Hybrid Loan-Investment Product Classification Spain Disputes .
HYBRID LOAN-INVESTMENT PRODUCT CLASSIFICATION IN SPAIN: LEGAL DISPUTES, REGULATORY FRAMEWORK AND CASE LAWS
1. Introduction
Hybrid loan-investment products are financial instruments that combine characteristics of traditional lending arrangements and investment products. They may provide investors with interest payments, repayment rights, capital participation, profit-linked returns or exposure to financial market performance.
In Spain, disputes concerning hybrid financial products frequently arise because banks and financial institutions market instruments as deposits or relatively safe lending arrangements even though their legal and economic characteristics may resemble complex investment products.
Examples include:
Participaciones preferentes (preference shares).
Subordinated debt instruments.
Convertible bonds.
Contingent convertible bonds (CoCos).
Structured deposits.
Structured bonds.
Profit-participating loans.
Hybrid capital instruments.
Loans incorporating derivatives.
Debt instruments linked to shares, indices or other financial assets.
The central legal issue is determining whether a particular instrument should be classified as a loan, deposit, transferable security, investment product or hybrid financial instrument.
Classification is important because it determines the applicable regulatory obligations, investor protection standards, disclosure requirements, contractual remedies, insolvency ranking and potential liability of the financial institution.
Spanish courts must examine the actual contractual characteristics of an instrument rather than relying exclusively on the commercial name assigned by the bank.
2. Legal Framework Governing Hybrid Loan-Investment Products in Spain
The principal legal framework consists of Spanish legislation and directly applicable European Union financial regulations.
A. Spanish Securities Market Legislation
Law 6/2023 of 17 March, on Securities Markets and Investment Services (Ley 6/2023, de los Mercados de Valores y de los Servicios de Inversión), establishes the Spanish framework for securities markets and investment services.
It regulates:
Financial instruments.
Investment services and activities.
Investment firms and other regulated institutions.
Investor protection.
Information and transparency obligations.
Conduct of business requirements.
Market supervision and enforcement.
Where a hybrid loan-investment product constitutes a financial instrument, the institution distributing or advising on it may become subject to the applicable investment services obligations.
B. MiFID II Framework
Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II) is particularly important.
It establishes requirements concerning:
Classification of financial instruments.
Client categorisation.
Suitability assessments.
Appropriateness assessments.
Product governance.
Disclosure of risks and costs.
Conflicts of interest.
Investment advice.
Execution of client orders.
A bank cannot avoid MiFID II obligations merely by describing an investment-linked product as a loan.
The actual legal characteristics and services provided must be examined.
C. Spanish Civil Code
The Spanish Civil Code is relevant to the contractual classification and validity of hybrid products.
Important provisions include:
Article 1088: Obligations may consist of giving, doing or refraining from doing something.
Article 1091: Contractual obligations have the force of law between contracting parties.
Article 1254: Definition of a contract.
Article 1255: Freedom of contract, subject to law, morality and public policy.
Article 1256: Contractual validity and performance cannot be left to the arbitrary discretion of one party.
Article 1261: Essential requirements for contractual validity.
Articles 1265 and 1266: Vitiated consent and error.
Article 1300: Annulment of contracts affected by defects in consent or other statutory grounds.
These provisions are relevant when an investor argues that a bank misrepresented the nature of a hybrid financial product.
D. Consumer Protection Legislation
Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, approving the consolidated text of the General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users, is relevant where the investor qualifies as a consumer.
Relevant protections include:
Transparency of contractual conditions.
Protection against unfair terms.
Clear pre-contractual information.
Protection against misleading commercial practices.
Remedies for unfair contractual provisions.
The application of consumer protection rules depends on the circumstances and the capacity in which the investor acted.
E. European Banking Regulation
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 (Capital Requirements Regulation or CRR), as amended, is relevant to hybrid capital instruments issued by banks.
It distinguishes between different categories of regulatory capital, including:
Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1).
Additional Tier 1 (AT1).
Tier 2 capital.
A financial instrument may be classified as a hybrid capital instrument for prudential purposes without necessarily being classified as an ordinary equity investment under every other area of law.
This distinction is particularly important in disputes involving contingent convertible bonds and preference shares.
3. Meaning and Characteristics of Hybrid Loan-Investment Products
A hybrid loan-investment product combines debt-related and investment-related characteristics.
