Principle of proportionality in Russian disciplinary sanctions.

PRINCIPLE OF PROPORTIONALITY IN RUSSIAN DISCIPLINARY SANCTIONS

1. INTRODUCTION

The principle of proportionality in Russian disciplinary law requires employers to impose sanctions that correspond to the seriousness of an employee's misconduct, the circumstances in which the violation occurred, the employee's previous conduct, and the consequences of the disciplinary offence. Disciplinary liability cannot be exercised arbitrarily, excessively, or merely as a mechanism for punishment.

Russian employment law primarily regulates disciplinary sanctions through Articles 192 and 193 of the Labour Code of the Russian Federation. Article 192 establishes the permissible disciplinary sanctions, while Article 193 provides procedural safeguards governing their imposition. Judicial review ensures that disciplinary measures are legally justified, procedurally compliant, and proportionate to the misconduct.

The proportionality principle is particularly important where employers impose dismissal, demotion-related consequences, reprimands, or other serious disciplinary measures for relatively minor violations.

2. LEGAL FRAMEWORK

A. ARTICLE 192 OF THE LABOUR CODE

Article 192 of the Russian Labour Code generally permits employers to impose the following disciplinary sanctions:

Warning.

Reprimand.

Dismissal on disciplinary grounds where legally permitted.

Other disciplinary sanctions may only be imposed where specifically provided by federal legislation, applicable statutes, or disciplinary regulations governing particular categories of employees.

The employer cannot invent disciplinary penalties outside the statutory framework.

B. ARTICLE 193 OF THE LABOUR CODE

Article 193 establishes procedural requirements, including:

Requesting a written explanation from the employee.

Allowing the statutory period for submitting an explanation.

Documenting the employee's refusal to provide an explanation.

Observing statutory time limits for imposing disciplinary sanctions.

Issuing an appropriate disciplinary order.

Communicating the disciplinary order to the employee.

Failure to comply with these procedural requirements may result in the sanction being declared unlawful.

3. PRINCIPLE OF PROPORTIONALITY

Proportionality requires an employer to evaluate several factors before imposing a disciplinary sanction.

A. GRAVITY OF THE MISCONDUCT

The employer must assess the nature of the violation, whether it involved negligence or intentional conduct, and whether the misconduct seriously affected workplace operations.

B. CONSEQUENCES OF THE VIOLATION

Actual harm, financial loss, safety risks, operational disruption, or damage to the employer's interests may influence the severity of the sanction.

C. EMPLOYEE'S PREVIOUS CONDUCT

The employee's disciplinary history, performance record, length of service, and previous compliance may be relevant.

D. CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE OFFENCE

Personal circumstances, workload, unclear instructions, inadequate training, workplace conditions, and the employee's ability to comply with the instruction must be considered.

E. CONSISTENCY OF DISCIPLINARY TREATMENT

Employees committing similar violations should generally receive comparable sanctions unless objective differences justify different treatment.

4. CASE LAWS AND JUDICIAL AUTHORITIES

CASE 1: SUPREME COURT OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION – PLENUM RESOLUTION NO. 2 OF 17 MARCH 2004

DIRECT AUTHORITY – PROPORTIONALITY OF DISCIPLINARY SANCTIONS

The Supreme Court's Plenum Resolution No. 2, concerning the application of labour legislation by courts, provides important guidance on disciplinary dismissal and employer obligations.

The Court emphasised that when considering disciplinary dismissal, courts must examine whether the employer took into account the seriousness of the misconduct, the circumstances in which it occurred, and the employee's previous conduct and attitude toward work.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE:

A disciplinary sanction must be justified by the actual circumstances of the violation and cannot be imposed mechanically.

RELEVANCE:

Employers must demonstrate that dismissal or another serious sanction was proportionate and that relevant mitigating circumstances were considered.

CASE 2: SUPREME COURT JUDICIAL PRACTICE ON DISCIPLINARY DISMISSAL

DIRECT AUTHORITY – PROOF OF THE LEGALITY OF DISMISSAL

Russian judicial practice establishes that the employer bears responsibility for proving the legal grounds for disciplinary dismissal and compliance with the statutory procedure.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE:

The employer must establish the employee's misconduct, the employee's culpability, and the legality of the disciplinary procedure.

RELEVANCE:

An employer cannot rely solely on an internal investigation report or managerial allegation. Evidence must establish the misconduct and support the proportionality of the sanction.

CASE 3: SUPREME COURT PRACTICE REGARDING FAILURE TO PERFORM EMPLOYMENT DUTIES

DIRECT AUTHORITY – ASSESSMENT OF THE NATURE OF THE VIOLATION

Russian courts distinguish between serious misconduct and minor or technical violations of employment duties.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE:

The nature of the employee's duties, the seriousness of the violation, and the consequences of the misconduct must be evaluated before disciplinary dismissal.

