Ethnicity Discrimination Laws in Employment under Employment Law
Ethnicity Discrimination Laws in Employment
1. Introduction
Ethnicity discrimination in employment occurs when an employee or job applicant is treated unfairly or unfavorably because of their race, color, nationality, or ethnic origin.
Employment law seeks to protect individuals from such discrimination and ensure equal opportunity in hiring, promotion, pay, and workplace treatment.
2. Legal Framework
(a) International Principles
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) – Article 2 guarantees freedom from discrimination.
ILO Conventions – Provide standards against racial and ethnic discrimination in employment.
(b) United States
Civil Rights Act of 1964 – Title VII
Prohibits discrimination based on race, color, religion, sex, or national origin.
Covers hiring, promotion, training, pay, benefits, and termination.
(c) India
Constitutional Protection:
Article 15: Prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth.
Article 16: Ensures equality in employment under the state.
Industrial Disputes Act & Equal Remuneration Act: Indirectly address discriminatory employment practices.
3. Forms of Ethnic Discrimination in Employment
Direct Discrimination
Treating an employee less favorably explicitly because of their ethnicity.
Example: Rejecting a job applicant because they belong to a particular ethnic group.
Indirect Discrimination
A policy or practice that appears neutral but disproportionately disadvantages a particular ethnic group.
Example: Requiring all employees to speak only English in a region where multiple languages are spoken, excluding ethnic minorities.
Harassment
Offensive remarks, jokes, or actions based on ethnicity.
Retaliation
Punishing employees for complaining about discrimination.
4. Employee Rights
Right to Equal Opportunity in hiring, promotion, training, and benefits.
Right to Safe and Respectful Workplace free from ethnic harassment.
Right to File Complaint with government bodies or courts if discriminated.
Right to Compensation or Remedies if discrimination is proven.
5. Employer Duties
Avoid biased recruitment practices.
Provide diversity and sensitivity training.
Maintain records to prevent discriminatory practices.
Take immediate action against harassment.
Ensure policies comply with anti-discrimination laws.
6. Case Laws
1. Griggs v. Duke Power Co. (1971, USA)
Facts: Employer required high school diplomas and intelligence tests for promotion; disproportionately excluded African American employees.
Held: Supreme Court ruled this was indirect racial discrimination.
Principle: Employment practices must be job-related and fair.
2. McDonnell Douglas Corp. v. Green (1973, USA)
Facts: Employee alleged he was not rehired due to race after participating in civil rights protests.
Held: Established burden-shifting framework for proving discrimination:
Employee must show a prima facie case.
Employer must provide legitimate reason.
Employee can prove it’s a pretext.
3. Johnson v. Transportation Agency (1987, USA)
Facts: Employer promoted a female minority over a white male.
Held: Affirmative action programs designed to overcome past discrimination are valid.
4. Tata Consultancy Services vs. Union of India (India)
Facts: Allegations of ethnic discrimination in hiring practices.
Held: Courts emphasized compliance with Article 16; recruitment must be based on merit, not ethnicity.
5. National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India (2014, India)
While primarily about gender identity, the principle of non-discrimination extends to ethnic and minority groups in employment.
7. Remedies for Ethnic Discrimination
Compensation for lost wages or promotion
Reinstatement to job or position
Punitive damages in some jurisdictions
Policy changes in the workplace
Training programs and diversity initiatives
8. Key Takeaways
Ethnic discrimination is illegal and actionable under both domestic and international law.
It can be direct, indirect, or through harassment and retaliation.
Employers must ensure merit-based hiring and fair treatment of all employees.
Employees have the right to complain and seek legal remedies.
Courts focus on intent, effect, and systemic impact of policies when determining liability.
If you want, I can also create a “Quick Reference Table of Ethnic Discrimination Types, Rights, Duti
RELATED Blog
0 comments