Victim Rights, Compensation, And Restorative Justice Measures
1. Victim Rights in India
Victims of sexual offenses and other crimes have been increasingly recognized as stakeholders in the criminal justice system. The key aspects include:
Right to Protection
Safe environment during investigation and trial (e.g., witness protection, no direct confrontation with the accused).
Court may allow in-camera trials under Section 327 CrPC for sexual offenses.
Right to Participation
Victims can be kept informed about investigation progress.
They may be allowed to participate in plea bargaining or restorative justice initiatives.
Right to Compensation and Rehabilitation
Under Section 357 CrPC, courts may award compensation to victims.
State Victim Compensation Schemes (e.g., under Section 357A CrPC) provide monetary relief for medical treatment, rehabilitation, and loss of livelihood.
Right to Speedy Trial
Fast-track courts for sexual assault cases, especially under POCSO (Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012).
Right to Legal Aid
Free legal assistance under Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987.
2. Compensation and Restorative Justice
Restorative Justice: Focuses on rehabilitation of the victim and reintegration into society, rather than only punishing the offender.
Methods include:
Monetary compensation for trauma or injury
Counseling and trauma care
Community-based rehabilitation programs
Apology or acknowledgment from the offender (in minor cases or juvenile cases)
3. Landmark Cases
Case 1: State of Punjab v. Gurmit Singh (1996) 2 SCC 384
Facts: Gang rape case. Victims underwent severe trauma.
Judgment: Court emphasized punishment of offenders but also acknowledged the need for victim rehabilitation and counseling.
Significance: Highlighted psychological support as part of justice.
Case 2: Rudal Sah v. State of Bihar (1983) 4 SCC 141
Facts: Victim imprisoned illegally; case indirectly led to recognition of state responsibility towards victims.
Judgment: Supreme Court stressed compensation where the state fails in its duty to protect citizens.
Significance: Laid foundation for state compensation as a principle of justice.
Case 3: Delhi Domestic Working Women’s Forum v. Union of India (1995) 1 SCC 14
Facts: Domestic workers faced sexual harassment and exploitation.
Judgment: Court held that victims must be provided rehabilitation, counseling, and financial support, alongside prosecution of offenders.
Significance: Expanded victim rights to compensation and social protection.
Case 4: Delhi Domestic Working Women’s Forum v. Union of India (another aspect)
The Supreme Court ordered compensation for sexual harassment, emphasizing restorative justice to reintegrate victims into society.
Case 5: Lillu v. State of Haryana (2010)
Facts: Minor victim of sexual assault. Delayed reporting and trauma affected her.
Judgment: Court awarded monetary compensation under Section 357A CrPC for psychological treatment and future security.
Significance: Reinforced the victim compensation scheme and rehabilitation as integral to justice.
Case 6: State of Madhya Pradesh v. Ramesh (2011)
Facts: Victim’s family sought compensation after brutal assault and murder.
Judgment: Court not only upheld conviction but directed state to pay monetary compensation to surviving family members.
Significance: Recognized compensation as a right alongside punishment of offender.
Case 7: Sakshi v. Union of India (2004) 5 SCC 518
Facts: Sexual harassment and rape cases often left victims unsupported.
Judgment: Supreme Court ordered that victim rehabilitation, counseling, and victim-friendly infrastructure in courts are essential.
Significance: Strengthened the idea of restorative justice measures as a core part of trial proceedings.
4. Key Principles from Case Law
Monetary Compensation
Victims or their families can claim compensation from the state under Section 357A CrPC.
Psychological and Social Rehabilitation
Counseling and social reintegration are emphasized in cases like Gurmit Singh and Sakshi.
Victim Participation and Dignity
Courts prioritize in-camera trials, anonymity, and legal aid to uphold victims’ rights.
State Responsibility
If the state fails to prevent the crime or provide timely protection, compensation becomes mandatory (Rudal Sah).
Restorative Justice
Justice is not only punitive but also rehabilitative, ensuring victims regain dignity, safety, and financial security.
RELATED Blog
comments