Human Rights Due Diligence Claims
1. Introduction
Human Rights Due Diligence (HRDD) Claims refer to legal claims brought against companies, multinational corporations, parent companies, investors, suppliers, and other business organisations for failing to identify, prevent, mitigate, monitor, or remedy adverse human-rights impacts connected with their business activities.
Human Rights Due Diligence is an important part of modern Business and Human Rights (BHR) law. It recognises that businesses have responsibilities beyond earning profits and complying with ordinary commercial regulations. They must also respect fundamental human rights throughout their operations and supply chains.
These responsibilities include protecting:
The right to life and human dignity.
Freedom from forced labour and human trafficking.
Workers' rights and workplace safety.
Freedom from discrimination.
Indigenous peoples' rights.
The right to health and a safe environment.
Privacy and freedom of expression.
The rights of children and vulnerable communities.
The right to adequate housing and livelihood.
Human Rights Due Diligence claims generally arise when a company fails to investigate foreseeable human-rights risks or takes inadequate measures despite knowing that its activities may cause serious harm.
2. Meaning and Nature of Human Rights Due Diligence
Human Rights Due Diligence is a continuous process through which businesses identify, assess, prevent, mitigate, and account for their actual and potential human-rights impacts.
The principal international framework is the United Nations Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights (UNGPs), 2011.
The framework establishes three fundamental pillars:
| Pillar | Explanation |
|---|---|
| State duty to protect | Governments must protect individuals against human-rights abuses by businesses and other third parties. |
| Corporate responsibility to respect | Businesses must avoid infringing human rights and address adverse impacts with which they are involved. |
| Access to remedy | Victims must have access to effective judicial and non-judicial remedies. |
Under UNGP Principle 17, human-rights due diligence should include assessing actual and potential impacts, integrating findings, taking appropriate action, tracking responses, and communicating how impacts are addressed.
Importantly, the UNGPs are not themselves a directly enforceable international treaty imposing automatic civil liability on every corporation. Their standards may become legally relevant through domestic legislation, negligence law, statutory duties, contractual obligations, and judicial interpretation.
3. Essential Elements of Human Rights Due Diligence Claims
A. Identification of human-rights risks
Companies must identify potential human-rights violations arising from their own operations, subsidiaries, business relationships, and supply chains.
Examples include:
Unsafe factories.
Forced labour in manufacturing.
Child labour in agricultural supply chains.
Discrimination in recruitment.
Environmental contamination affecting communities.
B. Prevention of human-rights violations
Businesses must take reasonable measures to prevent foreseeable human-rights violations.
For example, a multinational clothing company sourcing products from overseas factories should investigate workplace conditions and take appropriate action where serious labour abuses are identified.
C. Assessment of actual and potential impacts
Companies should evaluate the seriousness, scale, scope, and remediability of human-rights risks.
A company cannot satisfy its responsibilities merely by adopting a general human-rights policy without examining the actual risks associated with its business.
D. Supply-chain accountability
Human-rights responsibilities extend beyond a company's immediate employees and premises.
Claims may arise where businesses:
Ignore forced labour among suppliers.
Continue purchasing from abusive manufacturers.
Fail to investigate serious allegations.
Exercise commercial pressure that contributes to unsafe working conditions.
Fail to respond to repeated human-rights violations.
E. Monitoring and reporting
Companies should continuously monitor whether their prevention and mitigation measures are effective.
Relevant evidence includes:
Human-rights impact assessments.
Supplier audits.
Internal investigation reports.
Risk registers.
Sustainability disclosures.
Employee complaints.
Remediation records.
F. Remediation and compensation
Where a company causes or contributes to adverse human-rights impacts, it should provide for or cooperate in legitimate remediation.
Depending on the applicable law, remedies may include compensation, restoration, rehabilitation, injunctions, apologies, and corrective measures.
