Trade Secrets under Intellectual Property
✅ What is a Trade Secret?
A trade secret is a form of intellectual property (IP) that consists of confidential business information which provides a company with a competitive edge. It includes:
Formulas (e.g., Coca-Cola recipe)
Practices
Processes
Designs
Instruments
Patterns
Business information (like customer lists or pricing strategies)
Unlike patents or copyrights, trade secrets are not registered with any government authority. They are protected by maintaining secrecy, and legal protection is available as long as the information remains secret.
✅ Legal Definition
As per Article 39 of the TRIPS Agreement (WTO, 1995), trade secrets are protected if:
The information is secret (not generally known or readily accessible),
It has commercial value because it is secret, and
Reasonable steps have been taken to keep it secret.
✅ Key Features of Trade Secrets
| Feature | Explanation |
|---|---|
| No registration required | Protection is automatic if secrecy is maintained |
| Duration | Potentially unlimited, until secrecy is lost |
| Disclosure | If voluntarily disclosed, protection is lost |
| Enforcement | Through breach of contract, tort, or confidentiality laws |
✅ Examples of Trade Secrets
Coca-Cola formula
Google's search algorithm
KFC’s chicken spice mix
Apple’s product design processes
✅ Legal Protection Mechanisms
Non-Disclosure Agreements (NDAs)
Non-Compete Clauses
Employment Contracts
Confidentiality Policies and internal safeguards
Litigation for misappropriation
✅ India’s Legal Position on Trade Secrets
India does not have a specific statute for trade secrets but provides protection through:
Contract Law (Indian Contract Act, 1872)
Equity principles
Common law remedies (injunctions, damages)
Information Technology Act, 2000 (for digital misappropriation)
✅ Key Indian Case Laws
1. Zee Telefilms Ltd. v. Sundial Communications Pvt. Ltd. (2003)
Facts: Plaintiff shared a concept for a TV serial with the defendant in confidence. The defendant used a similar concept without permission.
Held: The Bombay High Court held that the idea was shared in confidence, and its use without consent amounted to a breach of trust and misappropriation of a trade secret.
2. Mr. Anil Gupta & Anr. v. Mr. Kunal Dasgupta & Ors. (2002)
Facts: A concept for a reality show was disclosed during discussions. Later, a similar concept was aired without involving the plaintiff.
Held: The Delhi High Court granted an injunction, recognizing confidential ideas as protectable under trade secret law when disclosed in good faith.
3. John Richard Brady v. Chemical Process Equipments P. Ltd. (1987)
Facts: Plaintiff shared technical know-how for manufacturing equipment. The defendant used it to start a competing business.
Held: The Delhi High Court held that confidential information disclosed in the course of a business relationship is protectable and issued a permanent injunction.
✅ International Case Law
1. E.I. DuPont deNemours & Co. v. Christopher (1970, USA)
Facts: Defendants took aerial photographs of a plant under construction to reverse-engineer trade secrets.
Held: The court held that even without trespass, acquiring trade secrets through improper means like aerial surveillance was misappropriation.
2. Coco v. A.N. Clark (Engineers) Ltd. (1969, UK)
Test for breach of confidence:
The information must have the necessary quality of confidence.
It must have been disclosed in circumstances implying confidentiality.
There must be an unauthorized use of that information.
This case laid down the foundational test for trade secret protection in common law jurisdictions.
✅ Remedies for Trade Secret Misappropriation
Injunction – To stop further use or disclosure
Damages or Account of Profits
Return or destruction of confidential material
Criminal prosecution (in cases of theft or breach of trust)
✅ Comparison with Other Forms of IP
| Aspect | Trade Secret | Patent | Copyright |
|---|---|---|---|
| Protection | Automatic, through secrecy | Requires registration | Automatic |
| Disclosure | Must be kept secret | Full public disclosure | Not required |
| Duration | Unlimited (if secret) | 20 years | Life + 60 years (India) |
| Enforcement | Contract law, tort, equity | Patent law | Copyright Act |
✅ Challenges in Trade Secret Protection
Proving misappropriation
Maintaining effective internal controls
No protection if someone reverse-engineers the product
Limited remedies in absence of a written contract
✅ Conclusion
Trade secrets play a vital role in protecting business interests, especially in the absence of formal IP registrations. While India lacks a dedicated law, the judiciary has actively safeguarded trade secrets using contract and equity principles. Businesses must proactively use contracts, policies, and security measures to ensure confidentiality and maintain legal protection.
RELATED Blog
0 comments