Intercreditor Agreements Enforceability .

INTERCREDITOR AGREEMENTS – ENFORCEABILITY

Detailed Explanation with Case Laws – Spain, European Union and Comparative Banking Law

1. Introduction

An Intercreditor Agreement (ICA) is a contractual arrangement between two or more creditors of the same borrower that regulates their respective rights, priorities, obligations, remedies, and enforcement procedures.

Intercreditor agreements are particularly important in syndicated lending, project finance, leveraged finance, corporate restructuring, infrastructure financing, and insolvency proceedings.

A typical arrangement may involve:

Senior lenders.

Junior lenders.

Mezzanine lenders.

Secured creditors.

Unsecured creditors.

Bondholders.

Security agents.

Facility agents.

Institutional investors.

The main purpose of an intercreditor agreement is to establish how different creditors will exercise their rights when the borrower defaults or becomes insolvent.

For example, a company may borrow €100 million from a senior lending bank and €40 million from a junior lender. Both creditors may have contractual claims against the same borrower.

An intercreditor agreement can establish that the senior lender must be paid first and that the junior lender cannot enforce its debt until the senior lender has received the agreed amount.

The central legal question is whether these contractual arrangements are enforceable against the parties, third parties, insolvency administrators, and competing creditors.

In Spain, enforceability depends on Spanish contract law, security law, insolvency legislation, and applicable European Union financial regulations.

2. Meaning and Legal Nature of Intercreditor Agreements

An intercreditor agreement is generally a private contractual agreement between creditors.

It establishes a framework governing the relationship between creditors rather than replacing the underlying loan agreements.

Its provisions commonly address:

Payment priority.

Security ranking.

Enforcement rights.

Standstill obligations.

Payment subordination.

Turnover obligations.

Voting arrangements.

Debt restructuring.

Appointment of security agents.

Insolvency distributions.

Release of security.

Dispute resolution.

An ICA may be entered into before or after the financing arrangements are completed.

Its enforceability depends on whether the relevant parties have validly consented to its terms, whether its provisions are sufficiently certain, and whether they comply with mandatory law.

Importantly, an agreement between creditors does not automatically change the statutory ranking of claims against all third parties.

3. Legal Framework in Spain

A. Spanish Civil Code

The Spanish Civil Code provides the principal contractual framework for intercreditor agreements.

Article 1091 – Binding Force of Contracts

Contracts have the force of law between the contracting parties and must be performed according to their terms.

This provision is fundamental to ICA enforceability.

Where two lenders agree that one lender will receive repayment before another, the agreement may be contractually binding between them.

Article 1255 – Freedom of Contract

Parties may establish agreements, clauses, and conditions they consider appropriate, provided they are not contrary to law, morality, or public policy.

This allows lenders to negotiate:

Seniority arrangements.

Payment restrictions.

Enforcement standstills.

Turnover provisions.

Voting procedures.

Contractual subordination.

However, contractual freedom cannot override mandatory insolvency rules or prejudice third-party rights where the law does not permit it.

Article 1256 – No Unilateral Determination of Contractual Validity

The validity and performance of contracts cannot be left to the discretion of only one contracting party.

This principle is relevant where an intercreditor agreement gives one creditor extensive unilateral powers over restructuring or enforcement.

Article 1257 – Relative Effect of Contracts

Contracts generally produce effects between the contracting parties and their successors, subject to statutory exceptions.

Consequently, an ICA ordinarily binds the creditors that entered into it, but does not automatically impose contractual obligations on an unrelated creditor or insolvency administrator.

Article 1261 – Essential Requirements of Contracts

A valid contract requires:

Consent.

A certain object.

A lawful cause.

An intercreditor agreement must satisfy these essential contractual requirements.

Article 1275 – Unlawful Cause

Contracts without a lawful cause, or with an unlawful cause, do not produce legal effects.

This may become relevant if contractual arrangements are designed to circumvent mandatory creditor-protection or insolvency rules.

B. Spanish Insolvency Law – Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020

The Spanish Insolvency Act, approved by Royal Legislative Decree 1/2020, is particularly important.