4. Major Legal Grounds for Human Rights Due Diligence Claims
Human Rights Due Diligence claims can arise under several legal principles.
| Legal ground | Nature of claim |
|---|---|
| Negligence | Failure to take reasonable steps to prevent foreseeable harm. |
| Human-rights violations | Involvement in conduct infringing protected rights. |
| Parent-company liability | Failure by a parent company to exercise reasonable care in its own management or oversight activities. |
| Statutory non-compliance | Breach of applicable mandatory due-diligence legislation. |
| Environmental liability | Failure to prevent environmental damage affecting human rights. |
| Labour law violations | Failure to prevent forced labour, discrimination, or unsafe employment conditions. |
| Misrepresentation | False or misleading claims concerning corporate human-rights practices. |
| Contractual liability | Breach of contractual human-rights commitments or supplier obligations. |
A claimant must establish the relevant legal cause of action. Failure to conduct due diligence does not automatically establish liability for every subsequent injury.
5. Important International Legal Frameworks
1. UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights, 2011
Establish the international standard for corporate responsibility to respect human rights and conduct human-rights due diligence.
2. OECD Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises on Responsible Business Conduct, 2023
Provide standards concerning human rights, employment, environmental protection, supply-chain responsibility, and responsible business conduct.
3. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 1966
Protects civil and political rights, including life, liberty, privacy, equality, and freedom of expression. States have obligations to protect these rights, including against certain abuses by private actors.
4. International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, 1966
Protects rights relating to work, health, education, social security, and an adequate standard of living.
5. ILO Declaration on Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work
Provides an important framework for labour rights, including freedom of association, elimination of forced labour, abolition of child labour, and elimination of employment discrimination.
6. UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, 1989
Provides protections against economic exploitation and other practices harmful to children's development.
6. Important Case Laws on Human Rights Due Diligence Claims
The following decisions are particularly relevant to corporate accountability, parent-company responsibility, human-rights risk management, and access to remedies.
Case 1. Vedanta Resources Plc v. Lungowe (2019)
Landmark UK Supreme Court decision
Citation: [2019] UKSC 20.
Facts:
Approximately 1,826 Zambian villagers brought proceedings against Vedanta Resources Plc, a UK-based parent company, and its Zambian subsidiary, Konkola Copper Mines.
The claimants alleged that mining operations had resulted in toxic discharges contaminating water sources and damaging their health, property, and livelihoods.
Legal issues:
Whether the parent company could owe a direct duty of care to individuals affected by its subsidiary's activities.
Whether the parent company's public commitments and involvement in environmental and human-rights standards were relevant.
Whether the claims could proceed in England.
Judgment:
The UK Supreme Court allowed the proceedings to continue in England.
It recognised that a parent company may owe a direct duty of care where its own conduct, supervision, management, or assumption of responsibility justifies such a duty.
Importance:
This case is extremely important for Human Rights Due Diligence claims because corporate policies, public statements, and representations concerning the supervision of subsidiaries may become relevant when determining whether a parent company has assumed responsibility.
It demonstrates that corporate human-rights commitments can have legal consequences in appropriate circumstances.
Case 2. Okpabi v. Royal Dutch Shell Plc (2021)
Citation: [2021] UKSC 3.
Facts:
Residents of the Ogale and Bille communities in Nigeria brought proceedings against Royal Dutch Shell Plc and its Nigerian subsidiary.
They alleged that oil spills and environmental contamination had damaged their communities, land, water resources, and livelihoods.
Legal issues:
Whether the UK parent company could owe a duty of care to affected Nigerian communities.
Whether the parent company exercised sufficient control or involvement in the relevant operations.
Whether the claimants could pursue proceedings in the UK.
Judgment:
The UK Supreme Court allowed the claimants' appeal concerning jurisdiction.
It emphasised that parent-company liability must be assessed by examining the actual relationship between the parent and subsidiary rather than assuming that separate corporate personality automatically excludes liability.
Importance:
The decision strengthened the possibility of holding multinational corporations accountable for human-rights and environmental harm connected with overseas subsidiaries.
It also confirmed the importance of examining actual corporate management, policies, supervision, and operational involvement.
Case 3. Nevsun Resources Ltd. v. Araya (2020)
Citation: 2020 SCC 5, Supreme Court of Canada.
Facts:
Three Eritrean workers brought proceedings against Nevsun Resources Ltd., a Canadian mining company.
