Civil Law And Specific Performance Judicial Enforcement Of Obligations In Uae .
1. Introduction
Specific performance is an important civil-law remedy through which a court orders a contracting party to perform the exact obligation undertaken under a legally valid contract rather than merely paying monetary compensation for its breach.
In the United Arab Emirates (UAE), specific performance plays a significant role in contractual disputes involving:
Sale and purchase of immovable property.
Construction and infrastructure agreements.
Commercial supply contracts.
Share purchase agreements.
Banking and financing arrangements.
Real estate development.
Intellectual property licensing.
Long-term commercial agreements.
Delivery of goods and machinery.
Transfer of ownership and registration of property.
The fundamental principle is that a valid contractual obligation should ordinarily be performed according to its agreed terms. Where a party refuses to perform, the other party may seek judicial intervention, subject to the nature of the obligation, the applicable legislation and the availability of an appropriate remedy.
The principal legislative foundation is the UAE Civil Transactions framework, supplemented by the Civil Procedure legislation, commercial legislation, real estate regulations and applicable emirate-specific laws.
An important distinction: Specific performance and enforcement of judgments are two different stages. Specific performance is the substantive remedy sought from the court; judicial enforcement is the procedural process through which the resulting judgment or enforceable instrument is implemented.
2. Applicable UAE legislation
A major legislative development must be considered when studying this subject in 2026.
Current framework
Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 promulgating the Civil Transactions Law, effective from 1 June 2026, replaced Federal Law No. 5 of 1985.
This means that the applicable statutory provisions depend partly on when the contract was made and the relevant transitional rules.
A. Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 – Civil Transactions Law
The new Civil Transactions Law establishes the general principles governing contractual obligations and their enforcement.
Important provisions include:
Article 221 – Good-faith performance
Contracts must be performed according to their contents and in accordance with good faith. Contractual obligations may also extend to requirements arising from law, custom and the nature of the transaction.
Article 222 – Reciprocal obligations
In bilateral contracts, a party may have the right to withhold its corresponding performance when the other party fails to perform an obligation that is due.
Article 292 – Compulsory performance
The debtor must perform an obligation when it becomes due and its legal conditions are satisfied. If the debtor refuses, performance may be compelled.
Articles 293–294 – Voluntary and compulsory performance
These provisions distinguish voluntary performance from compulsory performance, including performance in kind and performance by way of compensation.
Articles 331–332 – Specific performance
These provisions are particularly important to the subject.
The new framework recognizes performance in kind where it remains possible. It also addresses circumstances in which performance would impose an excessive burden on the debtor, allowing monetary substitution subject to the statutory protection of the creditor's interests.
UAE Legislation+3
B. Former Federal Law No. 5 of 1985
For contracts governed by the former Civil Transactions Law, Article 272 was particularly important.
It provided that where one party failed to perform a bilateral contract, the other party could, after giving notice, demand:
Performance of the contract; or
Rescission of the contract.
The judge could order immediate performance, grant additional time or order rescission with compensation where appropriate.
Article 272 remains important when studying historical UAE judgments, but it should not be incorrectly cited as the current statutory provision for contracts governed by the 2025 law.
UAE Legislation+1
C. Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2022 – Civil Procedure Code
This legislation governs the procedural enforcement of civil and commercial judgments.
Article 212 identifies enforceable instruments, including qualifying judgments and orders, notarised documents and court-certified settlements.
The enforcement process is supervised by the competent execution court.
The legislation also provides mechanisms for:
Attachment of assets.
Seizure of funds.
Sale of attached property.
Enforcement against debtors.
Execution of enforceable judgments.
Recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments and arbitral awards.
Polaris Legal Library+1
D. Federal Decree-Law No. 50 of 2022 – Commercial Transactions Law
Commercial contracts may also be subject to the Commercial Transactions Law.
It is relevant to:
Commercial sales.
Supply contracts.
Banking transactions.
Commercial agency relationships.
Business financing.
Commercial payment obligations.
The Civil Transactions Law supplements the commercial framework where appropriate.
