Human Rights Law at Turkey
Human Rights Law in Turkey is a complex issue, with a rich legal framework but significant concerns related to the implementation and protection of human rights. While the Turkish Constitution of 1982 guarantees many fundamental rights and freedoms, challenges persist, particularly in areas like freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, minority rights, and the rule of law. Turkey's relationship with human rights has been closely scrutinized both domestically and internationally, particularly in recent years under President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan's government.
1. Constitutional Protection of Human Rights
The Constitution of Turkey (1982) guarantees a wide range of human rights, but these rights are often subject to limitations for reasons such as national security, public order, and morality. Key rights include:
Right to Life: The right to life is protected, and the death penalty was formally abolished in 2004.
Freedom of Expression: The Constitution provides for freedom of expression, but this right is restricted by laws prohibiting defamation, insults to the government, and threats to national security or public order.
Freedom of Assembly: Turkish citizens are guaranteed the right to assemble peacefully, though this right is frequently curtailed, particularly during protests.
Freedom of Religion: Freedom of belief is guaranteed, though the practice of religion is sometimes restricted, particularly for religious minorities.
Right to Privacy: The Constitution guarantees the right to privacy, but concerns about government surveillance, especially in the context of the state of emergency declared after the 2016 coup attempt, have raised alarm.
Equality Before the Law: Discrimination based on race, language, religion, or sex is prohibited, although gender-based discrimination remains a significant challenge.
Labor Rights: The Constitution guarantees the right to work and the right to form and join trade unions.
2. International Human Rights Commitments
Turkey is a party to many important international human rights conventions, including:
International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR): Turkey is a signatory to the ICCPR, which protects civil and political rights such as freedom of speech, the right to a fair trial, and protection from torture and arbitrary detention.
International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR): Turkey has ratified the ICESCR, committing to protect economic, social, and cultural rights, including the right to health, education, and an adequate standard of living.
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination (CERD): Turkey ratified CERD, which commits it to eliminating racial discrimination.
Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW): Turkey ratified CEDAW, committing to eliminate gender-based discrimination and advance women's rights.
Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC): Turkey is a party to the CRC, committing to ensuring the protection and rights of children.
Convention Against Torture (CAT): Turkey has ratified CAT and is bound by its provisions prohibiting torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment.
3. Civil and Political Rights
While Turkey's Constitution and international commitments provide for civil and political rights, their implementation has faced significant challenges, particularly under the government of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan.
Freedom of Expression: Although guaranteed by law, freedom of expression is frequently curtailed in practice. Journalists, academics, and activists critical of the government often face harassment, imprisonment, and legal prosecution under broad charges such as "terrorist propaganda" or "insulting the president."
The government has imposed restrictions on social media, and several prominent media outlets have been shut down or taken over by government-aligned entities.
Press Freedom: Turkey ranks poorly in global press freedom indices, with many journalists imprisoned or forced into exile. The Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) regularly reports on violations of press freedom in Turkey.
Freedom of Assembly and Association: The right to peacefully assemble is constitutionally guaranteed, but in practice, protests have been violently suppressed, particularly during the Gezi Park protests of 2013 and other political protests.
Authorities frequently use excessive force against protesters and have imposed restrictions on public gatherings.
Political Dissent and Arrests: The government has cracked down on political opposition, particularly since the 2016 attempted coup. Thousands of individuals, including military personnel, civil servants, academics, journalists, and members of opposition parties, have been detained or dismissed from their jobs.
State of Emergency (2016–2018): Following the 2016 coup attempt, a state of emergency was declared, which allowed for mass arrests, purges of the judiciary, military, and civil service, and restrictions on freedoms of assembly and expression.
Judicial Independence: The independence of the judiciary has been a growing concern. President Erdoğan’s influence over the judiciary has raised fears of politicized legal decisions and the erosion of the rule of law.
In 2014, the government took control of the Constitutional Court and began to exert greater influence over the judiciary, further diminishing judicial independence.
4. Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights
Right to Education: The Constitution guarantees the right to education, and Turkey has made significant strides in improving access to education, especially for girls. However, issues related to educational quality, especially in rural areas, remain.
Right to Health: Turkey provides universal healthcare through a public system, and access to healthcare has generally improved. However, there are concerns about the privatization of healthcare services and inequalities in healthcare access.
Social Security: Turkey provides social security benefits to its citizens, including pensions, unemployment benefits, and health insurance. However, some marginalized groups face difficulties accessing these services.
Right to Work: Labor rights are guaranteed under the Constitution, but in practice, there are concerns about labor exploitation, particularly in the informal sector. Workers, particularly in the agricultural and construction sectors, often face unsafe working conditions and insufficient wages.
5. Women’s Rights
Turkey has made significant strides in women’s rights, but challenges remain:
Gender Equality: The Constitution guarantees gender equality, but women in Turkey face significant challenges in terms of employment, political representation, and violence.
Violence Against Women: Despite the enactment of laws aimed at protecting women from domestic violence, violence against women remains a serious issue, with a rising number of femicides reported each year.
In 2021, Turkey withdrew from the Istanbul Convention, an international treaty aimed at preventing and combating violence against women. This move sparked widespread protests and criticism from women’s rights groups.
6. LGBTQ+ Rights
Same-sex relations are legal in Turkey, but LGBTQ+ individuals face significant social stigma and discrimination. There are no legal protections against discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity.
Freedom of Expression for LGBTQ+ activists and organizations is restricted, and LGBTQ+ events, such as pride parades, have been banned or met with violence by authorities in recent years.
Transgender Rights: Transgender individuals face discrimination in employment, healthcare, and social services, and are often subjected to harassment or violence.
7. Kurdish Rights
The Kurdish minority in Turkey has faced long-standing discrimination and repression. The Kurdish issue has been a central aspect of Turkey's human rights challenges:
Language Rights: The use of the Kurdish language in public life and education has been restricted, although there have been some recent reforms to allow for limited use of Kurdish in certain contexts.
PKK Conflict: The government has engaged in a prolonged conflict with the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), which has led to human rights violations on both sides, including the targeting of civilians, arbitrary detentions, and mass arrests of Kurdish politicians and activists.
8. Migrant and Refugee Rights
Turkey hosts one of the largest refugee populations in the world, mainly due to the Syrian Civil War. While Turkey has provided shelter and access to some services for refugees, the rights of migrants remain a complex issue:
Refugees and Asylum Seekers: Refugees in Turkey, especially Syrians, face limited access to social services, employment, and healthcare. Many live in poor conditions and are vulnerable to exploitation.
Deportation: There are reports of arbitrary deportations, particularly of Syrians, and limited protections for those seeking asylum.
9. Human Rights Institutions and Civil Society
Human Rights and Equality Institution of Turkey (HRIT) is tasked with overseeing human rights protections but lacks sufficient independence and authority.
Civil Society Organizations (CSOs): While active in human rights advocacy, many civil society organizations face increasing restrictions. The government has targeted NGOs and activists critical of its policies, particularly through legal challenges and restrictions on foreign funding.
European Court of Human Rights: Many human rights cases from Turkey are brought before the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), and Turkey has faced numerous judgments for violations of human rights, including arbitrary detention, freedom of expression, and freedom of assembly.
Conclusion
While Turkey has a strong legal framework that theoretically protects a wide range of human rights, the implementation of these rights has been deeply affected by political developments, especially under President Erdoğan’s leadership. Freedom of expression, judicial independence, and minority rights remain significant concerns, while challenges in addressing issues such as gender-based violence, LGBTQ+ rights, and the Kurdish issue continue to affect human rights conditions. Democratic backsliding and authoritarian measures have placed considerable strain on the country's human rights landscape. Continued international pressure and internal reforms will be crucial to ensuring that Turkey can uphold its human rights commitments.
RELATED Blog
0 comments