A. Debt Characteristics
A conventional loan normally creates a creditor-debtor relationship.
Its characteristics include:
An obligation to repay principal.
A contractual interest obligation, where applicable.
A defined maturity date or repayment mechanism.
Creditor rights against the borrower.
Potential enforcement rights in the event of default.
B. Investment Characteristics
An investment product may expose the investor to market or issuer-related risks.
Its characteristics may include:
Variable returns.
Capital loss.
Conversion into shares.
Subordination to other creditors.
Dependence on issuer profitability.
Discretionary coupon payments.
Exposure to market prices.
Lack of a guaranteed secondary market.
C. Hybrid Characteristics
A hybrid instrument may contain both categories.
For example, a convertible bond may initially provide an investor with a debt claim but subsequently convert into shares.
Similarly, preference shares may provide preferential distribution rights while exposing the investor to substantial capital-loss and insolvency risks.
The existence of debt-like contractual terminology does not necessarily establish that the product is a conventional loan.
4. Legal Tests for Classification of Hybrid Products
Spanish courts and regulators should examine several substantive factors.
A. Repayment Obligation
The first question is whether the issuer has an enforceable obligation to repay the principal.
A conventional loan generally provides a contractual repayment claim.
However, some hybrid products permit conversion, write-down or loss absorption instead of ordinary repayment.
If repayment is conditional or uncertain, the product may have substantial investment characteristics.
B. Nature of Interest Payments
The court should determine whether interest is:
Fixed.
Variable.
Linked to issuer profits.
Subject to regulatory restrictions.
Discretionary.
Deferrable or cancellable.
An instrument whose coupons depend on profitability or regulatory capital conditions differs significantly from an ordinary fixed-interest loan.
C. Subordination
Subordination is another important classification factor.
A subordinated creditor ranks behind ordinary unsecured creditors under the applicable contractual and insolvency rules.
However, subordination alone does not automatically transform a loan into an equity instrument.
D. Conversion Rights
Where the instrument provides for conversion into shares, the investor may face equity-related risks.
Mandatory conversion or conversion following specified financial triggers can significantly affect the instrument's legal and economic classification.
E. Loss Absorption
The possibility of principal reduction or permanent write-down is especially relevant.
AT1 instruments, for example, may contain contractual mechanisms for absorbing losses when specified regulatory conditions are met.
Such instruments should not be presented as ordinary capital-protected deposits.
F. Transferability and Marketability
The availability of secondary-market trading may indicate investment characteristics.
Nevertheless, transferability is not conclusive because certain loans and debt claims may also be transferable.
G. Commercial Substance
The overall economic substance of the agreement must be examined.
The court should consider the rights and obligations actually created, rather than relying solely on the title of the instrument.
5. Major Categories of Hybrid Loan-Investment Products
A. Participaciones Preferentes
Preference shares are among the most important examples in Spanish financial litigation.
They generally provide preferential economic rights but may involve:
Perpetual or indefinite duration.
Subordination.
Discretionary remuneration.
Loss of principal.
Limited liquidity.
Dependence on issuer profitability.
Spanish litigation has frequently involved investors who believed they were purchasing relatively secure bank products.
The legal dispute concerns whether the bank adequately explained that preference shares were high-risk investment instruments.
B. Subordinated Debt
Subordinated debt is a debt instrument in which repayment ranks behind certain other creditor claims.
It remains debt in contractual terms, but its risk profile is different from ordinary senior lending.
Relevant disputes concern:
Whether investors understood subordination.
Whether maturity and repayment were properly disclosed.
Whether market risks were adequately explained.
Whether the bank conducted appropriate client assessments.
C. Convertible Bonds
Convertible bonds combine a debt claim with the possibility or obligation of conversion into equity.
Important classification questions include:
Whether conversion is optional or mandatory.
Whether conversion depends on market prices.
Whether the principal is protected.
Whether the investor can demand repayment.
Whether conversion may occur following specified financial triggers.
D. Contingent Convertible Bonds
CoCos are hybrid capital instruments that may convert into equity or suffer principal write-down following specified regulatory or contractual triggers.
They are especially relevant under the European prudential framework.
The CRR requirements governing Additional Tier 1 and Tier 2 instruments are central to their classification.
E. Structured Deposits
Structured deposits combine deposit-related contractual protection with returns linked to an underlying market variable.
A structured deposit must be distinguished from a structured investment product.
