Tort law at Turkey
Tort law in Turkey is governed by the Turkish Civil Code (Law No. 4721), which came into effect on 1 January 2002. The Civil Code is heavily influenced by Swiss civil law but also draws on principles of Roman law and European legal traditions. The Turkish tort law system allows individuals to seek compensation for harm caused by wrongful acts, including both intentional and negligent conduct.
Key Features of Tort Law in Turkey
1. Legal Framework
Turkish Civil Code: The primary source of tort law in Turkey is the Turkish Civil Code, specifically Part Three, which deals with liability for unlawful acts (torts). It provides a comprehensive set of rules for addressing civil wrongs.
Turkish Code of Obligations (Law No. 6098): This code also plays an important role in regulating civil liability, particularly in areas related to contractual obligations and specific tort actions that intersect with contractual issues, such as damage caused by defects in products or services.
Constitution of Turkey: The Constitution guarantees personal rights, including the right to life, property, and dignity, which are fundamental for tort claims related to personal injury, property damage, and defamation.
2. General Principles of Tort Law
To establish a tort in Turkey, the following elements must be proven:
Wrongful Act: The defendant must have committed an unlawful act. This can be an intentional or negligent act that violates the legal rights of another person.
Fault: The defendant must be at fault (either intentional or negligent). In Turkish tort law, negligence refers to the failure to exercise reasonable care, while intentional acts involve deliberate wrongdoing.
Damage: The plaintiff must prove that they have suffered damage as a result of the wrongful act. This damage can be physical, psychological, or material (e.g., damage to property, loss of income).
Causation: There must be a causal link between the defendant’s act and the plaintiff’s damage. The damage must be a direct result of the defendant’s wrongful behavior.
3. Types of Torts in Turkey
Tort law in Turkey addresses a variety of wrongful acts, and these can be categorized into different types of torts:
Negligence: A common cause of action in tort law, negligence occurs when someone fails to exercise reasonable care, causing harm to another. Examples include car accidents, medical malpractice, and accidents in the workplace.
Intentional Torts: Intentional acts, such as assault, battery, and false imprisonment, can result in tort claims. These are cases where the defendant deliberately causes harm to the plaintiff.
Defamation: Defamation laws in Turkey provide remedies for individuals who have been harmed by false statements that damage their reputation. Defamation can be either libel (written) or slander (spoken).
Trespass: Trespassing involves the unlawful interference with someone else’s property, such as entering private property without permission or causing damage to someone’s possessions.
Nuisance: Nuisance involves unreasonable interference with someone’s enjoyment of their property. Examples might include excessive noise, pollution, or obstruction of access to property.
Strict Liability: In certain situations, such as in cases involving product liability or dangerous activities, a defendant may be held liable even without proof of fault. This is strict liability, where harm is caused regardless of negligence or intent.
Vicarious Liability: Employers in Turkey can be held liable for the torts committed by their employees during the course of their work.
4. Damages in Turkish Tort Law
Damages in Turkish tort law are aimed at compensating the plaintiff for the harm suffered. The types of damages include:
Compensatory Damages: The primary remedy in tort cases, compensatory damages aim to return the plaintiff to the position they were in before the harm occurred. These damages can be for both material (e.g., medical bills, loss of income) and non-material (e.g., pain and suffering, emotional distress) damages.
Punitive Damages: Turkish tort law generally does not recognize punitive damages, as the focus is on compensating the victim rather than punishing the defendant.
Moral Damages: In cases where the defendant's actions cause psychological harm or suffering, the plaintiff may be awarded moral damages. This includes compensation for harm to reputation, dignity, and emotional well-being.
Future Losses: In cases where the plaintiff suffers long-term or permanent harm (e.g., loss of earning capacity due to a disability), future losses can be calculated and awarded as part of the damages.
5. Defamation Law
Defamation is an important area of tort law in Turkey. The Turkish Penal Code also covers defamation, but civil claims are often brought in addition to any criminal charges. Defamation can include false statements that harm an individual’s reputation, either in writing or orally.
Freedom of Expression: Turkish defamation law must balance freedom of expression with the protection of personal dignity. A statement made in good faith or in the public interest may be a defense to a defamation claim.
6. Product Liability and Strict Liability
Product Liability: Under the Turkish Code of Obligations, manufacturers and sellers may be strictly liable for damage caused by defective products. If a product causes harm, such as an injury or property damage, the injured party can claim damages without needing to prove fault.
Strict Liability for Dangerous Activities: Those who engage in hazardous activities (e.g., using explosives or handling toxic substances) can be held strictly liable for any harm caused, even if no negligence can be proven.
7. State Liability
State and Administrative Liability: The state may be held liable for harm caused by the actions or negligence of public authorities or civil servants. The Turkish administrative courts have jurisdiction over claims against the state and its agencies, while civil courts handle private tort claims.
8. Statute of Limitations
The statute of limitations for tort claims in Turkey is typically 10 years from the date the plaintiff becomes aware of the damage and the identity of the responsible party. For certain types of claims (e.g., defamation), the limitation period may be 3 years.
9. Comparative Negligence
Comparative negligence is recognized under Turkish tort law, which means that if the plaintiff is partially at fault for their own injury, their compensation may be reduced in proportion to their degree of fault.
10. Court Procedures
Civil Courts: Tort claims are typically filed in the civil courts. These courts examine the facts, evidence, and legal arguments before determining liability and the amount of damages.
Criminal Courts: In some cases, torts may overlap with criminal offenses (e.g., assault or defamation). In these cases, both civil and criminal proceedings may occur.
Specialized Courts: Certain torts, such as those involving intellectual property rights or specific commercial interests, may be handled in specialized courts.
Summary
Tort law in Turkey is governed by the Turkish Civil Code and aims to provide remedies for wrongful acts that cause harm. It is based on fault, requiring proof of wrongful conduct, damage, and causation. The law recognizes various torts, including negligence, defamation, and product liability. Damages are awarded to compensate the victim for both material and non-material harm, and there is an emphasis on compensatory rather than punitive damages. While strict liability applies in specific areas, torts involving public authorities are handled by administrative courts. Comparative negligence can reduce the plaintiff’s compensation if they are partially at fault.
RELATED Blog
0 comments