Civil Law And Strata Law And Jointly Owned Property In Uae .
1. Introduction
Statelessness, refugee status and civil rights protection are important areas of civil law and human rights law because they concern the legal identity, personal security, family relationships, property rights and social existence of individuals who lack effective nationality or have been forced to leave their countries.
In the United Arab Emirates (UAE), these issues arise in connection with:
Stateless persons, including long-term residents commonly referred to as Bidoon.
Refugees and asylum-seekers fleeing armed conflict or persecution.
Children born in the UAE to stateless or foreign parents.
Individuals whose nationality has been withdrawn or disputed.
Foreign residents facing deportation or immigration detention.
Families experiencing separation because of immigration restrictions.
Access to education, healthcare, employment and property.
Legal recognition of identity documents and civil status.
The central legal question is:
How can the UAE protect the civil and fundamental rights of individuals who do not possess a recognized nationality, have refugee-like protection needs or cannot obtain effective legal recognition of their identity?
The answer requires examining UAE constitutional law, nationality legislation, civil transactions law, immigration legislation, international human rights treaties and comparative judicial decisions.
An important distinction must be maintained: refugee status, statelessness and foreign-resident status are three different legal conditions. A foreign national is not automatically a refugee, and a refugee is not necessarily stateless.
2. Meaning and legal nature of statelessness
A. Definition of statelessness
Under Article 1(1) of the 1954 Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless Persons, a stateless person is someone who is not considered a national by any state under the operation of its law.
For example:
A person is born in Country A, but the nationality laws of Country A do not grant citizenship by birth. The person's parents are citizens of Country B, but Country B does not permit transmission of nationality in the circumstances of the birth.
If neither country recognizes that person as a national, the person may be stateless.
B. Categories of stateless persons
Statelessness may arise in several ways.
1. De jure statelessness
The individual is not legally recognized as a national by any state.
2. De facto statelessness
The individual possesses a nationality in formal legal terms but cannot effectively obtain protection or recognition from the state concerned.
3. Statelessness from birth
A child acquires no nationality at birth because of gaps or conflicts in nationality legislation.
4. Statelessness through nationality deprivation
An individual loses nationality through withdrawal, cancellation or other state action without acquiring another nationality.
5. Administrative statelessness
A person cannot establish nationality because of missing birth certificates, identity documents, registration records or other official evidence.
6. Intergenerational statelessness
Statelessness continues from parents to children across several generations.
C. Bidoon and statelessness in the UAE
Abu Dhabi Real Estate Market Overview & Forecast (2025 & 2026) | The Luxury Playbook
The term Bidoon is used in the Gulf region to describe certain individuals who lack recognized nationality.
In the UAE context, statelessness has historically involved people who cannot establish citizenship despite longstanding family or residential connections with the country.
Issues may include:
Lack of recognized nationality.
Difficulties obtaining official identification.
Restricted access to certain public services.
Problems registering births and marriages.
Employment and residency difficulties.
Challenges in establishing inheritance rights.
Limited opportunities for naturalization.
There is no reliable publicly established comprehensive official count of stateless people in the UAE.
The UAE has undertaken initiatives concerning the Bidoon population, including nationality and documentation measures. However, the existence of such initiatives does not mean that every affected person has acquired UAE nationality.
3. UAE constitutional framework for civil rights protection
The UAE Constitution provides the foundation for legal protection of individuals, including important protections relevant to foreigners and stateless persons.
A. Article 25 – Equality before the law
Article 25 establishes equality before the law and prohibits distinctions on specified grounds.
Its wording must be read carefully: it refers to equality of all individuals in law and also expressly addresses distinctions among UAE citizens based on origin, nationality, religion and social status.
The provision is relevant when examining discriminatory treatment and access to legal protection.
B. Article 26 – Personal liberty and protection against torture
Article 26 provides constitutional safeguards concerning personal liberty, arrest, detention and protection against torture or degrading treatment.
It is particularly relevant to stateless individuals and refugees facing immigration detention.
C. Article 28 – Fair trial and presumption of innocence
Article 28 protects the presumption of innocence and fair-trial safeguards.
These protections are important where a refugee or stateless person becomes involved in criminal or immigration-related proceedings.
D. Article 40 – Rights of foreigners
Article 40 is particularly significant because it addresses the rights and freedoms of foreigners under applicable international instruments and UAE legislation.
It helps explain why civil and human rights protections cannot be understood exclusively as privileges of UAE citizenship.