E. Federal Law No. 6 of 2018 – Arbitration
Where a contract contains an arbitration agreement, contractual disputes may be referred to arbitration.
An arbitral tribunal may determine contractual rights and grant remedies within its jurisdiction and the applicable law.
However, coercive implementation of certain remedies, especially land-title registration, may require judicial assistance.
3. Meaning and essential elements of specific performance
Specific performance is a remedy requiring the defaulting party to perform the precise obligation agreed upon.
For example:
A agrees to sell a commercial building to B for AED 10 million. B pays the agreed amount, but A refuses to transfer ownership.
Instead of seeking only compensation, B may request an order requiring A to complete the sale and cooperate with the necessary registration procedures.
Essential requirements
1. Valid contract
The claimant must establish that a legally valid and enforceable contract exists.
2. Identifiable contractual obligation
The obligation must be sufficiently clear to allow the court to determine what performance is required.
3. Breach or refusal
The defendant must have failed or refused to perform an obligation that has become due.
4. Claimant's readiness and willingness
Where the contract involves reciprocal obligations, the claimant must establish that they have performed, or are ready and able to perform, their corresponding obligations.
5. Possibility of performance
The requested performance must remain legally and practically possible.
6. Compliance with mandatory law
The remedy cannot require an unlawful transfer, violation of public policy or infringement of protected third-party rights.
4. Specific performance versus monetary compensation
| Basis | Specific performance | Monetary compensation |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Actual performance | Financial substitute |
| Objective | Fulfil contractual expectations | Compensate for loss |
| Suitable for | Transfer of property, delivery of goods | Financial and consequential losses |
| Practical requirement | Performance remains possible | Loss must be legally recoverable |
| Court intervention | Order to perform | Order to pay |
| Example | Transfer of a purchased building | Payment for failure to transfer |
Specific performance is especially important where money alone cannot adequately protect the claimant's contractual interest.
However, it is not automatically granted in every contractual dispute.
5. Judicial conditions for granting specific performance
A. Impossibility of performance
A court cannot ordinarily compel a party to perform something that has become objectively and legally impossible.
Example: A seller agrees to transfer a particular property but that property has been lawfully destroyed or its transfer has become legally impossible.
The court must consider whether another legally permissible form of performance remains available.
B. Excessive burden
The new Civil Transactions Law recognizes the need to balance the creditor's entitlement to performance against an excessive burden on the debtor.
A court may consider monetary substitution where the statutory conditions are satisfied.
C. Third-party rights
Specific performance cannot ordinarily be used to defeat legally protected rights of third parties.
Example: A seller cannot be ordered to transfer property in a manner that unlawfully overrides an earlier protected ownership interest.
D. Reciprocal obligations
A purchaser who has not paid the agreed consideration may not automatically obtain an unconditional order requiring the seller to transfer ownership.
The court examines the contractual sequence of obligations and whether the claimant has fulfilled the conditions for performance.
E. Good faith
The court may examine whether the claimant has acted honestly and consistently with contractual obligations.
A claimant cannot generally rely on a contractual breach that was materially caused by the claimant's own improper conduct.
F. Personal obligations
Where the obligation depends upon unique personal skill, artistic judgment or personal confidence, a court may need to consider whether compulsory performance is legally and practically appropriate.
Compensation may be more suitable in certain circumstances.
6. Important case laws on specific performance and judicial enforcement
The following cases provide useful judicial guidance. They include onshore UAE judgments and decisions from the DIFC and ADGM courts. The distinction matters because the DIFC and ADGM have separate legal systems and their judgments are not automatically binding on mainland UAE courts.
Case 1. Dubai Court of Cassation – Case No. 77 of 2011
Onshore UAE · Construction contract
Facts and legal issue:
The dispute concerned the rights of parties under a construction contract when contractual work was not properly completed.
The judgment considered the remedies available to the innocent party under UAE construction law, including termination and the appointment of another contractor to complete the remaining work at the defaulting contractor's expense.
Legal principles:
Contractual obligations must be performed according to their agreed terms.
The innocent party may seek appropriate remedies when the contractor fails to perform.
The relationship between termination and replacement performance must be properly established.