They alleged that they had been subjected to forced labour, slavery, cruel treatment, and other serious abuses in connection with mining operations in Eritrea.
Legal issues:
Whether customary international law could apply to corporate defendants.
Whether claims based on international human-rights violations could proceed against a corporation.
Whether the proceedings should be dismissed at an early stage.
Judgment:
The Supreme Court of Canada refused to strike out the claims at the preliminary stage.
It recognised that customary international law could potentially apply directly to corporations and that the pleaded claims required further consideration.
The Court did not finally determine that Nevsun was liable for the alleged abuses.
Importance:
This decision is significant because it demonstrates that corporations may face claims based on serious violations of customary international law.
It strengthens the development of corporate human-rights accountability beyond conventional domestic negligence principles.
Case 4. Choc v. Hudbay Minerals Inc. (2013)
Citation: 2013 ONSC 1414, Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Canada.
Facts:
The case concerned allegations of serious human-rights abuses involving security personnel associated with mining operations in Guatemala.
The claimants brought proceedings against Canadian mining companies, alleging responsibility for violence and other abuses connected with the operations of their subsidiaries.
Legal issues:
Whether Canadian parent companies could owe duties of care to individuals affected by overseas operations.
Whether claims involving alleged human-rights abuses could proceed against corporate defendants.
Whether corporate policies and supervision were relevant to establishing responsibility.
Judgment:
The Ontario Superior Court refused to dismiss the claims at the preliminary stage, allowing important aspects of the proceedings to continue.
Importance:
The case demonstrates how inadequate corporate oversight, security arrangements, and human-rights risk management can become relevant to civil claims against parent companies.
It is particularly relevant to businesses operating in regions where communities face risks arising from private security forces.
Case 5. Four Nigerian Farmers and Stichting Milieudefensie v. Shell (2021)
Citation: ECLI:NL:GHDHA:2021:132 and related judgments, Hague Court of Appeal.
Facts:
Nigerian farmers and environmental organisations brought proceedings concerning oil pollution affecting communities in the Niger Delta.
They alleged that oil spills had damaged agricultural land, waterways, and community livelihoods.
Legal issues:
Whether the Nigerian subsidiary was responsible for oil-spill damage.
Whether the Dutch parent company owed a duty of care.
Whether appropriate preventive and remedial measures were necessary.
Judgment:
The Hague Court of Appeal found the Nigerian subsidiary liable in relation to certain oil spills and recognised a limited duty of care on the part of the parent company.
The court also ordered the installation of a leak-detection system on a relevant pipeline.
Importance:
This decision demonstrates that corporate accountability can involve both compensation for existing harm and preventive measures designed to reduce future human-rights and environmental risks.
Case 6. Milieudefensie v. Royal Dutch Shell (2021)
Citation: ECLI:NL:RBDHA:2021:5339, District Court of The Hague.
Facts:
Friends of the Earth Netherlands and other organisations brought proceedings against Royal Dutch Shell concerning the company's contribution to climate change.
The claimants argued that the company's emissions and inadequate climate policies threatened human rights and the interests of present and future generations.
Legal issues:
Whether corporations have responsibilities concerning climate-related human-rights impacts.
Whether the company's climate policies were consistent with its duty of care.
Whether preventive judicial relief could be granted.
Judgment:
The District Court of The Hague ordered Shell to reduce its aggregate CO₂ emissions by a net 45% by the end of 2030 compared with 2019 levels.
The Hague Court of Appeal subsequently reversed that specific reduction order in November 2024, while recognising that Shell has an obligation to limit its contribution to climate change.
Importance:
This litigation illustrates the relationship between corporate due diligence, environmental protection, climate responsibility, and human rights.
It also demonstrates that courts may examine whether companies have taken adequate preventive measures against foreseeable environmental risks.
Case 7. Das v. George Weston Limited (2017)
Citation: 2017 ONSC 4129, Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Canada.
Facts:
The litigation arose from the collapse of the Rana Plaza garment factory in Bangladesh in 2013, which killed and injured numerous workers.
