Industrial Designs Law in San Marino
San Marino, a small and landlocked country surrounded by Italy, has its own legal system, which includes protections for intellectual property, including industrial designs. The country’s laws regarding industrial designs are closely aligned with European Union standards, although San Marino is not a member of the EU. Industrial design protection in San Marino is governed by a framework that ensures the aesthetic appearance of a product is legally protected, preventing others from copying or imitating the design.
Industrial designs are typically registered to protect the visual appearance of a product, such as its shape, pattern, or ornamentation. This protection is separate from patent protection, which covers functionality, and is usually granted for a period of 5 years with the possibility of renewal.
Let’s explore some hypothetical case studies to better understand how industrial design law functions in San Marino.
1. Industrial Design Registration Process
In San Marino, a designer or a company can register their industrial design with the Industrial Property Office of San Marino, which is responsible for managing intellectual property rights. The design must be new and have an individual character, meaning it must not be identical or similar to existing designs that have been made available to the public.
Example Case 1:
Applicant: A local San Marino company designs a new ergonomic chair for office use.
Outcome: The company files a design registration with the Industrial Property Office. The application is reviewed to ensure that the design is new (not previously disclosed) and has an individual character (not closely resembling other existing office chair designs). If approved, the company receives exclusive rights to the design for five years, which can be renewed up to four times, providing a total protection of 25 years. During this period, no other company in San Marino can produce or sell chairs with the same visual design.
2. Infringement of Industrial Design Rights
Once an industrial design is registered, the holder has the exclusive right to use the design and prevent others from copying it. If someone uses the registered design without permission, it constitutes infringement. The owner of the industrial design can take legal action against the infringer.
Example Case 2:
Design Owner: A San Marino fashion designer creates a distinctive handbag design and registers it with the Industrial Property Office.
Infringer: A competing designer in San Marino starts selling handbags that closely resemble the registered design.
Outcome: The fashion designer sends a cease-and-desist letter to the competing designer. When no action is taken, the designer files a lawsuit in San Marino’s courts for infringement of industrial design rights. The court could rule in favor of the designer, ordering the infringing designer to stop selling the imitative handbags and to compensate the designer for any damages caused.
3. Partial Designs and Originality
An industrial design can protect only the specific visual aspects of a product, but it must also meet the requirement of originality. In some cases, only part of a product's design may be protected, especially if that part is visually distinctive.
Example Case 3:
Applicant: A local San Marino company develops a new, innovative design for the handles of kitchen utensils, which are both functional and aesthetically appealing.
Outcome: The company submits a design registration for just the handle design, not the entire kitchen utensil. The design is granted protection because it demonstrates originality, and the handle's appearance is sufficiently distinct from other utensils. If another manufacturer produces utensils with similar-looking handles, the company could claim that its partial design is being infringed.
4. Opposition and Invalidity of Design Registrations
Industrial design registrations in San Marino are subject to challenges. Any party can file an opposition against the registration of a new design if they believe that the design does not meet the requirements for protection, such as novelty or individual character. In some cases, a design registration can be invalidated if it is found not to meet these criteria.
Example Case 4:
Opponent: A company in Italy files an opposition against a design registration in San Marino for a new type of bicycle frame.
Grounds: The Italian company claims that the design is not new, as similar designs have already been publicly available.
Outcome: The Industrial Property Office examines the opposition and compares the disputed design with existing designs. If the office determines that the design is not novel and that prior designs have been disclosed to the public, it could cancel the registration. In this case, the bicycle frame design would no longer enjoy protection in San Marino.
5. International Protection through the Hague Agreement
San Marino is a member of the Hague Agreement concerning the international registration of industrial designs. This means that businesses in San Marino can seek protection for their industrial designs in multiple countries through a single application.
Example Case 5:
Applicant: A San Marino-based furniture manufacturer designs a new line of contemporary chairs and wants to secure protection in several countries, including Italy, France, and Germany.
Outcome: The company files a single international application under the Hague Agreement through the San Marino Industrial Property Office. The design is registered internationally in several countries, providing the manufacturer with protection in each of these jurisdictions for a period of 5 years, with the possibility of renewals.
6. Use of Industrial Design in Branding and Marketing
Design registrations in San Marino can also be used as a tool for branding and marketing. A unique design can help distinguish a product in the marketplace and increase its commercial value. The design's protection also prevents competitors from copying it, allowing the brand owner to maintain a competitive edge.
Example Case 6:
Brand Owner: A San Marino luxury watch company creates a new design for its watch face, which is characterized by a unique pattern of concentric circles.
Outcome: The company registers the design in San Marino to protect the appearance of the watch face. The design becomes an integral part of the company’s branding strategy. As a result, the company is able to market its watches as exclusive, using the unique design as a key selling point. Competitors attempting to replicate the design face legal challenges, ensuring that the company can maintain its premium brand image.
Conclusion
San Marino offers a robust framework for industrial design protection, aligned with international standards like the Hague Agreement, and backed by local legal procedures for the registration, enforcement, and challenge of industrial designs. As with other jurisdictions, the law provides mechanisms for preventing infringement and for invalidating registrations that do not meet legal criteria. Businesses and designers in San Marino benefit from these protections, especially in industries where aesthetics and product design are essential to market success.
RELATED Blog
comments