Guardianship under Muslim Law
Guardianship under Muslim law differs from the general Indian legal framework, particularly under the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, as it is governed by Islamic principles and personal law. Muslim law distinguishes between guardianship and custody, and the criteria for who may be a guardian or custodian, as well as their roles and responsibilities, are based on Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh). The specifics may vary somewhat depending on whether the individual is Sunni or Shia, as well as the particular school of thought they follow.
Here is an outline of the key concepts regarding guardianship under Muslim law:
1. Types of Guardianship
Muslim law recognizes two types of guardianship:
A. Guardianship of Person (Hizanat)
This pertains to the responsibility for the child’s physical care and custody. It is mostly concerned with the child’s upbringing and welfare, including education, health, and emotional needs. In this regard:
Mother's Guardianship: The mother has the right to custody (hizanat) of her minor children, especially when they are younger. The general rule is that a mother has custody of a boy until the age of 7 and of a girl until she reaches puberty, although this can vary based on different schools of thought.
Father’s Role: Although the mother has the first claim to custody, the father retains the final authority as the guardian of the person, which includes overall responsibility for the child's welfare, even if the mother has physical custody.
B. Guardianship of Property (Wilayat)
This refers to the management and control of the minor's property and finances. The father is typically the natural guardian of the minor’s property, and he is entitled to manage the property until the child reaches adulthood. In his absence, this responsibility may fall to the paternal grandfather.
2. Guardianship of a Minor under Muslim Law
In the context of a minor child, guardianship is classified into two categories:
Natural Guardians: These are individuals who are automatically entitled to guardianship under Islamic law. This typically includes:
Father: The father is generally considered the natural guardian of his minor children. He has the right to make decisions regarding the child’s welfare, including education and marriage.
Paternal Grandfather: If the father is deceased, the paternal grandfather may assume the role of the guardian, although his powers may be limited depending on the circumstances.
Mother: While the mother’s right to custody is widely acknowledged, her right to act as the guardian of the child’s property is limited under Islamic law.
Testamentary Guardians: A parent (especially the father) may also appoint a guardian by will. A testamentary guardian is someone who is designated by the parent to care for the child in case the parent dies. This appointment can include the care of the child’s person and property. However, a testamentary guardian does not have absolute control, and the court can intervene if necessary.
3. Mother’s Right to Custody (Hizanat)
Muslim law places special emphasis on the mother’s right to custody (hizanat), especially in the early years of the child's life:
For boys, the mother typically has custody until the child turns 7 years old.
For girls, the mother has custody until the girl reaches puberty (around 9 years old under Sunni law).
After these ages, the child may be given the option of choosing which parent or guardian they wish to live with, though the father retains overall legal authority.
4. Father’s Role as a Guardian
The father has a dominant role in matters relating to the child's welfare and property:
Property Guardianship: The father is the natural guardian of the child’s property and is responsible for managing it until the child reaches maturity. If the father is deceased, the paternal grandfather assumes the role.
Decision-Making Authority: The father can make decisions regarding the child’s education, marriage, and religious training.
Custody Rights After the Age of 7 or Puberty: After the mother’s custody period ends, the father may assume the child’s physical custody if it is deemed in the child’s best interests.
5. Rights of Other Family Members
Paternal Grandfather: If the father is absent or deceased, the paternal grandfather can assume guardianship of both the minor's person and property. The paternal grandfather holds a higher position than the maternal grandfather under Muslim law.
Maternal Relatives: The maternal grandfather and mother’s siblings do not have the same rights as the father or paternal grandfather regarding guardianship of the minor’s property, but they can play an important role in the child’s upbringing and may even be awarded custody in certain circumstances if the father or paternal grandfather is unfit or unavailable.
6. Removal of Guardianship
The court or the guardianship authority may intervene and remove a guardian if it is proven that the guardian is unfit or incapable of fulfilling their duties. For example, if the guardian abuses the child or is negligent in providing proper care, the court can order a change of guardian.
Muslim law allows for flexibility in cases where the welfare of the child requires a change in guardianship, but the best interests of the child remain the primary concern.
7. Guardianship and Custody Disputes
In situations where there is a dispute over who should have custody or guardianship, the Shariah Court or Family Court can intervene and decide based on the best interests of the child. Although the father is generally the ultimate guardian, in practice, the court may prioritize the welfare of the child in awarding custody to either the mother or the father.
8. Age of Majority
The age of majority (when a child reaches adulthood) under Islamic law is typically when a person reaches puberty. However, when it comes to the management of property, the father or paternal grandfather has the authority to manage the minor’s property until the child reaches the age of discretion (usually 18 years of age or more).
9. Islamic Laws and Modern Family Courts
In the modern context, particularly in India, Muslim law is often applied alongside secular family law. The Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 still applies in certain situations to minors who are Muslim, but if there is a conflict between Islamic law and secular law, the latter prevails in the court's decision.
The Indian Muslim Women (Protection of Rights on Divorce) Act, 1986 also impacts the guardianship of children, especially in cases of divorce, by ensuring that custody is awarded in the best interest of the child while considering Islamic principles.
Conclusion
Guardianship under Muslim law is a blend of personal and family law principles, emphasizing the best interests of the child while also recognizing the father’s primary authority. The mother's custody rights are strongly recognized, particularly during the early years, but the ultimate authority lies with the father or paternal grandfather in most circumstances.
Muslim law also emphasizes flexibility, allowing for different interpretations depending on the school of thought (e.g., Hanafi, Shafi'i, Maliki, or Hanbali) and allowing courts to make decisions that best protect the child’s welfare.
RELATED Blog
comments