North Dakota Administrative Code Title 16 - Economic Development Commission
North Dakota Administrative Code (NDAC)
Title 16 — Economic Development Commission
📌 Overview
NDAC Title 16 governs the rules and procedures of the North Dakota Economic Development Commission (EDC), which operates under the North Dakota Department of Commerce. The EDC’s primary mission is to promote economic growth in North Dakota by supporting business development, investment, and community economic initiatives.
Title 16 codifies the administrative regulations that guide how the Commission operates, including programs, funding, grant management, reporting, and compliance.
🔍 Key Functions of the Economic Development Commission
Business attraction and expansion: Offering assistance and incentives to businesses considering locating or expanding in North Dakota.
Grant and loan programs: Administering state funds to stimulate economic growth, including grants, low-interest loans, and tax credits.
Community development: Supporting local governments and organizations with resources for infrastructure, workforce development, and planning.
Monitoring and compliance: Ensuring recipients of state economic development funds comply with program requirements.
📘 Key Provisions in NDAC Title 16
1. Commission Structure and Authority
The EDC is composed of appointed members representing various sectors including business, agriculture, education, and labor.
The Commission establishes policies, approves grants, and oversees program implementation.
NDAC Title 16 sets the framework for meetings, voting, recordkeeping, and transparency.
2. Grant and Loan Program Administration
The rules describe eligibility criteria for applicants, application procedures, deadlines, and required documentation.
Guidelines for grant approvals, loan underwriting, disbursement, and reporting are detailed.
Recipients must adhere to conditions such as job creation targets, use of funds, and compliance with nondiscrimination laws.
3. Economic Incentives and Tax Credits
The Commission administers certain economic incentives, including tax credit programs aimed at encouraging investment.
The NDAC sets forth how credits are earned, certified, transferred, or forfeited if requirements are not met.
4. Compliance and Enforcement
The Commission monitors recipients for compliance through audits, progress reports, and site visits.
Procedures for dealing with noncompliance include:
Repayment of funds
Loss of eligibility for future funding
Other administrative penalties
5. Public Records and Transparency
The NDAC requires that meetings and decisions be conducted in compliance with North Dakota’s Open Meetings and Public Records laws.
Records of Commission actions, grant awards, and financial transactions must be available to the public.
⚖️ Relevant Legal Principles and Case Law
Although specific case law regarding the Economic Development Commission in North Dakota is sparse, general legal principles related to administrative agencies, economic incentives, and contract enforcement apply:
1. Administrative Discretion and Judicial Review
Courts generally afford deference to the Economic Development Commission’s decisions regarding grant awards and program administration, so long as they:
Follow statutory authority
Are not arbitrary or capricious
Adhere to procedural requirements
Legal Principle: Challenges to grant denials or funding conditions will fail if the Commission acts within its discretion and follows fair procedures.
2. Contract and Funding Agreements
Grants and loans awarded by the Commission typically involve legally binding agreements.
Recipients must comply with contract terms, including performance metrics like job creation or investment levels.
Breach of these terms can trigger remedies such as fund repayment or termination of incentives.
Legal Principle: Courts uphold the enforcement of economic development agreements so long as terms are clear and parties had opportunity to negotiate or accept conditions.
3. Transparency and Open Meetings
The Commission’s adherence to open meeting laws is crucial.
Failure to provide adequate notice or conduct public business transparently can invalidate Commission decisions.
Legal Principle: Courts may invalidate actions taken in secret or without proper notice, emphasizing public accountability.
4. Equal Protection and Nondiscrimination
Economic development programs funded or administered by the state must comply with nondiscrimination laws.
Recipients of funds must not discriminate based on race, gender, religion, or other protected classes.
Failure to comply may result in loss of funding or legal challenges.
Hypothetical Case Illustration
Suppose a company receives a grant from the Economic Development Commission contingent on creating 50 new jobs within two years. The company fails to meet this requirement. The Commission demands repayment of the grant.
If the company challenges the demand, the court will look at:
Whether the grant agreement clearly stated job creation as a condition
Whether the Commission followed procedural rules in demanding repayment
If the company had a fair chance to comply or explain failure
Typically, courts uphold the Commission’s right to enforce grant conditions if the process was fair.
📑 Summary Table
| Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Governing Authority | North Dakota Economic Development Commission |
| NDAC Title | Title 16 |
| Primary Functions | Business growth, grants/loans, economic incentives, compliance |
| Grant Administration | Eligibility, application, approval, reporting, enforcement |
| Contractual Obligations | Job creation, investment, use of funds |
| Legal Standards | Administrative discretion, contract enforcement, transparency |
| Compliance Monitoring | Audits, progress reports, penalties for noncompliance |
✅ Final Notes
NDAC Title 16 provides a regulatory framework that supports North Dakota’s economic development strategy.
The Commission balances flexibility in funding decisions with accountability to the public.
Entities working with the Commission should carefully review program rules and comply with all grant or loan conditions.
RELATED Blog
0 comments