Arbitration Law in Puerto Rico (US)
Arbitration law in Puerto Rico is governed by both U.S. federal law and Puerto Rican local law. As an unincorporated territory of the United States, Puerto Rico follows the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), but also has its own regulations and provisions under Puerto Rico law. The general principles of arbitration in Puerto Rico are aligned with those of the U.S. mainland but are tailored to the local legal system.
Here is an overview of arbitration law in Puerto Rico:
1. Federal Arbitration Act (FAA)
- Puerto Rico is subject to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), which applies to arbitration agreements involving interstate commerce. The FAA provides a comprehensive framework for the enforcement of arbitration agreements and the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards.
- Under the FAA, arbitration agreements are generally enforceable, and courts must stay litigation and compel arbitration when a valid arbitration agreement exists, provided the dispute involves interstate commerce.
Key provisions of the FAA include:
- Section 2: Arbitration agreements are enforceable as long as the agreement is valid, and there is a commercial relationship between the parties.
- Section 3: Courts must stay court proceedings if the issue is subject to arbitration.
- Section 9: Federal courts will confirm an arbitral award unless there are limited grounds for vacating or modifying it.
2. Puerto Rican Law
- Puerto Rico Civil Code (Article 1401 and following) includes some provisions for arbitration that are consistent with the U.S. federal framework but also reflect the island's unique legal system.
- Act No. 55 of 1999: The Puerto Rican Arbitration Act provides specific guidance for arbitration proceedings in Puerto Rico, including the appointment of arbitrators, the conduct of hearings, and the enforcement of awards.
- Arbitration agreements are recognized in Puerto Rican law, and disputes can be referred to arbitration even when parties are located within Puerto Rico.
- Choice of Law: The Puerto Rican courts apply the FAA in cases of interstate commerce but may apply local law when there is a dispute about local issues. If the dispute involves purely intrastate commerce or matters within the local jurisdiction, the courts may reference Puerto Rican arbitration law or local case law.
3. Arbitration Agreements
- As in the mainland U.S., arbitration agreements in Puerto Rico are generally enforceable. The FAA and local law require that the arbitration agreement must be in writing and mutually agreed upon by the parties.
- Enforceability: The courts will enforce an arbitration agreement unless it is found to be unconscionable, invalid, or otherwise unenforceable under contract law principles.
- Mandatory Arbitration Clauses: Arbitration clauses are commonly included in commercial contracts, particularly in the context of business transactions, employment agreements, and consumer contracts.
4. Arbitration Procedure
- Arbitral Institutions: Arbitration in Puerto Rico can be institutional or ad-hoc:
- Institutional Arbitration: Many parties in Puerto Rico use established arbitral institutions like the American Arbitration Association (AAA), the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC), or the Puerto Rico Arbitration Center for managing arbitration proceedings.
- Ad-hoc Arbitration: In ad-hoc arbitration, the parties select their own arbitrators and set the rules of procedure, often based on UNCITRAL or other institutional rules if agreed upon.
- Arbitrators: The parties in Puerto Rico are free to select their own arbitrators, and in the absence of agreement, a court may appoint an arbitrator. The Puerto Rico Arbitration Act and FAA provide guidelines for appointing arbitrators, including qualifications and neutrality.
5. Recognition and Enforcement of Awards
- Domestic Arbitration: Awards issued in Puerto Rico are enforceable in Puerto Rican courts. If a party refuses to comply with an award, the other party can petition the court for recognition and enforcement of the arbitral award.
- International Arbitration: Puerto Rico is a signatory to the New York Convention (1958), meaning that it enforces foreign arbitral awards in the same manner as the U.S. mainland. Foreign arbitral awards are recognized and enforceable unless specific grounds, such as violation of public policy or due process, are raised.
- Grounds for Vacating Awards: Under both the FAA and Puerto Rican law, a party can seek to vacate an arbitral award on very limited grounds:
- The award was obtained through corruption or fraud.
- The arbitrators exceeded their authority.
- The arbitrators were biased.
- There was a procedural error that affected the fairness of the proceedings.
6. Role of the Courts
- Supportive Role: Puerto Rican courts play a supportive role in the arbitration process. They can compel arbitration if a party refuses to arbitrate, stay judicial proceedings if an arbitration agreement exists, and provide interim measures such as injunctions.
- Limited Role in Award Review: As with other U.S. jurisdictions, Puerto Rican courts intervene minimally in arbitration matters. The courts will generally uphold an arbitral award unless there are significant procedural issues or the award violates public policy.
7. Public Policy Exception
- Arbitration awards in Puerto Rico, whether domestic or international, may be refused recognition or enforcement if the award violates public policy. However, this exception is narrowly construed and applied only in cases where the award contravenes fundamental principles of Puerto Rican law.
8. Advantages of Arbitration in Puerto Rico
- Efficiency and Cost-Effectiveness: Arbitration in Puerto Rico is considered an efficient and cost-effective alternative to litigation, with faster resolution times and greater flexibility in procedures.
- International Recognition: As part of the U.S. legal system and a signatory of international treaties like the New York Convention, Puerto Rico benefits from a reliable framework for the enforcement of arbitration agreements and foreign awards.
- Neutral Forum: Puerto Rico can serve as a neutral forum for resolving disputes between international parties, especially in cases involving U.S. and Latin American businesses.
9. Recent Developments
- Puerto Rico has continued to develop as an arbitration hub, with increasing use of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms in both domestic and international disputes. The Puerto Rico Arbitration Center and local institutions have become more active in promoting arbitration services.
Summary:
Arbitration in Puerto Rico is primarily governed by the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and Puerto Rican local laws, such as Act No. 55 of 1999. The jurisdiction benefits from the enforcement of arbitration agreements and arbitral awards under the New York Convention and the FAA. Courts play a supportive role in arbitration and intervene only in exceptional circumstances. Arbitration is a preferred method for resolving disputes in Puerto Rico, especially for businesses engaged in international commerce.
RELATED Blog
0 comments