Civil Laws at Germany
Germany operates under a quintessential civil law system, meaning its laws are primarily codified in comprehensive written codes, rather than relying heavily on judicial precedent as in common law systems. Its legal tradition is deeply rooted in Roman law, particularly the Pandectist school, which emphasized systematic and abstract legal concepts.
The cornerstone of German civil law is the Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (BGB), which translates to the Civil Code. Enacted in 1896 and effective from January 1, 1900, the BGB is renowned for its systematic structure, conceptual precision, and logical coherence. It has been significantly influential, inspiring civil codes in many other countries, including Japan, South Korea, and Switzerland.
Here's an in-depth look at civil laws in Germany:
1. Primary Sources of Civil Law:
The Grundgesetz (Basic Law for the Federal Republic of Germany) (1949): This is the supreme law of Germany, serving as its constitution. It establishes the fundamental rights and duties of citizens (e.g., human dignity, freedom, equality), the structure of government, and the principles of the rule of law. All other laws, including civil laws, must conform to the Basic Law.
The Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (BGB - Civil Code): This is the central pillar of German private law. It is divided into five main books, each dealing with a specific area:
Book 1: General Part (Allgemeiner Teil) (§§ 1-240): This foundational book sets out general concepts applicable to all areas of civil law, such as the definitions of persons (natural and legal), legal capacity, domicile, legal transactions (declarations of will, formation of contracts), representation, limitation periods, and the exercise of rights (e.g., the principle of good faith - Treu und Glauben).
Book 2: Law of Obligations (Recht der Schuldverhältnisse) (§§ 241-853): This extensive section deals with:
Contracts: General principles of contract formation, validity, effects, and termination. Specific types of contracts like sale, lease, loan, service contracts, etc.
Torts (Deliktsrecht): Rules concerning civil wrongs and the obligation to compensate for damages caused by unlawful acts (e.g., negligence, intentional harm, product liability).
Other Sources of Obligations: Unjust enrichment (ungerechtfertigte Bereicherung), management of another's affairs without mandate (Geschäftsführung ohne Auftrag).
Book 3: Law of Property (Sachenrecht) (§§ 854-1296): This book regulates rights related to tangible and intangible assets:
Possession and Ownership: The acquisition, transfer, and protection of ownership over movable and immovable property.
Other Real Rights: Rights in rem such as usufruct (Nießbrauch), easements (Dienstbarkeiten), mortgages (Hypotheken), and land charges (Grundschuld).
Book 4: Family Law (Familienrecht) (§§ 1297-1921): This part governs legal relationships within the family:
Marriage: Requirements, impediments, celebration, effects, marital property regimes (e.g., community of accrued gains - Zugewinngemeinschaft, which is the default regime), and dissolution (divorce).
Parent-Child Relations: Filiation (legal relationship between parents and children), parental care (elterliche Sorge), maintenance obligations, and adoption.
Book 5: Law of Succession (Erbrecht) (§§ 1922-2385): This book regulates the legal fate of a person's estate after death:
Testamentary Succession: Wills, their types (e.g., holographic will, notarial will, joint will), validity, and interpretation.
Intestate Succession (gesetzliche Erbfolge): Rules for inheritance when there is no valid will.
Forced Heirship (Pflichtteil): Establishes the portion of the estate that must be reserved for certain close relatives (e.g., descendants, spouse, parents).
Other Specialized Statutes (Bundesgesetze): Numerous other laws complement or modify the BGB's provisions, or cover specialized civil matters not extensively detailed in the BGB:
Code of Civil Procedure (Zivilprozessordnung - ZPO): Governs the rules and procedures for civil litigation in German courts. (Most recently amended up to November 7, 2022).
Commercial Code (Handelsgesetzbuch - HGB): Regulates commercial transactions, merchants, commercial companies (e.g., sole proprietorships, general partnerships), and commercial agents.
Law on Limited Liability Companies (GmbHG), Stock Corporation Act (AktG), etc.: Specific laws for different types of commercial entities.