E. Article 41 – Right to complain
Article 41 recognizes the right to submit complaints to competent authorities, including judicial authorities, concerning violations of constitutional rights and freedoms.
This is relevant to persons seeking remedies for unlawful administrative action or violations of their legally protected rights.
UAE Legislation+2
4. Nationality legislation and protection against statelessness
A. Federal Law No. 17 of 1972 Concerning Nationality and Passports
The principal nationality legislation is Federal Law No. 17 of 1972, as amended, including Federal Decree-Law No. 16 of 2017.
The legislation regulates:
Acquisition of UAE nationality.
Nationality by descent.
Naturalization.
Nationality of children.
Nationality through marriage in specified circumstances.
Loss and withdrawal of nationality.
Recognition of certain historical nationality claims.
B. Nationality by descent
The law recognizes nationality through specified parental relationships.
Generally, a child born to a UAE national father acquires UAE nationality by law.
The law also recognizes specified situations involving a UAE national mother, including circumstances where the father is unknown, stateless or legally unestablished.
C. Children of UAE national mothers
The 2017 amendments introduced Article 10 bis, which provides a mechanism for children of Emirati women married to foreign nationals to obtain UAE nationality after meeting statutory requirements.
This is important for preventing intergenerational nationality problems.
However, the mechanism is not identical to unrestricted automatic transmission of nationality in every case.
D. Naturalization
Naturalization is governed by statutory requirements and the relevant competent authorities.
It should not be treated as an automatic entitlement merely because a person has lived in the UAE for a long period.
E. Withdrawal of nationality
Nationality withdrawal raises important legal questions involving:
Statutory authority.
Procedural fairness.
Individual circumstances.
Family consequences.
Risk of statelessness.
Access to judicial or administrative review.
The possibility of nationality deprivation must be examined alongside the Constitution and applicable international obligations.
ICJ Web+2
5. The important connection with the UAE Civil Transactions Law 2025
An especially important development for this topic is Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 promulgating the new Civil Transactions Law, effective from 1 June 2026.
This legislation contains a particularly relevant provision concerning stateless individuals.
Article 24 – Applicable law for stateless persons
Article 24 expressly provides:
The law of the United Arab Emirates shall apply in the case of stateless persons.
This provision is significant in private international law.
It can become relevant where a stateless individual is involved in a civil dispute concerning:
Personal legal status.
Family relationships.
Contractual capacity.
Civil obligations.
Property transactions.
Other matters involving conflict of laws.
For example:
A stateless person habitually residing in Dubai enters into a civil contract with another individual. A question arises concerning which national law governs the person's legal status.
Article 24 provides a specific UAE-law connecting rule for stateless persons.
However, an essential distinction must be made:
Article 24 does not grant UAE nationality or automatically confer refugee status.
It determines the applicable law for relevant private international law questions. It is not a nationality-granting provision.
Article 75 of the same law addresses natural persons and confirms that UAE nationality is determined according to the applicable nationality legislation.
UAE Legislation+1
6. Refugee status under the UAE legal framework
A. Meaning of refugee status
A refugee is generally a person who has left their country because of a well-founded fear of persecution based on grounds such as:
Race.
Religion.
Nationality.
Membership of a particular social group.
Political opinion.
The internationally recognized definition is contained in Article 1A(2) of the 1951 Refugee Convention.
Refugees may also require protection because of armed conflict, torture, serious human rights violations or other threats to life and personal security.
B. UAE and the 1951 Refugee Convention
An important feature of UAE refugee law is that the UAE is not a party to:
The 1951 Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees.
The 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees.
The 1954 Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless Persons.
The 1961 Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness.
Consequently, the UAE does not operate a domestic refugee-status determination framework based on the 1951 Convention in the same way as states that have ratified it.
UNHCR nevertheless maintains a role concerning refugees and asylum-seekers in the country.
Rights Mapping and Analysis Platform+1
C. Humanitarian residence and immigration protection
The UAE immigration framework provides different forms of residence and entry permission, including arrangements for humanitarian cases.
Federal Decree-Law No. 29 of 2021 concerning Entry and Residence of Foreigners is an important part of the immigration framework.
Humanitarian residence arrangements should not be confused with formal recognition as a refugee under the 1951 Convention.
Their availability and duration depend on applicable regulations and decisions of competent authorities.
D. Role of UNHCR
The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees plays an important humanitarian and protection-related role.