Under MiFID II, structured deposits are specifically addressed in the regulatory framework, although they are not automatically treated as transferable securities.
Their classification depends on their contractual structure.
F. Profit-Participating Loans
A participating loan (préstamo participativo) is a financing arrangement in which remuneration may be linked to the borrower's business performance.
Article 20 of Royal Decree-Law 7/1996 provides the principal Spanish statutory framework.
Such loans retain debt characteristics while incorporating a variable remuneration mechanism.
They should not automatically be classified as ordinary equity investments simply because remuneration depends on profits.
6. Regulatory Disputes Concerning Misclassification
Misclassification disputes generally arise in the following situations.
A. Marketing an Investment Product as a Deposit
A bank may market a subordinated or preference instrument using expressions such as secure savings, guaranteed income or bank deposit.
The investor may subsequently discover that the product involves substantial capital-loss risks.
The legal question is whether the marketing communication was misleading or omitted material information.
B. Failure to Explain Capital Risk
A financial institution may emphasise potential interest payments without adequately explaining the possibility of principal loss.
Such conduct may violate applicable information and conduct requirements.
C. Incorrect Client Categorisation
MiFID II distinguishes between retail clients, professional clients and eligible counterparties.
Incorrectly categorising a retail investor as a professional client may reduce the protection available to that investor.
D. Failure to Conduct Suitability or Appropriateness Assessments
The bank's obligations depend on the investment service provided.
For investment advice or portfolio management, suitability requirements apply.
For other relevant investment services, appropriateness requirements may apply, subject to the statutory exceptions and execution-only conditions.
E. Inadequate Explanation of Liquidity Restrictions
Hybrid products may not have a functioning secondary market.
Where investors cannot easily recover their capital, this risk must be communicated appropriately.
F. Concealment of Subordination and Insolvency Risk
Investors must receive sufficiently clear information about their position in the issuer's capital structure.
Failure to explain the possibility of receiving little or no recovery during insolvency may support contractual or regulatory claims.
7. Important Spanish and European Case Laws
The following judicial decisions are particularly relevant to the classification, marketing and sale of hybrid loan-investment products.
Case 1: Genil 48 SL and Comercial Hostelera de Grandes Vinos SL v Bankinter SA
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-604/11.
Judgment: 30 May 2013.
Legal principles:
The CJEU examined the application of MiFID requirements to financial derivative transactions.
The judgment addressed the obligations of investment firms when providing investment services and the consequences of non-compliance with conduct-of-business requirements.
The Court clarified that the consequences of violating MiFID obligations are principally determined by national law, subject to the principles of equivalence and effectiveness.
Relevance to Spain:
This decision is important in disputes involving hybrid loan products containing embedded derivatives.
A bank cannot avoid the relevant investment services obligations merely because the derivative forms part of a broader financing arrangement.
The nature of the service and the financial instrument must be examined.
Case 2: Banif Plus Bank Zrt v Csaba and Viktória Csipai
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-472/11.
Judgment: 21 February 2013.
Legal principles:
The judgment concerned consumer protection and unfair contractual terms in financial arrangements.
The CJEU considered the role of national courts in examining potentially unfair contractual provisions.
Relevance:
The decision is relevant where hybrid loan-investment products contain complex contractual terms concerning payment obligations, risk allocation or termination.
It supports effective judicial examination of contractual transparency and consumer protection issues.
However, it does not establish a universal classification test for hybrid securities.
Case 3: Andriciuc and Others v Banca Românească SA
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-186/16.
Judgment: 20 September 2017.
Legal principles:
The Court examined foreign-currency loan arrangements and the transparency requirements applicable to contractual terms concerning exchange-rate risk.
The judgment emphasised that consumers must be able to understand the potentially significant economic consequences of contractual obligations.
Relevance:
Although the case concerned foreign-currency loans rather than hybrid securities, it is important for disputes involving loan products linked to financial-market variables.
It demonstrates the importance of explaining the actual economic risk rather than merely disclosing technical contractual wording.
Case 4: Spanish Supreme Court – Preference Shares Litigation
Court: Tribunal Supremo.
Judgment: STS 244/2013, 18 April 2013.
Legal principles:
The Spanish Supreme Court examined disputes concerning the acquisition of preference shares and defects in investor consent.
The litigation reflects the importance of examining whether the investor received adequate information about the characteristics and risks of the financial instrument.
