Workers’ Compensation and Disability under Employment Law

11 Jul 2025 --
0 Comments

🛠️ Workers’ Compensation and Disability in Employment Law

➤ Overview

Workers’ Compensation and Disability Law are two key areas of employment law that protect employees who experience illness or injury—either work-related or non-work-related—and govern how employers must respond.

Workers’ Compensation: Covers injuries or illnesses that arise out of and in the course of employment.

Disability Law: Protects employees with disabilities, whether or not the disability is work-related, and provides rights to reasonable accommodation and non-discrimination.

⚖️ Part 1: Workers’ Compensation

✅ What Is It?

Workers’ compensation is a system of state-mandated insurance that provides wage replacement, medical care, and rehabilitation benefits to employees injured or made ill due to job-related activities.

It is a “no-fault” system, meaning that employees receive benefits regardless of who was at fault for the injury.

📜 Key Legal Principles

Administered at the state level (e.g., Nevada Revised Statutes Chapter 616A–616D).

In exchange for guaranteed benefits, employees usually waive the right to sue their employer for negligence (known as the “exclusive remedy rule”).

💼 Benefits Include:

Medical expenses

Temporary total disability (TTD)

Permanent partial disability (PPD)

Vocational rehabilitation

Death benefits to dependents

🚨 Requirements for Coverage

To be eligible, the injury or illness must:

Arise out of employment: There must be a connection between the work and the injury.

Occur during the course of employment: The injury happened while the employee was doing their job.

🔍 Case Law: Workers’ Compensation

🔹 Larson v. Industrial Commission, 77 Nev. 456 (1961)

Facts: A worker was injured while taking a break in a company-designated rest area.

Holding: The Nevada Supreme Court held the injury compensable because it occurred within the course and scope of employment, even though the employee wasn’t actively working at the time.

Key Point: “Course of employment” includes activities reasonably incidental to the job.

🔹 Bailey v. Industrial Insurance Commission, 102 Nev. 635 (1986)

Facts: Employee developed carpal tunnel syndrome from repetitive motion.

Holding: Occupational diseases caused by repetitive motion over time are covered under workers’ compensation.

Key Point: The injury does not have to be from a single event; gradual-onset injuries are compensable.

🔹 Mendoza v. Clark County School District, 107 Nev. 226 (1991)

Facts: A janitor slipped on wet stairs and was denied compensation.

Holding: The court ruled in favor of the employee, reinforcing the broad coverage of injuries that occur on work premises.

♿ Part 2: Disability Law

✅ What Is It?

Disability law under employment is governed mainly by:

The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)

State equivalents (e.g., Nevada Equal Rights Commission statutes)

The ADA prohibits discrimination against qualified individuals with disabilities and requires employers to provide reasonable accommodations, unless it causes undue hardship.

🔍 Key Legal Elements

To be protected under the ADA, an individual must:

Have a physical or mental impairment that substantially limits one or more major life activities;

Have a record of such an impairment;

Or be regarded as having such an impairment.

🧩 ADA and Workers’ Comp: How They Interact

Workers’ compensation covers medical and wage-related benefits for work-related injuries.

ADA becomes relevant when:

An injured employee returns to work with a disability.

The employer must consider reasonable accommodations, such as modified duties or schedules.

The employer is prohibited from discrimination based on the injury or related disability.

🔍 Case Law: Disability Law

🔹 EEOC v. UPS Supply Chain Solutions, 620 F.3d 1103 (9th Cir. 2010)

Facts: Employee with a back injury requested accommodation to avoid heavy lifting. Employer refused and terminated her.

Holding: The 9th Circuit held that UPS violated the ADA by failing to engage in the interactive process to identify reasonable accommodations.

Key Point: Employers must engage in a dialogue to assess accommodation options.

🔹 Humphrey v. Memorial Hospitals Association, 239 F.3d 1128 (9th Cir. 2001)

Facts: A medical transcriptionist with OCD requested a flexible work schedule as an accommodation. Her employer refused and fired her for absenteeism.

Holding: The court held that failing to accommodate her disability violated the ADA.

Key Point: Reasonable accommodations must be explored before termination for conduct linked to a disability.

🔹 Chevron USA v. Echazabal, 536 U.S. 73 (2002)

Facts: Chevron denied employment to a man whose liver condition could be worsened by workplace toxins.

Holding: The Supreme Court upheld the denial, allowing employers to refuse employment where the job poses a direct threat to the applicant's health.

Key Point: Employers can consider direct threats to health but must have medical evidence.

🔄 Comparison Chart: Workers’ Comp vs. Disability Law

Feature	Workers’ Compensation	Disability (ADA)
Purpose	Compensate for work-related injuries	Prevent discrimination and require accommodations
Trigger	Injury/illness arising out of employment	Physical/mental impairment limiting major life activity
Coverage	Medical care, lost wages, rehab	Job protection, accommodations
Fault	No-fault system	Not based on injury cause
Employer Duties	Provide benefits through insurance	Avoid discrimination; accommodate disability
Enforcement	State workers' comp boards	EEOC or state agencies

📌 Practical Scenario

Example:
An employee injures their back lifting heavy materials at work. They receive workers’ compensation for treatment and time off. Upon return, they cannot lift more than 10 pounds. The employer must now assess whether they can reasonably accommodate the lifting restriction under the ADA without undue hardship.