Interpretation of Statutes at Aruba (Netherlands)
Here's an overview of Interpretation of Statutes in Aruba, part of the Kingdom of the Netherlands:
⚖️ Interpretation of Statutes in Aruba (Netherlands)
Aruba, while an autonomous country within the Kingdom of the Netherlands, follows a civil law tradition influenced by Dutch legal principles, particularly in statutory interpretation.
🔹 Legal System Background
Aruba has its own constitution (Staatsregeling van Aruba) and local laws.
The Kingdom of the Netherlands remains responsible for defense, foreign affairs, and some aspects of constitutional law.
The judicial system is integrated with the Dutch Caribbean courts and ultimately answers to the Supreme Court of the Netherlands (Hoge Raad).
🔹 Principles of Statutory Interpretation
Grammatical Interpretation (Letterlijke interpretatie)
Interpreting the statute based on the ordinary, literal meaning of the words.
Systematic Interpretation (Systematische interpretatie)
Understanding a provision in context with the broader legal framework and structure of the law.
Teleological (Purposive) Interpretation (Doelgerichte interpretatie)
Focusing on the intent or purpose of the law as expressed in the legislative history or overall goal.
Historical Interpretation (Wetshistorische interpretatie)
Considering the legislative history (e.g., parliamentary debates, committee reports) to determine the lawmaker's intention.
Comparative Interpretation
When relevant, courts may compare with Dutch law or decisions from the Netherlands due to their close legal ties.
🔹 Judicial Authority
The Common Court of Justice of Aruba, Curaçao, Sint Maarten, and of Bonaire, Sint Eustatius and Saba hears appeals and interprets statutes.
The Supreme Court of the Netherlands serves as the court of last resort for Aruba.
🔹 Constitutional and Human Rights Considerations
The Aruban Constitution and the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) play a role in statutory interpretation.
Courts may interpret statutes in line with fundamental rights or international treaties.
🔹 Use of Precedent
While Aruba follows civil law (not common law), case law is important for consistency.
Dutch jurisprudence (especially from the Hoge Raad) is highly persuasive in interpreting similar legal provisions.
Summary:
In Aruba, statutes are interpreted using civil law techniques — prioritizing literal meaning, legal coherence, legislative intent, and when relevant, Dutch legal tradition. Courts aim to give effect to the purpose of the law and ensure rights-consistent interpretations, especially in line with constitutional and international norms.
RELATED Blog
0 comments