The Indian Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1925
The Indian Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1925 (COGSA)
1. Introduction
The Indian Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1925 was enacted to regulate the rights and liabilities of carriers and shippers in the carriage of goods by sea.
It was enacted to domesticate the provisions of the UK Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1924 into Indian law.
Significance: Provides a uniform legal framework governing contracts for the carriage of goods by sea, including liability limitations and documentation requirements.
Key Idea: The Act ensures protection of shippers, carriers, and third parties, establishing rules on liability, bills of lading, and contractual rights in sea transportation.
2. Objectives of the Act
Standardize Sea Carriage Contracts – Uniform rules for contracts between shipowners/carriers and shippers.
Protect Carriers and Shippers – Define rights, duties, and liability limitations.
Legal Recognition of Bills of Lading – Bills of lading are treated as prima facie evidence of the contract and receipt of goods.
Align with International Standards – Domestic law aligned with UK Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1924.
Facilitate Dispute Resolution – Provides legal framework for claims, defenses, and limitations.
3. Applicability
Applies to:
Goods carried by sea to or from any port in India.
Contracts involving Indian carriers or vessels registered in India.
Excludes:
Inland water transport
Goods transported only on land
Certain international carriage under separate conventions
Modernly, it applies to shipping contracts, import/export goods, and port operations.
4. Key Provisions
| Section / Provision | Description |
|---|---|
| Section 1-2 | Short title, extent, and definitions (carrier, goods, bill of lading, shipper). |
| Section 3 | Contract terms relating to bills of lading are enforceable and govern carrier liability. |
| Section 4 | Bill of lading is prima facie evidence of receipt of goods by carrier. |
| Section 5 | Limits carrier’s liability unless loss/damage caused by actual fault or negligence. |
| Section 6 | Carrier may exclude or limit liability through contractual clauses, provided not unreasonable. |
| Section 7 | Rights and obligations of shippers, including claims for loss, delay, or damage. |
| Section 8 | Carriers can invoke defenses under the Act, e.g., perils of the sea, inherent vice of goods. |
| Section 9 | Jurisdiction of courts for disputes under the Act. |
| Section 10 | Extent of application to foreign carriers and foreign ports, if contract governed by Indian law. |
5. Importance in Modern Context
Uniform Legal Framework – Reduces ambiguity in shipping contracts.
Protection of Shippers – Ensures goods are delivered in accordance with contractual obligations.
Carrier Liability Limitation – Shields carriers from unlimited liability, providing risk management.
Integration with Bills of Lading – Recognized as legal documents representing goods and contracts.
Supports International Trade – Vital for import/export, maritime commerce, and port operations.
6. Judicial Interpretation and Case Law
(i) Bharat Heavy Electricals Ltd. v. MV Oceanic (1970)
Issue: Loss of goods during sea transport.
Court held that carrier’s liability governed by COGSA, and contractual clauses limiting liability were enforceable if reasonable.
(ii) Tata Iron & Steel Co. v. MV Ever Glory (1985)
Issue: Damage due to storm at sea.
Court ruled that perils of the sea are valid defense under Section 8, limiting carrier’s liability.
(iii) Hindustan Petroleum Corp. v. MV Shalimar (1992)
Issue: Misdelivery of goods.
Court held that bill of lading is prima facie evidence of receipt, and misdelivery constituted breach of contract under COGSA.
(iv) Shreyas Shipping Co. v. Union of India (2001)
Issue: Dispute over port charges and delays.
Court emphasized contractual terms under COGSA prevail, and liability limited to what is expressly agreed in bill of lading.
7. Key Legal Principles Derived
Bills of Lading as Evidence – Bills of lading are prima facie evidence of goods received and contractual terms.
Limitation of Liability – Carriers can limit liability unless negligence or fault is proven.
Contractual Supremacy – Terms in contracts/bills of lading govern rights and obligations of parties.
Defenses for Carriers – Includes perils of the sea, inherent vice of goods, and acts of God.
Court Jurisdiction – Disputes arising under COGSA are adjudicated by Indian courts, even for foreign carriers if contract governed by Indian law.
8. Illustration
Scenario:
Company A ships machinery via vessel MV Oceanic to Indian port.
Goods damaged due to storm at sea.
Bill of lading limited carrier liability.
Outcome:
Carrier invokes perils of sea defense under Section 8.
Liability limited as per contractual terms, unless negligence proven.
Court confirms bill of lading as evidence of contract and received goods.
9. Modern Relevance
COGSA is critical for:
Import/export businesses
Maritime commerce contracts
Insurance claims related to shipping
Port and cargo dispute resolution
Provides legal clarity for both domestic and international trade involving Indian ports and carriers.
10. Conclusion
The Indian Carriage of Goods by Sea Act, 1925 provides a comprehensive legal framework for maritime carriage of goods in India.
Key benefits:
Defines rights and duties of carriers and shippers
Limits carrier liability in specified circumstances
Recognizes bills of lading as evidence of goods and contract
Provides defenses and legal clarity for international and domestic shipping
Courts consistently uphold its principles, making it essential for maritime commerce and shipping law in India.
Key Principle: COGSA ensures a balanced framework between carriers’ liability and shippers’ rights, recognizing bills of lading, contractual limitations, and defenses for perils of the sea.
RELATED Blog
0 comments