RELEVANCE:

A minor procedural error, isolated mistake, or technical failure should not automatically justify the most severe disciplinary sanction.

CASE 4: SUPREME COURT PRACTICE ON REPEATED DISCIPLINARY VIOLATIONS

DIRECT AUTHORITY – REPEATED MISCONDUCT AND PRIOR SANCTIONS

Russian labour law permits dismissal in certain circumstances involving repeated failure to perform employment duties without valid reasons where the employee has an existing disciplinary sanction.

Courts examine whether the previous sanction was lawful, whether it remained effective, and whether the subsequent violation was properly established.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE:

Repeated misconduct must be legally established; an employer cannot manufacture repetition through invalid or improperly imposed sanctions.

RELEVANCE:

The proportionality of dismissal depends upon the validity of previous disciplinary measures and the nature of the subsequent offence.

CASE 5: SUPREME COURT PRACTICE ON ABSENCE FROM WORK

DIRECT AUTHORITY – DISMISSAL FOR ABSENCE

Russian judicial practice concerning dismissal for absenteeism requires courts to examine whether the employee's absence constituted legally recognised misconduct and whether the employer properly evaluated the reasons for absence.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE:

The circumstances surrounding absence, including possible valid reasons, must be considered rather than treating every absence as automatically warranting dismissal.

RELEVANCE:

Employers must investigate the circumstances of absence and distinguish intentional misconduct from circumstances involving illness, emergencies, or other legally relevant explanations.

CASE 6: SUPREME COURT PRACTICE ON PROCEDURAL VIOLATIONS UNDER ARTICLE 193

DIRECT AUTHORITY – PROCEDURAL FAIRNESS

Russian courts have consistently treated compliance with Article 193 as a critical element of disciplinary liability.

LEGAL PRINCIPLE:

A disciplinary sanction may be unlawful where the employer fails to request an explanation, violates statutory time limits, improperly documents misconduct, or fails to comply with notification requirements.

RELEVANCE:

Even where misconduct is established, procedural violations may invalidate the disciplinary sanction. Proportionality and procedural legality are separate requirements.

5. FACTORS CONSIDERED BY COURTS

Courts generally examine:

The nature and seriousness of the misconduct.

Whether the employee acted intentionally or negligently.

The consequences of the misconduct.

The employee's previous disciplinary record.

The employee's work history and performance.

Whether the employee was properly instructed.

Whether the employer applied the rules consistently.

Whether mitigating circumstances were considered.

Whether the disciplinary procedure was followed.

Whether the sanction was excessive in relation to the violation.

6. EMPLOYER COMPLIANCE REQUIREMENTS

Employers should maintain a structured disciplinary process.

A. INVESTIGATION

Investigate the alleged violation and collect reliable evidence before imposing a sanction.

B. EMPLOYEE EXPLANATION

Request a written explanation and allow the employee the legally required opportunity to respond.

C. PROPORTIONALITY ASSESSMENT

Prepare a written assessment explaining why the selected sanction is appropriate considering the misconduct, consequences, prior conduct, and mitigating circumstances.

D. CONSISTENCY

Compare the sanction with disciplinary measures imposed in similar cases.

E. PROCEDURAL COMPLIANCE

Ensure compliance with Article 193 and applicable internal regulations.

F. DOCUMENTATION

Maintain investigation reports, evidence, employee explanations, disciplinary orders, and records of communication.

7. LEGAL CONSEQUENCES OF DISPROPORTIONATE SANCTIONS

Where a disciplinary sanction is disproportionate or procedurally unlawful, courts may:

Declare the disciplinary sanction unlawful.

Cancel the disciplinary order.

Reinstate an unlawfully dismissed employee.

Award compensation for lost wages.

Award compensation for moral harm where legally justified.

Require correction of employment records.

Impose additional consequences under applicable employment law.

8. CONCLUSION

The principle of proportionality is a fundamental safeguard against arbitrary disciplinary power under Russian employment law. Articles 192 and 193 of the Labour Code require employers to impose lawful sanctions and comply with procedural requirements, while judicial interpretation emphasises the importance of evaluating the gravity of misconduct, surrounding circumstances, employee history, and consequences.

A disciplinary sanction must not be automatic or punitive beyond what the misconduct reasonably warrants. Employers must investigate violations carefully, consider mitigating circumstances, maintain consistent disciplinary practices, and provide procedural fairness.

The legality of disciplinary action therefore depends not merely on whether an employee violated a workplace rule, but also on whether the employer selected a legally permissible, procedurally valid, and proportionate sanction.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT