Section 257 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, (BSA), 2023
Section 257 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (Indian Evidence Act, 2023) pertains to admissibility of electronic records as evidence in court. This section is a critical provision in the context of modernizing legal proceedings with respect to the use of electronic evidence.
Below are some hypothetical cases and legal scenarios where Section 257 might be applied:
1. Case of Digital Evidence in Criminal Proceedings (Hypothetical Case)
Facts: A person is accused of cybercrime involving the manipulation of bank records. The prosecution intends to present digital evidence, such as server logs, email correspondence, and video recordings of online transactions, to prove the crime.
Issue: Whether electronic records, such as server logs and emails, are admissible in court under Section 257 of the BSA.
Ruling: The court would likely admit the digital records as evidence if they meet the standards set in Section 257, ensuring the integrity of the evidence is intact. The records would need to be properly authenticated by a witness familiar with the technology used, or through certification under the provisions of the Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act).
Importance of Section 257: This section would help establish that the electronic records (like emails or logs) are authentic and have not been tampered with.
2. Case of Admissibility of Social Media Posts in Defamation Suit
Facts: A public figure files a defamation suit against an individual who posted derogatory comments about the plaintiff on social media. The defendant claims that the post is not an authentic representation of their views and was doctored.
Issue: Can screenshots or copies of social media posts be admitted as evidence under Section 257?
Ruling: Section 257 could permit the admission of screenshots or digital copies of the post as evidence, provided they are certified or supported by an expert in digital forensics who can testify that the posts are genuine and not altered. The prosecution may also rely on metadata or logs from the social media platform itself.
Importance of Section 257: It allows for the use of digital content, such as social media posts, in a court of law if the authenticity can be verified.
3. Case of Electronic Contract in Commercial Dispute
Facts: A business dispute arises where one party claims a contract was made electronically via email exchanges, and the other party denies it. The email thread, along with digital signatures, forms the basis of the alleged contract.
Issue: Whether the email exchanges and digital signatures can be admitted as valid evidence under Section 257.
RELATED Blog
comments