West Virginia Code of State Rules Agency 110 - Tax
I. Overview of Agency 110
Agency 110 of the West Virginia Code of State Rules contains the tax rules administered by the West Virginia State Tax Department. These rules provide clarification, interpretation, and procedural guidance for state tax laws. They cover:
Personal Income Tax – Rules define who is taxable, what counts as income, filing procedures, credits, and residency rules.
Sales and Use Tax – Rules clarify taxable goods and services, exemptions, reporting, and record-keeping.
Municipal Business & Occupation Taxes – Rules define classifications of businesses, what receipts are taxable, and how to report them.
Carrier and Franchise Taxes – Rules include calculations, apportionment methods, and illustrative examples.
Procedures – Filing deadlines, payment methods, audit procedures, penalties, and interest.
Important Point: These rules do not create new taxes or change statutory law; they explain and operationalize the statutes.
II. Purpose of Agency 110
Agency 110 rules serve several functions:
Interpretation of statutes: Clarify ambiguous terms like “gross income,” “resident,” or “service business.”
Procedural guidance: Explain how to file returns, pay taxes, keep records, and respond to audits.
Illustrative examples: Show hypothetical situations to guide compliance.
While rules carry administrative authority, they cannot override statutory language.
III. Judicial Principles and Case Law
West Virginia courts have addressed the authority and limitations of Agency 110 rules. Key principles include:
Rules cannot exceed statutory authority
Example: In Griffith v. Frontier West Virginia Inc., the court struck down a rule that imposed obligations beyond what the statute allowed. The agency cannot change the law under the guise of interpretation.
Deference to agency interpretation is limited
If a statute is ambiguous, courts may give some weight to the agency’s interpretation.
But if the statute is clear, the agency cannot rewrite it. Courts review these matters de novo.
Proper promulgation required
Rules must follow the West Virginia Administrative Procedures Act. Informal guidance, letters, or memos cannot impose enforceable obligations.
Burden of proof in tax disputes
Taxpayers generally must prove a rule or assessment is incorrectly applied.
Factual findings are reviewed for clear error; legal interpretations are reviewed independently.
Example: Syncor Intl. Corp. v. Palmer
The court emphasized that an agency cannot enforce a regulation that effectively changes statutory language. Agencies must stay within the statute’s framework.
IV. Practical Application of Agency 110 Rules
Definitions matter
Terms like “gross income,” “service business,” or “resident” affect tax liability.
Procedures must be followed
Filing deadlines, payment methods, reporting forms, and recordkeeping are critical.
Illustrative examples provide guidance
Example problems show how to calculate tax or allocate income correctly under complex rules.
V. Summary of Key Takeaways
Agency 110 is the set of West Virginia rules implementing tax laws.
Covers personal income, sales/use taxes, municipal taxes, carrier taxes, and administrative procedures.
Rules clarify statutes but cannot contradict or expand them.
Courts enforce rules only if properly promulgated and consistent with statutes.
Taxpayers must follow rules on definitions, filing, reporting, and recordkeeping to avoid penalties.
RELATED Blog
comments