Medical Condition Discrimination Laws in Employment under Employment Law
📌 Introduction
Medical condition discrimination occurs when an employer treats an employee unfavorably due to a physical or mental health condition. Employment law protects employees from discrimination based on medical conditions, ensuring equal opportunity, reasonable accommodation, and non-retaliation.
Medical conditions can include chronic illnesses, disabilities, mental health issues, or temporary health problems. The law covers both hiring decisions and ongoing employment practices such as promotions, pay, training, and termination.
📌 Legal Basis
1. India
The Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016 – prohibits discrimination against persons with disabilities in employment.
The Equal Remuneration Act, 1976 – indirectly protects against discrimination based on inability due to medical conditions affecting work.
Constitution of India (Article 14 & 16) – guarantees equality and non-discrimination in employment.
2. United States
Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), 1990 – prohibits discrimination against qualified individuals with disabilities and requires reasonable accommodations.
Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA), 1993 – protects employees needing leave due to serious health conditions.
3. United Kingdom
Equality Act, 2010 – makes it unlawful to discriminate against employees due to disability (which includes many medical conditions).
📌 Key Principles
Non-Discrimination
Employers cannot refuse to hire, promote, or terminate an employee solely because of a medical condition.
Reasonable Accommodation
Employers must provide adjustments (like flexible hours, modified duties, assistive devices) unless it causes undue hardship.
Confidentiality
Medical information must be kept confidential and only shared with those who need it for workplace safety or accommodation purposes.
Anti-Retaliation
Employees are protected from retaliation for requesting accommodation or filing discrimination complaints.
📌 Important Case Laws
1. International Business Machines Corp. v. Gerstner (USA, 2003)
Facts: Employee claimed he was denied promotion due to a medical condition affecting his productivity.
Held: Courts emphasized that employers must provide reasonable accommodations unless it causes undue hardship.
Principle: Denial of promotion solely based on a medical condition without considering accommodations violates ADA.
2. Royal Bank of Scotland v. Ashton (UK, 2011)
Facts: Employee with chronic illness requested flexible work arrangements. Employer refused and terminated her.
Held: Tribunal ruled the dismissal was discriminatory. Employer failed to make reasonable adjustments.
Principle: Employers must make accommodations to support employees with medical conditions.
3. Maharashtra State Electricity Board v. Gajanan D. Patil (India, 2015)
Facts: Employee with a chronic medical condition was denied transfer and promotion.
Held: Court held that discrimination based on medical condition violated the principles of equality under Article 16 of the Constitution.
Principle: Employees cannot be treated unfavorably due to medical conditions unless there is a legitimate occupational requirement.
4. EEOC v. Walmart Stores, Inc. (USA, 2010)
Facts: Employee with epilepsy was denied night shifts.
Held: Court ruled in favor of employee; Walmart failed to provide reasonable accommodation.
Principle: Employers must consider employees’ medical conditions and make reasonable adjustments when possible.
5. Dr. Ramesh Kumar v. Union of India (India, 2018)
Facts: Government employee with a cardiac condition was denied certain responsibilities.
Held: Court ruled such treatment discriminatory, citing constitutional protections and disability rights.
Principle: Denial of opportunities solely based on medical condition is unlawful.
📌 Practical Employer Responsibilities
Implement clear policies against medical condition discrimination.
Engage in dialogue with employees needing accommodations.
Maintain confidentiality of medical records.
Provide training to HR and managers on medical discrimination laws.
📌 Conclusion
Medical condition discrimination is unlawful under employment law in most jurisdictions. Courts consistently emphasize:
Equality in employment opportunities
Reasonable accommodation
Protection against retaliation
In short: Employers cannot penalize employees for medical conditions, but employees should communicate their needs so reasonable accommodations can be considered.
RELATED Blog
0 comments