The court must examine the contractual arrangement before permitting another contractor to take over the work.
Importance:
This decision is particularly relevant to construction contracts because it illustrates that the remedy must correspond to the contractual relationship and the nature of the breach.
The decision was also discussed in BAM Higgs & Hill LLC v Affan Innovative Structures LLC.
Case 2. VTJ Limited v Mohammed Ammar Al Hassan [2018] DIFC CA 009
DIFC Court of Appeal · 6 November 2018
Facts:
The dispute concerned an alleged contract for the sale of a property unit in the Parks Tower development in the DIFC.
The claimant sought specific performance of the alleged sale agreement or, alternatively, reimbursement of sums paid.
The first-instance court dismissed the claim, and the claimant appealed.
Legal issues:
Whether an enforceable sale agreement existed.
Whether the claimant had established the contractual requirements for specific performance.
Whether the property transaction could be implemented through the relevant registration procedures.
Legal significance:
The decision demonstrates that:
Specific performance requires proof of a binding contractual obligation.
The court must examine the actual agreement rather than rely merely on negotiations or payments.
Property registration requirements are relevant to the enforceability of a transfer.
Alternative monetary remedies may be considered where specific performance cannot be established.
Importance for the UAE:
This case is particularly useful for real-estate sale agreements, where the purchaser seeks actual transfer rather than merely reimbursement.
DIFC Courts+1
Case 3. BAM Higgs & Hill LLC v Affan Innovative Structures LLC and Another [2021] DIFC CFI 106
DIFC Court of First Instance · 2021
Facts:
The dispute involved a construction subcontract and disagreements about completion of contractual works.
The parties disagreed over whether the main contractor could take over the remaining subcontract works without first terminating the subcontractor's contractual engagement.
Legal issues:
Construction obligations.
Defective and incomplete performance.
Contractual termination.
Replacement contractors.
The limits of remedies under UAE law.
Judicial reasoning:
The court examined Dubai Court of Cassation Case No. 77 of 2011 and the interpretation of Article 877 of the former Civil Transactions Law.
It explained that, in the absence of an appropriate contractual provision, the main contractor could not simply take over the remaining subcontract works while leaving the original subcontractor employed under the subcontract.
Legal principles:
The contractual structure determines the permissible remedy.
A party cannot disregard the agreed contractual relationship.
Termination and replacement performance must be distinguished.
Contractual remedies must be consistent with the applicable law.
Importance:
This case demonstrates that specific performance and substitute performance must be analysed in the context of the actual construction contract.
DIFC Courts
Case 4. Salem Dwela v DAMAC Park Towers [2018] DIFC CFI 083
DIFC Court of First Instance · 2018
Facts and subject:
This property-related dispute concerned contractual completion and the parties' obligations in relation to a real-estate transaction.
Legal significance:
The case is useful for examining:
Contractual completion obligations.
Property-related contractual rights.
The importance of establishing the terms of the transaction.
The distinction between contractual entitlement and the remedy available.
Relevance to specific performance:
A claimant seeking completion of a property transaction must demonstrate that the agreement is sufficiently certain and that the required transfer can legally be implemented.
Qualification: This is a DIFC decision and should not be treated as a mainland UAE Court of Cassation judgment.
Case 5. Al Khaleej Investment P.S.C. v Ocean Pearl Real Estate Comp LLC [2026] ADGMCFI 0017
Major 2026 authority
ADGM Court of First Instance · 5 June 2026
Facts:
The dispute concerned a sale and purchase agreement dated 24 December 2024 involving land on Al Reem Island.
The agreed purchase price was AED 105 million, and the purchaser provided a security cheque for AED 21 million.
The transaction was not completed, and the purchaser sought specific performance or, alternatively, damages.
The seller challenged the enforceability of the agreement.
Judicial decision:
The ADGM Court held that the agreement was binding and enforceable and granted specific performance.
The decision required the seller to take the necessary steps to complete the sale, subject to the purchaser tendering the purchase price.
The seller's counterclaim, including its claim concerning forfeiture of the security cheque, was dismissed.
Legal principles:
A valid land sale agreement may be specifically enforced.
Property rights must be considered alongside registration requirements.
The transition of land registration arrangements does not necessarily invalidate existing contractual obligations.
Specific performance is a discretionary remedy.
Damages may be considered where actual performance cannot be achieved.
Importance for the UAE:
This decision is particularly significant because it demonstrates how a UAE court within the ADGM jurisdiction can order actual completion of a substantial real-estate transaction.
However, its equitable reasoning arises from the ADGM legal framework and should not be automatically applied to mainland UAE proceedings.
33 Chambers+1
Case 6. A32 v B32 [2026] ADGMCFI 0018
ADGM Court of First Instance · 9 June 2026
Facts:
The dispute concerned an option agreement relating to a property unit on Al Maryah Island.
An arbitral tribunal had found that the option agreement was valid and subsisting and that specific performance was required.
The successful party subsequently sought judicial enforcement.
Legal questions:
Could the arbitral award be enforced?
Could the court make an order requiring the actual transfer of property?
What was the relationship between arbitral jurisdiction and judicial enforcement?
Could the seller be required to submit the necessary registration documents?
Judicial decision:
The court granted the enforcement application and ordered the seller to:
Take the necessary steps to transfer the title deed.
Submit the required documents to the ADGM Registration Authority.
Complete the transfer free from encumbrances, charges and third-party claims.
Legal principles:
An arbitral tribunal can determine contractual validity and enforceability within its jurisdiction.
The court can provide coercive orders necessary to implement an enforceable award.
Judicial enforcement can include affirmative obligations to complete property registration.
The distinction between deciding contractual rights and implementing them is essential.
Importance:
This is a particularly valuable authority for the relationship between specific performance, arbitration and judicial enforcement.
jusmundi.com+1
Case 7. Faysal Mohamad Awad v 3AM Property Investment Company LLC [2025] ADGMCFI 0045
ADGM Court of First Instance · 7 March 2025
Facts and subject:
The proceedings concerned property-related contractual rights and the requirements for an enforceable agreement.
The court considered the statutory requirements governing dispositions of land, limitation issues and the availability of specific performance.
Legal significance:
The decision is useful for understanding:
The importance of a sufficiently binding property agreement.
Statutory formalities governing land transfers.
The distinction between contractual rights and registered ownership.
Limitation defences.
The availability of specific performance as a remedy.
The court's ability to consider additional enforcement measures.
Importance for UAE practice:
A party cannot assume that every property-related promise creates an automatically enforceable right to registration. The underlying agreement and applicable registration requirements must be established.
assets.adgm.com
Case 8. A32 v B32 – Arbitral Award dated 3 October 2025
Abu Dhabi-seated arbitration · 2025
Facts:
The arbitral tribunal considered the validity and enforceability of an option agreement between the parties.
The tribunal determined that the agreement remained valid and that relief in the nature of specific performance was necessary.
The award subsequently became the subject of recognition and enforcement proceedings before the ADGM Court.
Legal principles:
Arbitration can determine contractual validity.
Contractual rights may be enforced through an arbitral award.
The distinction between arbitral relief and coercive judicial orders is important.
Courts can provide implementation orders within their enforcement jurisdiction.
Importance:
When combined with the June 2026 judgment in A32 v B32, this arbitration illustrates the full enforcement sequence: contractual determination, arbitral award, judicial recognition and coercive implementation.
Arbitral Digest Archive+1
Case-law comparison
| Case | Court or tribunal | Main principle |
|---|---|---|
| Dubai Cassation 77/2011 | Onshore UAE | Construction performance and replacement contractor |
| VTJ v Al Hassan (2018) | DIFC Court of Appeal | Property sale and enforceability |
| BAM Higgs & Hill v Affan (2021) | DIFC CFI | Construction remedies and termination |
| Salem Dwela v DAMAC (2018) | DIFC CFI | Property completion obligations |
| Al Khaleej v Ocean Pearl (2026) | ADGM CFI | Specific performance of land sale |
| A32 v B32 (2026) | ADGM CFI | Judicial implementation of an arbitral award |
| Awad v 3AM (2025) | ADGM CFI | Property formalities and specific relief |
| A32 v B32 arbitration (2025) | Abu Dhabi-seated arbitration | Contractual validity and performance |
These decisions illustrate the development of specific-performance principles across different UAE judicial jurisdictions. They are not eight interchangeable precedents under one uniform procedural system.