Its functions include:
Identifying persons requiring international protection.
Assessing protection needs under its mandate.
Providing relevant humanitarian assistance.
Supporting vulnerable refugees.
Facilitating protection-related cooperation.
Working with competent authorities.
UNHCR's recognition of an individual under its mandate should be distinguished from a UAE-issued immigration or nationality status.
7. Non-refoulement and protection against forced return
Non-refoulement is one of the most important principles of international refugee and human rights law.
It means that a person should not be returned to a country where there are legally relevant grounds to believe that the person would face prohibited serious harm.
A. Article 3 of the Convention Against Torture
The UAE acceded to the Convention Against Torture (CAT) on 19 July 2012.
Article 3 prohibits the expulsion, return or extradition of a person to another state where substantial grounds exist for believing that the person would be in danger of being subjected to torture.
This protection is not dependent on whether the person has formally obtained refugee status.
treaties-prod.un.org+2
B. Scope of protection
The principle is relevant in cases involving:
Deportation.
Extradition.
Immigration removal.
Transfer to another state.
Return following immigration detention.
A person alleging a risk of torture should have the risk assessed individually and effectively.
C. Important distinction
CAT Article 3 specifically concerns the risk of torture.
It should not be treated as identical to the broader refugee non-refoulement protection under Article 33 of the 1951 Refugee Convention.
The prohibition of return to torture also exists independently of refugee recognition.
The wider customary international law position concerning other forms of serious harm requires careful legal analysis and should not be assumed to reproduce every provision of the Refugee Convention in UAE domestic law.
8. Civil rights of refugees and stateless persons
The protection of civil rights involves more than immigration permission.
It also concerns the individual's ability to participate in ordinary legal and social life.
A. Right to legal identity
Legal identity is essential for accessing government services and exercising civil rights.
Problems arise where a person lacks:
Birth certificates.
Recognized passports.
National identity documents.
Marriage certificates.
Official family records.
A lack of documentation can affect the person's ability to prove age, parentage, marriage, inheritance and contractual capacity.
B. Family rights and marriage
Statelessness can create difficulties in:
Marriage registration.
Divorce proceedings.
Recognition of parentage.
Child custody.
Guardianship.
Family reunification.
Inheritance.
For example, where a stateless father cannot establish recognized nationality or identity, the child's civil registration and family documentation may become complicated.
The relevant UAE personal-status legislation and applicable conflict-of-laws rules must be examined.
C. Property rights
Stateless persons and refugees may encounter legal difficulties when acquiring, registering or transferring property.
However, lack of nationality does not automatically eliminate all property rights.
The legal position depends on:
Applicable property legislation.
Emirate-specific ownership restrictions.
Validity of the underlying transaction.
Registration requirements.
Applicable immigration rules.
D. Employment rights
Stateless persons and refugees may face difficulties obtaining employment authorization because of missing or unrecognized identity documents.
The UAE Labour Relations framework regulates employment relationships and provides protections for workers within its scope.
A person's lack of nationality does not, by itself, establish that an employer can disregard contractual wages or other applicable labour obligations.
E. Education
Children requiring international protection may face difficulties accessing education because of documentation, financial or residency problems.
The Convention on the Rights of the Child is particularly relevant.
Article 22 addresses protection and humanitarian assistance for children seeking refugee status or considered refugees.
Article 7 addresses birth registration, the right to a name and the right to acquire a nationality.
The UAE is a party to the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
F. Healthcare
Access to healthcare may involve:
Emergency medical assistance.
Public-health protections.
Insurance requirements.
Treatment of children.
Protection of vulnerable individuals.
Administrative documentation.
Statelessness should not be confused with the absence of all legally protected healthcare interests.
G. Access to justice
A stateless individual may need to initiate proceedings involving:
Employment disputes.
Family disputes.
Property claims.
Contractual disputes.
Immigration decisions.
Compensation claims.
Article 41 of the Constitution is relevant to the right to complain to competent authorities.
Practical access may nevertheless depend on identity documentation, procedural requirements, legal representation and the particular jurisdiction.
9. At least seven important case laws and judicial precedents
There is an important research limitation: there is no well-established published series of UAE appellate judgments specifically determining refugee status or the legal rights of the Bidoon population.
The following are therefore comparative international decisions. They are useful for interpreting principles that may inform UAE legal analysis, but they are not binding UAE precedents.
