Insolvency Law at Switzerland
In Switzerland, insolvency law is governed by the Swiss Debt Enforcement and Bankruptcy Act (Schuldbetreibungs- und Konkursgesetz, or DEBA). This law provides the framework for the insolvency proceedings of both individuals and companies, and it focuses on the principles of fairness, transparency, and providing opportunities for debt restructuring where possible.
Switzerland offers a dual system for dealing with insolvency: one for individuals (personal bankruptcy) and one for companies (corporate bankruptcy). The law aims to balance the protection of creditors with providing debtors a fresh start when appropriate, while also promoting the continuity of businesses through reorganization procedures.
Key Legislation
Swiss Debt Enforcement and Bankruptcy Act (DEBA) (1889): This is the core legislation governing insolvency in Switzerland, covering both corporate and individual bankruptcies, debt collection, and related enforcement procedures.
Swiss Code of Obligations (Obligationenrecht, OR): This includes general provisions related to contracts and commercial law, and also impacts corporate governance, which can be relevant in insolvency matters.
Swiss Corporate Reorganization Act: Provides mechanisms for reorganizing businesses in financial distress to avoid liquidation and preserve their ongoing operations.
Types of Insolvency Procedures in Switzerland
1. Bankruptcy (Konkurs)
Bankruptcy is the most common insolvency procedure in Switzerland and can be initiated by either the debtor or creditors when a company or individual is unable to meet its obligations.
Initiation:
Creditors or debtors can apply to the debt enforcement office (Betreibungsamt) to initiate bankruptcy proceedings. For companies, the procedure is usually triggered when there is evidence that the company cannot pay its debts.
In practice, the creditor or debtor files for bankruptcy when a debtor has stopped paying its debts or when payments are due but not made.
Process:
Once bankruptcy is declared, a bankruptcy trustee (Konkursverwalter) is appointed to oversee the liquidation of the debtor’s assets.
The trustee is responsible for identifying and valuing the debtor's assets, selling them, and distributing the proceeds among creditors according to the priority rules.
In a corporate bankruptcy, the business may be liquidated entirely, and its assets are sold off to repay creditors.
Outcome:
If the assets are insufficient to satisfy the debts, the remaining liabilities are typically written off. This is common in cases where the debtor has no assets or very limited assets.
After all assets are liquidated and creditors are paid, the business is dissolved.
2. Reorganization (Sanierung or Nachlassstundung)
Switzerland has provisions for reorganizing businesses that are in financial difficulty but have the potential to recover and avoid liquidation. The reorganization procedure is designed to help financially distressed businesses survive through restructuring.
Initiation:
Reorganization proceedings can be initiated by the debtor or creditors, and a request for a reorganization moratorium (Nachlassstundung) can be filed with the court.
This procedure allows the business to stop creditor actions temporarily (usually up to six months) while it works on a debt restructuring plan.
Process:
During the moratorium period, creditors are temporarily barred from initiating new debt collection actions, giving the debtor time to propose a restructuring plan.
The debtor, often with the help of professional advisers, works to negotiate with creditors to reduce, extend, or reschedule debt payments.
A reorganization plan is developed and needs to be approved by the creditors and the court. In some cases, a judicial reorganization administrator is appointed to help oversee the process and ensure fair negotiations.
Outcome:
If the reorganization plan is successfully approved, the company can emerge from the procedure with a restructured debt load and continue operating.
If the restructuring fails, the business may be forced into bankruptcy.
3. Debt Adjustment for Individuals (Privatkonkurs)
This procedure applies to individuals who are unable to meet their financial obligations. The purpose of this process is to give individuals a chance to restructure their debts and achieve financial relief.
Initiation:
Individuals can initiate a debt adjustment procedure by filing a request with the debt enforcement office.
The procedure applies to individuals with debts that exceed their ability to repay.
Process:
A debt adjustment plan is developed to allow the individual to pay off debts over a fixed period, usually up to five years. The debtor makes regular payments to a trustee, who distributes the funds to creditors.
After the payment period, any remaining eligible debts are typically written off.
Outcome:
The debtor receives debt relief at the end of the plan, provided they have made all payments as agreed.
Certain types of debt (e.g., maintenance obligations) are not eligible for discharge under the debt adjustment procedure.
Priority of Claims in Insolvency
The Swiss DEBA law establishes a hierarchy of claims to determine the order in which creditors are paid during bankruptcy proceedings:
Costs of the Bankruptcy Procedure: Administrative costs, including trustee fees, are paid first.
Secured Creditors: Creditors with secured claims (e.g., those holding mortgages, liens, or other forms of security over assets) are paid next.
Preferential Creditors: This includes employees with unpaid wages, pension claims, and certain tax obligations.
Unsecured Creditors: General creditors, including suppliers, vendors, and others who do not have secured claims, are next in line.
Shareholders: Any remaining assets are distributed to the company’s shareholders, if applicable.
Key Features of Swiss Insolvency Law
Emphasis on Debt Restructuring: Switzerland’s insolvency law places significant emphasis on providing options for debt restructuring and reorganization, particularly for businesses. The moratorium procedure allows companies to restructure their finances and avoid bankruptcy, if possible.
Court Supervision: Both bankruptcy and reorganization procedures are subject to judicial oversight. Courts supervise the appointment of trustees and administrators and ensure that the proceedings are fair and comply with legal requirements.
Transparency: The insolvency process in Switzerland is structured to be transparent, with clear guidelines for creditors on the priority of claims and the distribution of assets.
Debtor Protection: The law allows individuals to reorganize their finances through debt adjustment procedures, offering them the opportunity to repay their debts over a manageable period and receive debt relief once the plan is completed.
International Considerations: Switzerland is a member of the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), and as such, it participates in international agreements related to cross-border insolvencies, which can impact businesses and individuals with international ties.
Challenges and Considerations
Costs and Complexity: The process of reorganization and bankruptcy can be costly and complex, particularly for smaller businesses. Legal and financial advisors are often necessary to navigate these procedures successfully.
Stigma Around Bankruptcy: Although Switzerland offers various mechanisms for restructuring and debt relief, there may still be some stigma around bankruptcy, which could discourage businesses from seeking protection early enough to save the company.
Limited Access to Debt Adjustment for Individuals: While individuals can access debt adjustment, the process can be slow and cumbersome, and it is not always an option for individuals with certain types of debts, such as maintenance obligations or criminal fines.
Conclusion
Switzerland's insolvency laws are designed to balance the interests of creditors and debtors, providing mechanisms for both corporate reorganization and individual debt adjustment. With a focus on debt restructuring and the rehabilitation of viable businesses, the Swiss system promotes financial recovery while ensuring fair treatment of creditors. For companies, reorganization is a key tool for avoiding liquidation, while individuals have access to debt relief through debt adjustment procedures.
RELATED Blog
0 comments