7. Judicial procedure for obtaining specific performance in the UAE
A party seeking specific performance generally proceeds through the following stages.
Examination of the contract
The claimant establishes the contractual relationship, agreed obligations, payment conditions and performance deadlines.
Formal notice of breach
The claimant provides notice where required by the contract or applicable law and gives the defaulting party an opportunity to perform.
Filing a civil or commercial claim
The claimant approaches the competent court, requesting specific performance and, where appropriate, alternative compensation.
Submission of evidence
Evidence may include contracts, invoices, correspondence, bank transfers, expert reports, completion certificates and registration documents.
Judicial examination
The court considers validity, breach, reciprocal obligations, possibility of performance and the appropriate remedy.
Judgment
The court may order actual performance, grant additional time, award compensation or provide another legally appropriate remedy.
Execution proceedings
Once the judgment becomes enforceable, the successful party may initiate execution proceedings before the competent execution court.
8. Methods of judicial enforcement
A. Enforcement of monetary obligations
Where the judgment requires payment of money, enforcement may involve:
Attachment of bank accounts.
Attachment of receivables.
Seizure of movable assets.
Attachment and sale of eligible property.
Other legally permitted execution measures.
B. Enforcement of property-transfer obligations
Where a seller refuses to transfer property after a judgment ordering specific performance, the successful party may seek implementation of the transfer through the competent court and land-registration authority.
The court's order must be sufficiently clear regarding the required transfer and applicable registration formalities.
C. Enforcement of construction obligations
Where a contractor is ordered to fulfil a contractual obligation, the execution process depends on the nature of the obligation and the wording of the judgment.
If actual performance is no longer possible, the court may have to consider the legally available alternative remedies.
D. Enforcement of arbitral awards
Under the UAE Arbitration Law, an arbitral award can be recognized and enforced through the competent court, subject to the statutory requirements.
The distinction between an award determining contractual rights and a court order implementing a property transfer is illustrated by A32 v B32.
9. Defences against specific performance
A defendant may resist a specific-performance claim on several grounds.
| Defence | Legal argument |
|---|---|
| Contractual invalidity | No valid enforceable agreement exists |
| Impossibility | The promised performance cannot legally or practically occur |
| Claimant's default | The claimant failed to fulfil reciprocal obligations |
| Lack of certainty | The contractual obligation is insufficiently defined |
| Third-party rights | Performance would unlawfully prejudice another person's rights |
| Force majeure | An applicable event has made performance impossible |
| Limitation | The claim is barred under applicable limitation rules |
| Mandatory legal restrictions | The requested performance violates applicable law |
| Excessive burden | Statutory conditions for monetary substitution are satisfied |
A defence of impossibility must be distinguished from mere inconvenience, increased expense or commercial difficulty. The court examines the facts and applicable statutory conditions.
10. Specific performance in different sectors of the UAE economy
A. Real estate
DP retrofits 11 Dubai towers to offset over 100 tonnes of CO2 - Facilities Management Middle East
Specific performance may be requested where a developer or seller refuses to complete a valid property transaction.
Examples include:
Transfer of title.
Delivery of possession.
Completion of sale agreements.
Execution of registration documents.
Compliance with contractual handover obligations.
B. Construction and infrastructure
Construction Management Software for UAE & Gulf | Arkan
Construction disputes may involve incomplete work, defective performance, delayed completion and refusal to comply with contractual specifications.
The court must examine whether actual performance remains appropriate and how the contract allocates responsibility.
C. Banking and financial services
Specific performance may arise in disputes involving:
Release of securities.
Execution of financing documents.
Delivery of pledged assets.
Contractually required release of guarantees.
Compliance with settlement arrangements.
