Inter-Creditor Dispute Resolution Frameworks .

1. Introduction

Inter-creditor dispute resolution frameworks refer to the legal, contractual and institutional mechanisms used to resolve disputes between two or more creditors who have financial claims against the same borrower, debtor, company or group of companies.

These disputes commonly arise in corporate lending, syndicated loans, secured financing, project finance, insolvency proceedings, restructuring transactions and cross-border banking arrangements.

For example, a company may borrow money from:

Bank A, which holds a first-ranking security interest.

Bank B, which holds a second-ranking security interest.

Bank C, which provides unsecured financing.

Bondholders who hold debt securities issued by the company.

If the company becomes insolvent, all creditors may compete for repayment from the same limited pool of assets.

Disagreements may arise regarding repayment priority, enforcement rights, security interests, voting rights, restructuring proposals and distribution of insolvency proceeds.

Inter-creditor agreements and statutory insolvency frameworks therefore play an important role in establishing creditor rights and resolving disputes.

In Spain, inter-creditor disputes are principally governed by Spanish insolvency legislation, contractual obligations, secured transactions law, EU insolvency rules and applicable civil and commercial law.

2. Meaning and Nature of Inter-Creditor Disputes

An inter-creditor dispute occurs when creditors disagree about their respective legal or financial rights against a common debtor.

The most common disputes include:

A. Priority disputes

Creditors disagree over which creditor should receive repayment first.

B. Security enforcement disputes

A secured creditor attempts to enforce collateral, while another creditor challenges the enforcement.

C. Payment waterfall disputes

Creditors disagree about the order in which available funds should be distributed.

D. Restructuring disputes

Some creditors support a restructuring proposal, while others oppose it.

E. Voting disputes

Creditors challenge voting rights, voting percentages or the classification of claims.

F. Insolvency distribution disputes

Creditors dispute the allocation of assets during insolvency proceedings.

G. Contractual interpretation disputes

Creditors disagree about the interpretation of inter-creditor agreements, subordination clauses or enforcement restrictions.

3. Legal Framework Governing Inter-Creditor Disputes in Spain

A. Spanish Insolvency Law

The principal legislation is:

Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020 of 5 May – Consolidated Text of the Insolvency Law (Texto Refundido de la Ley Concursal – TRLC).

This legislation governs:

Insolvency proceedings.

Recognition of creditor claims.

Classification of insolvency claims.

Secured creditor rights.

Creditor participation.

Insolvency administration.

Restructuring plans.

Liquidation and distribution of assets.

The legislation was significantly amended by Law 16/2022, which implemented Directive (EU) 2019/1023 on preventive restructuring frameworks.

B. Spanish Civil Code

The Spanish Civil Code governs contractual obligations and creditor relationships.

Important provisions include:

Article 1091: Contractual obligations have the force of law between the contracting parties.

Article 1101: Liability for damages arising from breach of obligations.

Article 1255: Freedom of contract, subject to law, morality and public order.

Article 1258: Contracts bind parties to their agreed terms and consequences arising from good faith, usage and law.

Article 1278: Contracts are generally binding regardless of their form, subject to legal exceptions.

These provisions are relevant when interpreting inter-creditor agreements.

C. Spanish Mortgage Legislation

Law 2/1981 on the Regulation of the Mortgage Market and Law 5/2019 regulating real estate credit contracts may be relevant in particular financing contexts.

Mortgage ranking and enforcement are also governed by the Spanish Mortgage Law and applicable procedural legislation.

D. Spanish Commercial Law

The Spanish Companies Act, Royal Legislative Decree 1/2010, may become relevant where disputes involve corporate guarantees, directors' obligations, capital structures and company restructuring.

4. EU Legal Framework

A. Directive (EU) 2019/1023

The EU Restructuring and Insolvency Directive establishes preventive restructuring frameworks for financially distressed businesses.

Its objectives include:

Preventing unnecessary insolvency.

Encouraging early restructuring.

Protecting business continuity.

Facilitating negotiations between debtors and creditors.

Establishing cross-class cram-down mechanisms.

Improving restructuring efficiency.

The Directive is particularly relevant where creditors disagree over a restructuring proposal.

B. Regulation (EU) 2015/848 on Insolvency Proceedings

This regulation governs cross-border insolvency proceedings within the EU.

It addresses:

Jurisdiction over insolvency proceedings.

Recognition of insolvency judgments.