Case 1. Nottebohm Case (Liechtenstein v. Guatemala), 1955
International Court of Justice · Judgment of 6 April 1955
Facts:
Friedrich Nottebohm was originally a German national who had lived in Guatemala for many years.
During the Second World War, he obtained Liechtenstein nationality through naturalization.
Liechtenstein subsequently sought to exercise diplomatic protection on his behalf against Guatemala.
The dispute concerned whether Guatemala was required to recognize the nationality granted by Liechtenstein for the purposes of diplomatic protection.
Judgment:
The International Court of Justice held that the nationality in question could not be relied upon against Guatemala for diplomatic protection because the necessary genuine connection between Nottebohm and Liechtenstein had not been established.
Legal principles:
Nationality has an important connection with the legal relationship between an individual and a state.
Genuine connections may matter when nationality is invoked internationally for diplomatic protection.
Formal acquisition of nationality and its international opposability are distinct questions.
Nationality can have important consequences for international legal protection.
Relevance to the UAE:
The case is useful when examining nationality claims by long-term residents and stateless individuals.
However, it must not be misinterpreted as creating a general rule that every person must prove a genuine connection to acquire nationality under domestic law.
ICJ Web+1
Case 2. Soering v. United Kingdom (1989)
European Court of Human Rights · Application No. 14038/88
Facts:
Jens Soering faced extradition from the United Kingdom to the United States, where he was charged with murder.
He argued that extradition would expose him to the death-row phenomenon and treatment contrary to Article 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Judgment:
The European Court of Human Rights held that extradition would violate Article 3 if it exposed the applicant to a real risk of inhuman or degrading treatment.
Legal principles:
A state must consider the foreseeable consequences of extradition.
Human rights obligations may restrict international transfers.
Protection against inhuman treatment is not limited to the state's own territory.
The existence of a real and foreseeable risk is central to the assessment.
Relevance to the UAE:
This decision is useful when examining the consequences of deportation or extradition of refugees, asylum-seekers and stateless persons.
In the UAE context, CAT Article 3 provides the directly relevant treaty protection where there is a substantial risk of torture.
HUDOC+1
Case 3. Chahal v. United Kingdom (1996)
European Court of Human Rights · Application No. 22414/93
Facts:
Chahal was a Sikh political activist who faced deportation from the United Kingdom to India.
He argued that his return would expose him to torture or inhuman treatment.
The British authorities raised national-security concerns.
Judgment:
The European Court held that Article 3 protection was absolute.
National-security concerns could not justify returning a person where substantial grounds established a real risk of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment.
Legal principles:
Protection against torture cannot be balanced against national-security convenience under Article 3.
Immigration authorities must examine individual risks.
The legal assessment cannot depend solely on the person's immigration status.
The possibility of serious harm must be assessed before removal.
Relevance to the UAE:
The decision provides important comparative guidance for deportation and extradition proceedings.
The UAE's obligations under CAT Article 3 must be examined independently of the Refugee Convention.
HUDOC
Case 4. Genovese v. Malta (2011)
European Court of Human Rights · Application No. 53124/09
Facts:
The applicant was born in Scotland to a British mother and a Maltese father outside marriage.
He was denied Maltese nationality under the applicable nationality legislation.
The legal dispute concerned discrimination in nationality transmission based on the circumstances of birth and the sex of the parent.
Judgment:
The European Court found a violation of Article 14 in conjunction with Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
It recognized that nationality may form part of an individual's private life and social identity.
Legal principles:
Nationality can be an important aspect of personal identity.
Arbitrary nationality decisions may engage human-rights protection.
Discrimination in nationality legislation may violate equality guarantees.
Children should not be subjected to unjustified distinctions based on their parents' marital status.
Relevance to the UAE:
This decision is particularly relevant when considering nationality transmission by Emirati mothers, children born outside marriage and the civil identity of stateless children.
It provides comparative guidance for examining whether nationality legislation creates unjustified discriminatory outcomes.
Melbourne Law School
Case 5. M.S.S. v. Belgium and Greece (2011)
European Court of Human Rights · Application No. 30696/09
Facts:
The applicant was an Afghan asylum-seeker who entered the European Union through Greece and subsequently travelled to Belgium.
Under the European Dublin system, Belgium transferred him back to Greece.
He complained about detention conditions, living conditions and deficiencies in the asylum procedure.
Judgment:
The European Court found violations relating to the applicant's treatment in Greece and Belgium's failure to adequately consider the risks associated with transferring him.
