Will Contests under Trusts and Estates
Will Contests under Trusts and Estates Law
I. Introduction to Will Contests
A will is a legal document expressing a person's wishes as to the distribution of their property after death. A Will Contest refers to a legal challenge made by an interested party who disputes the validity or terms of a will in probate court.
Purpose of Will Contests:
To ensure that the testator’s true intentions are respected.
To protect heirs from fraud, undue influence, or mistakes.
To rectify defects or irregularities in the execution of the will.
II. Grounds for Contesting a Will
The most common legal grounds on which a will can be contested include:
1. Lack of Testamentary Capacity
The testator must have the mental capacity to understand:
The nature of making a will,
The extent of their property,
The claims of potential beneficiaries.
If the testator was insane, mentally ill, or under the influence of drugs/alcohol at the time of making the will, it can be invalidated.
2. Undue Influence
Occurs when someone coerces or manipulates the testator to make a will that reflects someone else’s interests rather than their own.
The influence must overpower the free will of the testator.
3. Fraud or Forgery
If the will was procured by fraudulent means, or the signature was forged, it can be challenged.
Fraud includes misrepresentation or concealment of facts.
4. Improper Execution
Wills must comply with strict formalities (usually signed, witnessed, and dated).
Failure to follow these statutory requirements can invalidate a will.
5. Revocation
A will may be revoked intentionally by the testator or by operation of law.
Contestants may argue the will is revoked or superseded by a later will.
6. Mistake
A will made based on a mistake of fact or law may be contested, though this is generally difficult.
7. Lack of Due Execution
If the will was not properly signed or witnessed as required by law.
III. Parties Who Can Contest a Will
Typically, only interested parties such as heirs, beneficiaries, or creditors with a legal interest can challenge a will.
Sometimes, a person who would inherit under intestacy laws may contest if excluded.
IV. Legal Process of Will Contest
Initiated by filing a petition in probate court after the will is submitted for probate.
The contestant must present evidence supporting one of the grounds.
The burden of proof usually lies on the challenger.
If the will is declared invalid, the estate may pass through intestate succession or under an earlier valid will.
V. Important Case Laws
1. Banks v. Goodfellow (1870)
A landmark English case establishing the legal test for testamentary capacity.
Held: The testator must understand the nature of making a will, know the extent of their property, and the claims of others but may still have some mental illness.
The case is foundational in most common law jurisdictions.
2. Re: Estate of Khalil (1974)
Facts: Testator was influenced by a caregiver to make a will favoring the caregiver.
Held: Court invalidated the will due to undue influence; free will was overpowered.
Principle: If undue influence removes free agency, the will is void.
3. In Re: Estate of Smith (1942)
Facts: Will was challenged for improper execution (lack of witnesses).
Held: Will declared invalid due to failure to comply with statutory formalities.
Principle: Strict compliance with execution rules is necessary for validity.
4. Estate of Turner (1985)
Facts: Contest based on fraud; testator was misled about contents of the will.
Held: Will was set aside due to fraudulent misrepresentation.
Principle: Fraudulent inducement nullifies the will.
5. Re: Estate of Johnson (2000)
Facts: Contest over mental capacity; testator was elderly with dementia.
Held: The court allowed expert testimony and ruled that the testator lacked capacity at the time the will was executed.
Principle: Capacity is assessed at the time of making the will, not generally at death.
VI. Differences Between Will Contest and Trust Contest
Will Contest challenges the validity of a will.
Trust Contest disputes the terms or validity of a trust, which is a legal arrangement managing property.
Trusts often avoid probate and have different legal procedures.
VII. Remedies in Will Contest
Declaring the will invalid or partially invalid.
Probate of an earlier valid will or default to intestate succession.
Monetary damages or relief may be sought in cases of fraud or undue influence.
VIII. Conclusion
Will contests are critical mechanisms that protect against unjust or invalid dispositions of a decedent’s estate. Courts carefully balance respecting the testator's wishes with protecting against fraud, coercion, and incapacity. The success of a contest depends on clear evidence and strict adherence to legal standards.
RELATED Blog
0 comments