Prosecution Of Spousal Assault Cases In Village Courts
I. Legal Framework
Relevant Laws:
Muluki Criminal Code (2017) – Sections relevant to domestic violence and spousal assault:
Section 277–280: Voluntarily causing hurt; simple or grievous bodily harm.
Section 278: Assault causing death (if extreme violence occurs).
Section 301–303: Harassment, verbal abuse, or intimidation.
Domestic Violence (Crime and Punishment) Act, 2009 – Specifically addresses violence against spouses, marital rape, economic abuse, and provides mechanisms for redress.
Village Court Act / Local Level Courts Act – Village Courts have jurisdiction over minor criminal offences and mediation; more severe cases are forwarded to District Courts.
Jurisdiction of Village Courts:
Minor spousal assault cases (causing injury without lasting disability) are usually handled at Village Court.
Village Courts may mediate disputes but can also impose penal sentences up to their legal limits.
If assault is severe (e.g., leading to grievous injury or death), the case is escalated to the District Court.
Procedure:
Complaint lodged by the victim or family at the Village Court.
Court conducts preliminary investigation; attempts reconciliation/mediation.
If unsuccessful or assault is severe, the accused is prosecuted under criminal provisions.
Punishment can include fine, imprisonment, or both, depending on severity.
II. Case Illustrations
Case 1: Bhaktapur Village Court – Physical Assault (2022)
Facts:
A husband repeatedly slapped and kicked his wife after an argument over household expenses.
Victim filed a complaint at Bhaktapur Village Court, citing visible bruises and minor injuries.
Legal Issues:
Assault causing hurt (Muluki Criminal Code, Section 277).
Domestic violence under Domestic Violence (Crime and Punishment) Act.
Court Action:
Village Court attempted mediation first.
Husband admitted assault; wife demanded legal action due to repeated incidents.
Court imposed 3 months imprisonment and a fine of NPR 10,000.
Significance:
Demonstrates Village Court’s dual role: reconciliation and penal enforcement.
Even minor physical assault is punishable, especially when repeated.
Case 2: Kaski Village Court – Battery With Object (2021)
Facts:
A husband struck his wife with a kitchen utensil, causing a fracture on her hand.
Complaint lodged by victim’s family; police brought accused to Village Court.
Legal Issues:
Causing hurt with weapon (Muluki Criminal Code, Section 278).
Economic abuse and intimidation (Domestic Violence Act).
Court Action:
Village Court verified medical report confirming fracture.
Mediation was refused by victim due to fear.
Imposed 6 months imprisonment, fine NPR 15,000; instructed husband to pay medical expenses.
Significance:
Shows Village Court handling mid-level assault cases with weapon.
Integration of medical evidence into prosecution.
Case 3: Rautahat Village Court – Recurrent Verbal and Physical Abuse (2020)
Facts:
Husband repeatedly verbally abused and slapped wife over dowry disputes.
Victim sought police protection; filed complaint at Village Court.
Legal Issues:
Psychological abuse, verbal harassment (Domestic Violence Act).
Simple assault causing hurt (Criminal Code).
Court Action:
Court held reconciliation meeting; mediation unsuccessful.
Husband fined NPR 8,000; probation imposed for six months.
Court warned of imprisonment for repeat offense.
Significance:
Highlights Village Court use of reconciliation as first step, but penal consequences applied when mediation fails.
Case 4: Sindhupalchok Village Court – Severe Injury (2019)
Facts:
Husband beat wife with a stick, causing deep cuts and hospitalization.
Case filed at Village Court due to remote location; police investigation supported victim.
Legal Issues:
Grievous hurt (Muluki Criminal Code, Section 278).
Domestic Violence Act violations.
Court Action:
Village Court referred to District Court due to severity.
Local court ordered temporary protective measures: husband prohibited from approaching victim.
Case escalated to District Court for sentencing.
Significance:
Shows Village Courts’ limitation: severe assaults escalated to higher court.
Village Courts can still enforce protection orders and immediate relief.
Case 5: Dolakha Village Court – Assault During Pregnancy (2021)
Facts:
Pregnant wife was assaulted by husband after argument over household chores.
Complaints cited threat to pregnancy and minor injuries.
Legal Issues:
Causing hurt to a pregnant woman (Aggravated assault under Criminal Code).
Domestic Violence Act provisions for spousal protection.
Court Action:
Court issued protection order preventing husband from entering home.
Imposed 2 months imprisonment suspended for 1 year as husband promised to attend counseling.
Court monitored compliance with protection order.
Significance:
Village Court applied both penal and protective measures.
Suspension of sentence emphasizes rehabilitation and reconciliation.
Case 6: Lalitpur Village Court – Economic Abuse With Threats (2022)
Facts:
Husband prevented wife from accessing bank account; threatened to evict her.
Complaint included both verbal abuse and economic control.
Legal Issues:
Economic abuse (Domestic Violence Act).
Threats/intimidation (Criminal Code, Section 301).
Court Action:
Mediation attempted; husband required to provide financial access.
Village Court imposed fine of NPR 5,000 and counseling sessions.
Court warned of stricter penalties if threats continued.
Significance:
Village Courts can handle non-physical spousal abuse.
Enforcement blends mediation, fines, and counseling.
III. Observations & Patterns
Types of Liability in Village Courts:
Physical assault: slaps, kicks, battery with object.
Severe injury: fractures, deep cuts, harm to pregnant spouse.
Psychological abuse: verbal harassment, threats, intimidation.
Economic abuse: restricting access to funds or property.
Enforcement Approach:
Step 1: Mediation/Reconciliation (priority).
Step 2: Penal action if mediation fails or assault is severe.
Step 3: Protective orders for victim (stay away, no contact).
Punishments Applied:
Short-term imprisonment (2–6 months), fines (NPR 5,000–15,000).
Compensation for medical or property damage.
Suspended sentences conditional on good behavior or counseling.
Limitations:
Severe assault often escalated to District Court.
Enforcement depends on police reporting and medical documentation.
Repeated offenders face stricter punishment and cumulative liability.
Role of Medical Evidence:
Essential in proving assault and determining severity.
Village Court uses medical reports to escalate cases appropriately.
IV. Conclusion
Village Courts in Nepal play a dual role in spousal assault cases:
Mediation & reconciliation to maintain social harmony.
Criminal prosecution under Muluki Criminal Code and Domestic Violence Act when assault occurs, repeated, or severe.
The above six cases illustrate:
Handling of minor and moderate assaults locally.
Escalation of serious cases to District Court.
Use of fines, imprisonment, protective orders, and counseling.
Legal recognition of physical, psychological, and economic abuse under Nepalese law.
Key Principle: The Village Court balances community-level dispute resolution with criminal accountability, ensuring spousal assault is addressed even in remote areas.
RELATED Blog
comments