Privacy, dignity and personal autonomy |
| Article 32 | Constitutional remedies |
| Article 226 | High Court judicial review |
| Article 38 | Promotion of social welfare |
| Article 39 | Protection of economic and social interests |
Important Indian judicial precedents include:
Justice K.S. Puttaswamy v. Union of India (2017) – Privacy and informational autonomy.
Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015) – Freedom of online expression.
Anuradha Bhasin v. Union of India (2020) – Constitutional protection of internet-based freedoms.
National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India (2014) – Dignity, equality and recognition of individual identity.
These judgments can guide the development of constitutional protections for individuals participating in AI-driven society.
10. International Legal Frameworks
Human-AI collective rights are connected with several international instruments.
| Instrument | Legal significance |
|---|---|
| Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 1948 | Dignity, equality and expression |
| ICCPR, 1966 | Privacy, liberty and participation |
| ICESCR, 1966 | Education, work and economic development |
| Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2006 | Accessible and inclusive technology |
| UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, 2011 | Corporate accountability |
| UNESCO Recommendation on the Ethics of AI, 2021 | Human-centred AI governance |
| OECD AI Principles, 2019 | Responsible and trustworthy AI |
| Council of Europe Framework Convention on AI, 2024 | Human rights, democracy and rule of law in AI governance |
These instruments provide important foundations for ensuring that AI-assisted collective activities remain consistent with human rights.
11. Major Challenges in Human-AI Collective Rights
1. Absence of legal personality: AI systems generally cannot independently hold legal rights or obligations.
2. Unclear ownership: Human and machine contributions may be difficult to separate.
3. Accountability gaps: Developers, operators and users may dispute responsibility for harm.
4. Algorithmic discrimination: Collective decisions may disadvantage particular communities.
5. Data exploitation: Human contributions and personal information may be commercially exploited.
6. Unequal economic benefits: AI productivity gains may be concentrated among technology companies.
7. Lack of transparency: Individuals may not understand how AI-assisted decisions are made.
8. Cross-border jurisdiction: AI systems may operate across several countries with different legal rules.
9. Human autonomy: Excessive reliance on AI may reduce meaningful human decision-making.
10. Collective representation: Communities affected by AI systems may lack effective mechanisms to challenge decisions collectively.
12. Recommendations for Legal Development
A comprehensive legal framework for Human-AI Collective Rights should include:
Recognition of human contributions to AI-assisted innovation.
Clear rules governing AI-assisted intellectual property.
Mandatory human oversight in consequential decisions.
Collective data protection and anti-discrimination safeguards.
Transparent allocation of civil liability.
Protection of workers collaborating with AI systems.
Fair distribution of economic benefits.
Independent algorithmic audits.
Accessible remedies for affected communities.
Protection against manipulative AI systems.
Clear contractual rules for human-AI collaboration.
International cooperation concerning AI-related disputes.
13. Future Scope of Human-AI Collective Rights
Future legal development may involve several emerging concepts.
Human-AI collective intellectual property.
Rights of human-machine research teams.
Collective algorithmic decision-making rights.
Human-AI digital identity protection.
Collective biometric privacy.
Rights of workers in AI-integrated workplaces.
AI-assisted democratic participation.
Human-AI scientific knowledge ownership.
Collective protection against automated discrimination.
Legal recognition of human-machine collaborative organisations.
An especially important future question is whether groups of individuals affected by the same AI system should receive enhanced collective procedural rights, including collective access to information, independent review and group remedies.
Such protections could be developed without granting AI systems independent human rights or legal personality.
14. Conclusion
Human-AI Collective Rights represent an emerging field of legal scholarship concerned with the relationship between human autonomy, technological collaboration, collective interests and legal accountability.
The decisions in Thaler v. Vidal, Thaler v. Perlmutter, Thaler v. Comptroller-General, Commissioner of Patents v. Thaler, Moffatt v. Air Canada, State v. Loomis and the SyRI judgment illustrate the legal challenges associated with AI-generated innovation, automated decision-making, corporate responsibility and the protection of human rights.
These decisions demonstrate three important principles:
AI participation does not automatically create independent legal personality.
Human and organisational accountability must remain identifiable.
Human rights must remain protected when decisions and activities are performed through collaborative technological systems.
Ultimately, the purpose of Human-AI Collective Rights should be to create a legal environment in which humans can collaborate with intelligent technologies while retaining dignity, autonomy, equality, fair recognition and effective legal protection.
The fundamental objective is not to make humans subordinate to artificial intelligence, but to ensure that artificial intelligence advances collective human interests under accountable legal governance.

comments