Applicable insolvency law.

Coordination of insolvency proceedings.

Cooperation between insolvency practitioners.

It is particularly important when creditors are located in different EU Member States.

C. Brussels I Recast Regulation – Regulation (EU) 1215/2012

This regulation governs jurisdiction and recognition and enforcement of judgments in civil and commercial matters.

However, insolvency proceedings falling within the scope of Regulation 2015/848 are excluded from its general application.

Ordinary contractual disputes between creditors may still fall within Brussels I Recast, depending on their nature.

D. Directive (EU) 2023/2225 and Banking Regulation

Banking-related creditor disputes may also involve financial consumer protection and banking obligations where the relevant facts fall within their scope.

However, the principal EU framework for inter-creditor restructuring disputes remains Directive 2019/1023 and Regulation 2015/848.

5. Inter-Creditor Agreements: Meaning and Importance

An inter-creditor agreement is a contractual arrangement between creditors that regulates their respective rights and obligations concerning a common borrower.

Such agreements are particularly common in syndicated lending and project finance.

The agreement generally establishes:

Priority of repayment.

Ranking of security interests.

Enforcement rights.

Voting arrangements.

Standstill obligations.

Payment restrictions.

Subordination arrangements.

Distribution of enforcement proceeds.

Dispute resolution procedures.

Example

Assume a Spanish company borrows €100 million.

CreditorLoan amountSecurity
Bank A€50 millionFirst-ranking mortgage
Bank B€30 millionSecond-ranking security
Bank C€20 millionUnsecured loan

The company becomes insolvent and its assets generate €60 million.

The creditors may disagree over how the €60 million should be distributed.

The inter-creditor agreement may establish a payment waterfall and determine the contractual rights between the creditors.

However, contractual arrangements cannot automatically override mandatory insolvency priorities or prejudice third parties where the law does not permit it.

6. Main Mechanisms of Inter-Creditor Dispute Resolution

A. Negotiation

Negotiation is usually the first method of resolving inter-creditor disputes.

Creditors communicate directly to resolve disagreements concerning:

Payment priority.

Loan repayment schedules.

Security enforcement.

Restructuring proposals.

Distribution of collateral proceeds.

Negotiation is commercially attractive because it reduces legal costs and avoids lengthy litigation.

B. Mediation

Mediation involves an independent third party who assists creditors in reaching a mutually acceptable settlement.

In Spain, mediation is governed by Law 5/2012 on Mediation in Civil and Commercial Matters, subject to its scope and exclusions.

Mediation is particularly useful where creditors wish to maintain an ongoing lending relationship.

C. Arbitration

Inter-creditor agreements may contain arbitration clauses.

Arbitration allows disputes to be resolved by an independent tribunal rather than ordinary courts.

Spanish arbitration is governed principally by Law 60/2003 on Arbitration.

Arbitration is particularly useful for:

Cross-border syndicated lending.

Contractual subordination disputes.

Interpretation of payment waterfalls.

Disputes involving international lenders.

However, matters reserved to insolvency courts or involving mandatory insolvency effects cannot necessarily be removed from the statutory insolvency process through arbitration.

D. Judicial Litigation

Creditors may approach competent courts where negotiation, mediation or arbitration cannot resolve the dispute.

Litigation may concern:

Contractual breach.

Invalidity of security arrangements.

Enforcement of guarantees.

Ranking of claims.

Distribution of insolvency proceeds.

Challenges to restructuring arrangements.

E. Insolvency Proceedings

Where the debtor is insolvent, statutory insolvency procedures become central.

The insolvency court determines matters within its jurisdiction, including disputes concerning the recognition, classification and treatment of claims.

7. Creditor Ranking and Priority Disputes

Creditor ranking is one of the most important elements of inter-creditor litigation.

Under the Spanish TRLC, insolvency claims are classified broadly into the following categories:

ClassificationDescription
Claims against the insolvency estateClaims payable from the insolvency estate under statutory rules
Specially privileged claimsCertain claims secured by specific assets
Generally privileged claimsCertain categories of claims receiving general priority
Ordinary claimsClaims without special or general privilege
Subordinated claimsClaims receiving lower statutory priority

The classification is important because it determines how creditors participate in insolvency distributions.

Specially privileged creditors

These include qualifying secured creditors whose claims are protected by security over particular assets.

Generally privileged creditors

These receive statutory priority over ordinary claims in accordance with the TRLC.