Relevance:
The decision is important in determining whether an investor understood that preference shares were not equivalent to ordinary deposits.
The legal analysis focuses on the nature of the product, the information supplied and the investor's consent.
Case 5: Spanish Supreme Court – Subordinated Debt and Financial Mis-selling
Court: Tribunal Supremo.
Relevant jurisprudence: The Supreme Court's 2013–2015 preference-share and subordinated-debt decisions.
Legal principles:
Spanish courts have recognised that the purchase of complex financial instruments may involve an essential error of consent where the investor was not properly informed about material characteristics and risks.
Relevant considerations include:
The investor's experience.
The complexity of the product.
The bank's information obligations.
The possibility of capital loss.
The liquidity and maturity characteristics.
The investor's understanding of the transaction.
Relevance:
These principles are central to disputes concerning hybrid loan-investment products.
A bank's failure to explain the actual legal nature of a product may support an action for annulment where the applicable requirements are established.
Case 6: Spanish Supreme Court – Financial Derivative Contracts
Court: Tribunal Supremo.
Judgment: STS 840/2013, 20 January 2014.
Legal principles:
The Supreme Court addressed financial derivative transactions and the obligations of financial institutions to provide adequate information to clients.
The judgment is significant for the assessment of investor understanding and the consequences of insufficient disclosure.
Relevance:
It is relevant where a financing agreement contains embedded swaps, interest-rate derivatives or other investment-related elements.
A transaction presented as a conventional loan may require additional regulatory and contractual analysis if it contains a separate financial derivative.
Case 7: Banif Plus Bank Zrt v László Lantos
Court: Court of Justice of the European Union.
Case: C-312/14.
Judgment: 3 December 2015.
Legal principles:
The judgment concerned the application of MiFID rules to financial derivative transactions and the circumstances in which investment services requirements apply.
Relevance:
It is useful when analysing whether a hybrid financing arrangement constitutes an investment service or contains a financial instrument subject to MiFID requirements.
The distinction between ordinary lending and investment-related activity must be assessed by reference to the transaction's actual legal characteristics and the service provided.
8. Classification Under Spanish Insolvency Law
Classification becomes particularly important when the issuer or borrower enters insolvency proceedings.
The applicable framework is the consolidated text of the Spanish Insolvency Law, approved by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020 (Texto Refundido de la Ley Concursal).
The treatment of a hybrid instrument depends on its legal nature, contractual terms and any applicable statutory ranking rules.
A. Ordinary Claims
Ordinary unsecured creditors generally rank ahead of subordinated claims in the distribution of insolvency assets.
B. Subordinated Claims
Subordinated claims are subject to the ranking provisions of the Insolvency Law.
Article 281 of the Insolvency Law identifies categories of subordinated claims.
However, not every instrument described as hybrid automatically falls within the same statutory category.
Contractual and statutory subordination must be distinguished.
C. Equity-Like Instruments
Where an instrument constitutes equity rather than debt, the holder may not have an ordinary creditor claim for repayment of principal.
The legal classification can therefore materially affect insolvency recovery.
D. AT1 and Other Regulatory Capital Instruments
AT1 instruments are designed to absorb losses and may contain contractual write-down or conversion mechanisms.
Their treatment must be assessed under the relevant banking resolution and prudential rules as well as the applicable insolvency framework.
9. Liability of Spanish Banks for Incorrect Classification
A financial institution may face several forms of liability.
A. Civil Liability
An investor may seek annulment of the purchase contract where the requirements for defective consent are established.
Articles 1265, 1266 and 1300 of the Civil Code may be relevant.
B. Contractual Liability
A bank may be liable for breach of contractual duties or applicable pre-contractual obligations.
Article 1101 of the Civil Code may be relevant where contractual obligations are breached through fraud, negligence or delay.
C. Regulatory Liability
The CNMV may supervise investment services and investigate breaches of applicable securities-market requirements.
Potential regulatory breaches include:
Misleading marketing.
Inadequate risk disclosure.
Failure to comply with client classification rules.
Failure to conduct required assessments.
Breaches of product governance requirements.
Conflicts of interest.
D. Consumer Protection Liability
Where consumer protection legislation applies, misleading commercial practices or unfair contractual conditions may give rise to additional remedies.
E. Limitation Periods
Claims must be assessed under the limitation rules applicable to the specific legal action.
For annulment based on vitiated consent, Article 1301 of the Civil Code is particularly important.
The applicable starting point and limitation period must be examined in light of the instrument, transaction date and relevant jurisprudence.
10. Role of the CNMV and Banco de España
Two supervisory institutions have important but distinct responsibilities.
A. Comisión Nacional del Mercado de Valores (CNMV)
The CNMV supervises Spanish securities markets and relevant investment services.
Its responsibilities include:
Supervising investment firms and relevant market participants.
Monitoring investor protection standards.
Reviewing marketing and disclosure practices.
Supervising compliance with applicable securities legislation.
Taking enforcement action within its statutory powers.
It is particularly relevant when a bank distributes hybrid instruments classified as financial products.
B. Banco de España
Banco de España supervises credit institutions within its statutory responsibilities and participates in the European banking supervisory framework.
Its role is relevant to:
Prudential banking supervision.
Regulatory capital requirements.
Banking conduct within its assigned competences.
Supervision of credit institutions.
Financial stability.
The CNMV and Banco de España may therefore have complementary roles in disputes involving hybrid products issued or distributed by banks.
11. European Banking Union and Resolution Issues
Hybrid capital instruments must also be considered under the European Banking Union framework.
Important legislation includes:
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 (CRR).
Directive 2014/59/EU (Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive or BRRD).
Regulation (EU) No 806/2014 establishing the Single Resolution Mechanism.
These instruments establish the regulatory framework for bank capital, recovery and resolution.
A. Bail-in
Bail-in allows eligible liabilities to be written down or converted into equity during bank resolution.
The statutory hierarchy and exclusions must be respected.
B. Loss Absorption
Hybrid capital instruments may be designed to absorb losses before ordinary creditors are affected.
C. Investor Risk
Investors must understand that certain hybrid instruments may suffer substantial losses even where the bank continues to operate or undergoes an orderly resolution.
D. Contractual and Regulatory Classification
An instrument's classification under CRR and BRRD does not automatically determine every aspect of its civil-law or consumer-law treatment.
Each legal regime must be analysed independently.
12. Major Legal Issues in Hybrid Loan-Investment Product Classification Disputes
The following issues are particularly important in Spanish litigation.
Issue 1: Misleading Product Description
Whether the financial institution incorrectly described an investment instrument as a conventional loan or deposit.
Issue 2: Lack of Repayment Guarantee
Whether the investor was informed that repayment depended on conversion, issuer solvency or regulatory triggers.
Issue 3: Discretionary Coupon Payments
Whether the bank explained that interest payments could be deferred, cancelled or suspended.
Issue 4: Hidden Subordination
Whether the investor understood the instrument's position in the creditor hierarchy.
Issue 5: Embedded Derivatives
Whether the financing arrangement contained a separate derivative instrument requiring investment services analysis.
Issue 6: Incorrect Client Assessment
Whether the bank properly classified the investor and complied with the relevant suitability or appropriateness requirements.
Issue 7: Insufficient Product Governance
Whether the institution identified the appropriate target market and distributed the product through a compatible distribution strategy.
Issue 8: Conflict Between Contractual and Regulatory Classification
Whether the product was treated differently under civil law, securities regulation, prudential rules and insolvency law.
13. Practical Example: Hybrid Loan-Investment Product Mis-selling
Assume that a Spanish bank offers an individual investor a financial product worth EUR 100,000.
The bank describes it as a long-term savings loan offering annual returns of 6%.
However, the contractual terms contain the following conditions:
The product has no ordinary fixed maturity.
Interest payments depend on the issuer's profitability.
The principal is subordinated.
The instrument may be converted into shares.
The investor may suffer a permanent capital loss.
There is no guaranteed secondary market.
The investor believes that the product is equivalent to a conventional bank deposit.
Subsequently, the bank experiences financial difficulties and suspends coupon payments.
Legal Analysis
First, the instrument must be examined under its contractual terms.
Second, the presence of conversion rights, subordination and capital-loss exposure indicates significant investment characteristics.
Third, the bank's marketing statements must be examined to determine whether they accurately described the product.
Fourth, the applicable MiFID requirements must be identified.
Fifth, the court must assess whether the investor received sufficient information to understand the financial risks.
Sixth, the court must determine whether there was an essential error of consent or another actionable legal defect.
Possible Remedies
Depending on the facts and applicable limitation rules, the investor may seek:
Annulment of the purchase contract.