Labour Law (Arbeitsrecht): A comprehensive body of law governing individual and collective labor relations (e.g., Protection Against Dismissal Act - Kündigungsschutzgesetz, Works Constitution Act - Betriebsverfassungsgesetz). While related to civil law (contracts), it's often considered a distinct area due to its social dimension.
Intellectual Property Laws: Separate laws for patents (Patentgesetz), trademarks (Markengesetz), copyrights (Urheberrechtsgesetz), and other IP rights.
Consumer Protection Laws: Often found in the BGB (e.g., consumer contracts, distance selling) but also in specialized acts.
Insolvency Code (Insolvenzordnung - InsO): Regulates insolvency proceedings for both individuals and companies.
Land Register Ordinance (Grundbuchordnung): Governs the public register for real estate, crucial for property rights.
European Union Law: As a member state of the EU, German civil law is significantly influenced by EU directives and regulations. EU law has supremacy over national law in its areas of competence. Directives (which set goals for member states to achieve through national law) have led to numerous amendments to the BGB and other civil laws, particularly in consumer protection, competition law, and aspects of contract law. Regulations (which are directly applicable) also form part of German law.
Case Law (Rechtsprechung): While a civil law system, the decisions of higher courts, especially the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH - Federal Court of Justice), play a crucial role in interpreting the codes and developing the law. Although not formally binding precedents in the common law sense, their interpretations are highly influential and generally followed by lower courts to ensure legal consistency.
2. Key Characteristics of German Civil Law:
Codification: The BGB is the central and most important piece of civil legislation, providing a systematic and comprehensive framework.
Abstractness and Precision: The BGB is known for its highly abstract concepts and precise language, aiming for comprehensive coverage and minimizing gaps.
Categorical System: The division into five books and a "General Part" reflects a highly logical and systematic approach to legal concepts.
Freedom of Contract: A core principle, allowing parties wide latitude to shape their agreements, subject to statutory limits and public policy.
Good Faith (Treu und Glauben): A fundamental principle embedded throughout the BGB, requiring parties to act honestly and fairly in legal relations.
Principle of Abstraction (Abstraktionsprinzip): A key feature of German property law. It distinguishes between the contract of obligation (e.g., a contract of sale, which creates the obligation to transfer ownership) and the real agreement (the actual act of transferring ownership, which is a separate legal transaction). The invalidity of the contract of obligation does not automatically invalidate the real agreement.
3. Judicial System for Civil Matters:
Germany has a multi-branch judicial system, with specialized courts for different areas of law. Civil matters fall under the "Ordinary Jurisdiction" (Ordentliche Gerichtsbarkeit).
Local Courts (Amtsgerichte): These are the lowest courts. They handle smaller civil claims (generally up to €5,000), family law matters (e.g., divorce, child custody), and non-contentious matters (e.g., probate, guardianship, land register entries).
Regional Courts (Landgerichte): These courts serve two main functions:
First Instance: For civil cases with a value in dispute exceeding €5,000 and for specific types of cases regardless of value (e.g., complex commercial disputes, intellectual property cases). They may hear cases with a single judge or a panel (Kammer).
Appellate Court: They hear appeals from the Amtsgerichte in civil matters.
Higher Regional Courts (Oberlandesgerichte - OLG): These courts are primarily appellate courts, hearing appeals from the Landgerichte. They also have original jurisdiction for certain specific matters (e.g., some corporate law cases).
Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof - BGH): This is the highest court of ordinary jurisdiction in Germany. It acts as the final court of appeal for legal questions in civil (and criminal) cases. Its role is to ensure the uniform application of law and to develop legal principles. It focuses on questions of law, not factual findings.
Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht): This is separate from the ordinary judiciary and ensures that all laws and state actions comply with the Basic Law. Individuals can file constitutional complaints if their fundamental rights are violated.
In summary, German civil law is a highly sophisticated, comprehensive, and systematically organized body of law, characterized by its codified nature, abstract concepts, and the significant influence of the BGB. While it forms part of the broader European legal landscape and is constantly influenced by EU law, it maintains its distinct identity and continues to be a leading example of the civil law tradition globally.
RELATED Blog
0 comments