Procedural Aspects of Counterclaims
Procedural Aspects of Counterclaims
What is a Counterclaim?
A counterclaim is a claim made by a defendant against the plaintiff in the same suit.
It arises out of a cause of action connected or related to the plaintiff's claim.
The defendant essentially becomes a counter-plaintiff for that claim.
Legal Provisions:
Order 8 Rule 6 of the CPC governs counterclaims.
It allows the defendant to make a claim against the plaintiff in response to the plaintiff’s original suit.
The counterclaim should be filed with the written statement.
The court will try the counterclaim together with the original suit.
Procedural Aspects of Counterclaims:
1. Filing of Counterclaim:
The defendant must raise the counterclaim in the written statement filed under Order 8 Rule 1.
Counterclaim can be made at the time of filing the written statement or, with the court’s permission, later.
It should be a separate and distinct cause of action from the plaintiff’s claim.
2. Nature of Counterclaim:
Counterclaim may be connected with the plaintiff’s claim or entirely different but must be maintainable.
It must not be a mere set-off; it should be an independent claim.
A cross-suit or separate suit is not necessary; counterclaims consolidate related disputes.
3. Value of Counterclaim:
The counterclaim should state the value of the claim, and the defendant may be liable to pay court fees accordingly.
4. Suit and Counterclaim Tried Together:
The original suit and counterclaim are adjudicated together to avoid multiplicity of litigation and promote judicial economy.
5. Effect on Jurisdiction:
If the counterclaim exceeds the pecuniary jurisdiction of the court, the court can decline jurisdiction over the counterclaim but still proceed with the original suit.
6. Court Fees:
The defendant must pay court fees on the counterclaim as per the Court Fees Act.
Failure to pay the correct fee may lead to the counterclaim being rejected.
7. Reply by Plaintiff:
The plaintiff has the right to file a written statement in reply to the counterclaim under Order 8 Rule 7.
The counterclaim and the plaintiff’s reply form part of the pleadings.
8. Amendment and Addition:
A defendant may seek permission to amend or add to the counterclaim during the proceedings.
9. Dismissal of Counterclaim:
If the counterclaim is not maintainable or lacks jurisdiction, it may be dismissed without affecting the main suit.
Important Case Laws:
1. S.R. Tewari v. S.K. Tripathi, AIR 1956 SC 316
The Supreme Court clarified that a counterclaim must be a distinct cause of action and not a mere defense or set-off.
The court held that the object of allowing counterclaim is to enable complete adjudication in one suit.
2. Yeshwant Singh v. Gajanan Moreshwar, AIR 1961 SC 1372
The court ruled that counterclaim can be filed even if it is unrelated to the plaintiff’s claim, provided it is maintainable.
Courts emphasized judicial economy and avoidance of multiplicity of proceedings.
3. Shah Nakhoda & Co. v. Union of India, AIR 1962 SC 105
It was held that counterclaim must be filed with the written statement; otherwise, permission of court is needed.
The suit and counterclaim must be tried together, subject to jurisdictional limitations.
4. B.K. Educational Services Pvt. Ltd. v. Parag Gupta and Associates, (2015) 6 SCC 612
Supreme Court reiterated that counterclaims promote completeness of adjudication.
Courts should allow counterclaims liberally to avoid fragmented litigation.
Distinction Between Counterclaim and Set-Off:
| Aspect | Counterclaim | Set-Off |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Independent claim against plaintiff | Reduction/deduction from plaintiff’s claim |
| Cause of Action | Separate cause of action | Arises from the same transaction or cause of action |
| Court Fees | Payable on counterclaim | No separate court fees usually |
| Pleading | Filed with written statement as counterclaim | Mentioned as a defense or reduction |
Summary Table:
| Procedural Aspect | Details |
|---|---|
| Governing Rule | Order 8 Rule 6 CPC |
| When to File | Along with written statement |
| Nature | Separate cause of action, not mere defense |
| Court Fees | Payable as per Court Fees Act |
| Trial | Suit and counterclaim tried together |
| Reply | Plaintiff may file reply to counterclaim |
| Amendments | Allowed with court permission |
| Consequence of Non-compliance | Counterclaim may be rejected |
Conclusion:
Counterclaims under the CPC are a procedural mechanism to allow defendants to assert their claims against plaintiffs in the same suit, facilitating judicial economy by consolidating disputes. While it requires careful adherence to procedural norms like filing with written statement and paying court fees, the law encourages their use to avoid multiplicity of litigation. Courts have consistently interpreted provisions liberally to promote fairness and efficiency.
RELATED Blog
0 comments