Restitution of the amounts paid, subject to applicable legal adjustments.
Damages for breach of contractual or statutory obligations.
Consumer protection remedies, where applicable.
Regulatory investigation by the competent supervisory authority.
The availability of any remedy depends on the evidence, the contractual structure and the legal cause of action.
14. Evidence Required in Spanish Hybrid Product Litigation
An investor bringing a classification or mis-selling claim should consider obtaining:
The original subscription agreement.
The complete product prospectus.
The Key Information Document, where applicable.
The bank's promotional material.
Risk disclosure documents.
Client categorisation records.
Suitability or appropriateness assessments.
Recorded investment recommendations.
Correspondence with bank employees.
Statements showing coupon payments and losses.
Secondary-market valuation records.
Relevant contractual amendments.
Expert financial evidence may also be useful to explain the instrument's actual economic characteristics.
15. Recommendations for Financial Institutions
Spanish banks should implement a classification framework that distinguishes between lending products, deposits, securities and hybrid instruments.
Recommended measures include:
Substantive legal review of product terms.
Clear identification of repayment obligations.
Separate assessment of debt and equity characteristics.
Identification of embedded derivatives.
Transparent explanation of coupon deferral.
Disclosure of subordination and loss-absorption mechanisms.
Proper client categorisation.
Suitability and appropriateness controls.
Product governance and target-market assessments.
Consistent documentation across marketing and contractual materials.
The product's regulatory classification should be documented separately from its civil-law, prudential, accounting and insolvency treatment.
16. Conclusion
Hybrid loan-investment product classification is an important area of Spanish banking and financial law because modern financial instruments frequently combine debt, equity and derivative characteristics.
The legal classification of these products cannot be determined solely by the terminology used by financial institutions.
Spanish courts must examine the contractual rights, repayment obligations, coupon structure, subordination, conversion rights, loss-absorption mechanisms and economic substance of the instrument.
The MiFID II framework, Law 6/2023, the Spanish Civil Code, consumer protection legislation, CRR and insolvency legislation provide different but interconnected regulatory perspectives.
The jurisprudence of the CJEU, particularly Genil 48 (C-604/11) and Andriciuc (C-186/16), together with Spanish Supreme Court litigation concerning preference shares, subordinated debt and financial derivatives, provides important principles for resolving disputes.
The central legal principle is that financial institutions must accurately identify and explain the nature of the products they distribute. A product that contains substantial investment risk cannot legitimately be presented as a risk-free conventional lending or deposit arrangement merely because it includes debt-related terminology.
Ultimately, correct classification protects investors, strengthens market transparency, improves regulatory compliance and promotes confidence in the Spanish banking system.
17. Principal Legal Authorities
Spanish Civil Code, Articles 1088, 1091, 1101, 1254, 1255, 1256, 1261, 1265, 1266, 1300 and 1301.
Law 6/2023 of 17 March, on Securities Markets and Investment Services.
Royal Legislative Decree 1/2007, General Law for the Protection of Consumers and Users.
Royal Decree-Law 7/1996, Article 20, concerning participating loans.
Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020, Spanish Insolvency Law.
Directive 2014/65/EU (MiFID II).
Regulation (EU) No 575/2013 (Capital Requirements Regulation).
Directive 2014/59/EU (Bank Recovery and Resolution Directive).
Regulation (EU) No 806/2014 (Single Resolution Mechanism).
CJEU, Genil 48 SL and Comercial Hostelera de Grandes Vinos SL v Bankinter SA, C-604/11, 30 May 2013.
CJEU, Banif Plus Bank Zrt v Csaba and Viktória Csipai, C-472/11, 21 February 2013.
CJEU, Andriciuc and Others v Banca Românească SA, C-186/16, 20 September 2017.
CJEU, Banif Plus Bank Zrt v László Lantos, C-312/14, 3 December 2015.
Spanish Supreme Court, STS 244/2013, 18 April 2013.
Spanish Supreme Court, STS 840/2013, 20 January 2014.
Research qualification: The cited decisions should be checked against their complete judgments before being used in formal pleadings. The CJEU decisions concerning consumer credit and derivatives provide relevant interpretative principles but do not all directly determine the classification of hybrid securities. The Spanish Supreme Court preference-share and subordinated-debt authorities should be supplemented with the exact judgment applicable to the particular instrument and transaction.

comments