The claimants sought to establish responsibility against companies connected with the supply chain, including a Canadian corporate defendant.
Legal issues:
Whether a company connected with an overseas supply chain could owe a duty of care to affected workers.
Whether commercial relationships and corporate involvement could establish legal responsibility.
Whether the claimants could pursue negligence-based proceedings.
Judgment:
The court considered the duty-of-care allegations and the relevant corporate relationships in determining whether the claims could proceed.
Importance:
The case is relevant to supply-chain due diligence because it highlights the legal risks associated with sourcing products from factories operating under dangerous working conditions.
It also illustrates the difficulty of establishing liability based merely on a purchasing relationship.
7. Comparative Analysis of Important Cases
| Case | Jurisdiction | Principal legal significance |
|---|---|---|
| Vedanta v. Lungowe (2019) | UK | Parent-company duty of care and corporate commitments. |
| Okpabi v. Shell (2021) | UK | Parent-company involvement and overseas harm. |
| Nevsun v. Araya (2020) | Canada | Potential corporate liability under customary international law. |
| Choc v. Hudbay (2013) | Canada | Parent-company negligence and overseas human-rights abuses. |
| Four Nigerian Farmers v. Shell (2021) | Netherlands | Environmental damage, subsidiary liability, and parent-company duty. |
| Milieudefensie v. Shell (2021) | Netherlands | Corporate climate responsibility and preventive obligations. |
| Das v. George Weston (2017) | Canada | Supply-chain relationships and workplace safety claims. |
These cases must be distinguished carefully: some establish that claims can proceed beyond preliminary procedural stages, while others contain substantive findings. They do not all establish a universal, independently enforceable corporate due-diligence cause of action.
8. Categories of Human Rights Due Diligence Litigation
A. Forced Labour Due Diligence Claims
These claims arise where companies fail to identify or prevent forced labour within their supply chains.
Examples include:
Exploitation of migrant workers.
Debt bondage.
Confiscation of passports.
Compulsory unpaid labour.
Human trafficking in manufacturing.
B. Environmental Human Rights Due Diligence Claims
Companies may face claims where their activities create foreseeable environmental risks affecting fundamental rights.
Examples include:
Toxic industrial pollution.
Water contamination.
Destruction of agricultural land.
Hazardous waste disposal.
Climate-related harm.
C. Indigenous Peoples' Rights Due Diligence Claims
These disputes concern the failure to identify and address risks affecting indigenous communities.
Important issues include:
Land rights.
Cultural heritage.
Traditional livelihoods.
Inadequate consultation.
Failure to obtain free, prior and informed consent where applicable.
D. Workplace Human Rights Due Diligence Claims
These claims concern failures involving:
Occupational health and safety.
Workplace discrimination.
Sexual harassment.
Wage exploitation.
Unsafe working conditions.
Restrictions on freedom of association.
E. Digital Human Rights Due Diligence Claims
Modern corporations also have responsibilities to examine the human-rights consequences of digital technologies.
Examples include:
Biased artificial-intelligence recruitment systems.
Unlawful employee surveillance.
Algorithmic discrimination.
Inadequate data protection.
Facial-recognition misuse.
Digital censorship and suppression of expression.
F. Financial and Investment Due Diligence Claims
Financial institutions and investors may face questions about whether they adequately identify and address human-rights risks connected with their financing and investment activities.
Examples include financing projects associated with forced displacement, labour exploitation, or serious environmental damage.
The nature and extent of their legal responsibility depend on their involvement, applicable legislation, and the relevant facts.
9. Corporate Responsibilities Under Human Rights Due Diligence
A responsible company should establish a comprehensive due-diligence system.
Human Rights Due Diligence Lifecycle
Policy commitment
Adopt a corporate human-rights policy approved by senior management.
Risk identification
Identify actual and potential human-rights impacts.
Risk assessment
Evaluate the seriousness and likelihood of adverse impacts.
Preventive action
Introduce safeguards, supplier requirements, and corrective measures.
Monitoring
Review the effectiveness of preventive measures.
Communication
Disclose relevant information about the company's due-diligence activities.