Ordinary creditors

These are creditors whose claims do not qualify for privileged or subordinated status.

Subordinated creditors

These receive repayment after ordinary claims, subject to the applicable statutory rules.

A contractual subordination arrangement may affect the relationship between the parties, but its effect in insolvency must be assessed under the TRLC and applicable mandatory law.

8. Important Case Laws

The following judgments are relevant to inter-creditor disputes, creditor priority, insolvency proceedings, contractual obligations and restructuring.

Case 1: Re Lehman Brothers International (Europe)

Case: [2017] UKSC 38

Court: UK Supreme Court

Legal issue: Distribution of assets and creditor rights in insolvency.

Background:

The litigation concerned the distribution of assets held by Lehman Brothers International (Europe) following its collapse.

The dispute involved the interpretation of contractual and statutory rights relating to client money.

Judgment and legal principles:

The Supreme Court considered how the relevant statutory client-money regime operated in insolvency and how distributions should be made.

Importance:

Demonstrates the complexity of creditor and beneficiary claims in financial institution insolvency.

Highlights the importance of statutory distribution rules.

Shows why contractual expectations must be assessed against mandatory insolvency legislation.

Relevance to Spain:

The judgment is persuasive comparative authority, not binding Spanish or EU law. Its reasoning is useful when analysing competing financial claims and distribution mechanisms.

Case 2: Belmont Park Investments Pty Ltd v BNY Corporate Trustee Services Ltd

Case: [2011] UKSC 38

Court: UK Supreme Court

Legal issue: Contractual subordination and anti-deprivation principles.

Background:

The dispute involved structured financial transactions and contractual provisions that altered the distribution of financial rights following insolvency-related events.

Judgment and legal principles:

The Supreme Court considered the relationship between commercial contractual arrangements and insolvency principles.

It recognised that genuine commercial transactions and contractual subordination arrangements are not automatically invalid merely because they affect the distribution of assets on insolvency.

Importance:

Contractual subordination can be commercially legitimate.

Insolvency-triggered arrangements require careful legal examination.

Courts must distinguish genuine commercial arrangements from provisions that improperly remove assets from an insolvent estate.

Relevance to Spain:

Useful comparative authority when interpreting inter-creditor subordination and payment waterfall clauses, subject to Spanish mandatory insolvency rules.

Case 3: British Eagle International Airlines Ltd v Compagnie Nationale Air France

Case: [1975] 1 WLR 758

Court: House of Lords

Legal issue: Contractual arrangements and insolvency distribution.

Background:

The case concerned an airline settlement arrangement under which financial obligations between participating airlines were settled through a clearing-house system.

When British Eagle became insolvent, a dispute arose over whether the contractual settlement mechanism could operate independently of ordinary insolvency distribution principles.

Judgment:

The House of Lords rejected the arrangement to the extent that it attempted to displace the mandatory statutory insolvency distribution regime.

Legal principles:

Parties cannot simply contract out of mandatory insolvency distribution rules.

Contractual arrangements must comply with applicable insolvency law.

The pari passu principle protects the statutory distribution framework.

Relevance to Spain:

This is important comparative authority for disputes involving payment waterfalls, creditor priorities and contractual arrangements that may prejudice other creditors.

Case 4: Re Spectrum Plus Ltd

Case: [2005] UKHL 41

Court: House of Lords

Legal issue: Classification and validity of security interests.

Background:

The dispute concerned whether a charge over a company's book debts was a fixed charge or a floating charge.

Judgment:

The House of Lords held that the relevant charge was floating because the company retained sufficient control over the proceeds of the book debts.

Legal principles:

The legal substance of a security arrangement is more important than its contractual label.

The classification of security interests determines creditor priority.

Creditors must carefully examine the debtor's control over secured assets.

Relevance to Spain:

This provides useful comparative reasoning for disputes concerning the nature and ranking of security interests.

Case 5: Re New Bullas Trading Ltd

Case: [1994] 1 BCLC 485

Court: English Court of Appeal

Legal issue: Classification of fixed and floating charges.

Legal significance:

The case concerned the classification of security over book debts and their proceeds.

Its approach was subsequently rejected by the House of Lords in Re Spectrum Plus Ltd.

Importance:

It illustrates the difficulties associated with security classification and the importance of determining the actual legal and commercial rights attached to collateral.