It regulates:

Classification of insolvency claims.

Secured creditor rights.

Subordinated claims.

Insolvency distributions.

Restructuring plans.

Creditor voting.

Avoidance of prejudicial transactions.

Enforcement of security.

An intercreditor agreement cannot simply create a new statutory insolvency priority that contradicts mandatory insolvency legislation.

The distinction between contractual priority and statutory insolvency ranking is essential.

For example, two lenders may agree that Lender A will receive all distributions before Lender B.

That agreement may be enforceable between those lenders. However, it does not necessarily mean that Lender A acquires a higher statutory insolvency classification against every other creditor.

C. Spanish Security Law

Security interests may be created through mortgages, pledges, guarantees, and other legally recognised arrangements.

Relevant legislation includes:

Spanish Civil Code.

Mortgage Law.

Royal Decree-Law 5/2005 concerning financial collateral arrangements, where applicable.

Relevant provisions of Spanish insolvency legislation.

The enforceability of an intercreditor agreement must be distinguished from the creation and perfection of a security interest.

An agreement between lenders does not automatically create a valid mortgage or pledge over the borrower's assets.

The relevant security must satisfy the applicable formalities, registration requirements, and perfection rules.

4. Types of Intercreditor Agreements

A. Senior and Junior Debt Agreement

This arrangement establishes that senior lenders receive payment before junior lenders.

Example:

Senior lender: €80 million.

Junior lender: €30 million.

The agreement may require the junior lender to refrain from receiving payments until the senior debt has been discharged.

B. Payment Subordination Agreement

Under payment subordination, junior creditors agree that payments received from the borrower must first satisfy senior debt.

This may include:

Principal.

Interest.

Default interest.

Enforcement expenses.

Contractually agreed costs.

The precise scope depends on the wording of the agreement and mandatory law.

C. Security Subordination Agreement

Security subordination regulates the relative priority of security interests.

For example, a first-ranking mortgage holder may have priority over a second-ranking mortgage holder.

However, the legal effectiveness of the arrangement depends on the applicable property and security law, including registration and third-party effectiveness.

D. Enforcement Subordination Agreement

This restricts junior creditors from independently enforcing their claims while senior creditors are exercising agreed enforcement rights.

It may contain a standstill period.

E. Turnover Agreement

A turnover clause requires a junior creditor to transfer payments or recoveries received contrary to the agreed priority arrangements to the senior creditor or security agent.

Its effectiveness depends on the precise drafting, applicable property law, and the legal status of the funds.

F. Security Agent Agreement

A security agent holds or administers security for the benefit of multiple lenders.

The agreement regulates:

Appointment of the security agent.

Powers of enforcement.

Instructions from lenders.

Distribution of recoveries.

Release of security.

Replacement of the agent.

5. Enforceability of Payment Priority Clauses

Payment priority is one of the most important provisions in an ICA.

A typical clause may provide:

"The junior creditor shall not receive any payment from the borrower until all outstanding senior obligations have been irrevocably discharged in full."

Under Article 1091 of the Spanish Civil Code, a properly concluded agreement is generally binding between the contracting parties.

However, three separate issues must be considered:

Whether the clause is enforceable between the creditors.

Whether the borrower is bound by the clause.

Whether the clause changes the statutory ranking of claims in insolvency.

These questions do not necessarily produce the same answer.

A payment priority arrangement may be enforceable between the lenders even where the insolvency classification of their respective claims remains governed by mandatory legislation.

6. Enforceability of Subordination Clauses

Subordination means that one creditor agrees to rank behind another creditor for specified purposes.

There are two important forms.

A. Contractual Subordination

Contractual subordination operates through an agreement between creditors.

The junior creditor agrees to postpone payment or transfer specified recoveries to the senior creditor.

Its principal legal foundation is contractual freedom under Article 1255 and the binding force of contracts under Article 1091.

B. Statutory Subordination

Statutory subordination arises under insolvency legislation.

