West Virginia Code of State Rules Agency 54 - Solid Waste Management Board
I. Overview and Purpose
Agency 54 governs the management, regulation, and enforcement of solid waste disposal and recycling programs in West Virginia. The rules are administered by the Solid Waste Management Board, which oversees solid waste facilities, landfills, transfer stations, recycling operations, and hazardous waste storage under state law.
The objectives of Agency 54 are to:
Protect public health and the environment by regulating solid waste handling;
Set standards for waste facility operation, permitting, and closure;
Implement state and federal solid waste laws consistently; and
Provide enforcement mechanisms to ensure compliance with solid waste management standards.
The regulations ensure that municipalities, private operators, and other entities handle waste safely and sustainably, preventing contamination of soil, water, and air.
II. Statutory Authority
Agency 54 is promulgated under the authority granted to the Solid Waste Management Board by the West Virginia Solid Waste Management Act. This authority allows the Board to:
Adopt rules for solid waste management;
Require permits for construction, operation, or closure of waste facilities;
Conduct inspections and investigations; and
Impose civil penalties or sanctions for noncompliance.
This statutory authority ensures that the regulations have full legal force and that violations can be enforced administratively or in court.
III. Scope and Applicability
Agency 54 applies to:
Solid waste facility operators, including landfills, transfer stations, composting sites, and recycling facilities;
Municipalities and private businesses that generate, transport, or manage solid waste; and
Persons responsible for waste disposal or management activities that may affect public health or the environment.
The rules do not govern hazardous waste regulated exclusively under separate hazardous waste laws, except where integrated management overlaps with municipal solid waste.
IV. Structure of Agency 54
Agency 54 is organized into sections covering:
Definitions – Key terms such as “solid waste,” “landfill,” “operator,” “permit,” and “closure plan.”
Permitting Procedures – Requirements for obtaining, modifying, and renewing permits for solid waste facilities.
Design and Operating Standards – Technical requirements for facility construction, leachate management, environmental monitoring, and staffing.
Closure and Post-Closure Requirements – Procedures for safe closure of landfills, including capping, monitoring, and financial assurance.
Inspection and Enforcement – Authority for inspections, reporting, corrective action, and civil penalties.
Recordkeeping and Reporting – Requirements for maintaining operational, financial, and environmental records.
Public Participation – Notice requirements for permit applications, hearings, and public comment.
V. Key Provisions Explained
1. Definitions
Agency 54 defines:
Solid Waste – Any discarded material, including household garbage, commercial waste, and construction debris.
Landfill – A site for the permanent disposal of solid waste in a controlled manner.
Permittee/Operator – The individual or entity responsible for operating a solid waste facility.
Closure – Steps necessary to safely seal and monitor a landfill or facility after waste disposal ceases.
These definitions determine regulatory applicability, compliance requirements, and enforcement scope.
2. Permitting Requirements
Construction Permit – Required before a new solid waste facility is built. Requires submission of site plans, engineering designs, environmental assessments, and proof of financial assurance for closure.
Operating Permit – Required before accepting waste; includes operational procedures, staffing, environmental monitoring, and contingency planning.
Modification of Permit – Needed when major operational changes are planned, such as increasing capacity or changing waste types.
Renewal – Permits must be renewed periodically with updated compliance information.
Permits are essential to ensure that public health and environmental standards are met before waste is handled.
3. Facility Design and Operations
Operators must follow standards including:
Proper site selection to avoid groundwater contamination;
Installation of liners, leachate collection, and stormwater management systems;
Daily cover of landfill waste;
Environmental monitoring (groundwater, surface water, and methane gas);
Staffing by qualified personnel, including certified sanitarians or environmental engineers.
These standards prevent environmental degradation and protect nearby communities.
4. Closure and Post-Closure
When a facility reaches capacity or ceases operation:
Operators must submit a closure plan, detailing capping, grading, and revegetation;
Post-closure monitoring must continue for a specified period to detect contamination;
Financial assurance (e.g., bonds or trust funds) must cover closure and monitoring costs.
This ensures the long-term safety of closed facilities.
5. Inspection and Enforcement
The Board has authority to:
Conduct inspections of facilities without prior notice;
Require corrective actions for noncompliance;
Issue fines, orders to suspend operations, or revoke permits;
Pursue civil or administrative penalties to ensure compliance.
Enforcement authority ensures that regulations are not merely advisory.
6. Public Participation
Agency 54 provides for:
Public notice of permit applications and modifications;
Opportunities for public comment and participation in hearings;
Transparency in enforcement and closure activities.
These provisions align with administrative law principles requiring stakeholder engagement in environmental regulation.
VI. Practical Effects
Agency 54 ensures that:
Solid waste is handled, stored, and disposed of safely;
Facility operators maintain environmental and operational standards;
Public health is protected from landfill hazards, contamination, and nuisance;
Communities are informed and able to participate in decision-making.
Noncompliance can result in financial penalties, operational suspension, or legal action.
VII. Case Law Context
West Virginia courts have addressed Agency 54 rules in several contexts:
A. Procedural Compliance
Courts have held that:
The Board must follow its own permitting and enforcement procedures;
Failure to provide proper notice, opportunity for public comment, or administrative hearing can invalidate enforcement actions.
B. Enforcement and Penalties
Courts upheld civil penalties when facility operators knowingly violated permit requirements, such as improper waste disposal or failure to monitor leachate.
License or permit revocation has been affirmed where operators failed to comply with closure or monitoring obligations.
C. Judicial Oversight
Courts generally defer to the Board on technical and operational judgments (e.g., facility design or safety measures) but strictly review procedural fairness:
Decisions are overturned if the Board acts arbitrarily, exceeds authority, or fails to follow established rules.
Courts have emphasized that penalties must be proportional to violations and supported by record evidence.
D. Example Principles
While not citing specific case numbers, general principles derived from court rulings include:
Agencies must apply rules uniformly;
Notice and hearing rights for permit applicants or the public are enforceable;
Environmental and public health risks justify strict enforcement;
Operators cannot claim ignorance of standards once permits are issued.
VIII. Summary
West Virginia CSR, Agency 54 – Solid Waste Management Board:
Establishes regulatory and permitting framework for solid waste facilities;
Sets technical, operational, and closure standards to protect health and the environment;
Grants the Board authority for inspection, enforcement, and penalties;
Ensures public participation in permitting and enforcement decisions;
Is interpreted in case law under principles of procedural fairness, administrative due process, and technical deference, with courts generally upholding enforcement when rules are followed.
RELATED Blog
comments