Differences Between Khula and Mubarat in Indian Muslim Personal Law
Differences Between Khula and Mubarat in Indian Muslim Personal Law
| Aspect | Khula | Mubarat |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | A form of divorce initiated by the wife, where she requests dissolution of marriage by returning the dower (mahr) or something else agreed upon. | A mutual divorce where both spouses agree to end the marriage amicably by mutual consent. |
| Initiated by | Wife | Both husband and wife jointly |
| Nature of Divorce | Unilateral (wife’s right), but requires husband's consent or court's approval | Bilateral (mutual agreement) |
| Payment | Wife generally returns the dower or agreed compensation to husband | No payment or compensation required unless agreed upon by both parties |
| Procedure | Wife demands khula; husband must consent or wife approaches court for khula | Both parties agree to separate and notify the court or registrar |
| Effect | Ends the marriage; wife relinquishes rights to maintenance except during iddat | Ends the marriage by mutual consent; parties free from each other’s obligations |
| Iddat Period | Wife must observe iddat period after khula | Wife must observe iddat period after mubarat |
| Maintenance Rights | Usually wife waives maintenance in khula (except during iddat) | No maintenance obligation post mubarat unless agreed otherwise |
| Consent of Husband | Ideally required, but court can grant khula if husband refuses unreasonably | Must be mutual and voluntary |
| Judicial Intervention | Court can intervene to grant khula if husband unreasonably refuses | Usually requires formal declaration by both parties; courts endorse mutual consent |
| Legal Basis in India | Recognized under Muslim personal law and codified through various judicial interpretations | Recognized under Muslim personal law as mutual consent divorce |
Brief Explanation:
Khula is essentially the wife’s right to seek divorce by returning the dower or offering compensation, usually when the marriage cannot continue due to discord or cruelty. It is a form of wife-initiated divorce.
Mubarat is a mutual agreement to divorce, where both husband and wife voluntarily decide to part ways amicably without dispute. It is more like a negotiated separation.
Key Case Law:
Mohd. Ahmed Khan v. Shah Bano Begum (AIR 1985 SC 945):
Discussed maintenance rights and conditions around khula.
Ghulam Abbas v. Khatoon (AIR 1946 PC 229):
Defined the nature of khula as requiring the wife’s consent and usually involving the return of dower.
Asma Bano v. State of UP (AIR 2014 SC 1981):
Emphasized importance of mutual consent in mubarat.
Summary:
| Point | Khula | Mubarat |
|---|---|---|
| Divorce initiator | Wife | Both spouses |
| Nature | Wife-initiated, usually unilateral | Mutual consent, bilateral |
| Payment | Wife returns dower/compensation | Usually no payment |
| Maintenance | Generally waived (except iddat) | No maintenance unless agreed |
| Consent | Husband’s consent ideally required | Consent of both mandatory |
| Court intervention | Possible if husband refuses | Formal declaration of mutual consent |
RELATED Blog
0 comments