Inheritance Laws in France
Inheritance laws in France are governed by both statutory law and civil law principles, with particular attention given to forced heirship rules that aim to protect family members from disinheritance. French inheritance laws are primarily outlined in the French Civil Code (Code Civil).
Here is an overview of the inheritance laws in France:
1. Testate Succession (Inheritance According to a Will)
In France, individuals can dispose of their estate through a valid will. However, French law imposes restrictions on the extent to which a person can freely distribute their property, due to the forced heirship rules that protect family members, particularly children and sometimes the surviving spouse.
Formal Requirements for a Will:
- Written Will: A will must be in writing to be valid. The will can be either handwritten, typed, or notarial (created before a notary).
- Witnesses: If a handwritten will (called a holographic will) is used, it must be entirely in the testator's handwriting and signed. There is no need for witnesses in this case. However, a notarial will requires two witnesses and a notary.
- Revocation: A will can be revoked or changed at any time by the testator, provided the new will complies with the formal requirements.
Freedom of Testation and Forced Heirship:
French law limits the testator’s ability to freely dispose of their estate. The law enforces forced heirship rules, which ensure that certain close family members (typically children and, in some cases, the surviving spouse) inherit a portion of the estate, regardless of what the will says.
- Children's Rights: The primary beneficiaries of forced heirship laws are the children of the deceased. A parent cannot completely disinherit their children unless specific conditions are met.
- Surviving Spouse: The surviving spouse has certain inheritance rights, which are influenced by whether the deceased left children or not.
The portion of the estate that the testator is free to bequeath to others (i.e., disposable portion) depends on the number of children:
- One child: The testator may freely dispose of up to half of the estate.
- Two children: The testator may freely dispose of up to one-third of the estate.
- Three or more children: The testator may freely dispose of one-quarter of the estate.
The remainder of the estate is reserved for the children as their reserved portion (part reserved for forced heirship).
2. Intestate Succession (Inheritance Without a Will)
If the deceased does not leave a will, the estate will be distributed according to intestate succession laws set forth in the French Civil Code. The estate will be distributed to the deceased’s relatives in a specific order of priority.
Order of Intestate Succession:
Spouse and Children:
- If the deceased was married, the estate is divided between the spouse and the children.
- If the deceased has children, the spouse does not automatically inherit everything, but they are entitled to a portion of the estate.
- The children inherit the estate equally.
- If the estate consists of community property (property acquired during the marriage), the surviving spouse receives one-quarter of the estate in full ownership, and the children inherit the remaining three-quarters.
- If the estate consists of separate property, the surviving spouse can choose between a life interest (usufruct) over part of the estate or a fixed share in full ownership.
When There Is No Spouse:
- If the deceased has no surviving spouse, the estate is divided among the children. If there are no children, the estate goes to the parents, followed by siblings, nieces and nephews, and more distant relatives, depending on the family structure.
No Heirs:
- If there are no heirs (i.e., no surviving spouse, children, or other relatives), the estate will eventually pass to the French state.
3. Forced Heirship and Reserved Shares
Under French inheritance law, forced heirship laws ensure that certain family members, particularly children, are entitled to a portion of the estate, regardless of the testator's wishes.
- Reserved Share for Children:
- One child: The child is entitled to half of the estate.
- Two children: The children are entitled to two-thirds of the estate, divided equally between them.
- Three or more children: The children are entitled to three-quarters of the estate, divided equally between them.
The remaining portion of the estate, called the disposable portion, can be left to anyone, including the surviving spouse or non-relatives.
Spouse’s Share:
If the deceased had children, the surviving spouse's share depends on the deceased’s assets. The surviving spouse may inherit a portion of the estate (either as usufruct over part of the property or in full ownership of a certain share). If there are no children, the surviving spouse inherits half of the estate.
If the deceased was married without a prenuptial agreement and their estate is considered community property, the surviving spouse automatically inherits one-quarter of the estate in full ownership.
4. Inheritance Procedure
The procedure for inheritance in France involves the following steps:
Probate:
- If the deceased left a will, the will must be submitted to the French notary for probate. The notary verifies the will and determines the legal heirs.
- If there is no will, the notary will prepare the certificate of inheritance (attestation d'hérédité), identifying the legal heirs.
Notification of Heirs:
- The notary will notify the heirs of their rights and responsibilities.
Valuation and Distribution of Assets:
- The estate is appraised, debts are settled, and assets are distributed according to the will or the laws of intestate succession.
- Real property may need to be registered in the names of the new owners with the French Land Registry.
Paying Debts and Taxes:
- Before assets are distributed, any debts or liabilities, including inheritance taxes, must be paid.
5. Inheritance Taxes
France imposes inheritance taxes on the assets inherited by beneficiaries. The tax rate depends on the value of the estate and the relationship between the deceased and the heir.
Spouse and Children: The spouse and children benefit from exemptions or reduced tax rates. For example, children have a tax-free allowance of €100,000 each, and the surviving spouse is exempt from inheritance taxes entirely.
Other Relatives: Relatives such as siblings or cousins are subject to higher tax rates and smaller exemptions. For example, siblings are entitled to a €15,932 exemption and are taxed at rates starting at 35%.
Non-Relatives: Inheritance from a non-relative is subject to the highest tax rates, with taxes up to 60%.
The rates for inheritance tax are progressive, with the amount of tax due increasing as the value of the estate increases.
6. Special Considerations for International Inheritance
In cases where the deceased or the heirs are non-French or live abroad, international inheritance laws come into play. France is a member of the European Union, and EU regulations allow for the application of French inheritance laws to estates, even when the deceased was a national of another EU country. Additionally, international treaties may affect the administration of estates and taxation.
France also follows the European Succession Regulation (Brussels IV), which allows individuals to choose the law of their nationality to govern their estate, even if they reside in another country. This can simplify the inheritance process for people with assets in multiple countries.
7. Disputes and Legal Challenges
Disputes may arise over inheritance matters, especially regarding the validity of a will, the division of assets, or claims for reserved portions.
- Challenges to the Will: Family members may contest the validity of a will if they believe the deceased lacked mental capacity or was under undue influence.
- Disagreements Over Forced Heirship: If a testator disinherits a child or fails to provide the legal reserved share, the child may challenge the will to claim their rightful portion.
- Distribution of Assets: Disputes may arise among heirs regarding the fair distribution of the estate, especially when the estate consists of complex assets like real estate or family businesses.
Conclusion
French inheritance laws are based on forced heirship rules that ensure family members, particularly children, receive a reserved portion of the estate, regardless of the deceased’s wishes. The law also allows for testate succession through a valid will, with certain limitations. The surviving spouse has a recognized share of the estate, depending on whether there are children or not. Inheritance taxes are progressive, with exemptions and lower rates for close family members. The inheritance process involves probate through a notary, and disputes can arise over the validity of wills or claims for reserved portions.
RELATED Blog
0 comments