Law of Evidence at Bahamas
The law of evidence in The Bahamas is primarily governed by the Evidence Act (Chapter 65), which outlines the rules and principles for admissibility, presentation, and evaluation of evidence in legal proceedings. This Act applies to both civil and criminal cases and incorporates various common law principles adapted to Bahamian legal practice.
Key Provisions of the Evidence Act
1. Admissibility of Evidence
Section 4 of the Evidence Act permits the introduction of facts relevant to any fact in issue, including those that explain circumstances, show motive, or assist in assessing damages or penalties. However, hearsay evidence is generally inadmissible unless it falls within specified exceptions, such as statements made in the presence of the opposing party or official records made in the course of duty . (Evidence Act (The Bahamas))
2. Hearsay Evidence
While hearsay evidence is typically excluded, Section 39 outlines several exceptions where such evidence may be admissible. These include statements made by a deceased person regarding the cause of death, statements made in the ordinary course of business, and certain admissions or confessions . (Evidence Act (The Bahamas))
3. Documentary Evidence
Documents can be introduced as evidence through primary or secondary means. Primary evidence refers to the original document, while secondary evidence includes certified copies or oral accounts of the document's contents. The Act also addresses the proof of documents requiring attestation, specifying conditions under which such documents can be admitted without the presence of an attesting witness . (Evidence Act (The Bahamas))
4. Witness Testimony
Witnesses are required to testify based on their personal knowledge. The Act outlines procedures for examination in chief, cross-examination, and re-examination, emphasizing the importance of direct testimony. It also addresses issues related to leading questions and the credibility of witnesses . (Evidence Act (The Bahamas))
5. Prior Judgments
Section 118 of the Evidence Act stipulates that judgments in previous lawsuits are admissible as evidence in subsequent cases. Such judgments are conclusive in civil cases and prima facie evidence in criminal cases regarding the facts determined in those proceedings . (Can Prior Judgments Be Admitted as Evidence in The Bahamas? | M. Margaret Gonsalves-Sabola)
6. Presumptions
The Act establishes certain presumptions, such as the presumption of legitimacy for children born during a valid marriage and the presumption of validity for marriages shown to have been celebrated. These presumptions can influence the burden of proof in legal proceedings . (Evidence Act (The Bahamas))
Application in Legal Practice
Legal practitioners in The Bahamas must navigate these provisions to effectively present and challenge evidence in court. Understanding the nuances of admissibility, the exceptions to hearsay rules, and the treatment of documentary and witness evidence is crucial for the conduct of litigation. The Evidence Act serves as a foundational statute ensuring that legal proceedings are conducted with fairness and in accordance with established legal standards.
RELATED Blog
0 comments