Criminal Convictions and Deportation under Immigration Law
Criminal Convictions and Deportation Under Immigration Law
Overview
In immigration law, certain criminal convictions can lead to the deportation (removal) of non-citizens from the United States or other countries. Deportation is a legal process where an individual is formally removed from a country due to violations of immigration or criminal laws.
A criminal conviction can make a non-citizen deportable or inadmissible, affecting their right to remain or enter the country.
Key Legal Concepts
1. Deportable vs. Inadmissible
Deportable: Non-citizens already lawfully admitted or present in a country may be deported after conviction of certain crimes.
Inadmissible: Individuals seeking entry can be denied admission due to criminal history.
2. Categories of Crimes Affecting Deportability
Crimes involving moral turpitude (CIMT): Crimes involving dishonesty or moral wrongdoing.
Aggravated felonies: Serious crimes such as murder, rape, drug trafficking, firearms offenses, or theft with significant penalties.
Controlled substance offenses: Drug-related crimes.
Firearms offenses
Domestic violence, stalking, child abuse
Each category triggers specific grounds for deportation.
3. Removal Proceedings
If a non-citizen is convicted of a deportable offense, immigration authorities may initiate removal proceedings before an immigration judge.
The individual may be eligible for relief from removal depending on the nature of the conviction, time elapsed, and other factors.
Important Legal Principles
Categorical Approach: Courts look at the statute under which the person was convicted, not the specific facts of the case, to determine if it qualifies as a deportable offense.
Finality of Conviction: Deportation can only be based on a conviction that is final (no longer subject to appeal).
Effect on Naturalization: Certain convictions can also bar naturalization or cause denaturalization.
Relevant Case Law
1. INS v. St. Cyr (2001)
Facts: A lawful permanent resident was convicted of a controlled substance offense and faced deportation under new laws eliminating certain relief.
Issue: Whether non-citizens with convictions before a law’s enactment could still seek relief from deportation.
Ruling: The Supreme Court held that certain individuals could seek relief despite new statutes limiting options, emphasizing fairness and reliance interests.
Significance: Protected some non-citizens from automatic deportation based on past convictions.
2. Matter of Silva-Trevino (2011)
Facts: The Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) applied a new method for determining whether a conviction qualified as an aggravated felony.
Issue: Whether immigration authorities could consider facts beyond the conviction record.
Ruling: The BIA ruled that a “modified categorical approach” allowed looking beyond the conviction record for facts.
Significance: Allowed broader interpretation of convictions affecting deportability.
3. Padilla v. Kentucky (2010)
Facts: A lawful permanent resident was convicted of a drug offense without being properly advised that it could lead to deportation.
Issue: Whether failure to inform about deportation consequences violated the right to counsel.
Ruling: The Supreme Court held that defense attorneys must advise non-citizens about deportation risks of guilty pleas.
Significance: Established constitutional protections to prevent wrongful deportations.
Process After Criminal Conviction
Notification: Immigration authorities are notified of the conviction.
Detention: The individual may be detained pending proceedings.
Removal Proceedings: An immigration judge determines removability.
Relief Consideration: The individual may apply for relief, such as cancellation of removal, asylum, or waiver of deportation.
Appeal: Decisions may be appealed to higher immigration authorities or federal courts.
Defenses and Relief
Cancellation of Removal: Available for long-term residents with good moral character.
Waivers: Possible for certain offenses under specific conditions.
Asylum or Refugee Status: Protection for individuals fearing persecution.
Post-Conviction Relief: Vacating or reducing convictions can affect deportability.
Summary
Certain criminal convictions trigger mandatory or discretionary deportation under immigration law.
The nature of the crime (moral turpitude, aggravated felony, drug offenses) determines removability.
Courts use a categorical approach to classify convictions.
Supreme Court rulings, such as Padilla, require proper legal advice regarding deportation risks.
Non-citizens facing deportation due to convictions have limited but important avenues for relief.
RELATED Blog
0 comments