Law of Evidence at Sweden
In Sweden, the Law of Evidence is primarily governed by the Swedish Code of Judicial Procedure (Rättegångsbalken), which sets out the rules and principles for presenting and assessing evidence in both civil and criminal cases. Sweden follows a civil law system, influenced by both Nordic and continental European legal traditions, with an emphasis on written law and judicial interpretation.
Key Aspects of the Law of Evidence in Sweden:
1. Types of Evidence:
Documentary Evidence: Written documents, such as contracts, official records, emails, and letters, are widely used in both civil and criminal proceedings. Documents must be presented in their original form whenever possible, and their authenticity is crucial.
Witness Testimony: Witnesses are a central part of evidence in Swedish legal proceedings. Witnesses are required to testify in court, and their testimony is subject to both direct and cross-examination.
Expert Testimony: In cases requiring specialized knowledge, expert witnesses may be appointed. Their role is to assist the court by providing technical or professional opinions (e.g., forensic experts, medical experts, financial auditors, etc.).
Physical Evidence: Objects or physical materials related to the case, such as weapons, drugs, or other items, can be presented as evidence.
Confessions: In criminal cases, confessions made by the accused can be used as evidence, but they must be voluntary and not coerced.
2. Admissibility of Evidence:
Relevance: Evidence must be relevant to the issues being litigated. Swedish law applies a general rule of relevance, meaning that evidence must help clarify the facts of the case.
Legality: Evidence obtained through illegal means, such as without proper consent or through coercion, is inadmissible in Swedish courts. The court will exclude any evidence that violates the Swedish Constitution or other legal provisions that protect personal privacy and rights.
Burden of Proof: The burden of proof generally rests with the party making a claim or accusation. In civil cases, this is typically the plaintiff, while in criminal cases, it is the prosecution that must prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
3. Hearsay Evidence:
Hearsay (statements made outside of court by someone not testifying in the trial) is generally inadmissible in Swedish courts, except under certain circumstances. There are limited exceptions where hearsay evidence may be allowed, for instance, if the original speaker is unavailable to testify or if the statement falls within recognized exceptions.
However, written statements from a person who is not present at trial may be allowed, but their reliability is carefully scrutinized by the court.
4. Burden of Proof:
Civil Cases: The burden of proof lies with the party making the claim. The claimant must present enough evidence to prove the facts of the case by a preponderance of the evidence (the greater weight of the evidence).
Criminal Cases: In criminal cases, the prosecution carries the burden of proof. The defendant is presumed innocent until proven guilty, and the prosecution must prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
5. Witnesses:
Competence of Witnesses: In Sweden, any person who can testify to the facts relevant to the case is generally considered a competent witness. However, there are exceptions, such as witnesses who may have a conflict of interest or those with a close relationship to one of the parties.
Witness Testimony: Witnesses are examined in court under oath, and their testimony is subject to cross-examination. The court evaluates their credibility and reliability. While Sweden follows an inquisitorial model, where judges play an active role in gathering facts, witnesses' testimonies are still central to the case.
Witness Protection: In serious criminal cases, especially those involving organized crime, there are mechanisms to protect the identity and safety of witnesses. This may include measures like witness anonymity or relocation.
6. Expert Testimony:
Role of Experts: Experts can be appointed by the court or requested by the parties involved. Experts are typically called to provide opinions on technical issues or areas that require specific knowledge, such as forensic evidence, medical assessments, or financial analyses.
Reliability of Expert Evidence: Expert opinions are not binding on the court, but they are given significant weight, particularly in complex matters. The court evaluates whether the expert's testimony is credible and whether it aligns with other evidence.
7. Electronic Evidence:
Admissibility of Electronic Evidence: Electronic evidence (e.g., emails, text messages, video recordings, social media posts, etc.) is recognized and admissible in Swedish courts. However, such evidence must be authentic and reliable.
Digital Authentication: Electronic evidence must be properly authenticated to ensure its integrity. In cases involving digital documents or communications, expert testimony may be required to confirm the source and reliability of the evidence.
8. Criminal Law Evidence:
Confessions: In criminal law, a confession made by the accused can be admissible, but it must be voluntary. Swedish law prohibits confessions that have been coerced or made under duress.
Physical Evidence: Physical evidence such as fingerprints, DNA, or objects found at a crime scene is crucial in criminal cases. Swedish courts assess the reliability and relevance of such evidence during trial.
Forensic Evidence: Forensic tests (e.g., blood tests, forensic analysis of digital evidence) are common in criminal trials. The court considers expert testimony regarding the validity and accuracy of the forensic findings.
9. Family Law Evidence:
In family law matters, such as divorce or child custody disputes, the court will often rely on documentary evidence (e.g., marriage certificates, financial records) and witness testimony. The court may also appoint experts (e.g., psychologists) to provide insights into the well-being of children in custody cases.
10. Presumptions:
Swedish law recognizes certain legal presumptions. For instance, if a person is found in possession of stolen property, there may be a presumption that they are the thief, although this presumption can be rebutted.
11. Procedural Rules:
Swedish Civil Procedure Code: The Swedish Code of Judicial Procedure (Rättegångsbalken) governs how evidence is presented in civil cases. It outlines rules for submitting documents, presenting testimony, and examining physical evidence.
Swedish Criminal Procedure Code: The Swedish Criminal Procedure Code governs the presentation of evidence in criminal trials. It provides detailed rules for how evidence is collected, the rights of the accused, and how evidence is presented to the court.
In both civil and criminal cases, judges play an active role in gathering evidence, questioning witnesses, and ensuring that the evidence is presented in a fair and unbiased manner.
RELATED Blog
0 comments