Override Approvals Governance.
OVERRIDE APPROVALS GOVERNANCE
1. Meaning of Override Approvals
Override approvals refer to situations where a higher authority within a company or corporate group (such as the Board, a committee, or the holding company) authorises an action that overrides existing policies, delegated limits, internal controls, or standard approval hierarchies.
Examples include:
Board overriding a delegation matrix
Group headquarters approving exceptions to local policies
Senior management bypassing normal approval channels
2. Why Override Approvals Exist
Override approvals are permitted to:
Address emergencies
Enable commercial flexibility
Respond to exceptional business situations
However, they pose serious governance, compliance, and liability risks if not properly controlled.
📌 Overrides are exceptions, not substitutes for governance.
3. Legal Framework Governing Override Approvals
Override approvals must comply with:
Statutory provisions
Articles of Association
Fiduciary duties of directors
Principles of delegation and non-abdication
Standards of care, diligence, and good faith
4. Core Governance Risks of Override Approvals
Undermining internal controls
Dilution of accountability
Abuse of discretion
Regulatory non-compliance
Personal liability of approvers
Lifting of corporate veil in group contexts
5. Judicial Principles on Override Approvals
(At least 6 Case Laws)
1. Automatic Self-Cleansing Filter Syndicate Co. Ltd. v. Cuninghame (1906)
Held:
Powers vested in directors must be exercised in accordance with the company’s constitution.
Relevance:
Override approvals cannot contradict statutory provisions or articles.
2. Howard v. Patent Ivory Manufacturing Co. (1888)
Held:
Acts beyond authority are ultra vires and void.
Relevance:
Overrides beyond permissible limits are legally invalid.
3. Hogg v. Cramphorn Ltd. (1967)
Held:
Directors must exercise powers for proper purposes and in good faith.
Relevance:
Override approvals motivated by improper purposes breach fiduciary duty.
4. Official Liquidator v. P.A. Tendolkar (1973)
Held:
Directors can be liable for negligence even without direct participation.
Relevance:
Approving overrides without due diligence exposes directors to liability.
5. Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Escorts Ltd. (1986)
Held:
Corporate autonomy must be respected unless misused.
Relevance:
Group-level override approvals must not destroy subsidiary autonomy.
6. N. Rangachari v. BSNL (2007)
Held:
Internal arrangements do not override statutory responsibility.
Relevance:
Override approvals cannot be used as a defence against statutory default.
7. Sunil Bharti Mittal v. CBI (2015)
Held:
Criminal liability requires active role or mens rea.
Relevance:
Those granting overrides may be personally liable if involvement is established.
6. Override Approvals and Fiduciary Duties
Directors and senior managers approving overrides must ensure:
Proper purpose
Good faith
Due care and diligence
No conflict of interest
📌 Override ≠immunity from accountability.
7. Override Approvals vs Delegation of Authority
| Aspect | Delegation | Override Approval |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Planned & structured | Exceptional & discretionary |
| Frequency | Routine | Rare |
| Documentation | Pre-defined | Case-specific |
| Risk level | Moderate | High |
| Accountability | Clear | Often diffused |
8. Governance Safeguards for Override Approvals
To ensure legality and accountability:
Written justification for every override
Authority-specific override limits
Mandatory legal/compliance review
Time-bound validity
Board or committee ratification
Independent director oversight
Audit trail and reporting
9. Consequences of Improper Override Approvals
Acts declared ultra vires
Director and senior manager liability
Regulatory penalties
Breakdown of internal controls
Veil lifting in group structures
10. Conclusion
Override approvals test the integrity of corporate governance.
While flexibility is necessary, courts consistently emphasise that:
Overrides must be lawful
Authority must be exercised for proper purposes
Accountability cannot be bypassed
Effective override approvals governance ensures that exceptions remain controlled, justified, and transparent, rather than becoming a gateway to abuse and liability.
RELATED Blog
comments