D. Commercial supply agreements
A purchaser may request delivery of specifically identified machinery, equipment or goods rather than simply receiving monetary compensation.
However, the availability of the goods, their uniqueness and the contractual terms are important.
E. Corporate transactions
Specific performance may also arise in disputes involving:
Transfer of company shares.
Completion of share purchase agreements.
Delivery of corporate documents.
Exercise of contractual options.
Compliance with shareholder agreements.
The remedy remains subject to applicable company law, regulatory approval and registration requirements.
11. Practical drafting recommendations for UAE contracts
Businesses seeking stronger protection should consider including the following contractual provisions:
Clear performance obligations: Define exactly what each party must deliver or complete.
Performance deadlines: Establish specific dates and milestones.
Notice provisions: Specify the method and period for notifying contractual breaches.
Cure periods: Give the defaulting party a defined opportunity to remedy a breach.
Cooperation obligations: Require both parties to execute necessary documents and provide reasonable assistance.
Specific performance clause: Expressly acknowledge the right to seek specific performance where legally available.
Alternative compensation: Establish appropriate remedies if actual performance becomes impossible.
Governing law: Clearly identify the applicable legal system.
Dispute resolution: Specify the competent courts or agreed arbitration mechanism.
Enforcement arrangements: Identify the documents, registrations and cooperation required to implement the contractual outcome.
A contractual clause requesting specific performance does not guarantee that the court will grant it. The court retains the powers and discretion provided by the applicable law.
12. Critical analysis: Challenges in UAE judicial enforcement
The UAE framework faces several practical challenges.
1. Delay in enforcement: Even after obtaining a judgment, practical enforcement may take time, particularly where assets are difficult to locate.
2. Cross-border transactions: Foreign parties and overseas assets create jurisdictional and recognition issues.
3. Multiple judicial systems: Mainland UAE courts, DIFC Courts and ADGM Courts operate under different procedural and substantive frameworks.
4. Property-registration formalities: A contractual right to transfer property does not automatically produce registered ownership.
5. Arbitration enforcement: The relief granted by an arbitral tribunal must be compatible with the applicable arbitration law and available judicial enforcement mechanisms.
6. Impossibility and excessive burden: Courts must balance the creditor's entitlement against the legal and practical possibility of actual performance.
7. Transitional legislation: Contracts governed by the former 1985 Civil Transactions Law must be distinguished from contracts governed by the 2025 legislation.
13. Conclusion
Specific performance and judicial enforcement form an important part of the UAE's civil-law system.
The new Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 strengthens the statutory framework governing contractual obligations, good-faith performance and compulsory fulfilment. The Civil Procedure Code provides the procedural machinery for implementing enforceable judgments.
The principal legal distinction is between the right to demand contractual performance and the court's ability to compel that performance.
The cases of VTJ Limited v Mohammed Ammar Al Hassan, BAM Higgs & Hill v Affan, Al Khaleej Investment v Ocean Pearl and A32 v B32 illustrate the significance of contractual certainty, property registration, actual performance and judicial enforcement.
Ultimately, UAE law seeks to protect contractual expectations while ensuring that judicial remedies remain legally possible, proportionate and consistent with third-party rights and mandatory legislation.
14. Important legislation and judicial authorities for examination
| Authority | Subject |
|---|---|
| Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 | Civil Transactions Law |
| Federal Decree-Law No. 42 of 2022 | Civil Procedure Code |
| Federal Decree-Law No. 50 of 2022 | Commercial Transactions Law |
| Federal Law No. 6 of 2018 | Arbitration |
| Dubai Cassation Case No. 77/2011 | Construction performance |
| VTJ Ltd v Al Hassan [2018] | Property specific performance |
| BAM Higgs & Hill [2021] | Construction remedies |
| Al Khaleej v Ocean Pearl [2026] | Land-sale specific performance |
| A32 v B32 [2026] | Judicial enforcement of arbitral award |
Academic takeaway: The central principle of UAE specific-performance law is that contractual obligations should be fulfilled in kind where legally and practically possible. Where actual performance cannot appropriately be compelled, the court may consider monetary compensation or another remedy permitted by law.

comments