Remediation
Provide or cooperate in effective remedies where the company caused or contributed to harm.
10. Evidentiary Requirements in Human Rights Due Diligence Claims
Claimants generally need to establish the elements of the relevant legal cause of action.
Important categories of evidence include:
| Evidence | Legal relevance |
|---|---|
| Corporate human-rights policies | Establishes publicly stated responsibilities. |
| Supplier contracts | Demonstrates commercial relationships and obligations. |
| Internal risk assessments | Shows knowledge of foreseeable risks. |
| Audit reports | Identifies possible compliance failures. |
| Employee testimonies | Establishes actual workplace conditions. |
| Environmental reports | Demonstrates pollution and environmental impacts. |
| Board communications | May establish corporate knowledge and decision-making. |
| Sustainability reports | May reveal representations and commitments. |
| Whistleblower complaints | May establish prior warnings. |
| Remediation records | Shows whether the company responded appropriately. |
The claimant must also establish causation and legally recoverable damage where these are required by the applicable cause of action.
11. Available Remedies
Depending on the jurisdiction and legal basis, courts and other competent bodies may provide:
1. Compensatory damages: Financial compensation for personal injury, property damage, and economic loss.
2. Injunctive relief: Orders requiring companies to stop unlawful conduct or introduce preventive measures.
3. Restoration: Rehabilitation of contaminated land, water resources, or damaged livelihoods.
4. Rehabilitation: Medical, psychological, and social support for affected individuals.
5. Declaration of liability: Judicial recognition that the defendant breached an applicable legal obligation.
6. Corrective action: Changes to corporate policies, supplier arrangements, or operational practices.
7. Collective remedies: Relief through representative or group proceedings where permitted by law.
12. Major Challenges in Human Rights Due Diligence Litigation
Despite growing international recognition, these claims face several difficulties.
1. Corporate separation: Parent companies and subsidiaries are separate legal entities, making it difficult to establish direct parent-company liability.
2. Jurisdictional barriers: Victims may face difficulties bringing proceedings in the home country of a multinational corporation.
3. Evidentiary difficulties: Internal corporate documents and supply-chain information may be inaccessible.
4. Causation: Establishing a connection between corporate conduct and the particular human-rights injury can be challenging.
5. Regulatory fragmentation: Different countries impose different due-diligence requirements.
6. Weak enforcement: Voluntary corporate commitments may not provide effective remedies.
7. Access to justice: Victims may lack sufficient financial resources, legal representation, or protection against retaliation.
13. Future Development of Human Rights Due Diligence Law
Human Rights Due Diligence is moving from voluntary corporate responsibility towards more formal regulatory obligations.
Important developments include:
Mandatory corporate human-rights due-diligence legislation.
Greater accountability for multinational supply chains.
Stronger protection of migrant and vulnerable workers.
Human-rights assessments of artificial intelligence.
Greater scrutiny of corporate climate policies.
Increased disclosure and transparency requirements.
Improved access to remedies for overseas victims.
Stronger investor and financial-institution accountability.
The European Union's Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD) is an important legislative development in this area. Its scope, implementation, and applicable requirements must be assessed according to the relevant legislative amendments and implementation dates.
14. Conclusion
Human Rights Due Diligence Claims represent an important development in modern civil liability and international human-rights law. They seek to ensure that businesses do not ignore the human consequences of their commercial activities.
The decisions in Vedanta v. Lungowe, Okpabi v. Shell, Nevsun v. Araya, Choc v. Hudbay, and Milieudefensie v. Shell demonstrate the expanding role of domestic courts in examining corporate responsibility for human-rights and environmental harm.
The central legal principle is that businesses must take appropriate steps to identify, prevent, mitigate, and address adverse human-rights impacts connected with their operations.
However, the existence of a due-diligence failure, the availability of a civil cause of action, and the establishment of corporate liability remain distinct legal questions. Their resolution depends on applicable legislation, judicial precedent, evidence, causation, and the nature of the company's involvement.
Ultimately, Human Rights Due Diligence seeks to transform corporate accountability from a voluntary ethical commitment into an increasingly enforceable legal responsibility.

comments