Under the Spanish Insolvency Act, certain claims are classified as subordinated because of their statutory characteristics.

The two categories must not be confused.

A creditor's contractual promise to rank behind another creditor does not automatically alter the statutory classification of the claim against the insolvency estate.

7. Enforceability Against Insolvency Administrators

One of the most complex legal issues concerns the effect of an intercreditor agreement during insolvency proceedings.

An insolvency administrator must apply the mandatory rules governing:

Claim verification.

Claim classification.

Security rights.

Avoidance of transactions.

Distribution of insolvency proceeds.

The administrator is not automatically bound by every private arrangement between lenders.

An ICA may nevertheless remain relevant where it creates valid contractual rights between creditors.

For example, if a junior lender receives a distribution in breach of a valid turnover obligation, the senior creditor may have a contractual claim against the junior lender.

Whether the arrangement affects the distribution made by the insolvency estate is a separate question.

8. Enforceability of Standstill Clauses

A standstill clause prevents a junior creditor from taking independent enforcement action for an agreed period or until specified conditions are satisfied.

Common restrictions include:

No independent enforcement of security.

No commencement of insolvency proceedings, to the extent legally permissible.

No acceleration of junior debt.

No independent recovery action.

No exercise of specified voting rights.

Standstill clauses are generally capable of being contractually binding between sophisticated creditors.

However, they cannot prevent a creditor from exercising rights that mandatory law makes non-waivable.

Their scope must therefore be assessed carefully.

A court may also examine whether the provision is clear, proportionate, and consistent with public policy.

9. Enforceability of Turnover Clauses

A turnover clause requires junior lenders to transfer certain amounts received from the borrower to senior lenders.

For example:

A borrower pays €5 million to a junior lender despite an agreement requiring all payments to go to the senior lender.

The junior lender may be required to transfer that amount to the security agent.

The enforceability of such a clause depends on:

The contractual wording.

Whether the junior lender received the payment.

Whether the payment falls within the turnover definition.

Whether mandatory insolvency rules apply.

Whether third-party property rights are affected.

A turnover clause should expressly address principal, interest, enforcement proceeds, distributions, set-off recoveries, and other relevant receipts.

10. Important Case Laws

The following cases provide relevant principles concerning creditor priority, contractual enforceability, security, and insolvency. They should not all be treated as direct Spanish intercreditor-agreement precedents.

Case 1: Re SSSL Realisations (2002) Ltd

Court: High Court of England and Wales.

Legal significance: Contractual subordination and the effect of intercreditor arrangements.

The case is relevant to the analysis of contractual rights between creditors and the distinction between contractual arrangements and the statutory insolvency distribution framework.

Legal principles:

Contractual subordination must be interpreted according to its actual wording.

The rights of creditors under private agreements must be distinguished from their statutory insolvency rights.

The effect of a subordination arrangement depends on the legal mechanism used to implement it.

Application:

This is a useful comparative authority when drafting payment-subordination and turnover clauses.

Case 2: Re Maxwell Communications Corporation plc (1993)

Court: High Court of England and Wales.

Legal issue: Priority arrangements and insolvency distributions.

The case is relevant to the interaction between contractual creditor arrangements and the insolvency distribution process.

Legal significance:

Private creditor agreements must be analysed separately from statutory insolvency ranking.

Contractual arrangements may affect the rights and recoveries of participating creditors.

Insolvency distributions remain subject to applicable statutory rules.

Application:

It is useful in analysing whether an ICA can regulate distributions between participating lenders without automatically changing the rights of unrelated creditors.

Case 3: Belmont Park Investments Pty Ltd v BNY Corporate Trustee Services Ltd

Court: UK Supreme Court.

Citation: [2011] UKSC 38.

Legal issue: Financial collateral arrangements and insolvency principles.

The case involved structured financial transactions and arrangements designed to allocate financial risks in an insolvency context.

The Supreme Court considered the application of insolvency principles to contractual financial arrangements.

Legal significance:

Commercial certainty is important in sophisticated financial transactions.

Courts examine the substance and purpose of financial arrangements.

