What are the Challenges of Starting a New Business?
🔷 1. Regulatory and Legal Compliance
⚖️ Challenge:
New businesses often struggle with understanding and complying with multiple laws, such as:
Companies Act, 2013
GST laws
Labour laws
FDI & FEMA regulations
Intellectual Property laws
Environmental laws (for manufacturing units)
Failing to comply can result in fines, lawsuits, or shutdowns.
📌 Relevant Case Law:
✅ Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd. v. Union of India (1979 AIR 798)
The Supreme Court emphasized that ignorance of regulatory requirements is not a defense. Businesses must anticipate legal risks and ensure compliance from the start.
🔷 2. Access to Capital / Funding
💰 Challenge:
New businesses often face difficulties in:
Raising capital from banks or investors,
Meeting collateral requirements,
Managing cash flow in early stages.
Startups may struggle due to lack of credit history or assets.
📌 Relevant Legal Principle:
While there may not be a direct case law, the Startup India initiative and RBI guidelines have recognized the funding challenges and attempted to create mechanisms like:
Priority sector lending for MSMEs
SIDBI Venture Capital support
🔷 3. Licensing and Permits
📝 Challenge:
Startups in certain sectors need:
Trade licenses,
Environmental clearances,
Sectoral approvals (e.g., FSSAI for food businesses, IRDA for insurance, SEBI for financial services),
Fire safety and health permits.
Delays in obtaining these licenses can derail business operations.
📌 Relevant Case Law:
✅ Paryavaran Suraksha Samiti v. Union of India (2017) 5 SCC 326
The Supreme Court held that industries operating without valid environmental clearances are liable for closure. Compliance must be ensured before starting operations.
🔷 4. Intellectual Property Protection
💡 Challenge:
Startups often ignore or delay protecting their:
Brand name (Trademark),
Product innovation (Patent),
Content/Design (Copyright).
Failure to do so can lead to loss of competitive edge or legal disputes.
📌 Relevant Case Law:
✅ Yahoo Inc. v. Akash Arora & Anr. (1999 PTC 201 Delhi)
The Delhi High Court protected Yahoo’s trademark rights, emphasizing the importance of trademark registration and brand protection even for online businesses.
🔷 5. Choosing the Right Business Structure
🏢 Challenge:
Entrepreneurs may be unsure whether to choose:
Sole Proprietorship,
Partnership,
Limited Liability Partnership (LLP),
Private Limited Company.
Wrong structuring can affect tax liability, personal liability, and fundraising options.
📌 Legal Relevance:
Under the Companies Act, 2013, the choice of structure affects the extent of liability and regulatory obligations.
Section 3 of the Companies Act defines different forms of companies.
Salomon v. Salomon & Co. Ltd. (1897) (UK Case, followed in India) laid down the principle of corporate personality, stressing the legal distinction between a company and its members.
🔷 6. Taxation and Financial Record Keeping
🧾 Challenge:
Startups must comply with:
GST regulations,
TDS deductions,
Income Tax filings,
Annual returns and audits (especially for companies).
Non-compliance can attract penalties and disqualification of directors.
📌 Relevant Legal Provision:
Section 276CC of the Income Tax Act allows for prosecution for failure to file returns.
Companies Act, 2013 – Section 92 & 137: Annual return and financial statement filing.
🔷 7. Market Competition and Survival
📉 Challenge:
High competition, especially in sectors like food tech, e-commerce, and fintech, makes sustainability difficult. Many startups shut down due to:
Inadequate market research,
Pricing wars,
Lack of innovation.
📌 Legal Perspective:
While competition per se is not illegal, unfair competition (e.g., misleading ads, trademark infringement) is prohibited under:
Competition Act, 2002
Trademark Act, 1999
🔷 8. Hiring and Employment Compliance
👥 Challenge:
Startups often hire employees without:
Proper offer letters or contracts,
Compliance with EPF, ESI, and gratuity laws,
Workplace policies (e.g., POSH Act compliance).
This can lead to labour disputes or penalties.
📌 Relevant Case Law:
✅ Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan (1997) 6 SCC 241
Laid down the guidelines for prevention of sexual harassment at the workplace. Compliance is mandatory even for small businesses.
🔷 9. Dispute Resolution and Litigation Risk
⚖️ Challenge:
Startups may face:
Contractual disputes,
IP litigation,
Consumer complaints.
They often lack legal support to manage such issues, and litigation costs can be crippling.
📌 Legal Tools:
Arbitration clauses in contracts can provide alternative dispute resolution.
NCLT for company law disputes (e.g., shareholder issues).
🔷 10. Exit Strategy and Closure Challenges
🚪 Challenge:
Winding up a business is not easy in India, especially if:
There are pending liabilities,
The business is registered as a private limited company.
Lengthy closure processes can burden founders long after operations have ceased.
📌 Relevant Legal Provision:
Section 248 of the Companies Act, 2013: Allows for striking off company name.
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC) allows startup insolvency resolution.
✅ Summary Table
| Challenge | Legal Connection |
|---|---|
| Regulatory Compliance | Companies Act, GST, Labour laws |
| Capital/Funding | RBI, Startup India guidelines |
| Licensing & Permits | Paryavaran Suraksha Samiti case |
| IP Protection | Trademark, Copyright, Patent laws |
| Choosing Business Structure | Companies Act, Salomon case |
| Taxation | Income Tax Act, GST Act |
| Market Competition | Competition Act, Trademark Act |
| HR & Employment Laws | Labour Codes, POSH Act, Vishaka guidelines |
| Legal Disputes | Arbitration Act, NCLT, Consumer Protection Act |
| Exit Strategy | IBC, Section 248 (Strike Off) |
🔚 Conclusion
While starting a business is full of opportunity, it is equally full of legal and operational pitfalls. Founders must approach entrepreneurship with:
Strong legal knowledge or support,
Proper documentation and structure, and
An understanding of compliance and risk management.
Indian courts and legislations have evolved to support startups, but ignorance of the law can still be costly and fatal for a new business.
RELATED Blog
0 comments