Case 6: Katchen v. Landy

Case: 382 U.S. 323 (1966)

Court: United States Supreme Court

Legal issue: Bankruptcy jurisdiction and creditor claims.

Legal significance:

The Court examined the relationship between bankruptcy proceedings and disputes involving creditor claims and recovery of assets.

Importance:

The judgment is useful for comparative analysis of insolvency jurisdiction and the central role of insolvency courts in resolving creditor-related disputes.

It is not binding in Spain or the EU.

9. Cross-Border Inter-Creditor Disputes

Cross-border disputes become more complicated where creditors operate in different countries.

For example:

A Spanish company borrows from a German bank.

A French financial institution provides a second-ranking loan.

A Luxembourg investment fund holds subordinated debt.

A UK bondholder group holds unsecured securities.

The following legal issues may arise:

Which country's courts have jurisdiction?

Which law governs the inter-creditor agreement?

Which law determines the validity and ranking of security?

Will foreign insolvency proceedings be recognised?

How will creditor claims be treated?

Can foreign restructuring plans affect Spanish creditors?

EU Insolvency Regulation

Regulation (EU) 2015/848 provides the central framework for jurisdiction, recognition and coordination of qualifying EU insolvency proceedings.

Generally, the courts of the Member State where the debtor has its centre of main interests (COMI) have jurisdiction to open main insolvency proceedings.

Recognition of proceedings and judgments under the regulation facilitates cross-border insolvency administration.

However, the regulation contains important exceptions, including special rules concerning rights in rem over assets located in another Member State.

10. Restructuring Plans and Creditor Disputes in Spain

Spain's insolvency reforms under Law 16/2022 introduced an enhanced preventive restructuring framework.

This framework seeks to facilitate restructuring before a company reaches full insolvency.

Important mechanisms include:

A. Restructuring plans

A restructuring plan may modify debt obligations, payment schedules and other financial arrangements.

B. Creditor classes

Creditors are grouped into classes according to the statutory classification criteria and the similarity of their interests.

C. Class voting

Creditors vote on restructuring proposals according to the applicable statutory rules.

D. Cross-class cram-down

Under qualifying conditions, a restructuring plan may be imposed on dissenting creditor classes.

E. Judicial confirmation

The competent court may confirm restructuring plans where statutory requirements are fulfilled.

These mechanisms are especially important where secured and unsecured creditors disagree about the proposed restructuring.

11. Standstill Clauses and Enforcement Restrictions

Inter-creditor agreements commonly contain standstill clauses.

A standstill clause temporarily prevents certain creditors from enforcing their rights against the debtor or collateral.

For example, a junior creditor may agree not to initiate enforcement proceedings while the senior creditor is negotiating a restructuring.

Such provisions are designed to:

Prevent conflicting enforcement actions.

Preserve collateral value.

Facilitate coordinated restructuring.

Protect senior creditor rights.

Reduce the risk of disorderly asset liquidation.

However, enforceability depends on the wording of the agreement and applicable mandatory law.

A standstill clause cannot automatically override statutory insolvency stays or compulsory legal procedures.

12. Payment Waterfall Disputes

A payment waterfall establishes the sequence in which available money is distributed among creditors.

A typical contractual waterfall may be:

Statutory expenses and applicable enforcement costs.

Senior secured creditor payments.

Other secured creditor payments according to their ranking.

Senior unsecured creditors.

Junior creditors.

Subordinated creditors.

Shareholders, if any surplus remains.

This is only an illustrative contractual structure. Actual Spanish insolvency distributions are governed by the TRLC, including the statutory classification and treatment of claims against the estate.

Disputes commonly arise when:

A senior lender claims exclusive priority.

A junior creditor challenges the calculation of available proceeds.

A guarantor makes a payment and seeks reimbursement.

A security interest is challenged.

Contractual distributions conflict with mandatory insolvency rules.

13. Enforcement of Inter-Creditor Agreements

Inter-creditor agreements may be enforced through civil litigation or arbitration, depending on the nature of the dispute and the agreement.

Under Spanish law, the principal contractual principles are found in the Civil Code.

Important provisions include:

Article 1091: Binding force of contractual obligations.

Article 1101: Liability for contractual breach.

Article 1255: Freedom of contract.

Article 1258: Good faith and contractual consequences.

A creditor may seek remedies where another creditor breaches contractual obligations.

Potential remedies include:

Specific performance where legally available.