Insolvency principles must be considered alongside the contractual structure.

Financial collateral arrangements may receive special legal treatment.

Application:

This case is particularly useful when analysing structured finance, collateral arrangements, and creditor priority mechanisms.

Case 4: Re Lehman Brothers International (Europe)

Court: UK Supreme Court.

Citation: [2012] UKSC 6.

Legal issue: Insolvency distribution and the treatment of financial claims.

The litigation concerned the distribution of assets in the insolvency of Lehman Brothers International (Europe).

The Supreme Court considered important issues relating to statutory insolvency priorities and the treatment of claims.

Legal significance:

Insolvency distributions are governed by the applicable statutory framework.

Contractual and statutory rights must be carefully distinguished.

The legal classification of a claim may determine its priority in an insolvency.

Application:

This judgment provides important comparative guidance where lenders attempt to establish contractual priorities that interact with insolvency distributions.

Case 5: Re Nortel GmbH and Others

Court: UK Supreme Court.

Citation: [2013] UKSC 52.

Legal issue: Insolvency claims and contingent liabilities.

The Court considered the treatment of contingent liabilities and the classification of obligations in insolvency proceedings.

Legal significance:

The timing and nature of a liability may affect its treatment in insolvency.

Insolvency classification requires analysis of the underlying legal obligation.

Contractual arrangements cannot be considered independently of the statutory insolvency framework.

Application:

Relevant where intercreditor arrangements involve guarantees, indemnities, contingent obligations, and claims arising after insolvency commencement.

Case 6: Belmont Park Investments Pty Ltd v BNY Corporate Trustee Services Ltd – Anti-Deprivation Principle

The anti-deprivation principle is relevant to arrangements that seek to remove property from an insolvent estate because insolvency has occurred.

The UK Supreme Court considered the relationship between commercial financial arrangements and insolvency principles.

Application:

An ICA should not be drafted to disguise an unlawful deprivation of assets belonging to the borrower or insolvency estate.

The legal validity of the arrangement depends on its substance, purpose, and applicable statutory exceptions.

Case 7: British Eagle International Airlines Ltd v Compagnie Nationale Air France

Court: House of Lords.

Citation: [1975] 1 WLR 758.

Legal issue: Contractual arrangements and mandatory insolvency distribution rules.

The case concerned a contractual clearing arrangement under which airlines agreed to settle mutual claims through a central system.

The House of Lords held that the arrangement could not be used to defeat mandatory insolvency distribution rules.

Legal significance:

Contractual freedom is subject to mandatory insolvency law.

Parties cannot simply contract out of statutory insolvency priorities.

Private arrangements must not undermine the statutory distribution scheme.

Application:

This is a particularly important comparative authority for Spanish intercreditor agreements.

A private agreement between lenders cannot automatically override mandatory statutory insolvency rules.

Case 8: Re Bank of Credit and Commerce International SA (No 8)

Court: House of Lords.

Citation: [1998] AC 214.

Legal issue: Set-off and insolvency.

The decision concerned the operation of set-off in insolvency proceedings.

Legal significance:

The judgment illustrates the importance of statutory and contractual rules governing mutual obligations and insolvency set-off.

Application:

It is relevant where an ICA regulates the treatment of payments, counterclaims, and set-off between lenders.

11. European Union Law and Intercreditor Agreements

A. Directive (EU) 2019/1023 – Preventive Restructuring Directive

This Directive establishes a European framework for preventive restructuring.

It addresses:

Restructuring plans.

Classes of creditors.

Creditor voting.

Cross-class cram-down.

Protection of affected parties.

Insolvency-related restructuring procedures.

It is particularly relevant where intercreditor agreements regulate voting rights and restructuring decisions.

A contractual voting arrangement cannot automatically override mandatory restructuring-plan requirements.

B. Regulation (EU) 2015/848 – European Insolvency Regulation

The European Insolvency Regulation governs cross-border insolvency proceedings within the EU.

It addresses jurisdiction, recognition of insolvency proceedings, and applicable law.

In general, the law of the state opening the main insolvency proceedings governs important aspects of the insolvency procedure, subject to specified exceptions.

An intercreditor agreement involving lenders in several EU countries may therefore raise questions concerning:

Governing law.

Recognition of security rights.

Insolvency jurisdiction.

Cross-border enforcement.

Treatment of contractual subordination.

C. Directive 2002/47/EC – Financial Collateral Arrangements

This Directive provides a special framework for qualifying financial collateral arrangements.

It facilitates enforcement of eligible collateral arrangements and provides protections in certain insolvency situations.

However, not every security arrangement in an intercreditor agreement qualifies for this special regime.

The nature of the collateral, parties, and applicable requirements must be examined.

12. Voting Rights and Enforcement Decisions

Intercreditor agreements frequently establish voting mechanisms.

For example:

Senior lenders may control enforcement decisions.

Junior lenders may have limited voting rights.

Certain amendments may require unanimous consent.

Security releases may require majority lender approval.

Restructuring decisions may require specified lender thresholds.

These provisions are generally enforceable between the contracting parties if properly drafted.

However, voting rights under an ICA should not be confused with voting rights under mandatory insolvency restructuring legislation.

A contractual majority cannot necessarily bind creditors who are not parties to the agreement or override statutory voting requirements.

13. Security Agent and Trustee Enforceability

A security agent is commonly appointed to hold or administer security for a group of lenders.

The intercreditor agreement may provide that:

The security agent holds security for the secured creditors.

Enforcement decisions are taken according to lender voting thresholds.

The agent distributes recoveries according to the agreed waterfall.

The agent releases security after specified conditions are satisfied.

Lenders must indemnify the agent for specified liabilities.

In Spain, the legal structure must be carefully designed to ensure that the security is validly created and that the agent has the necessary authority.

The contractual appointment of an agent does not itself eliminate the need to comply with the formalities applicable to mortgages, pledges, or other security interests.

14. Grounds on Which an Intercreditor Agreement May Become Unenforceable

An ICA may be challenged on several grounds.

A. Lack of valid consent

Where a lender did not validly agree to the arrangement, enforcement may be challenged.

B. Unlawful contractual purpose

An agreement contrary to mandatory law or public policy may be invalid.

C. Lack of certainty

Ambiguous priority provisions may create interpretation disputes.

D. Fraudulent arrangements

An ICA designed to prejudice creditors or improperly remove assets may be subject to challenge.

E. Breach of mandatory insolvency law

An agreement cannot automatically override statutory creditor classifications or mandatory distribution requirements.

F. Lack of security perfection

A contractual promise of priority does not necessarily establish a valid or perfected security interest.

G. Improper amendment

Where an agreement requires unanimous approval for particular amendments, an amendment made without the required consent may be unenforceable.

H. Conflict with third-party rights

An ICA cannot automatically bind unrelated creditors or override rights protected by mandatory law.

15. Practical Example of Intercreditor Agreement Litigation

Assume a Spanish company borrows:

€100 million from Bank A as senior lender.

€50 million from Investment Fund B as junior lender.

€25 million from Fund C as mezzanine lender.

All three institutions execute an intercreditor agreement.

The agreement provides:

Bank A receives repayment first.

Fund B receives repayment after Bank A.

Fund C receives repayment after Fund B.

Junior creditors cannot independently enforce security.

All enforcement proceeds are distributed through a security agent.

Junior creditors must transfer payments received contrary to the waterfall.

The borrower subsequently enters insolvency proceedings.

A dispute arises because Fund B receives €10 million from the borrower before Bank A has been repaid.

Bank A alleges breach of the turnover clause.

The court may examine:

Whether the agreement was validly executed.

Whether the €10 million payment falls within the turnover provision.

Whether Fund B was contractually prohibited from accepting it.

Whether the payment was protected by any mandatory legal rule.

Whether Bank A has a valid contractual claim.

Whether the insolvency distribution framework affects the remedy.

The court may enforce the contractual obligation between the lenders without necessarily changing the statutory classification of their claims against the insolvency estate.

16. Remedies for Breach of an Intercreditor Agreement

Available remedies may include:

A. Specific performance

A court may require a party to comply with a contractual obligation where the relevant legal requirements are satisfied.

B. Damages

A creditor may seek compensation for losses caused by breach of the agreement.

C. Turnover recovery

A junior lender may be required to transfer payments received contrary to the agreed payment waterfall.

D. Injunctive relief

A creditor may seek appropriate interim relief to prevent an imminent breach, subject to procedural requirements.

E. Contractual indemnity

The agreement may provide for indemnification where a creditor's conduct causes specified losses.

F. Enforcement through arbitration

Where the agreement contains a valid arbitration clause, disputes may be resolved through arbitration, subject to the applicable law and the rights of non-parties.

17. Drafting Requirements for an Enforceable Intercreditor Agreement

To improve enforceability, an ICA should contain:

Clear identification of all creditors.

Precise definitions of senior, junior, and mezzanine obligations.

An express payment waterfall.

Clearly drafted subordination provisions.

Defined standstill periods.

Detailed turnover obligations.

Clear enforcement instructions.

Voting thresholds and amendment procedures.

Appointment and powers of the security agent.

Express treatment of insolvency distributions.

Governing law and jurisdiction.

Dispute resolution provisions.

Provisions addressing new lenders and transfers of debt.

Rules for releasing and replacing security.

Express treatment of set-off and counterclaims.

Consistency with underlying facility and security documents.

For Spanish transactions, additional attention should be given to the formal requirements for security creation, registration, insolvency classification, and the applicable restructuring regime.

18. Difference Between Contractual Priority and Insolvency Priority

This is the most important legal distinction.

Contractual priorityStatutory insolvency priority
Created through agreementCreated by legislation
Generally binds contracting partiesApplies according to insolvency law
Regulates creditor relationshipsDetermines statutory claim ranking
May establish payment waterfallsGoverns insolvency distributions
Cannot automatically bind outsidersApplies according to statutory rules

An ICA may create enforceable contractual obligations without changing the statutory ranking of claims.

This distinction is particularly important in Spanish insolvency proceedings.

19. Critical Legal Issues for Courts

Courts dealing with intercreditor agreement disputes may need to determine:

Whether the agreement was validly executed.

Whether all relevant lenders consented.

Whether the payment waterfall is sufficiently clear.

Whether contractual subordination is valid.

Whether security priority was properly created and perfected.

Whether the agreement binds successors and transferees.

Whether turnover obligations are enforceable.

Whether standstill provisions are legally permissible.

Whether contractual voting arrangements conflict with mandatory insolvency law.

Whether the agreement prejudices third-party rights.

Whether the insolvency administrator must recognise particular rights.

Whether a breach gives rise to damages or specific performance.

20. Conclusion

Intercreditor agreements are essential instruments in complex financing transactions because they provide contractual certainty regarding creditor priority, payment allocation, enforcement rights, and restructuring decisions.

In Spain, their enforceability is primarily based on the Spanish Civil Code, particularly Articles 1091, 1255, 1256, 1257, and 1261, together with the Spanish Insolvency Act and applicable security legislation.

The central legal distinction is between contractual subordination and statutory insolvency ranking.

Creditors can generally agree among themselves to establish payment priorities, standstill obligations, turnover mechanisms, and enforcement procedures. However, these arrangements cannot automatically override mandatory insolvency rules or prejudice third-party rights.

The comparative judgments in British Eagle, Belmont Park, Re Lehman Brothers, and Re Nortel illustrate important principles concerning contractual freedom, insolvency distributions, financial collateral, and creditor priority.

For a Spanish transaction, the enforceability of an ICA ultimately depends on the validity of the agreement, the legal structure of the security, the nature of the subordination mechanism, the applicable insolvency rules, and the rights of affected third parties.

LawGratis provides pro bono legal aid and resources to empower communities. Join us in making justice reachable for everyone! Follow our community on Instagram, YouTube, Facebook, and LinkedIn.

LEAVE A COMMENT