Legal principles:
Asylum-seekers are entitled to protection against inhuman treatment.
States must examine the actual conditions in the receiving country.
Deficiencies in asylum procedures can create serious human-rights consequences.
Immigration transfers require meaningful risk assessment.
Human dignity remains relevant during detention and reception.
Relevance to the UAE:
This case is important when examining the treatment of asylum-seekers in immigration detention and the consequences of transferring individuals to countries where their safety or fundamental rights may be threatened.
HUDOC
Case 6. Hirsi Jamaa and Others v. Italy (2012)
European Court of Human Rights · Application No. 27765/09
Facts:
Italian authorities intercepted migrants travelling by sea and transferred them to Libya.
The migrants were not individually assessed before being returned.
They argued that they faced serious risks in Libya and could subsequently be sent to countries where they would face persecution or ill-treatment.
Judgment:
The European Court found violations concerning collective expulsion and the prohibition of inhuman treatment.
It held that Italy exercised jurisdiction over the individuals while they were under the effective control of Italian authorities on the vessels.
Legal principles:
Human-rights obligations can apply outside national territory.
Effective state control is important in determining jurisdiction.
Individual protection assessments are essential.
Collective removal without appropriate safeguards can violate human rights.
States cannot avoid applicable human-rights responsibilities merely by conducting operations outside their territory.
Relevance to the UAE:
This case is relevant to maritime interception, immigration transfers and deportation operations involving persons seeking international protection.
It also illustrates the importance of examining effective control when determining extraterritorial human-rights responsibility.
HUDOC+1
Case 7. Kurić and Others v. Slovenia (2012)
European Court of Human Rights · Application No. 26828/06
Facts:
Following the dissolution of Yugoslavia, certain individuals who had been permanent residents of Slovenia were removed from the country's register of permanent residents.
The removal deprived them of legal residence documentation and affected their ability to exercise fundamental rights.
Some individuals became effectively stateless or experienced prolonged insecurity concerning their legal status.
Judgment:
The Grand Chamber found violations of Article 8 and other provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The Court emphasized the serious consequences of the administrative removal of long-term residents from the register.
Legal principles:
Administrative documentation can be essential to civil identity.
Long-term residents may have protected private and family life.
Arbitrary removal from residence registers can create serious human-rights consequences.
States must provide effective procedures to regularize legal status.
Administrative decisions should not create disproportionate harm to established family and social relationships.
Relevance to the UAE:
This case is particularly relevant to long-term residents who lack recognized nationality or experience difficulties renewing immigration documentation.
It demonstrates why administrative status and documentation should be examined as substantive civil-rights issues.
Melbourne Law School
Case-law summary
| Case | Principal legal issue | UAE relevance |
|---|---|---|
| Nottebohm (1955) | Nationality and genuine connection | Nationality claims |
| Soering (1989) | Extradition and serious harm | Protection against return |
| Chahal (1996) | Absolute protection against torture | Deportation safeguards |
| Genovese (2011) | Nationality discrimination | Children's nationality |
| M.S.S. (2011) | Asylum procedures and detention | Refugee treatment |
| Hirsi Jamaa (2012) | Extraterritorial jurisdiction | Maritime transfers |
| Kurić (2012) | Statelessness and residence documentation | Long-term residents |
These are comparative precedents from international courts. They do not establish that the UAE has adopted the European Convention on Human Rights or is directly bound by these judgments.
10. Civil liability and legal protection of stateless persons
Civil liability becomes important when stateless individuals experience wrongful conduct, discrimination, contractual exploitation or deprivation of legally protected interests.
A. Wrongful denial of civil documentation
Where an individual is legally entitled to a document but an authority or responsible party unlawfully refuses to provide it, the individual may seek an appropriate administrative or judicial remedy under the applicable law.
B. Employment exploitation
If an employer fails to pay wages or violates an enforceable employment obligation, the affected individual may pursue remedies under UAE labour legislation, subject to jurisdiction and procedural requirements.
C. Property and inheritance disputes
A stateless person may have legally recognized interests in property or inheritance.
The absence of nationality does not automatically extinguish those interests.
The court must consider the applicable substantive law, Article 24 of the Civil Transactions Law and relevant property and personal-status legislation.
D. Family separation
Unlawful conduct or decisions affecting family unity may raise issues concerning:
Child welfare.
Guardianship.
Custody.
Parentage.
Family registration.
Legally recognized residence rights.
E. Unlawful detention or removal
Where detention or removal violates applicable legal safeguards, the affected person may seek remedies available under UAE law and applicable international obligations.
The availability of compensation depends on the relevant legal basis, proof and jurisdiction.
11. Major legal challenges in the UAE
| Challenge | Legal problem | Possible protection |
|---|---|---|
| Bidoon statelessness | Lack of recognized nationality | Nationality and administrative review |
| Birth registration | Missing identity documents | Civil registration procedures |
| Refugee recognition | No comprehensive Refugee Convention asylum system | Humanitarian and protection arrangements |
| Deportation | Risk of torture following return | CAT Article 3 |
| Nationality withdrawal | Risk of statelessness | Constitutional and statutory safeguards |
| Family separation | Uncertain legal identity | Personal-status remedies |
| Employment exclusion | Documentation difficulties | Applicable labour protections |
| Property rights | Difficulty proving legal identity | Civil and property proceedings |
| Inheritance | Conflict-of-laws complications | Civil Transactions Law Article 24 |
| Access to justice | Procedural and documentation barriers | Constitutional complaint mechanisms |
A. Absence of a comprehensive refugee-status determination system
The absence of a domestic framework based on the 1951 Refugee Convention creates uncertainty about:
Refugee recognition.
Duration of protection.
Employment authorization.
Family reunification.
Appeals against adverse decisions.
Long-term residence.
B. Intergenerational statelessness
Where parents cannot establish nationality, children may inherit the same documentation difficulties.
This creates a cycle of exclusion affecting education, family registration and civil identity.
C. Nationality transmission and gender equality
Differences in the statutory mechanisms governing transmission of nationality through mothers and fathers create important questions concerning equality and prevention of childhood statelessness.
D. Administrative discretion
Humanitarian residence and nationality decisions may involve administrative discretion.
Clear procedures, transparent criteria and effective review mechanisms are important for protecting individuals against arbitrary decisions.
12. Important international conventions applicable to the UAE
The following table distinguishes treaties to which the UAE is a party from treaties it has not joined.
| International instrument | UAE position | Relevance |
|---|---|---|
| Convention Against Torture 1984 | Party since 2012 | Non-refoulement against torture |
| Convention on the Rights of the Child 1989 | Party | Children's identity and protection |
| Convention on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination 1965 | Party | Protection against racial discrimination |
| CEDAW 1979 | Party | Women's rights and nationality-related equality |
| 1951 Refugee Convention | Not a party | No treaty-based refugee framework |
| 1967 Refugee Protocol | Not a party | No protocol-based refugee framework |
| 1954 Stateless Persons Convention | Not a party | No treaty-based stateless-person status |
| 1961 Statelessness Reduction Convention | Not a party | No treaty-based reduction framework |
| ICCPR 1966 | Not a party | No ICCPR treaty obligations |
tbinternet.ohchr.org+3
A particularly important point is that the UAE's accession to CAT creates treaty obligations even though it has not acceded to the Refugee Convention.
13. Recommendations for strengthening UAE civil rights protection
The following reforms could improve the protection of stateless individuals and refugees.
1. Comprehensive statelessness legislation
A dedicated legal framework could establish a clear definition of statelessness, identification procedures and protections against arbitrary deprivation of nationality.
2. Improved nationality determination
Long-term residents with credible historical and family connections should have access to transparent nationality determination procedures.
3. Prevention of childhood statelessness
Birth-registration procedures and nationality safeguards should ensure that children do not remain without effective nationality because of gaps in parental nationality transmission.
4. Refugee protection framework
A comprehensive protection system could establish eligibility criteria, asylum procedures, temporary protection and appeal mechanisms.
5. Non-refoulement safeguards
Clear administrative procedures should ensure that every relevant risk of torture is assessed before deportation or extradition.
6. Legal identity protection
Accessible procedures should be available for obtaining birth certificates, identity documents and civil-status records.
7. Family unity
Appropriate legal mechanisms should protect children and families from unnecessary separation.
8. Access to justice
Legal assistance and accessible complaint mechanisms should be strengthened for persons who cannot establish their nationality or immigration status.
9. Civil registration reforms
Registration procedures should accommodate individuals who lack conventional identity documentation.
10. International cooperation
Cooperation with UNHCR and relevant international organizations could strengthen humanitarian protection, documentation and statelessness prevention.
14. Hypothetical legal problems and their application
Problem 1: Child born in the UAE to stateless parents
A child is born in Abu Dhabi. Neither parent possesses recognized nationality.
Legal issues:
Registration of birth.
Determination of parentage.
Nationality eligibility.
Prevention of childhood statelessness.
Legal identity.
Applicable law: UAE nationality legislation, civil registration legislation, the Convention on the Rights of the Child and relevant civil-law provisions.
Article 24 of the Civil Transactions Law may also become relevant to private international law questions concerning the child's civil status.
Problem 2: Refugee facing deportation
A foreign resident informs UAE authorities that returning to the country of origin would expose them to torture.
Legal issues:
Risk assessment.
Deportation procedure.
Humanitarian protection.
International treaty obligations.
Applicable law: CAT Article 3 and relevant UAE immigration legislation.
The absence of formal refugee recognition does not remove the protection against return to torture under CAT.
Problem 3: Stateless person seeking inheritance
A stateless person residing in Dubai inherits property under a legally relevant family relationship.
Legal issues:
Legal capacity.
Applicable inheritance law.
Proof of family relationships.
Property registration.
Applicable law: Civil Transactions Law Article 24, applicable personal-status legislation and property-registration rules.
Problem 4: Long-term resident whose identity documents are cancelled
An individual has lived in the UAE for several decades but loses access to recognized identity documentation.
Legal issues:
Administrative fairness.
Residence status.
Civil identity.
Family rights.
Access to justice.
The comparative principles in Kurić v. Slovenia are useful for analysing the consequences of administrative removal of legal status.
Problem 5: Child denied nationality because of parental circumstances
A child is born to an Emirati mother and foreign father, but the applicable nationality procedure has not been completed.
Legal issues:
Nationality transmission.
Equality.
Child's legal identity.
Risk of statelessness.
The principles in Genovese v. Malta provide useful comparative guidance concerning nationality and discrimination.
15. Conclusion
Civil law concerning statelessness, refugee status and civil rights protection in the UAE involves the interaction of nationality legislation, constitutional guarantees, private international law, immigration regulation and international human rights obligations.
Three particularly important legal developments deserve attention:
1. Constitutional protection: Articles 25, 26, 28, 40 and 41 provide important foundations for equality, liberty, fair-trial protection, foreigners' rights and access to complaints.
2. Civil Transactions Law 2025: Article 24 expressly provides that UAE law applies to stateless persons for the relevant conflict-of-laws purposes. This is a significant private international law provision, although it does not confer nationality.
3. International protection: The UAE's accession to the Convention Against Torture creates an important legal safeguard against returning individuals to countries where they face a substantial risk of torture.
The decisions in Nottebohm, Genovese, Kurić, Chahal, Soering, M.S.S. and Hirsi Jamaa provide important comparative principles concerning nationality, legal identity, equality, deportation, detention and human dignity.
Ultimately, the protection of stateless persons and refugees requires more than granting temporary permission to remain in a country. It requires effective access to legal identity, family rights, property, education, employment, healthcare and judicial remedies.
16. Important legislation and authorities for academic examination
| Authority | Main subject |
|---|---|
| UAE Constitution, Article 25 | Equality before the law |
| UAE Constitution, Article 26 | Personal liberty and protection against torture |
| UAE Constitution, Article 28 | Fair trial |
| UAE Constitution, Articles 40–41 | Foreigners' rights and complaints |
| Federal Law No. 17 of 1972 | Nationality and passports |
| Federal Decree-Law No. 16 of 2017 | Nationality amendments |
| Federal Decree-Law No. 29 of 2021 | Entry and residence of foreigners |
| Federal Decree-Law No. 25 of 2025 | Civil Transactions Law |
| CAT Article 3 | Protection against return to torture |
| CRC Articles 7 and 22 | Children's nationality and refugee protection |
| 1951 Refugee Convention | International refugee protection framework |
| 1954 Stateless Persons Convention | Stateless-person protection framework |
| 1961 Statelessness Convention | Prevention and reduction of statelessness |
Final academic observation: The most distinctive aspect of this subject in UAE civil law is Article 24 of the 2025 Civil Transactions Law. It expressly addresses stateless individuals through a conflict-of-laws rule, while nationality acquisition and refugee protection remain governed by separate legal frameworks. This distinction is essential when analysing civil rights, legal identity and international protection in the UAE.

comments