Damages.

Declaratory judgments.

Injunctions.

Enforcement of contractual payment obligations.

However, enforcement must remain consistent with mandatory insolvency law and the rights of third parties.

14. Regulatory and Institutional Challenges

Inter-creditor disputes create several challenges for regulators and courts.

ChallengeLegal concern
Conflicting security interestsUncertainty over collateral priority
Multiple creditor classesDisagreement over restructuring rights
Cross-border insolvencyJurisdictional conflict
Contractual subordinationEnforceability of priority arrangements
Payment waterfallDistribution disputes
Creditor votingValidity of restructuring decisions
Enforcement standstillConflicting enforcement rights
Insolvency recognitionRecognition of foreign proceedings
Guarantee enforcementAllocation of liability between creditors

15. Practical Example: Inter-Creditor Dispute in Spain

Assume a Spanish construction company obtains three loans:

Bank A: €50 million, first-ranking secured creditor.

Bank B: €30 million, second-ranking secured creditor.

Bank C: €20 million, unsecured creditor.

The company becomes insolvent.

The liquidation of its assets produces €55 million.

Bank A claims that it should receive the entire €50 million before other creditors receive anything.

Bank B argues that its second-ranking security entitles it to payment from the remaining collateral proceeds.

Bank C argues that certain assets were improperly transferred and that the insolvency estate should be increased.

The legal process would involve:

Determination of the validity of each creditor's claim.

Verification of the security documents.

Examination of the registration and ranking of security interests.

Classification of the claims under the TRLC.

Application of the statutory rules concerning collateral proceeds.

Resolution of disputes by the competent insolvency court.

Distribution of the available proceeds in accordance with applicable law.

The inter-creditor agreement may govern contractual relationships between Banks A, B and C, but cannot independently rewrite mandatory statutory insolvency priorities.

16. Recommendations for Effective Inter-Creditor Dispute Resolution

Financial institutions should adopt comprehensive inter-creditor arrangements containing:

Clearly defined creditor ranking.

Precise security descriptions.

Detailed payment waterfall provisions.

Express contractual subordination clauses.

Enforcement standstill provisions.

Transparent voting mechanisms.

Appropriate information-sharing obligations.

Negotiation and mediation procedures.

Clearly drafted arbitration or jurisdiction clauses.

Compliance with applicable insolvency legislation.

Creditors should also conduct regular reviews of security documentation, loan agreements and guarantees.

17. Conclusion

Inter-Creditor Dispute Resolution Frameworks are essential to the stability and predictability of banking, corporate finance and insolvency proceedings.

In Spain, these disputes are governed by the Spanish Insolvency Law, Civil Code, applicable security legislation and EU insolvency regulations.

Directive (EU) 2019/1023 has strengthened preventive restructuring mechanisms, while Regulation (EU) 2015/848 facilitates cross-border insolvency cooperation.

The cases Belmont Park, British Eagle, Re Spectrum Plus and Re Lehman Brothers International (Europe) provide important comparative judicial guidance on contractual subordination, creditor priorities, security classification and insolvency distribution.

The central legal principle is that creditors may contractually organise their financial relationships, but their agreements must operate within the limits of mandatory insolvency legislation and applicable third-party rights.

18. Important Legal Authorities – Quick Reference

AuthorityPrinciple
Spanish TRLC – Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020Insolvency and creditor classification
Law 16/2022Preventive restructuring reforms
Directive (EU) 2019/1023Restructuring and insolvency framework
Regulation (EU) 2015/848Cross-border insolvency
Spanish Civil Code Article 1091Binding contractual obligations
Spanish Civil Code Article 1101Contractual liability
Spanish Civil Code Article 1255Freedom of contract
Law 60/2003Arbitration
Law 5/2012Civil and commercial mediation
Belmont Park, [2011] UKSC 38Contractual subordination
British Eagle, [1975] 1 WLR 758Mandatory insolvency distribution
Re Spectrum Plus, [2005] UKHL 41Fixed and floating security
Re Lehman Brothers, [2017] UKSC 38Insolvency distribution
Katchen v. Landy, 382 U.S. 323 (1966)Bankruptcy jurisdiction

Academic and legal research note: The UK and US decisions above are comparative authorities, not binding precedents in Spain. Their principles must be applied with reference to Spanish statutory provisions and relevant CJEU and Spanish Supreme Court jurisprudence.

 

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT